I loved WATERSHIP DOWN; I enjoyed TALES FROM WATERSHIP DOWN. As the long-awaited continuation to Adams's original novel, it is only a sequel in the sense that it uses the same setting, motifs, and characters. Because trying to continue the plot of WATERSHIP DOWN would have been anticlimactic and, frankly, a crime, TALES reads more like a collection of rabbit folklore. The first part of the book is a juxtaposition of Adams's rabbit folklore mostly featuring the rabbit folklore hero El-ahrairah (but "The Rabbit's Ghost Story" is of exceptional note). Part II tells the stories of the journey home for El-ahrairah and his faithful companion Rabscuttle after seeking the aide of the Black Rabbit of Inle (told in the novel WATERSHIP). My favorite part, however, was Part III, which told additional stories about and provided more insight into the lives of the rabbits of Watership Down. This part makes the book worth reading, if only to revisit the characters of the original novel and meet some new ones. Of interesting note is the expanded role does play in these stories; WATERSHIP DOWN has been heavily criticized by some as sexist, chauvinistic, and inaccurate (rabbits form matriarchal societies, not patriarchal ones as depicted in the original novel). Whether a response to the critics or just a sign of the changing times (TALES was published in the 1990s, 20+ years after the original novel), the attention given to the female rabbit perspective on life in Watership Down only helps to better round out the intimate world Adams has crafted. -107 words to Super Review
Super! I loved WATERSHIP DOWN; I enjoyed TALES FROM WATERSHIP DOWN. As the long-awaited continuation to Adams's original novel, it is only a sequel in the sense that it uses the same setting, motifs, and characters. Because trying to continue the plot of WATERSHIP DOWN would have been anticlimactic and, frankly, a crime, TALES reads more like a collection of rabbit folklore. The first part of the book is a juxtaposition of Adams's rabbit folklore mostly featuring the rabbit folklore hero El-ahrairah (but "The Rabbit's Ghost Story" is of exceptional note). Part II tells the stories of the journey home for El-ahrairah and his faithful companion Rabscuttle after seeking the aide of the Black Rabbit of Inle (told in the novel WATERSHIP). My favorite part, however, was Part III, which told additional stories about and provided more insight into the lives of the rabbits of Watership Down. This part makes the book worth reading, if only to revisit the characters of the original novel and meet some new ones. Of interesting note is the expanded role does play in these stories; WATERSHIP DOWN has been heavily criticized by some as sexist, chauvinistic, and inaccurate (rabbits form matriarchal societies, not patriarchal ones as depicted in the original novel). Whether a response to the critics or just a sign of the changing times (TALES was published in the 1990s, 20+ years after the original novel), the attention given to the female rabbit perspective on life in Watership Down only helps to better round out the intimate world Adams has crafted.