Thanks to NetGalley and Wattpad Books for ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Just no.
Down World is a novel that wants to be an interesting, convoluted story full of twists and turns. But by wanting to be that, the novel forgot that you need some growth, otherwise the twists and turns just end up being a rollercoaster that just deposits you where you started from.
In Down World we follow a teenage girl called Marina who is just returning to her local school after spending some time at a private school after her brother died. On her first day at school, she meets a handsome young boy. She is also faced with the memories of her life from before everything changed. We also see that her family has been suffering in the years since the accident.
One day while at school she sort of sees something and then ends up investigating the things, e voilà she is told that there is a portal to another world on the school grounds. And somehow all of this is connected to her brother.
What follows is a twist after a twist, followed by a turn, and then a loophole, and then “we’re not really here” moments and there’s even a “he’s not his son!” revelation… Just no. This book has entirely too many things happen in the span of fewer than 370 pages! The author needed a clear plan and she just needed to stick to it.
In the description it says it’s for the fans of Stranger Things and Dark. As I haven’t watched Stranger Things, I can’t speak for them, but as a MASSIVE fan of Dark, I gotta say no, this is not for us. The reason why we LOVED Dark was not the fact that the story was convoluted, but that the convoluted story had a plan, a point, a clear direction, and was done in a very smart way. If you want something like Dark, just go on Netflix and watch the original once more.
Now, I don’t want to go into spoilers, but I need to rant a little bit here.
1) Her brother supposedly died after running in front of a train. They buried an empty coffin because “there was nothing left to bury.” How freakin’ fast are those trains going for the impact to be strong enough to vaporize a body?
2) Marina thinking things like these: “This was the moment I had been waiting for, and I didn’t know if I was strong enough to hear it.” Trust me, you’re 16 or 17, you’re not strong enough, it’s just that your author doesn’t really realize that and has superimposed her own age onto you. Do you honestly know any 16-year-olds who think that? Or behave like this one? I don’t and I spend my time surrounded by teenagers as I teach in a high school.
3) Marina has been planning a trip to Oregon for weeks now, setting up a fake story for her dad, setting up her assistant… but she never considered the fact that she would need to sleep somewhere or that she would need to find the people she was going to visit. Can you say, “dumb teenager much?”
4) At one point Marina’s mum has disappeared, her father is in “detention” because his wife is gone and his daughter was missing, a strange military installation has miraculously replaced the school but she’s “happy” because she’s lying next to a boy who is kissing her? Really? Priorities! Also, 10 pages before and 10 pages after she is making googly eyes at another boy.
5) Piper decides she will tell Marina what happened, but of course she has to do it “ab ovo” starting with the accident that claimed the lives of her parents, even though Marina, her brother and us all know the story. Just get to the point.
6) Every single woman is gorgeous, beautiful, moveiw star beautiful,..... we get it.
7) Random flashbacks! Especially the 4page one involving Marina, Robbie and her father visiting the mine as tourists. No!
8) Random statements: “skeletal eyes,” “Robbie saw our hands holding and he turned away.” HOLDING WHAT?
9) SHE. POKES. THE. GUARD. IN. THE. EYES!
10) “it’s a natural process with radioactive material. The nuclei are unstable. Proteins escaping and being repelled.” he says while looking at a beaker of pink glowy liquid. The fuck is this guy on about?
So, all in all, it’s a no from me I’m sad to say. I wanted to like this book, after all the blurb promised smart intrigue and parallel worlds, but it seems that this year when it comes to that I’m 0 for 2. Better luck with next book.