To celebrate the amazing Celtic harvest feast of All Hallow’s Eve, I put on my Marie Antoinette costume, holding a slice of cake in one hand (“Let the hallows eat cake, dammit!”) and this book in the other. As I turned the last few pages with wide eyes, I was jumping from the unexpected twists. I made my rounds, collecting my “threats” in the form of selected wine bottles and Belgian truffles. If anyone resisted giving me treats, I threatened to sing or show them my dance moves. So far, I’ve collected three cases of good wine—I’m so close to opening my own wine bar! Happy Halloween to you, too!
Let’s cut to the chase and talk about this fascinating book:
This is a deliciously entertaining mash-up of The Chain and The Whisper Man! It’s surprising, twisty, agitating, riveting, stunning—an exciting page-turner! I didn’t want it to end! It’s a heart-pounding, thrilling rollercoaster ride, and finishing it on Halloween made it all the more exhilarating. It gave me more of a rush than the Universal Studios Halloween experience (because, you know, the people scaring you there are paid to give you nightmares, which isn’t nearly as effective as what this book did to me!). Naturally, I gave it all of my five gazillion stars—and some of the treats I collected today! Well deserved, well played!
The story centers on Gabe, exhausted and crumbling, nicknamed “Thin Man.” He’s traveling and living in his camper van, passing through service stations, and leaving leaflets about his missing daughter. The authorities believe she’s already deceased. One day, he’s stuck in traffic on his way home and spots a girl in the back of an old car covered in cheesy bumper stickers. He’s certain it’s his daughter and that she’s been kidnapped. But by who?
Then there’s Katie, working as a waitress in a rundown restaurant where Gabe regularly stops by. She’s raising her kids alone after their father was killed in a home invasion. Katie knows what it’s like to lose someone and suffer deep grief. But she also knows something about the person who kidnapped Gabe’s daughter.
It’s all connected to a shadowy group called “Other People.” Their motto: An eye for an eye. Their method: vigilante justice. Quid pro quo. These operatives roam among the people, sniffing out those who carry sadness, grief, and hatred due to past injustices. They hand out cards that lead people to the dark web, where victims of injustice can request retribution. If the group’s masterminds deem the request acceptable, they fulfill it—within 24 hours. But of course, nothing is free. Once your request is completed, you owe them a favor. And until you repay it, you live in fear because they know everything about you. They’re always watching. So you’d better repay that favor and stay away from electronic devices!
We also meet a good Samaritan helping Gabe track down the vehicle seen during his daughter’s kidnapping. Meanwhile, there’s a girl in a vegetative state, lying in a hospital bed, kept alive on life support. Someone visits her regularly, reading her stories and passages from books. This part of the story is confusing at first, making you wonder who she is and how she ties into the larger plot.
After a series of final revelations and multiple twists, I had to massage my temples from overworking my precious grey cells. But by the end, I pieced everything together (and thanks to my spider senses, at least half of my guesses were right!). True to form, the author added some supernatural, mystical elements that gave me more jump scares and “holy shit” moments, but I loved these elements and how they fit into the story. The resolution of the characters’ entwined fates was deeply satisfying.
I’ve read The Chalk Man and The Hiding Place, but this is definitely my favorite work from this author. It’s the best Halloween treat or trick I’ve ever had!
Cheers!
Special thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group-Ballantine Books for sharing this fascinating book with me in exchange for my honest review.