'Mystery of Smugglers Cove' (The Hardy Boys Mystery Stories #64) by Franklin W. Dixon.
Rating: 3.25/5.
Disclaimer:
This was my first time reading this book. I have, probably, read the first 63 Hardy Boys books multiple times, but the same can not be said for the subsequent books in the series. It isn't because I'm partial to the Originals, but more so because the latter books were hard to find growing up. However, with the advent of digital books in recent times, I'm eager to pursue my childhood ambition of reading all 190 Hardy Boys books at least once.
The Hardy Boys books are a nostalgic affair. Had it not been for these books, it would have been difficult for me to cultivate my interest in reading and to later expand my reading preferences to include the fantasy and sci-fi genres. So, yeah, that's the main reason why you would rarely find me giving a rating of fewer than 3.5 stars (out of 5) to these Hardy Boys books.
Review:
As mentioned earlier, I rarely give a rating below 3.5 stars for the Hardy Boys books, but this book tested all of my patience. Simply put, even as a hardcore Hardy Boys fan who often dwells in nostalgia, this book failed to captivate my interest.
The Hardy Boys books aren't known for convoluted plotlines, and most of the time, they do have a straightforward plot. It's the same with this book, too, but the plot simply feels lackluster, even for a Hardy Boys storyline. The books contain two of the Hardy Boys' chums (which is always a welcome addition), but they didn't have as much of an active involvement in the plot as I would have preferred.
The book tries hard to maintain the mystery around the main boss' secret identity until the end. But, unfortunately, the main antagonist's identity is easily predictable right from the moment he is introduced in the book. The ending felt a bit rushed and far too convenient. But the climax, with the alligators and the moat, was an enjoyable affair to read. The action sequences interspersed with the trademark cliffhangers in between the chapters made up for the book's deficiencies to some extent.
That's it, then. Although this book didn't feel as good as the earlier Hardy Boys books, it still succeeded in transporting me back to the world and characters I loved while growing up. I do hope that if and when I do re-read this book, I end up enjoying it more than the first time around. On to the next one, then!