Benjamin (H) and his partner Jeremy are off-duty cops at a club, there to watch a band perform. Sarah (h) is a writer there to do a quick puff review of the same band. When the concert doesn't go as expected, Benjamin ends up saving Sarah from the resulting brawl, and sparks fly.
As a set-up for a sweet'n'steamy short story, this wasn't a bad set-up. It was all in the writing that made it hard to enjoy. I hate to tear apart someone's writing like this, especially a debut from a self-published author, but this one really needed an editor. A proofreader, at the very least! I was highlighting things that irked or distracted me left and right. For a short story, I had 26 highlights! For someone who doesn't do a lot of Kindle highlighting, that's through the roof! So here we go:
* Overall, the writing is clunky and childish, very simplistic. There's lots and lots of repetition, for example. Sometimes it's just a repeated theme (how many times did they think about 'how long had they lived without the other in their life'?) but sometimes it's right back-to-back ("Benjamin. Lean and tall, the other man, tall and slim, they were matching ages and physical perfection." Just awkward).
* The punctuation is ... problematic. I know it's a personal pet peeve of mine, due to several very grammar-focused English teachers in my school-age past. But still! Commas do not join complete, independent clauses - that's a comma splice and should be two independent sentences. Likewise, commas are needed with introductory clauses and with sentences joined with a conjunction. All these comma issues were liberally scattered throughout. Sometimes I had to read sentences a few times to figure out what was going. Like that "tall and slim" sentence above! And then you have clauses that aren't sentences, but standing alone too. Like I said, problematic. And I'll step off my soapbox now.
* The tense needs work. The writing is in present tense - like things are happening at the moment and we are experiencing them with the characters. It's not a reminiscing character looking back on how they met the love of their life. So sentences foreshadowing their meeting and its significance are really weird, as are sentences referring to something in the past but still using the present tense (a woman at the club "works" on her hair and stumbles on her stilettos.)
* Word choice issues. Quite a number of near-correct word choices, but choosing the wrong of the homophones (or near homophones). Like illusion/allusion, for example. Or it's/its. And then, just a number of odd word choices. His hands are described as "large and healthy"? Her hips are "lofty"? Or they go to the cafe and "take our order from an aspiring actor." They give their order, or the actor takes their order. Unless they're listening to what the actor says and not actually ordering for themselves?
* What is "old-world blue"? Benjamin's eyes are described like that twice. The only connection I have for that phrase is Fallout. And it has nothing to do with color.
I did get a little irritated with Sarah too. Not that she's not a likable character. But she's a little too aggressively body confident for my taste. The type that puts down other body types, you know? I know I'm on the curvy end of things, and am totally in favor of curvy h characters. But to be putting down other builds in bragging about your own usually tends to rub me a little the wrong way.
As I said at the beginning, I like the story. It's instalove, short and fast, but the characters are generally likable, and if the writing issues were addressed, it would have been a good quick escapism sort of read. There's a niche for this sort of quick read, and this would have been a good addition to that realm. With the help of a good editor and/or proofreader, at least.
Alternating 1st person POV. No cheating, no OW/OM drama, no love triangle nonsense. Two people meet, connect, and have lots of steamy times leading to their HEA. No real drama, just a fast escapism read - under an hour. HEA and no cliffhanger, though plenty of hints that Benjamin's partner Jeremy will be the H in the next story.
Would I read more? I highly doubt it. There are enough other authors writing this sort of story that are smoother reads.