COMPLETE REVIEW (for the whole "Hills of Silver Ruins", which comprises books #13 to #16)
After reading all 1200 pages, 374k words of this novel, I can tell you DO NOT READ THIS BOOK. Do not get invested in this story, in Gyousou or Taiki. Do NOT give this book a chance. You WILL be disappointed.
The first two parts of this four part novel drag like a slug. Nothing ever happens and you have to read over and over again that nothing ever happens and how that frustrates the protagonists. But then you push through because in part 3 everything starts moving and you're excited because Gyousou is back on scene and Taiki got political power again and you can see the story's climax coming with fireworks.
But it won't. There will be a bang, but off-screen. Spoilers ahead, who cares: after enduring what Asen does while usurping the throne, after all his crimes, his cruelty, his selfishness, he loses his battle off-screen. You have five chapters of characters deciding (one by one) to die in their last stand and then another five of them reuniting with characters that were never present in the story to begin with. And then, THEN, the book ends. A throwaway line at the end-summary these books have will tell you he lost and Gyousou is back on the throne and that's it. You won't get a satisfying ending, you won't even see the emperor and his usurper talk or interact. You won't even see Gyousou and Taiki interact beyond a "hey, you have grown".
1200 pages. 374 thousand words. I read all that, I invested all that time, I was expecting a satisfying ending, but I didn't even get a proper ending. I think Fuyumi Ono has no idea how to structure a novel and should go back to reading what a climax is. This book is so badly structured that it left me thinking that the genius behind the structure of book 3 that I loved so much wasn't there, it was just a fluke. After reading all nine books of the Twelve Kingdoms saga, I think I'm done with this author. I know there aren't any more books to read after this, but I won't even check if another one gets published.
This was the disappointment of the decade for me.
Ah! And one more thing: something I loved about this world was that motherhood wasn't a thing. Babies are born out of trees, so there are no gender roles. These books were populated by strong women that occupied the same spaces and held the same power as men. But in this book, not only 5% of the characters are women, you constantly hear that men have to fight to protect "women and children". This wasn't a thing! I was promised a world without gender roles. Why are suddenly women incapable of fighting? Why are they relegated to care for the children? What happened to you, Ono-sensei?