SPOILER ALERT
This was a mixed bag for me. It enjoyed the first of the series somewhat, and looked forward to this second installment hoping some of the issues with the first would be resolved.. I love a new venue, and the integration of the culture and myths of the Maori of New Zealand augmented the story beautifully as well as the well-done descriptions of the landscape and the atmosphere. The information on whales, sharks, kelp, and the use of scientific names for animals and plants enrich the narrative. And I appreciate most a character-driven story with a good character study and in many ways the protagonist Alexa Glock provides that. Again the issues from the first book are repeated in the second. I had made notes as I read and wrote this review before I went back to re-read my first. It was interesting that my observations were repeated.
While I find Alexa interesting at the same time she is very irritating and frustrating in her immaturity and unprofessionalism, the interference of her childhood and family issues, and her frequent first evaluation of male colleagues as bed partners (even as she is hiking through rough conditions to get to remains). She then gets aroused and lets thoughts of sex mess with her focus.
Alexa is a hothead: she describes her approach as "unorthodox", others see her as uncooperative and working outside the team. She makes quick judgements about the lack of phone service or resources (i.e. uber or lyft) and rudely says "Jesus, what kind of place is this?! This attitude when she was hired to function as a roving forensic through the Forensic Service Center, who will face varied venues as part of her job is incongruous. Further emphasized when she reflects on her fear of the unknown. She is a skillful and talented forensic criminal investigator with the added training in odontology, but she has a blurred view of her role. When she is recognized as a member of the team she interprets that as: I can do it all; the right to go anywhere, make her own decisions and not follow orders, second guess the boss, and she is angry when she is specifically told to stay put. She wants to function as law enforcement, even when she tells herself she is not a police officer. She then rationalizes veering from her orders the minute she can come up with a reason to deviate. It leads to mistakes, and danger for not just her.
In this installment her prior relationship with DI Bruce Horne who is sent in to head the investigation is a problem in her listening and behaving as a subordinate. She worries when he shows up without her knowing he is coming, thinking he might be there to fire her for failing to follow orders. He would not have been in a position to do that, at that point, which points out her wrong thinking. He says he went to Auckland "for a meeting" and she thinks he has come to Stewart Island specifically to see her. She challenges him in why he didn't let her know he was coming. All this in a couple of minutes, and I found it off putting for a 37-year-old to act like a twenty-year-old. When it is announced he is there as the SIO because Sgt. Wallace cannot head a homicide investigation, she calls him by his first name, interrupts and then her mind wanders on what about his children (He has accepted a promotion to Auckland Central, and she is surprised and critical as she doesn't like it when fathers do not put their children first). This is another example of her lack of focus, not listening when information is important. Another example: when hiking to the hunter's body she is told the hunter had a PLB, a personal locator beacon. Later when she told to pick up his device when it has been found she asks what that is. She is consistently dropping her crime kit and her tote that contains her phone, wallet and passport and leaving them. Someone else has to return them to her. She sees it as those items as having minds of their own. She does not see it as a lack of personal accountability.
This lack of insight is further revealed with her thoughts about the death of her new friend Mary who is killed in an automobile accident. She is angry and thinks "someone else leaving her". Mary was the one friend she made in the eight months she had been in New Zealand. She seems a misplaced character, a loner in a job that requires cooperation and relationship building.
The investigation that starts out as an identification of remains of a hunter, Robert King, who had disappeared months before, becomes a double homicide when the remains of a shark ravaged body washes up on the beach. Alexa orders an autopsy (without permission) and it is determined that the man had first been shot before thrown into the sea. The conflict between the cage diving businesses that cater to the tourists (cage diving to view sharks in the wild) that requires chumming to attract the sharks, and the rest of the community which consists of those afraid to enter the water any more and the paua (abalone) divers who risk their lives harvesting is the central issue of the story. Additionally the taking of sharks and teasing them is illegal, but their teeth, jaws and other parts, as well as those of whales, is lucrative and is the motive for the killings in the end. Andy Gray the owner of White Dive Tours was involved in illegal shark parts with another fisherman who was out of work, Sean Warren, and they had a dispute. Robert King had witnessed Warren harvesting the jaws from the beached whales from a year earlier and had been shot to prevent his telling. At the climax, Alexa and Constable Elyse Kopae return to Grays catamaran, the Apex, to get more blood evidence and Kopae is attacked and taken aboard the fishing trawler Darla Jo by Warren. Alexa hears her cries and gets aboard, eventually getting Warren caught in a net and hoisted up, as the police come to the rescue. Then as Horne flies out to finish the investigation, to get Stephen Neville, a ranger who had been accused of the murders, released, Alexa is again devastated that he did not tell her goodbye. She thinks: "pushed her away". As she leaves the island she is unable to voice her thanks or feelings to Nina, Wallace's wife who had been so kind to her. Her final thought: "Sharks should be left in peace, and she should too.
Alexa walked to the stern and leaned into the bracing future." Alexa behaves in this case much as she did in the her first. She learned nothing in this experience and I cannot leave the story thinking that she will face her next assignment with any more insight or that it will be "bracing".
I find that I lose interest in a series in which the character(s) do not grow, learn from their mistakes and gain insight. I will probably try the next in the series, but Alexa will need to mature and change over time or she will simply become boring. That would be unfortunate as the context of this series is fascinating, and the plots creative.