Personal Opinion : Look, I don't want to sound harsh but the ending took me off guard in a bad way.
I'm not gonna lie, I fell in love with the description. It was so good and I was captivated by it. I remember telling myself : "This is it! This is going to be my next favorite series!" And yeah, turns out it sorta didn't fall into my fav category in the end, and I'll like to tell you why.
First and foremost. I am truly disappointed as to how.... simple the writing was. Especially in terms of description. Hey, it is a science-fiction-fantasy Ya book. I expect more details about the places that were introduced throughout the plot. (For instance, the Island that I was kept reminded of? About how fascinating the place was, how glamorous?) Well honestly, I didn't get that feeling. This book has left me many blanks to fill in with my own imagination. (And that's probably fine with some people, but to me, frankly I think it's incomplete.) I just wished there were more descriptions.
But of course, to balance that lack of background description, there were lots of monologues from Maia that really got me to be able to relate to her. For example in the second book, everyone turned against her and there was one part where she thought to herself since no one took her word for the truth and tried to believe her, she decided to become the villain whom everyone kinda just expects she is. That reminded me of the Darkling from Shadow and Bones where he said one line that will be forever etched in my mind : "Fine. Make me your villain." It was on that spur of the moment, where I actually felt sympathy for Maia, where my heart would really break for her and for all the things that she'd been through. Because she's tough, and she's proved it.
Next, Maia. How do I put this? Just explain to me, how could you fall in love with a character in the first and second book, only to want to ditch the third because of how let-down she or he turned out to be? Yes, I used to love Maia, mainly in the first book. She gave me the feeling of being stubborn but not too stubborn, brave at some point but know when to cower. She's not like a boring heroine where she thinks she's the law. And it was truly enjoyable to read about her. I like in particular where she spilled out her past to Rise. It was sad but moving. She was....sad, mad, in some way.
Yet at some point in the third book, I was shocked at how much she changed! And it was out of the blue. I do recognize at the point, she was the face of the rebellion against the emperor and cause of the survival of humanity. Yet... I felt like there's too much romance getting in the way of the third book that completely made me think that Maia has some serious if not worrisome trust issues about Riser. In short, I just don't think she's putting her head in the game. You know? Basically about actually finding where her father stashed his precious creation? I honestly felt that she was being childish, if not irksome. She's just not a leader I would imagine putting my faith into when I'm practically in the middle of a major crisis between life and death.
Furthermore. What is with the love-triangle between the Gold prince, Dark prince and Maia? I get why Riser and Maia fell in love with each other (not really) after all they've been through. But what does the Caspian have to do with this romance, if not other than to create distance between Riser and Maia? I mean, for heaven's sake! He's never met her! And their first contact was only through a bloody letter. So suddenly after reading what Maia has to say, he's all over the heels of her. It began so suddenly and ended so quickly. That is correct, I meant that Caspian actually sacrificed his life for "the greater good." And I don't think anybody really wept for him. Well it was understandable cause doomsday still looms ahead of them, I don't suppose how anybody's gonna spare some time to cry over him.
Finally, which might sound weird when I bring it out. And that'll be the timeline of the entire story. How many of you agree that the time flow of this story is considerably confusing? From the very beginning, we know that Maia has 552 hours which I think in the book, mentioned less than 3 weeks left. (So about 2 weeks and a half) I just can't imagine how the entire plot was fitted into these remaining days.
First, they've gotta prepare for the assassination which is what the entire first book talked about. Then at the ending, Maia was imprisoned by the emperor because her assassination attempt failed. Right from the start of the second book, we know that Maia has been tortured. I don't recall it mentioning how long she has been in a bad state, but the impression it gave me was at least a week. Otherwise, I couldn't see how exactly tragic Maia was under the hands of her torturer. Keep Up, now the following plot includes how she escaped, how she squeezed herself into the rebel's camp and how she managed to win the Blood Trails. (Pardon me, I don't remember what it's called) And that was only the plot of the second book.
See what I mean there? I don't understand if it's just me who doesn't have a good grip of the time and it's concept or the book is just doing a terrible job trying to bombard all the details in a short span of time.
To sum up, it was not all bad. But it surely wasn't what I was anticipating. Not enough thrills. Not nearly exciting enough. And the romance (or love-triangle if you put Caspian in the picture) was more or less one in the eye for me. Nevertheless, these are all my personal thoughts and everybody has a different perspective.