"Timing the market" is a cliche phrase that I will attach to this review; it was released at the perfect time. It was released during the pinnacle moments of the Covid19 pandemic, particularly where the West was in need of gulps of hope. It was timed perfectly at its release. Many books contain wisdom and this one has a lot of it. It is very possible that readers depart this book feeling like they are equipped with better strategies on how to relate with their child and parent them. Hopefully this review does not discourage you from reading this book. There is a lot of wisdom here. As a professional educator that hopes to become a parent in the near future, I even found myself applying some of the insights in this book into the profession. Why does this book earn one star from my reading experience?
Education and the profession of teaching are exactly where this book earns its 1 star. Before I dive into this point, I need to get readers of this review imagining. I will then link it to Jonathon Swift and his A Modest Proposal and then come out with my point at the end. Please stay with me --if you want-- because I try to make my case all come together at the end of this review.
Imagine, for a moment, reading a statement like this: "you do not need to be a doctor in order to perform surgery on your child." This is a shocking statement that may evoke images of boiling babies in Jonathon Swift's A Modest Proposal. So parents do not need to be a doctors in order to perform surgery on their child(ren). Go ahead, diagnose, and cut them open, because you know your child best. This statement stands on this pillar (knowing thy child best). There is another pillar it stands on and lets explore it further (start boiling the water, sweet cakes).
Imagine with me for a moment that I then started to make generalized statements about hospitals and institutions where surgeons work: hospitals are noxious to patients. Hospitals are ill-equipped because they do not have enough resources to tailor to the needs of individual patients. Hospitals use dated approaches to doctoring. Hospitals do not meet the diverse needs of patients. In fact, so many patients are let down in hospitals and live less due to human error, particularly doctor fault. Hospitals are dangerous places for patients; this is why you do need to be a doctor to perform surgery on your child and why you do not need to be a professional doctor to do so. Get the baby ready for the pot of water. He is wailing, as Swift writes in A Modest Proposal.
Clarification is needed because I concern myself with some employer or principal reading this review and my digital footprint on Goodreads: written in the 2 paragraphs above are attempts at satire. Jonathon Swift did write a satire that mentions the boiling of babies to strengthen his point. My attempt may not mirror a professional scholar such as Swift. Thus stated, I will say this boldly: the paragraph above this one reflects the author's argument about teachers and schools! And what boils my baby is that the author pigeon holes all schools, and strongly advocates for parents being the educators for their children instead of professional certified teachers themselves. This evokes a "Pass the knife, hun. Lets cut her open because I think she is sick on the knee with a bruise" image in my cogs that cannot be removed.
Only in emergency situations or if the parent is a professional themselves may I ever suggest that a parent perform surgery on their child. Why do I NOT suggest that a parent does surgery on their child? For multiple reasons: 1) there is little to no evidentiary support for such a ridiculous claim. 2) to keep with the author's claim about not needing to be a professional, the parents are not formally trained in surgical procedures towards children. 3) These claims I am making are likely to anger doctors, just like it angered me as a teacher when the author makes claims about school systems and teachers just like I made claims about doctors above.
The sad, sad, sad thing about this book making the statement that parents do not need to be professionals to teach their children is that it provided absolutely no evidence to support such a claim. There is evidence to suggest that parents can homeschool.. There is scholarship that argues for and proves the benefits of homeschooling for children, but the author cites nothing. I am not suggesting that homeschooling is bad or that there are 0 benefits to it. There are and the research says so. However, this author clearly did not do her homework to prove her bold claim about "not needing to be a professional teacher to teach their child."
Had the author cited sources and proved to me that she actually did the research about her bold claim, then this book is easily a 5 star read. I am all for hearing other perspectives that are supported with research. There are many moments in this book where the author does provide solid evidence for her parenting strategies, but her education part, generally, is meek, and the part where she boldly claims that parents can just educate their child and not need be professional teachers to do so is baseless. In essence, Rickman claims that parents can do surgery on their child because hospitals are terrible and parents know their children best. This is fallacious logic.
Faulty logic and fallacious thinking need to be challenged. There are dangers that can result if we do not do our job as readers to challenge absurdities, such as reinforcing inaccuracies and misrepresentations in societies about teachers and schools.
I pondered this review for awhile, because I thought, well maybe I can give the author some leeway by chalking her claim about teachers to the struggles of the covid19 pandemic. The more I thought about it though, the more I realized I was trying to rationalize and excuse the author for her logic.
Ultimately, this is the first book I have ever read that earns a 1 star from me. It was great up until the chapter on education at home. And then, my nerves boiled over, and I was reminded about Jonathon Swift's A Modest Proposal.