What do you think?
Rate this book
Small Reckonings
John V. Hicks Long Manuscript Award, 2019
Saskatoon Award, 2021 Saskatchewan Book Awards
Glengarry Book Award Jury Short List, Recognition of Literary Excellence, 2021
In the early 20th century, as homesteaders in Saskatchewan are scratching out hard new lives on the Canadian prairie, William, an adventurer from New Zealand, brings his new bride, Louise, to the freshly broken earth of his farm near Watrous.
Physical and emotional isolation take their toll on everyone struggling to survive in the harsh landscape, and when William and Louise's second child, Violet, is born "feebleminded," it plunges Louise-a woman burdened with a dark secret-back into a time of shame and regret, even as the child draws out goodness and loyalty from her neighbours, Hank and Emily.
Then tragedy upends the family, and William, while struggling to raise and protect his daughter and find his way to forgiveness, must come to terms with the fact that no one is infallible.
Saskatoon Award, 2021 Saskatchewan Book Awards
Glengarry Book Award Jury Short List, Recognition of Literary Excellence, 2021
In the early 20th century, as homesteaders in Saskatchewan are scratching out hard new lives on the Canadian prairie, William, an adventurer from New Zealand, brings his new bride, Louise, to the freshly broken earth of his farm near Watrous.
Physical and emotional isolation take their toll on everyone struggling to survive in the harsh landscape, and when William and Louise's second child, Violet, is born "feebleminded," it plunges Louise-a woman burdened with a dark secret-back into a time of shame and regret, even as the child draws out goodness and loyalty from her neighbours, Hank and Emily.
Then tragedy upends the family, and William, while struggling to raise and protect his daughter and find his way to forgiveness, must come to terms with the fact that no one is infallible.
296 pages, Unknown Binding
2 people are currently reading
60 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews
April 9, 2026
Small Reckonings by Karin Melberg Schwier is a captivating novel that immerses readers into a world filled with mystery and emotion. The story begins with Constable Dickenson's unsettling discovery in a dimly lit barn, setting the stage for a suspenseful narrative that unfolds in two different periods.
The book starts with Constable Dickenson as he investigates a disturbing scene in a barn, uncovering the apparent suicide of a man named Nik. However, things aren't what they seem, as Nik's calm demeanor contradicts the typical signs of desperation. This mystery leaves readers questioning the circumstances surrounding his death. The book then proceeded to 1915 Toronto, where William Burke returned after a year of homesteading. He reconnects with Louise, and the story beautifully captures their blossoming relationship and life's challenges on the prairie.
This book was no doubt a fabulous read for me. It excels in its ability to transport readers into the intricate lives of its characters. The vivid descriptions of the rural setting and the emotional depth of the characters make it a truly immersive read. Violet's story added depth to the storyline of the book. The author's skillful storytelling and the ability to evoke empathy for the characters' struggles are commendable. The themes of human connection, resilience, and the complexities of rural life are skillfully interwoven.
While this book excels In character development and atmosphere, some readers may find the pacing slow at times. The pacing can also be leisurely, requiring patience to uncover the full depth of the characters and their stories. I also did not like the fact that they were no table of content in this book. I found it difficult to locate the pages I stopped at while I was reading this book, especially considering the lengthy nature of the book. I did not see any error in this book, which shows that it was expertly edited.
I rate this book four out of five stars. I deducted one star from this book book due to the issue already listed in the previous paragraph. This book covered themes of the resilience of individuals in the face of adversity, the power of human connection, love, loss, the impact of the past on the present, motherhood, pain, and growth.
This captivating novel will enthrall readers who appreciate suspenseful storytelling, intricate character development, and emotionally charged narratives. If you enjoy books that seamlessly weave together different timelines and explore the depths of human emotion, this book is a must-read. Be prepared for a journey that unfolds slowly but rewards your patience with a compelling and thought-provoking narrative. This will be a great read for you.
The book starts with Constable Dickenson as he investigates a disturbing scene in a barn, uncovering the apparent suicide of a man named Nik. However, things aren't what they seem, as Nik's calm demeanor contradicts the typical signs of desperation. This mystery leaves readers questioning the circumstances surrounding his death. The book then proceeded to 1915 Toronto, where William Burke returned after a year of homesteading. He reconnects with Louise, and the story beautifully captures their blossoming relationship and life's challenges on the prairie.
This book was no doubt a fabulous read for me. It excels in its ability to transport readers into the intricate lives of its characters. The vivid descriptions of the rural setting and the emotional depth of the characters make it a truly immersive read. Violet's story added depth to the storyline of the book. The author's skillful storytelling and the ability to evoke empathy for the characters' struggles are commendable. The themes of human connection, resilience, and the complexities of rural life are skillfully interwoven.
While this book excels In character development and atmosphere, some readers may find the pacing slow at times. The pacing can also be leisurely, requiring patience to uncover the full depth of the characters and their stories. I also did not like the fact that they were no table of content in this book. I found it difficult to locate the pages I stopped at while I was reading this book, especially considering the lengthy nature of the book. I did not see any error in this book, which shows that it was expertly edited.
I rate this book four out of five stars. I deducted one star from this book book due to the issue already listed in the previous paragraph. This book covered themes of the resilience of individuals in the face of adversity, the power of human connection, love, loss, the impact of the past on the present, motherhood, pain, and growth.
This captivating novel will enthrall readers who appreciate suspenseful storytelling, intricate character development, and emotionally charged narratives. If you enjoy books that seamlessly weave together different timelines and explore the depths of human emotion, this book is a must-read. Be prepared for a journey that unfolds slowly but rewards your patience with a compelling and thought-provoking narrative. This will be a great read for you.
August 11, 2020
I finished Small Reckonings in a day, and literally could not put it down except for when forced to by other life demands. It made me laugh, it made me anxious, it made me cry, it carried me away to a small town in Saskatchewan in the twenties and thirties. I couldn't even brace myself for the tough parts I knew were coming. Thank you to the author for the immersive experience. I so appreciated the insightful and sensitive way the author dealt with the character of Nik. I ached for the characters as they grappled with the conflicting images of and emotions around one they cared about, trusted and respected. The struggle was gut wrenching. But the humanity of each of the characters shone through. Nik's remorse and acceptance of responsibility did not absolve him, but it turned black and white to gray. It gave me a space to abhor the action and not the person. In the same way, sharing Hank's, Violet's and William's memories of the man intensified the trauma they were going through but at the same time, provided again that space to recognize his humanity. I need a bookclub chat after reading Small Reckonings! Encouraging some friends to read it so I can do just that. The author's talent for storytelling is a wonderful gift! I know it also comes from much hard work and discipline. Can't wait to read the sequel!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Read
July 5, 2020This book deserved to win its award and will probably win many more. It’s a gripping and engaging story that transports the reader to the gritty reality of homestead on the prairies of the 1920s to 1930s.
You fall in love with the characters who stay with you long after you finish reading the book. And are left thinking what has happened to the characters? What happened to Violet? And fervently hope for a sequel. Small Reckonings has the makings of a wonderful period piece movie. I would be first in line to see this movie.
You fall in love with the characters who stay with you long after you finish reading the book. And are left thinking what has happened to the characters? What happened to Violet? And fervently hope for a sequel. Small Reckonings has the makings of a wonderful period piece movie. I would be first in line to see this movie.
August 15, 2020
It is a very long time since I have read a book that captivated me in the way this one did.
Karen has done an amazing job with the character development and I know this because I felt every heart wrenching emotion of William, Louise and Violet. I would wake up at 2am and the story would be repeating itself in my mind and in my dreams. The book will stay with me for along time.
I cant wait for a sequel.
Karen has done an amazing job with the character development and I know this because I felt every heart wrenching emotion of William, Louise and Violet. I would wake up at 2am and the story would be repeating itself in my mind and in my dreams. The book will stay with me for along time.
I cant wait for a sequel.
November 24, 2023
Small Reckonings is a historical novel inspired by true-life events with fictional characters. It is set in a small town, Watrous, Saskatchewan, where Williams Burke and others lived and tended to their farms. On his visit to Toronto, Canada, Burke met Louise, and they subsequently got married. Louise soon gave birth to John and Violet, with the help of Dr. Speight and Hanusia. However, Violet was born with special circumstances and had an underlying health condition that made her vulnerable. The book went downhill when Violet's health didn't get better and Louise felt guilty, despite Williams' attempts to reassure her. Yet more tragedy awaits the family of Burke, and this would spur Louise to leave her family members on a lone journey.
Karin’s ability to connect with the emotions of the reader at this point was incredibly awesome. I was almost in tears reading the events that led to the tragedy that befell the Burke family. The next big thing for me here was the ability to develop a weak character into a strong one. Despite the novel’s length, it was a totally engaging read. The tension that came with the climax, the way events were unravelled, the structure of the book, the use of different themes, and the choice of words were excellent. Also, the pictorial illustrations and the use of imagery were well captured. I loved the romantic relationship between Williams and Louise, especially when he visited her in Toronto and how he stood by her. I also adored John’s ability to look out for Violet, his sister, despite her frustrating condition.
On the downside, I found the book’s confusing start disconcerting; I had to read way deeper into the middle of the book before I could relate back to the beginning of the story. Furthermore, I felt that the author drifted away from the storyline several times. The author's excessive focus on certain events and abrupt shifts to unrelated ones made it hard for me to follow the storyline at times. I had to do lots of thinking to reconnect the dots.
Due to my complaints, the novel deserves 4 out of 5 stars. Nonetheless, due to the nature of the events that occurred in the book and its educational and insightful content, it was a worthy read. I recommend it to lovers of historical books rooted in real-life events.
Karin’s ability to connect with the emotions of the reader at this point was incredibly awesome. I was almost in tears reading the events that led to the tragedy that befell the Burke family. The next big thing for me here was the ability to develop a weak character into a strong one. Despite the novel’s length, it was a totally engaging read. The tension that came with the climax, the way events were unravelled, the structure of the book, the use of different themes, and the choice of words were excellent. Also, the pictorial illustrations and the use of imagery were well captured. I loved the romantic relationship between Williams and Louise, especially when he visited her in Toronto and how he stood by her. I also adored John’s ability to look out for Violet, his sister, despite her frustrating condition.
On the downside, I found the book’s confusing start disconcerting; I had to read way deeper into the middle of the book before I could relate back to the beginning of the story. Furthermore, I felt that the author drifted away from the storyline several times. The author's excessive focus on certain events and abrupt shifts to unrelated ones made it hard for me to follow the storyline at times. I had to do lots of thinking to reconnect the dots.
Due to my complaints, the novel deserves 4 out of 5 stars. Nonetheless, due to the nature of the events that occurred in the book and its educational and insightful content, it was a worthy read. I recommend it to lovers of historical books rooted in real-life events.
January 16, 2024
My Ratings - 4.8/5
"Small Reckonings" is a tapestry of human emotions, intricately woven by Karin Melberg Schwier. The author masterfully captures the nuances of life on the Canadian prairie, where the struggle for survival is mirrored in the hearts of its characters. William's adventurous spirit from New Zealand converges with Louise's hidden past, creating a complex narrative that unfolds against the vast and unforgiving landscape.
The birth of Violet, marked by society's judgment, becomes a focal point for introspection, evoking both sympathy and admiration. Schwier portrays the profound impact of Violet's presence on the community, particularly through the unwavering support of neighbors Hank and Emily. Their loyalty and kindness serve as a poignant counterbalance to the isolation and shame Louise grapples with.
Tragedy, a powerful force in the narrative, propels William into a journey of self-discovery and forgiveness. The author skillfully explores the fragility of human connections and the realization that everyone, even those we hold dearest, is susceptible to imperfection.
"Small Reckonings" is not just a historical novel; it is a rich exploration of the human condition, love's endurance, and the redemptive power of forgiveness. Schwier's prose is evocative, drawing readers into the harsh beauty of the prairie and the equally challenging terrain of the human heart. This novel lingers in the mind, leaving behind a trail of emotions and reflections on the resilience of the human spirit.
"Small Reckonings" is a tapestry of human emotions, intricately woven by Karin Melberg Schwier. The author masterfully captures the nuances of life on the Canadian prairie, where the struggle for survival is mirrored in the hearts of its characters. William's adventurous spirit from New Zealand converges with Louise's hidden past, creating a complex narrative that unfolds against the vast and unforgiving landscape.
The birth of Violet, marked by society's judgment, becomes a focal point for introspection, evoking both sympathy and admiration. Schwier portrays the profound impact of Violet's presence on the community, particularly through the unwavering support of neighbors Hank and Emily. Their loyalty and kindness serve as a poignant counterbalance to the isolation and shame Louise grapples with.
Tragedy, a powerful force in the narrative, propels William into a journey of self-discovery and forgiveness. The author skillfully explores the fragility of human connections and the realization that everyone, even those we hold dearest, is susceptible to imperfection.
"Small Reckonings" is not just a historical novel; it is a rich exploration of the human condition, love's endurance, and the redemptive power of forgiveness. Schwier's prose is evocative, drawing readers into the harsh beauty of the prairie and the equally challenging terrain of the human heart. This novel lingers in the mind, leaving behind a trail of emotions and reflections on the resilience of the human spirit.
May 29, 2023
The Review
This was a profoundly moving and heartbreaking read. The grim and gritty realities of life in early 20th century Canada as families established land and home were well developed in this historical fiction read, bringing a realistic touch to the setting and atmosphere. The tension that builds within this particular family unit and the constant hits to their family dynamics were both tragic and engaging all at the same time.
The heart of this narrative rested in the compelling character growth and dynamics that the story established. The hardships and struggles that you see for William and Louise as Violet grows and struggles with her own problems were tragic to see and would impact any and all parents, and yet the hope and brightness that Violet brought to those around her was so moving, making the events that transpire towards the back half of the book that much more heartbreaking to behold.
The Verdict
Thought-provoking, emotional, and insightful, author Karin Melberg Schwier’s “Small Reckonings” is a must-read historical fiction and family drama that you don’t want to miss. The twists and turns in the family’s history and drama will keep readers invested, and the emotional investment that readers make especially in Violet’s story as she experiences hardship, loss, and unexpected trauma made this one story that will hit close to home for many readers.
This was a profoundly moving and heartbreaking read. The grim and gritty realities of life in early 20th century Canada as families established land and home were well developed in this historical fiction read, bringing a realistic touch to the setting and atmosphere. The tension that builds within this particular family unit and the constant hits to their family dynamics were both tragic and engaging all at the same time.
The heart of this narrative rested in the compelling character growth and dynamics that the story established. The hardships and struggles that you see for William and Louise as Violet grows and struggles with her own problems were tragic to see and would impact any and all parents, and yet the hope and brightness that Violet brought to those around her was so moving, making the events that transpire towards the back half of the book that much more heartbreaking to behold.
The Verdict
Thought-provoking, emotional, and insightful, author Karin Melberg Schwier’s “Small Reckonings” is a must-read historical fiction and family drama that you don’t want to miss. The twists and turns in the family’s history and drama will keep readers invested, and the emotional investment that readers make especially in Violet’s story as she experiences hardship, loss, and unexpected trauma made this one story that will hit close to home for many readers.
August 18, 2020
Thank you or your beautiful gift, Karin. It flowed fast for two days. Intriguing. Very much alive. A master class in teaching the hard-fought prairie experience. Actually, your book was more photographic than the written. I especially enjoyed the bits of yellow breaking through the draining drab of hard days, landscapes and souls.
Also a beautiful portrayal of Violet, challenging the labels of disabled. I, myself a child of parents who were young in Depression times – people of the caragana, lilac, crocus and relentless drought despair. Another thing I really liked about your book was how you set up the timeline. Peeking curiosity in the beginning and basically give out clues all along the way. I was a wonderful way to involve the reader all throughout the spiraling story.
I, myself as a girl child, where sexuality was often a weapon of power, directed without forewarning, never taught to have the right to say yes, or no.
Thank you so much for writing this book, with many story lines, so many lessons. Stories that often were hidden. Those who lived them tried to forget them. Heartache and shame with no blessings.
I await your next masterpiece. And now I’m going to read your book again.
Also a beautiful portrayal of Violet, challenging the labels of disabled. I, myself a child of parents who were young in Depression times – people of the caragana, lilac, crocus and relentless drought despair. Another thing I really liked about your book was how you set up the timeline. Peeking curiosity in the beginning and basically give out clues all along the way. I was a wonderful way to involve the reader all throughout the spiraling story.
I, myself as a girl child, where sexuality was often a weapon of power, directed without forewarning, never taught to have the right to say yes, or no.
Thank you so much for writing this book, with many story lines, so many lessons. Stories that often were hidden. Those who lived them tried to forget them. Heartache and shame with no blessings.
I await your next masterpiece. And now I’m going to read your book again.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 29, 2024
This is a real gem and I don’t understand why it has not received more reviews. It is a powerfully told story of homesteading on the prairies, with a twist: the hardworking couple has a beautiful little girl with Down syndrome. How they coped (badly, on the mother’s part) in a time and place when to be mentally disabled was considered shameful, if not downright sinful, is the thrust of this gripping story. The girl Violet is so charming and innocent that I feared for her safety, not without reason. When something terrible happens, it is her loving father who is the heroic figure of the tale. This novel deservedly won several awards and definitely should have a wider audience. Book clubs, take note!
August 13, 2020
This is a splendid book.The references to the Spanish Flu seemed quite prophetic and made me feel very fortunate as did the isolation of those early settlers.I loved all the domestic detail particularly
about food and putting things by.But the character of Violet really resonated for me:
her grief and forbearance were very moving.Thank you for a darn good read.
about food and putting things by.But the character of Violet really resonated for me:
her grief and forbearance were very moving.Thank you for a darn good read.
January 29, 2022
Oh my what a beautiful story. Looking forward to the sequel.
July 30, 2022
Based in Saskatchewan, inspired by true events.
July 21, 2020
What a beautiful book. At times heartbreaking, heart wrenching, heartwarming and ultimately heart opening. Each character is beautifully drawn. Having finished reading the book I find myself missing them now.
My grandparents homesteaded in Saskatchewan in the 19-teens. My dad was born in 1922 and grew up during the Depression. From the stories I heard told by him and my aunts and uncles I think Karen has captured the atmosphere, flavour and many of the attitudes of those times. Well done.
My grandparents homesteaded in Saskatchewan in the 19-teens. My dad was born in 1922 and grew up during the Depression. From the stories I heard told by him and my aunts and uncles I think Karen has captured the atmosphere, flavour and many of the attitudes of those times. Well done.
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews