What do you think?
Rate this book
The Ballad of Hattie Taylor
A daring young woman pushes back against societal constraints in a feminist, coming-of-age Western romance from New York Times bestselling author Susan Andersen.
In the small, bustling town of Mattawa, Oregon, the turn of the century offers a new kind of frontier for women: a vast and exciting range of possibilities—to a point. It’s a time for change, and no one is more eager to embrace new paths than free-spirited outsider Hattie Taylor. If only she could embrace Jake Murdock too.
Jake can’t remember a time he was so confused. Hattie is off-limits. The provoking spitfire is under his mother’s protection—his protection—and he has always belonged to another. But now, with the passing of his wife, Jake feels something shift between them. Frustratingly aware of Hattie as a woman, he struggles with new feelings, new questions, new desires.
But when a desperate decision born of good intentions turns out to have ugly repercussions, Hattie confronts a cruel reality she can no longer ignore: the truth of where women really stand and the actions men take to keep them there. To navigate her new world of tainted justice and privileged order Hattie will draw on the strength of the women around her—and Jake will learn what it truly means to support the woman he loves.
In the small, bustling town of Mattawa, Oregon, the turn of the century offers a new kind of frontier for women: a vast and exciting range of possibilities—to a point. It’s a time for change, and no one is more eager to embrace new paths than free-spirited outsider Hattie Taylor. If only she could embrace Jake Murdock too.
Jake can’t remember a time he was so confused. Hattie is off-limits. The provoking spitfire is under his mother’s protection—his protection—and he has always belonged to another. But now, with the passing of his wife, Jake feels something shift between them. Frustratingly aware of Hattie as a woman, he struggles with new feelings, new questions, new desires.
But when a desperate decision born of good intentions turns out to have ugly repercussions, Hattie confronts a cruel reality she can no longer ignore: the truth of where women really stand and the actions men take to keep them there. To navigate her new world of tainted justice and privileged order Hattie will draw on the strength of the women around her—and Jake will learn what it truly means to support the woman he loves.
400 pages, Paperback
First published January 5, 2021
39 people are currently reading
568 people want to read
About the author
Susan Andersen
104 books1,272 followersI grew up in a household with two brothers, a daddy, and my grandfather. Too many men, in other words. They diluted M'ma's influence by diverting my attention to things like the danger of answering nature's call in the dead of the night. I've got a hint for those of you raised in a less spit-and-scratch world: check before you sit, because chances are that seat is gonna be up. And they don't even have the grace to be embarrassed about it. According to my sweet baby boy, if you're the minority sex in the household, you oughtta be putting it up for them. Sigh.
Having brothers was a mixed bag. When anybody messed with me they were always quick with an offer to beat them up. That was sorta nice, although I personally believe it had more to do with the fact that guys just like to fight than with any towering concern for my welfare. You might think that's cynical but guess who the target was if no one else was around and they were tired of fighting each other? I must've spent half my childhood locked in the bathroom, screaming, "Dad's gonna get you when he gets home." I know, I know, nobody likes a stoolie. But it was either that or have my block knocked off on a regular basis, and trust me, Daddy was the best deterrent going.
A smart woman probably would've gone away to an all-girl school or moved in with some girlfriends at the first opportunity. Me, I got married to my high school sweetie. And the tradition continues. Our only kid (who hasn't been a kid for quite some time now) is the aforementioned sweet baby boy, and except for an Irish setter we had for eleven years a long time ago, even our pets have all been male. I just try to stay afloat whenever I find myself in the deep end of the testosterone pool, and if you don't think that isn't a trial sometimes, I'm here to tell you- it can be hell.
Then again, it can also be heaven. In fact, it mostly is. But listen, don't tell my guys I 'fessed up to that, okay? Trust me, it's difficult enough already, just trying to stay one step ahead of the game.
Having brothers was a mixed bag. When anybody messed with me they were always quick with an offer to beat them up. That was sorta nice, although I personally believe it had more to do with the fact that guys just like to fight than with any towering concern for my welfare. You might think that's cynical but guess who the target was if no one else was around and they were tired of fighting each other? I must've spent half my childhood locked in the bathroom, screaming, "Dad's gonna get you when he gets home." I know, I know, nobody likes a stoolie. But it was either that or have my block knocked off on a regular basis, and trust me, Daddy was the best deterrent going.
A smart woman probably would've gone away to an all-girl school or moved in with some girlfriends at the first opportunity. Me, I got married to my high school sweetie. And the tradition continues. Our only kid (who hasn't been a kid for quite some time now) is the aforementioned sweet baby boy, and except for an Irish setter we had for eleven years a long time ago, even our pets have all been male. I just try to stay afloat whenever I find myself in the deep end of the testosterone pool, and if you don't think that isn't a trial sometimes, I'm here to tell you- it can be hell.
Then again, it can also be heaven. In fact, it mostly is. But listen, don't tell my guys I 'fessed up to that, okay? Trust me, it's difficult enough already, just trying to stay one step ahead of the game.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews
November 26, 2020
The Ballad of Hattie Taylor by Susan Anderson is a historical romance set during the turn of the century in Oregon. The two main characters are compelling. Readers will love the book for their story. The moral and social culture weigh heavily in the story and drive the narrative as much as the romance does. Anderson built conflict that made me refuse to turn pages until I could calm my emotions and rationalize possible outcomes. I loved the main characters; they were real.
October 23, 2021
If you read "The Ballad of Hattie Taylor" you need to be aware it is in no way the light romance with humor that have been the hallmark of Susan Andersen's books. Running Wild was written more than five years ago. That was the last book Susan Andersen wrote that I loved. It was a light romance filled with humor, like most all of her other books which, for the most part, I just loved. What you get with "The Ballad of Hattie Taylor" is not a fun coming of age tale set during the turn of the century. Serious fare for a period story.
When orphaned Hattie Taylor arrives in Mattawa, Oregon she is an immediate outcast among the genteel upper crust families of this bustling frontier town. Social upheaval and women's rights were still a ways off. A woman's place was with her father till he gave her to her husband. Hattie's outspoken nature and free spirit made her life difficult. When she is raped and no justice could be hers if she wanted to exist in the community, she only has to wait two weeks until she can go to teacher's college in Seattle, WA. There she finds acceptance, friendship and a purpose for her life.
As soon as young Jake Murdock sets eyes on Hattie he knows that this young girl will change his life forever. Jake makes his life with a wife when tragedy strikes. The repercussions from that tragedy affect his life in ways both Jake and Hattie could never imagine. Years later, Jake is a man on a mission and the newly returned Hattie is his objective. But, even that is not going the way it should. Finding their way to each other is going to take a lot more than the true love they have for each other. 3 1/2-Stars
When orphaned Hattie Taylor arrives in Mattawa, Oregon she is an immediate outcast among the genteel upper crust families of this bustling frontier town. Social upheaval and women's rights were still a ways off. A woman's place was with her father till he gave her to her husband. Hattie's outspoken nature and free spirit made her life difficult. When she is raped and no justice could be hers if she wanted to exist in the community, she only has to wait two weeks until she can go to teacher's college in Seattle, WA. There she finds acceptance, friendship and a purpose for her life.
As soon as young Jake Murdock sets eyes on Hattie he knows that this young girl will change his life forever. Jake makes his life with a wife when tragedy strikes. The repercussions from that tragedy affect his life in ways both Jake and Hattie could never imagine. Years later, Jake is a man on a mission and the newly returned Hattie is his objective. But, even that is not going the way it should. Finding their way to each other is going to take a lot more than the true love they have for each other. 3 1/2-Stars
January 6, 2021
2.5
I really wanted to love this story. Sadly, it fell short for me in a few huge areas.
The Ballad of Hattie Taylor is an intriguing exploration of women's place in life and society in the early 20th century. It was interesting to get some perspectives of how women were regulated and viewed in that era. However, I felt that almost all of the men in the story were overly patronizing, controlling, and disappointing. Despite it truly being a highly patriarchal society at that time, I have a hard time believing that every male would be so domineering, cruel, and brutish to the point of violence. It did not help me believe the few love stories in the book, as they went against what the women said they stood for.
I adore the vivid cover - it really drew me in. Hattie was an intriguing and spirited character, and many of the other female characters were really strong. I also enjoyed the historical look at the many changes in American life at the turn of the century.
But the story itself lacks some real chances for a great moral. It could have been a liberating story in an earlier time, but right now it feels outdated. The romance felt forced and many sections made me cringe. Despite it perhaps being a historically accurate reflection on society in the 1900s, it lacked a balance with today's need for a fictional account with which we can relate and learn from.
If anything, this book will be eye-opening and should spark some great debate into the historical and current state of women's rights and sexual assault.
Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest review.
I really wanted to love this story. Sadly, it fell short for me in a few huge areas.
The Ballad of Hattie Taylor is an intriguing exploration of women's place in life and society in the early 20th century. It was interesting to get some perspectives of how women were regulated and viewed in that era. However, I felt that almost all of the men in the story were overly patronizing, controlling, and disappointing. Despite it truly being a highly patriarchal society at that time, I have a hard time believing that every male would be so domineering, cruel, and brutish to the point of violence. It did not help me believe the few love stories in the book, as they went against what the women said they stood for.
I adore the vivid cover - it really drew me in. Hattie was an intriguing and spirited character, and many of the other female characters were really strong. I also enjoyed the historical look at the many changes in American life at the turn of the century.
But the story itself lacks some real chances for a great moral. It could have been a liberating story in an earlier time, but right now it feels outdated. The romance felt forced and many sections made me cringe. Despite it perhaps being a historically accurate reflection on society in the 1900s, it lacked a balance with today's need for a fictional account with which we can relate and learn from.
If anything, this book will be eye-opening and should spark some great debate into the historical and current state of women's rights and sexual assault.
Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for the advanced digital copy in exchange for my honest review.
November 25, 2020
This book deals with the sensitive subject of rape, and the historical way that victims of rape were blamed for the crime. That being said, I really enjoyed the character of Hattie, from the time she was a child until her adulthood. She is a strong, independent woman in a time that does not value these qualities in women. I enjoyed the storyline and Hattie’s pursuit of happiness.
January 9, 2021
The synopsis of this book is misleading, where is the feminist part? And the romance sucked big time, Jacob was a major asshole, he was a Mr Jekill and Mr Hide, sometimes considerate but then a raging, handsy pervert, he is always trying to cop a feel with adult Hattie, is unnerving that he is the hero and romantic prospect.
I couldn't read the kissing scenes with these two, he was abusive and it really didn't felt like he loved her more just lusted after her, just plain lust
Then there was the fact that Jake also lusted for his wife Jane-Ellen, and raped her because she was his wife and it was her duty, even though she hated contact and even more sex.
The best character was Aunt Augusta, she kicked Jake ass handsomely, I really liked her.
In fact, most of the men in this book were domineering perverts plus everything revolved around sex, it was maddening, I think this was an exaggeration from the author's part, that really kills the romance mood for the first part of the book, then it became tolerable.
So, it was ok, at times I could barely stand to read it, but it improved on the last pages.
I couldn't read the kissing scenes with these two, he was abusive and it really didn't felt like he loved her more just lusted after her, just plain lust
Then there was the fact that Jake also lusted for his wife Jane-Ellen, and raped her because she was his wife and it was her duty, even though she hated contact and even more sex.
The best character was Aunt Augusta, she kicked Jake ass handsomely, I really liked her.
In fact, most of the men in this book were domineering perverts plus everything revolved around sex, it was maddening, I think this was an exaggeration from the author's part, that really kills the romance mood for the first part of the book, then it became tolerable.
So, it was ok, at times I could barely stand to read it, but it improved on the last pages.
January 6, 2021
The Ballad of Hattie Taylor is a saga that follows the life of orphaned Hattie from the age of eleven to her early twenties. Set in Oregon at the turn of the 20th century, it not only tells the story of Hattie but reflects upon the lives of all women of that era. It was a time where exciting possibilities were opening up but also when a woman's reputation was precarious and inequalities existed, not only between women and men but between women of different classes. Societal issues are highlighted through the actions of the characters as well as the (sometimes brutal) injustices they suffer.
The book is a well-written, thought-provoking, page-turner with complex, fully-formed characters and complicated relationships. Readers are taken on a life journey that evokes a full range of emotions. Make no mistake, this is Hattie's story and it is a compelling one. She is a character who endeared herself to me early on and I was firmly in her corner from start to finish. But there is also a rich supporting cast of characters who are vividly portrayed and critical to Hattie's story. Like many sagas, while they have pivotal parts to play in Hattie's life there are also individual stories to be told. Stories that will also evoke strong emotions. One that made a significant impact on me is that of a young maid, a minor character, but with an important role, whose courage I greatly admired and whose circumstances clearly delineated the line between classes.
It would be hard to discuss Jake in too much depth without giving away spoilers so I'll just say that my feelings about him, as well as his relationship with Hattie, and his relationship with his first wife, are mixed and leave it to you to make your own decisions about him.
There are parts of this book that will not be easy to read and many issues women still face today that I was left pondering long after finishing the book. Readers should know that Hattie ultimately claims a happy ending but it certainly isn't won without pain, forgiveness, healing, and internal strength.
Content Warning:
One thing the author does not do in this book is hold back from harsh realities of life. There are some major triggers that I was unaware of before beginning the book and the impact they had on me was deep. Not only was I filled with heartache and rage during the second half of the book, I'm still haunted by what happens to these characters. The mark of a good writer, certainly, to elicit such strong emotions but forewarned is forearmed. Readers who are sensitive to these topics should be aware that they will be dealing with the following issues on the page:
Rape
Beating
Adult death
Death in utero
*ARC received via NetGalley for fair and unbiased review
The book is a well-written, thought-provoking, page-turner with complex, fully-formed characters and complicated relationships. Readers are taken on a life journey that evokes a full range of emotions. Make no mistake, this is Hattie's story and it is a compelling one. She is a character who endeared herself to me early on and I was firmly in her corner from start to finish. But there is also a rich supporting cast of characters who are vividly portrayed and critical to Hattie's story. Like many sagas, while they have pivotal parts to play in Hattie's life there are also individual stories to be told. Stories that will also evoke strong emotions. One that made a significant impact on me is that of a young maid, a minor character, but with an important role, whose courage I greatly admired and whose circumstances clearly delineated the line between classes.
It would be hard to discuss Jake in too much depth without giving away spoilers so I'll just say that my feelings about him, as well as his relationship with Hattie, and his relationship with his first wife, are mixed and leave it to you to make your own decisions about him.
There are parts of this book that will not be easy to read and many issues women still face today that I was left pondering long after finishing the book. Readers should know that Hattie ultimately claims a happy ending but it certainly isn't won without pain, forgiveness, healing, and internal strength.
Content Warning:
One thing the author does not do in this book is hold back from harsh realities of life. There are some major triggers that I was unaware of before beginning the book and the impact they had on me was deep. Not only was I filled with heartache and rage during the second half of the book, I'm still haunted by what happens to these characters. The mark of a good writer, certainly, to elicit such strong emotions but forewarned is forearmed. Readers who are sensitive to these topics should be aware that they will be dealing with the following issues on the page:
Rape
Beating
Adult death
Death in utero
*ARC received via NetGalley for fair and unbiased review
July 8, 2020
I'd already been sold by a colleague’s description of ‘a grown-up Anne of Green Gables story, even though I never got into the original while I was young. Plus, it had me at hello with its gorgeous and unique package, all speaking to the story as well!
Right away you appreciate strong illustrative writing, aimed for readers who enjoy deep character depth and apt pacing.
I loved how there was no dancing around a superficial storyline; bad things happen in life and this propels our protagonist forward.
It was such a page turner~ to read a full life story instead of just a moment in time was also set this story apart as well.
I would encourage more than just romance readers to enjoy this (even with its well pleased spicy scenes) it hits a historical reader right in the happy place as well!
Galley borrowed from the publisher.
Right away you appreciate strong illustrative writing, aimed for readers who enjoy deep character depth and apt pacing.
I loved how there was no dancing around a superficial storyline; bad things happen in life and this propels our protagonist forward.
It was such a page turner~ to read a full life story instead of just a moment in time was also set this story apart as well.
I would encourage more than just romance readers to enjoy this (even with its well pleased spicy scenes) it hits a historical reader right in the happy place as well!
Galley borrowed from the publisher.
July 11, 2020
Beautiful exploration of life and society in the early 20th century through the lens of fiction. One would hope we only imagine the harsh world of yesteryear; however, many themes persist today. I love finding these gems that provide a glimpse into the world my grandparents may have experienced. I highly recommend this historical romance.
Advance digital copy provided by NetGalley. Thank you!
Advance digital copy provided by NetGalley. Thank you!
October 9, 2023
Absolutely BRILLIANT! Intriguing, thought provoking, realistic, bold, page-turning historical fiction meets western historical romance story of a young girl coming of age in turn of the 20th century Oregon. Rich in interesting historical detail and memorable characters, both lovable and loathsome. I really appreciated reading the different POV of multiple characters in the book as the story enfolded. Rich in the complexity of human relationships as the characters navigate their own feelings and experiences in the era they existed.This book will make you FEEL. It will MOVE you. It will DISTURB you. It has lighthearted moments that will make your heart sing and others that will make it clench. Maybe you will feel angry, or saddened. It's all awesome! GOOD BOOKS DO THAT!!
...Is that not why we read....to feel???🤔
Disturbing things happen in this book, as they do in life. Bad things happen to good people...and they survive.This book is about those kind of strong, resilient people.The heroine, Hattie is remarkable, as is the Hero, Jake. Theirs is a love story for the ages. Loved it!! 💛💛
...Is that not why we read....to feel???🤔
Disturbing things happen in this book, as they do in life. Bad things happen to good people...and they survive.This book is about those kind of strong, resilient people.The heroine, Hattie is remarkable, as is the Hero, Jake. Theirs is a love story for the ages. Loved it!! 💛💛
January 11, 2021
•Strong female characters
•Empowering
•Emotional
•Tough Topic
I honestly loved this book and I don't think I can stop talking about it once I start!
So, when I started this book I kind of didn't want to keep reading it. I wasn't too fond of the characters and didn't quite know where it was going. Then, all of a sudden, I loved it. The story took a turn that really grabbed me and I could relate to Hattie in more ways than one.
The story takes place over 10 years (1899-1909) and the littlest of things had me in awe and catching my breath. For instance, the introduction of automobiles I thought was awesome. The female rights forward theme of the book was told so elegantly that it isn't being shoved down your throat, which is a pet peeve of mine.
Characters: I really loved the characters. Her Aunt Augusta is awesome and Hattie is one of my favorite lead characters now. I feel you can really tell the growth and change in all the characters over the ten years, especially Hattie.
Writing: The writing was great. There isn't description for descriptions sake which I loved. I have another pet peeve when a story goes over board on description and ends up taking a whole page just talking about a room. This had just the right amount of detail.
•Empowering
•Emotional
•Tough Topic
I honestly loved this book and I don't think I can stop talking about it once I start!
So, when I started this book I kind of didn't want to keep reading it. I wasn't too fond of the characters and didn't quite know where it was going. Then, all of a sudden, I loved it. The story took a turn that really grabbed me and I could relate to Hattie in more ways than one.
The story takes place over 10 years (1899-1909) and the littlest of things had me in awe and catching my breath. For instance, the introduction of automobiles I thought was awesome. The female rights forward theme of the book was told so elegantly that it isn't being shoved down your throat, which is a pet peeve of mine.
Characters: I really loved the characters. Her Aunt Augusta is awesome and Hattie is one of my favorite lead characters now. I feel you can really tell the growth and change in all the characters over the ten years, especially Hattie.
Writing: The writing was great. There isn't description for descriptions sake which I loved. I have another pet peeve when a story goes over board on description and ends up taking a whole page just talking about a room. This had just the right amount of detail.
Read
January 10, 2021DNF at 40%.
I am incredibly grateful to Berkley Pub for gifting me an advanced copy of this book.
It was not what I originally thought it was going to be.
I did enjoy seeing Hattie as a young child.
By the time I DNF'd she was 18. At this point the book was mainly about how the men of the town ( the love interest included ) lusted after Hattie because of her curves and the fact that she didn't wear a corset.
The Love Interest - Sucked. I knew there would be an eventual romance between the two and I could not stick around for it.
I will not be rating this book. I probably will not be picking up anything else by this author.
I do not recommend this book. At all.
I am incredibly grateful to Berkley Pub for gifting me an advanced copy of this book.
It was not what I originally thought it was going to be.
I did enjoy seeing Hattie as a young child.
By the time I DNF'd she was 18. At this point the book was mainly about how the men of the town ( the love interest included ) lusted after Hattie because of her curves and the fact that she didn't wear a corset.
The Love Interest - Sucked. I knew there would be an eventual romance between the two and I could not stick around for it.
I will not be rating this book. I probably will not be picking up anything else by this author.
I do not recommend this book. At all.
January 18, 2021
Excellent western historical romance novel about a young girl who comes to live as a ward with a wealthy widow and her son. The book follows her life story. I enjoyed it.
March 9, 2021
This book has a lovely cover though that's all that it really has going for it. I'm confused why the ratings are so high. I normally don't bother finishing books that I dislike so I don't rate that many books 1 star. For some reason I kept going with this one though I did skim large portions, especially the ending because I was so over it by that point.
We first meet Hattie Taylor when she's eleven years old when she is taken in by distant family, Augusta and her son, Jake. Though he is over a decade older, it's obvious that Jake is the love interest in this book. And their relationship feels inappropriate and disturbing right from the beginning. Hattie's friend, Moses would have been a more appropriate love interest though I quite liked Nell. Anyway, Moses doesn't turn out to be all that great either. All of the men in this book are horrible, except Doc.
I wrote the book off as an outdated romance novel based on the beginning. As it went on and we got the perspectives of more women, I did feel like maybe Susan Anderson was interested in exploring the brutal lives that women faced in early 1900s America. And that is definitely an important part of the book. However, the questionable romance plots really take away from a feminist reading of Hattie's story. There's just so much wrong here.
I was also annoyed by the constant narration pointing out how beautiful and smart and kind Hattie was though she was completely oblivious to it herself. Really made me roll my eyes. I can't believe this was published in 2021. Reads like a 70s bodice ripper.
We first meet Hattie Taylor when she's eleven years old when she is taken in by distant family, Augusta and her son, Jake. Though he is over a decade older, it's obvious that Jake is the love interest in this book. And their relationship feels inappropriate and disturbing right from the beginning. Hattie's friend, Moses would have been a more appropriate love interest though I quite liked Nell. Anyway, Moses doesn't turn out to be all that great either. All of the men in this book are horrible, except Doc.
I wrote the book off as an outdated romance novel based on the beginning. As it went on and we got the perspectives of more women, I did feel like maybe Susan Anderson was interested in exploring the brutal lives that women faced in early 1900s America. And that is definitely an important part of the book. However, the questionable romance plots really take away from a feminist reading of Hattie's story. There's just so much wrong here.
I was also annoyed by the constant narration pointing out how beautiful and smart and kind Hattie was though she was completely oblivious to it herself. Really made me roll my eyes. I can't believe this was published in 2021. Reads like a 70s bodice ripper.
December 19, 2020
Let me first start off by saying that this book really should come with trigger warnings. From the synopsis I had not expected for some of the content to be so explicit and could potentially be hard for some people to read.
Hattie Taylor is anything but typical for her time period, she is spunky, free spirited and outspoken. Jake, her aunts son is married and off limits though Hattie can’t help but love him. After years in a loveless marriage and after the death of his wife Jake feels something between him and Hattie transition. While trying to protect her he actually but her at risk and soon Hattie sees where women really stand in society.
Though there is so much of this book that made me cringe due to the time frame it is written in, I really had a hard time when Hattie became harmed and at risk. I have no doubt there are a lot of people who will appreciate this book and the way it was written. I really loved Hatties character and was rooting for her the whole time.
Thank you Netgalley and Berkley for my ARC!
July 7, 2021
I really wanted to like this one…the whole thing is just icky. The main love interest (who is her cousin might I add, probably normal for the time period but still a little yuck) basically raised the main character while she was growing up, then he falls in love with her and attempts to sleep with her less than 48 hours after his wife dies. The romance and sexy scenes are both so weirdly written and cringey that they made me feel physically sick. The premise of the book and the pretty cover are so misleading. This book is no Anne of Green Gables might I tell you! Read with caution! I definitely under no circumstance would recommend to a friend.
It gets 2 stars for the sole reason that I liked aunt Augusta.
It gets 2 stars for the sole reason that I liked aunt Augusta.
January 6, 2021
The Ballad of Hattie Taylor is one of the best books I have read in a long time. Miss Andersen has always written contemporary books and was a little worried at first I wouldn’t like the book. Boy was I wrong, I was hooked after the first page. It starts with Hattie only 11 and all the changes she had to do from moving from a mining camp to a small town to complete strangers. All her journey in the book was wonderful. Won’t tell you any more as I don’t like spoilers in reviews. Just saying pick up this book and enjoy the ride. Thank you Susan Anderson for another great read
January 15, 2021
I loved this book. There are so many big issues and big feelings and emotions that have to be dealt with. There was so much real life tragedy that Hattie and Jake had to overcome. Beating the odds and dealing with massive trauma and trying to navigate life afterward just made the end result that much better!
January 11, 2021
Great Story
I think women will appreciate this story because it shows how much things have changed and how some things haven't. I loved the characters I could picture them in my mind, I felt like I knew them
I think women will appreciate this story because it shows how much things have changed and how some things haven't. I loved the characters I could picture them in my mind, I felt like I knew them
January 24, 2021
Historical fiction set at the beginning of the 20th century. A coming-of-age story about an independent young woman who faces an unexpected tragedy. Wonderful realistic characters and early 1900s atmosphere.
January 13, 2021
As reviewed at Roses Are Blue: https://wp.me/p3QRh4-1qg
After Hattie Taylor’s mother died, she was raised by her father, and his partner, both miners. This resulted in Hattie growing up with a colorful vocabulary, as well as not having a clue about how to act as a young lady. When she turned eleven, her father died, and she was sent to live with distant cousins in Oregon. Hattie struggled to learn to fit in to her new life, though she did well in school, and soaked up knowledge like a sponge. Still, her forthright manner didn’t let her have any female friends, and she only had one male friend while growing up. She came to love her new family, and they, her. She was particularly fond of Jake, and planned to marry him when she grew up.
Jacob Murdock is a young lawyer and ranch owner. When he learned that his mother planned to bring orphaned Hattie into their household, he was unsure at first. From the moment Jake picked Hattie up at the train station, he liked her, and soon grew to love her as a sister. Her frankness and curiosity amused and entertained him, and Jake was always willing to spend time with Hattie, answering her questions, and giving her advice. Being eleven years older, Jake didn’t realize that Hattie’s feelings were turning to a crush that would turn into love. Jake had been courting a local lady, Jane-Ellen, and they married not long after Hattie’s arrival.
Though Hattie had every intention of disliking the woman who captured Jake, she finds Jane-Ellen to be sweet and kind, and the two become fast friends. What doesn’t work out, however, is Jake’s marriage. Jake is a very sexual man, who was very disappointed to find his new wife has an aversion to intimacy. Her coldness in the bedroom is such a contrast from her warmth in every other facet of her personality, and it makes Jake truly miserable, and sends him on a path I found truly disappointing. Years into their marriage, Jane-Ellen finally becomes pregnant, and they are both ecstatic about the upcoming birth of their child. Before the child is born, tragedy happens, and the aftermath will set in motion another horrific event which will change Hattie’s life forever.
THE BALLAD OF HATTIE TAYLOR is a departure from what I usually read, as it encompasses the story of Hattie from an eleven year old child to her becoming an adult in her twenties, then giving a glimpse of her even more distant future. I love her spirit, her strength, and her resilience, as she bounced back time and again from the hard knocks she had to endure. A particularly devastating event may have wounded her greatly, but she was eventually able to stand up and move on with her life, becoming a successful teacher, earning the respect of the townspeople who formerly looked down on her, and finding the love of her life. THE BALLAD OF HATTIE TAYLOR is very well written, and held my attention, yet, there was so much tragedy, that I found I couldn’t feel uplifted, even with the happy ever after. I also found it hard to accept certain acts by the hero, which lessened my pleasure in the book. I believe that readers who enjoy a coming of age story, and aren’t averse to major traumatic events will enjoy this story which takes place at the beginning of the 20th century. I am adding an additional paragraph which absolutely contains spoilers for those who may be interested to know what pushed my buttons. If you do not want that much information, please don’t read the following…
SPOILER ALERT – Rape is a trigger for many readers, and THE BALLAD OF HATTIE TAYLOR contains a brutal attack on the main character by a vile and evil man who believes himself entitled to put every woman in her place. This action is particularly awful because the hero indirectly was responsible for its occurrence by refusing to listen to Hattie’s fears. In addition, the hero was repeatedly unfaithful to his first wife, something that made me question his ability to remain faithful to Hattie. There is also a heartbreaking death of a child, still in the womb.
After Hattie Taylor’s mother died, she was raised by her father, and his partner, both miners. This resulted in Hattie growing up with a colorful vocabulary, as well as not having a clue about how to act as a young lady. When she turned eleven, her father died, and she was sent to live with distant cousins in Oregon. Hattie struggled to learn to fit in to her new life, though she did well in school, and soaked up knowledge like a sponge. Still, her forthright manner didn’t let her have any female friends, and she only had one male friend while growing up. She came to love her new family, and they, her. She was particularly fond of Jake, and planned to marry him when she grew up.
Jacob Murdock is a young lawyer and ranch owner. When he learned that his mother planned to bring orphaned Hattie into their household, he was unsure at first. From the moment Jake picked Hattie up at the train station, he liked her, and soon grew to love her as a sister. Her frankness and curiosity amused and entertained him, and Jake was always willing to spend time with Hattie, answering her questions, and giving her advice. Being eleven years older, Jake didn’t realize that Hattie’s feelings were turning to a crush that would turn into love. Jake had been courting a local lady, Jane-Ellen, and they married not long after Hattie’s arrival.
Though Hattie had every intention of disliking the woman who captured Jake, she finds Jane-Ellen to be sweet and kind, and the two become fast friends. What doesn’t work out, however, is Jake’s marriage. Jake is a very sexual man, who was very disappointed to find his new wife has an aversion to intimacy. Her coldness in the bedroom is such a contrast from her warmth in every other facet of her personality, and it makes Jake truly miserable, and sends him on a path I found truly disappointing. Years into their marriage, Jane-Ellen finally becomes pregnant, and they are both ecstatic about the upcoming birth of their child. Before the child is born, tragedy happens, and the aftermath will set in motion another horrific event which will change Hattie’s life forever.
THE BALLAD OF HATTIE TAYLOR is a departure from what I usually read, as it encompasses the story of Hattie from an eleven year old child to her becoming an adult in her twenties, then giving a glimpse of her even more distant future. I love her spirit, her strength, and her resilience, as she bounced back time and again from the hard knocks she had to endure. A particularly devastating event may have wounded her greatly, but she was eventually able to stand up and move on with her life, becoming a successful teacher, earning the respect of the townspeople who formerly looked down on her, and finding the love of her life. THE BALLAD OF HATTIE TAYLOR is very well written, and held my attention, yet, there was so much tragedy, that I found I couldn’t feel uplifted, even with the happy ever after. I also found it hard to accept certain acts by the hero, which lessened my pleasure in the book. I believe that readers who enjoy a coming of age story, and aren’t averse to major traumatic events will enjoy this story which takes place at the beginning of the 20th century. I am adding an additional paragraph which absolutely contains spoilers for those who may be interested to know what pushed my buttons. If you do not want that much information, please don’t read the following…
SPOILER ALERT – Rape is a trigger for many readers, and THE BALLAD OF HATTIE TAYLOR contains a brutal attack on the main character by a vile and evil man who believes himself entitled to put every woman in her place. This action is particularly awful because the hero indirectly was responsible for its occurrence by refusing to listen to Hattie’s fears. In addition, the hero was repeatedly unfaithful to his first wife, something that made me question his ability to remain faithful to Hattie. There is also a heartbreaking death of a child, still in the womb.
January 1, 2021
Definitely trigger warnings to be addressed: rape, sexual assault, violence, chauvinism, graphic sexual depictions, child death, death, stillborn
Thank you to the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange of an honest review. Before reading this, remember that this book is set in the early 1900’s in Oregon. While this has some historical aspects, you often feel like you are reading a present day story.
This book is about Hattie, an 11 year old girl taken in by a very very distant aunt to teach her how to be a young lady of the times. She meets Augusta’s son Jake and her best friend Moses Marks. This is a story about a young girl growing, finding herself and living in a world where women are more about being seen and less about being heard.
I highly recommend that you go into this one with a very open mind. Some people will be appalled and this will not work for them. However some people will find how this is so relevant to today’s society and the current #MeToo movement. I will admit that there were times when I was disgusted and didn’t want to see what happened, but I needed to know. Plus this was for all those women that can’t or couldn’t tell their story because of the view society would have on them.
I will say that some reviews discuss how appalled women have been reading this, but I found it to be very true and honest and accurate for the lives and views that some women have. For example, a young woman gets raped yet still finds it in her to be commanded and be risky with her husband later on as he exerts control in a way they agree on.
So I think that this story fits with the time that it takes place. However I feel like you have to have an open mind to get through this book. I devoured it needing to read more and more. The writing was quirky and I did love the characters. Hattie was full of life and energy. I only gave it 4 stars because I felt it a little long and wordy with descriptions at some points. Other than that this is a book that you will either love and need more or not feel comfortable reading. I enjoyed it very much.
Thank you to the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange of an honest review. Before reading this, remember that this book is set in the early 1900’s in Oregon. While this has some historical aspects, you often feel like you are reading a present day story.
This book is about Hattie, an 11 year old girl taken in by a very very distant aunt to teach her how to be a young lady of the times. She meets Augusta’s son Jake and her best friend Moses Marks. This is a story about a young girl growing, finding herself and living in a world where women are more about being seen and less about being heard.
I highly recommend that you go into this one with a very open mind. Some people will be appalled and this will not work for them. However some people will find how this is so relevant to today’s society and the current #MeToo movement. I will admit that there were times when I was disgusted and didn’t want to see what happened, but I needed to know. Plus this was for all those women that can’t or couldn’t tell their story because of the view society would have on them.
I will say that some reviews discuss how appalled women have been reading this, but I found it to be very true and honest and accurate for the lives and views that some women have. For example, a young woman gets raped yet still finds it in her to be commanded and be risky with her husband later on as he exerts control in a way they agree on.
So I think that this story fits with the time that it takes place. However I feel like you have to have an open mind to get through this book. I devoured it needing to read more and more. The writing was quirky and I did love the characters. Hattie was full of life and energy. I only gave it 4 stars because I felt it a little long and wordy with descriptions at some points. Other than that this is a book that you will either love and need more or not feel comfortable reading. I enjoyed it very much.
April 7, 2023
I would say this is more historical fiction with romantic elements as opposed to a historical romance. Hattie was such a spitfire right from the first moment we met her, you can't help but root for her. All the women, Nell. Agusta, Mirabel, Opal, were amazing. This is definitely more of a story about women's rights and purity culture in the early 1900s.
The men in this book were harder to like. While I'm sure Jake and Moses are very historically accurate in thier attitudes and actions for the time, it's not what I've come to expect with the newer historical romance heroes. While I haven't read too many old school historicals, I would imagine they are similar to what you would find in them even though it was written in 2021
The men in this book were harder to like. While I'm sure Jake and Moses are very historically accurate in thier attitudes and actions for the time, it's not what I've come to expect with the newer historical romance heroes. While I haven't read too many old school historicals, I would imagine they are similar to what you would find in them even though it was written in 2021
March 22, 2021
Review to come.
Read
January 11, 2021The Ballad of Hattie Taylor by Susan Anderson is exactly what I needed. Think Anne of Green Gables meets Bridgerton - can you think of anything better?
Even though this is classified as a historical romance, moral and social change drive the story as much as the compelling relationship of the main characters, Hattie Taylor and Jake Murdock.
I loved the strong presence of feminist values intertwined with the intricacies and tough scenarios women faced then and still face today.
This novel is a true Bildungsroman dealing with a woman’s formative years that left me turning the pages deep into the night.
Released on January 5th, I highly suggest picking this one up as soon as possible!
Thank you to @berkleypub, @penguinrandomhouse, and @netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this book.
Even though this is classified as a historical romance, moral and social change drive the story as much as the compelling relationship of the main characters, Hattie Taylor and Jake Murdock.
I loved the strong presence of feminist values intertwined with the intricacies and tough scenarios women faced then and still face today.
This novel is a true Bildungsroman dealing with a woman’s formative years that left me turning the pages deep into the night.
Released on January 5th, I highly suggest picking this one up as soon as possible!
Thank you to @berkleypub, @penguinrandomhouse, and @netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this book.
March 25, 2021
In 2021 still facing certain injustices as a woman, we often forget what it was like for women in the early 1900's when this book takes place, and what they had to endure. If you enjoy historical romance and are fans of Lisa Kleypas and Julia Quinn be warned, this is not that type of story. For our main character, Hattie Taylor, this book is a lot of things; coming of age, injustices of women, sexual assault, and a story of healing and ultimately finding love and the enjoyment of sex between a husband and wife by the end. I can understand why this book would be a problem for some, but I think Hattie's story was simply amazing and worth the read.
June 14, 2022
I only finished this read as it was the only one downloaded on my phone for a flight.
*Spoilers* and also my honest opinion!
The blurb is way off base - the cover does not match the book. In this case, the cover, which is stunning, is significantly better than the absolute trash that this book passes itself off as.
Where to start?
This books tries to be woman forward in a 'bleak time', but it really misses the mark. It waste's a wonderful setting, Oregon is always stunning and is completely overlooked here, but worse than that, it takes the worse parts of a time period and applies them in a horrific way to a story. The central focus of the story is on a young woman, Hattie Taylor, who is ripped off of Anne Shirley mets Laura Ingles in the wild west, but everything is a dumpster fire, and nothing works. Hattie is raped, but somehow the Male protagonist/love interest (who up until her death, has been forcing himself on his uninterested wife?) makes it about him and his failings. There are so many historical inaccuracies that I would weep if that would get this book out of my eyes.
This books has everything you don't want - rape, internalized shame, shame on women as they clearly 'asked for it', horrific depictions of what may be asexuality - or at the very least unwanted sexual contact from your spouse, and them 'claiming what is theirs', with weird almost grooming elements, a truly awful attempt at being 'forward' but actually just further marginalizing women, men making everything about them, and really weird understandings of law and how medical systems work.
I would have given it a bog, fat zero, but as I can't, I gave it a one.
Don't waste your time. Absolute TRASH.
*Spoilers* and also my honest opinion!
The blurb is way off base - the cover does not match the book. In this case, the cover, which is stunning, is significantly better than the absolute trash that this book passes itself off as.
Where to start?
This books tries to be woman forward in a 'bleak time', but it really misses the mark. It waste's a wonderful setting, Oregon is always stunning and is completely overlooked here, but worse than that, it takes the worse parts of a time period and applies them in a horrific way to a story. The central focus of the story is on a young woman, Hattie Taylor, who is ripped off of Anne Shirley mets Laura Ingles in the wild west, but everything is a dumpster fire, and nothing works. Hattie is raped, but somehow the Male protagonist/love interest (who up until her death, has been forcing himself on his uninterested wife?) makes it about him and his failings. There are so many historical inaccuracies that I would weep if that would get this book out of my eyes.
This books has everything you don't want - rape, internalized shame, shame on women as they clearly 'asked for it', horrific depictions of what may be asexuality - or at the very least unwanted sexual contact from your spouse, and them 'claiming what is theirs', with weird almost grooming elements, a truly awful attempt at being 'forward' but actually just further marginalizing women, men making everything about them, and really weird understandings of law and how medical systems work.
I would have given it a bog, fat zero, but as I can't, I gave it a one.
Don't waste your time. Absolute TRASH.
November 2, 2020
First, I will say this book is compulsively readable. I wanted to see what happened from the first page to the last. That being said, this read like Anne of Green Gables fan fic written by someone who also enjoys an occasional cowboy romance paperback. No shame in that! But it can't be denied that between Hattie - a strong-willed red headed orphan with charm to spare, her beautiful and level-headed raven-haired best friend, Nell, and her best childhood friend, Moses - the Anne of Green Gables derivatives cannot be denied. The evil Roger Lord is a caricature and the only thing missing was him twirling his mustache. I wanted to love this book because it has its charms. If you want to read about Anne with an E getting laid, this is the book for you!
Read
November 25, 2020I enjoyed this book and I loved Hattie and her independence and disregard for the opinions of others. I also loved the emotional development and relationship development. Some of the characters in this book seemed way ahead of their time while others, Roger Lord especially, seemed insanely behind- emphasis on insane. I would highly recommend changing the blurb for the book. It doesn't match the book at all and gave me a different idea of what the book would be about until I started reading it. Advanced copy from NetGalley, thank you!
October 5, 2021
As other reviewers commented, the synopsis is misleading and there are some elements I had not expected and disliked. Maybe that is my fault as the setting of the Wild West and the title of a ballad could indicate some bawdy scenes; nevertheless, I feel the descriptive details of bedroom scenes cheapened the historical content and one woman's struggle against the redhead stereotype. Hattie Taylor is an interesting character and her life in the 1900's is accurately pictured in regards to society values and the role of women. Hattie,arrives as a twelve-year-old orphan and is raised by a distant relative in a ranching town. She is loved by those she interacts with, but the towns folk cannot accept her "wild ways." The main characters are well to do and the setting changes between their home in town and their ranch. In the town, bad things happen to good girls, single or married, as they are at the mercy of males. Hattie is resourceful, determined, and will not conform to the norms inflicted on her by a patriarchal society. Virginity is highly priced, so it is no surprise that a prominent resident sets out to put Hattie in her place. Unfortunately, most men, other than her older cousin and the doctor, do not get a good report in this novel. This was disappointing because I cannot believe that all men were of the same caliber.
February 11, 2021
I have to admit I was a little worried about reading this book after reading some of the other reviews. However, I was hooked from beginning to end. The characters are all well-developed and believable. They are flawed, but for the most part extremely likable (with one exception, the “villain”, who was abhorrent). The story deals with some tough subjects, but concentrates on Hattie’s resilience in overcoming the hardships and circumstances, rather than letting them destroy her sense of worth. I enjoyed Hattie’s strong yet vulnerable personality, and was rooting for her the entire time to get her happy ending.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews