What do you think?
Rate this book
The City Between #6
Between Walls
Don't get too close to humans.
That's rule number one. Well, it is if you're an emotionally constipated fae lord. As far as I'm concerned, the vampire could do a better job of keeping his distance, but he's never been that good at following the rules.
G'day. I'm Pet. Schrödinger's Pet, these days; depends who's asking.
I'm human, but when you hang around with enough Behindkind, it starts getting dangerous for the other humans around you. Humans like my friend Morgana. I tried to stay away, but now she needs my help and don't get too close to humans isn't exactly gunna cut it anymore.
I've got the feeling I'm about to find out why it's such a bad idea.
That's rule number one. Well, it is if you're an emotionally constipated fae lord. As far as I'm concerned, the vampire could do a better job of keeping his distance, but he's never been that good at following the rules.
G'day. I'm Pet. Schrödinger's Pet, these days; depends who's asking.
I'm human, but when you hang around with enough Behindkind, it starts getting dangerous for the other humans around you. Humans like my friend Morgana. I tried to stay away, but now she needs my help and don't get too close to humans isn't exactly gunna cut it anymore.
I've got the feeling I'm about to find out why it's such a bad idea.
257 pages, ebook
First published May 30, 2020
89 people are currently reading
249 people want to read
About the author
W.R. Gingell
46 books1,080 followersW.R. Gingell is a Tasmanian author of urban fantasy, fairy-tale retellings, and madcap science fiction who doesn’t seem to be able to write a book without a body suddenly turning up. She solemnly swears that all such bodies are strictly fictional in nature.
W.R. spends her time reading, drinking a truly ridiculous amount of tea, and slouching in front of the fire to write. Like Peter Pan, she never really grew up, and is still occasionally to be found climbing trees.
GOODREADS FRIEND POLICY: I don't tend to friend anyone unless they're a personal friend or someone from my close author circle. I have a limited social battery which needs constant care. If you want to keep up with my reading/writing, you can absolutely follow me here or on pretty much any social media site.
W.R. spends her time reading, drinking a truly ridiculous amount of tea, and slouching in front of the fire to write. Like Peter Pan, she never really grew up, and is still occasionally to be found climbing trees.
GOODREADS FRIEND POLICY: I don't tend to friend anyone unless they're a personal friend or someone from my close author circle. I have a limited social battery which needs constant care. If you want to keep up with my reading/writing, you can absolutely follow me here or on pretty much any social media site.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 165 reviews
January 6, 2022
Post-finale reread: This is definitely a lower-key instalment, but it contains some very excellent character and thematic material. All the relationships in the cast are developing now that Pet has won the right to be treated as an equal, and as always in the CITY BETWEEN books, there's stuff in here that is almost unbearably sharp, like Pet's reflection that she doesn't necessarily need to argue with the psychos over everything, but that she has been biting her tongue and pulling her head in so long that she doesn't know what is worth fighting about and what isn't anymore - the only thing she does know is that she needs to stick up for herself and others, even if she doesn't always do it at the right time or in the right way. Somehow, even I feel that on a subatomic level. This is a book about waking up and trying to face the world instead of run from it, trying to take charge of your life rather than let other people and circumstances control it, and what that costs you in the way of making mistakes.
Meanwhile, on a second read, this book drops some pretty shriek-worthy hints about the identity of the serial killer the three psychos have been hunting down all series - and wraps up in a gutpunch of a revelation. I'm going to be honest, after the incredibly strong run of books 3-4-5, this one feels a bit more scattered; the plot isn't tremendously strong or unified, in a way that means important plot details keep scuttling away out of my brain as I read. But the characters are all there, and so are the immortal one-liners:
"Oh yeah, he definitely ages well! Like a flamin' cheddar!"
--
Since Between Homes I've been waiting six months in an absolute ferment for the next City Between book, and now I don't know how I'm supposed to exist till the next one. Life is an endless round of frustration sometimes.
Everything I love about this series is back for Book 6. The fantastically lovable characters; the off-kilter humour (there are about five laugh-out-loud moments per page); the ship-teasing (oh my word, the ship-teasing in this book, while still completely demure, might be at an all-time high); the gradually-emerging story of a battle between ruthless factions for the throne of Behind; it's all coming into sharper focus. As always, it's not just fun and games and floods of gore: one of the things I love best about this series is the darker undercurrent of meaning that flashes to the surface every few chapters, with all the stealthy lethality of a thousand-year-old bladed temple booby-trap in an Indiana Jones movie.
Most of the Between books - particularly from Book 3 onwards - finish with a fairly heartbreaking culmination, and this one is particularly so. Some of the mysteries that have been tormenting us for the last four or five books are finally solved, in a way that is somewhat more low-key than previous books, but which doesn't spare the heartstrings. (Of course, I loved it.)
The reason I read the series is basically for the character interactions amongst the core cast. Detective Tuatu more or less sits this one out, but Pet and the psychos are all in fine form again, and I thought this one had a particularly fun balance of interactions among all of them. I have to say, I've been firmly convinced for six books now that none of the psychos are Pet's romantic endgame, but this book shook me slightly, and that's all I'll say about that *grin*.
Books 3 and 5 are still my absolute favourites in this series, and apart from the gutpunch at the end of this one, it feels a bit like a breather episode, more dedicated to dealing with the fallout from the previous book, and setting up future confrontations, than dealing out any big pyrotechnics. That's completely appropriate after the massive feels of the last book, but if I had a complaint, it would be that the character around whom the culmination of this book revolves, is not in the story as much as they might be. I'm sure previous books did a great job of setting up what happens in this one, but I think this one might work better when binged with the others, than at a six-month remove.
Finally, and this is very important, there is a scene in this book that involves a frog. It is delightful.
Meanwhile, on a second read, this book drops some pretty shriek-worthy hints about the identity of the serial killer the three psychos have been hunting down all series - and wraps up in a gutpunch of a revelation. I'm going to be honest, after the incredibly strong run of books 3-4-5, this one feels a bit more scattered; the plot isn't tremendously strong or unified, in a way that means important plot details keep scuttling away out of my brain as I read. But the characters are all there, and so are the immortal one-liners:
"Oh yeah, he definitely ages well! Like a flamin' cheddar!"
--
Since Between Homes I've been waiting six months in an absolute ferment for the next City Between book, and now I don't know how I'm supposed to exist till the next one. Life is an endless round of frustration sometimes.
Everything I love about this series is back for Book 6. The fantastically lovable characters; the off-kilter humour (there are about five laugh-out-loud moments per page); the ship-teasing (oh my word, the ship-teasing in this book, while still completely demure, might be at an all-time high); the gradually-emerging story of a battle between ruthless factions for the throne of Behind; it's all coming into sharper focus. As always, it's not just fun and games and floods of gore: one of the things I love best about this series is the darker undercurrent of meaning that flashes to the surface every few chapters, with all the stealthy lethality of a thousand-year-old bladed temple booby-trap in an Indiana Jones movie.
Most of the Between books - particularly from Book 3 onwards - finish with a fairly heartbreaking culmination, and this one is particularly so. Some of the mysteries that have been tormenting us for the last four or five books are finally solved, in a way that is somewhat more low-key than previous books, but which doesn't spare the heartstrings. (Of course, I loved it.)
The reason I read the series is basically for the character interactions amongst the core cast. Detective Tuatu more or less sits this one out, but Pet and the psychos are all in fine form again, and I thought this one had a particularly fun balance of interactions among all of them. I have to say, I've been firmly convinced for six books now that none of the psychos are Pet's romantic endgame, but this book shook me slightly, and that's all I'll say about that *grin*.
Books 3 and 5 are still my absolute favourites in this series, and apart from the gutpunch at the end of this one, it feels a bit like a breather episode, more dedicated to dealing with the fallout from the previous book, and setting up future confrontations, than dealing out any big pyrotechnics. That's completely appropriate after the massive feels of the last book, but if I had a complaint, it would be that the character around whom the culmination of this book revolves, is not in the story as much as they might be. I'm sure previous books did a great job of setting up what happens in this one, but I think this one might work better when binged with the others, than at a six-month remove.
Finally, and this is very important, there is a scene in this book that involves a frog. It is delightful.
December 9, 2025
"...Didn’t particularly want to be murdered today. I was wearing my good jeans."
Been waiting for this one to come out, and man I missed reading about this world and characters!
Also-I just want to say that I still love Pet's humor- and I'm glad that some of the side characters are getting some more background.
So, there was a lot going on in this one- we have Pet back at home with the Psychos- and its nice to see the balance is a little bit more....balanced in their relationships. Pet has more of a voice in the group and input into their cases- which is where this book starts off.
After trying to keep her distance to protect her friend Morgana. Pet is pulled back into her life after being asked to help track down her missing internet friend. They met through a mysterious game called City Fae that is a little to familiar for comfort- and has too much info to be just a regular video game.
Armed with this knowledge Team Psycho is pulled in a lot of different directions- from the Golden Fae, to possible Family Ties, and other outside groups all having an angle in this mystery.
However, we still have familiar and frustrating mysteries to question- such as what happened to Pet's parents, whats going on with her house, whats the mad ole bloke up to, and what is the killer from book one up to (STILL!) Yeah so a lot going on
But also still love me some sassy Pet.
“But after all, I shouldn’t wish to interfere with that charming insouciance of yours, so consider yourself free to ignore my advice.” I gazed at him for a few moments, then said, “Don’t you threaten me with the consequences of my actions.”
September 9, 2020
This is sixth in a UF series and characters and plot carry over from book to book. So I recommend reading in order. This book includes a new character and some events from a mid-series short story, but I didn't feel left out that I hadn't read it.
So Pet and her psychos are working on a changed dynamic and if there's a strength in the series that draws me most, it's Gingell managing these relationship developments so well. It has been a tricky dynamic from the start and showing progression over time is even harder. And I'm very happy with how it's going. The thing is, it has to be multi-layered because you not only have the relationship between Pet and each of the other three, but also the group dynamic to explore and I just love how each responds in their own idiom and how those reactions reverberate among the others.
And I've been thinking that the whole mystery around Morgana and her house of weird needed a resolution soon. So I'm glad this story centered, at least partially, on resolving that multilayered cake of weirdness. It was becoming a strain for Pet to remain ignorant of all the not-quite-right details there so it's as well to have that taken care of.
Anyway, this ends up another solid five stars and I can't wait for the next book. Unfortunately, I've caught up with the publication this time so I will actually have to wait...
A note about Chaste: Pet's relationships are still all platonic and thus very chaste. There's some hint of that changing a bit with JinYeong taking steps to differentiate his standing with her as "not pet". Which was interesting and I'd like to see how that progresses. He's by far the closest to her in maturity and temperament so if that does develop, I'm down with that. Provisionally. There's some deepening with her relationship with Zero as well, but I read that as more fatherly and would be extremely disappointed if Gingell chose to make that a romantic development.
So Pet and her psychos are working on a changed dynamic and if there's a strength in the series that draws me most, it's Gingell managing these relationship developments so well. It has been a tricky dynamic from the start and showing progression over time is even harder. And I'm very happy with how it's going. The thing is, it has to be multi-layered because you not only have the relationship between Pet and each of the other three, but also the group dynamic to explore and I just love how each responds in their own idiom and how those reactions reverberate among the others.
And I've been thinking that the whole mystery around Morgana and her house of weird needed a resolution soon. So I'm glad this story centered, at least partially, on resolving that multilayered cake of weirdness. It was becoming a strain for Pet to remain ignorant of all the not-quite-right details there so it's as well to have that taken care of.
Anyway, this ends up another solid five stars and I can't wait for the next book. Unfortunately, I've caught up with the publication this time so I will actually have to wait...
A note about Chaste: Pet's relationships are still all platonic and thus very chaste. There's some hint of that changing a bit with JinYeong taking steps to differentiate his standing with her as "not pet". Which was interesting and I'd like to see how that progresses. He's by far the closest to her in maturity and temperament so if that does develop, I'm down with that. Provisionally. There's some deepening with her relationship with Zero as well, but I read that as more fatherly and would be extremely disappointed if Gingell chose to make that a romantic development.
June 1, 2020
Another City Between story in which --
1. Secrets are revealed.
2. The fae lord thaws … a little
3. The steward remains the same … why change a good thing?
4: The vampire makes coffee … and has serious tie trauma.
5. The pet has a boyfriend for about ten minutes … his thoughts on the subject are debatable.
Spoilers below
.
.
.
So, this series brings out the character love and the shipping questions in everyone. I'm solidly on Team Good Ending myself (which means HAPPY ending in case you weren't aware). But I do occasionally lean towards Team JinPet in the shipping wars.
Honestly, I didn't get into this series at first because of JinYeong. I don't do glorification of vampires, witches and that lot, period (my life, my likes). But I was pleased to discover Gingell wasn't the typical author pushing JinYeong just because "pretty face." So I started to thoroughly enjoy his arc, especially in 3 and 5, and now he's my favorite little mosquito.
But this was like … I'm not sure. It seemed all the character development got chucked out the window. I know, there's something up, and I'm willing to be patient and let it all play out and of course, we only have Pet's POV. But still, I hope his thread will continue to be well developed and not dropped for other things.
1. Secrets are revealed.
2. The fae lord thaws … a little
3. The steward remains the same … why change a good thing?
4: The vampire makes coffee … and has serious tie trauma.
5. The pet has a boyfriend for about ten minutes … his thoughts on the subject are debatable.
Spoilers below
.
.
.
So, this series brings out the character love and the shipping questions in everyone. I'm solidly on Team Good Ending myself (which means HAPPY ending in case you weren't aware). But I do occasionally lean towards Team JinPet in the shipping wars.
Honestly, I didn't get into this series at first because of JinYeong. I don't do glorification of vampires, witches and that lot, period (my life, my likes). But I was pleased to discover Gingell wasn't the typical author pushing JinYeong just because "pretty face." So I started to thoroughly enjoy his arc, especially in 3 and 5, and now he's my favorite little mosquito.
But this was like … I'm not sure. It seemed all the character development got chucked out the window. I know, there's something up, and I'm willing to be patient and let it all play out and of course, we only have Pet's POV. But still, I hope his thread will continue to be well developed and not dropped for other things.
September 18, 2025
Sundry thoughts:
• I think the title might be referring to firewalls.
• Pet holds Athelas’s hand because “sometimes even psychos need their hands held” (44%). Aww.
• THE TIE FROG.
• Palomena is fabulous and I adore her.
• It’s hilarious how Pet is content to be ignorant about the things Morgana enjoys, yet they manage to develop a friendship.
• Zero’s eyes start growing bluer more often in this one…!
• So many heartbreaking things fall into place upon rereading.
This whole series is weird, yes, but this one has an extra helping of weird, and…I’m not sure how I feel about it. The writing is just as brilliant as always, however.
Content: violence and gore, a girl mentions meeting a creep/pervert on an online game, a brief conversation about struggling with suicidal thoughts
• I think the title might be referring to firewalls.
• Pet holds Athelas’s hand because “sometimes even psychos need their hands held” (44%). Aww.
• THE TIE FROG.
• Palomena is fabulous and I adore her.
• It’s hilarious how Pet is content to be ignorant about the things Morgana enjoys, yet they manage to develop a friendship.
• Zero’s eyes start growing bluer more often in this one…!
• So many heartbreaking things fall into place upon rereading.
This whole series is weird, yes, but this one has an extra helping of weird, and…I’m not sure how I feel about it. The writing is just as brilliant as always, however.
Content: violence and gore, a girl mentions meeting a creep/pervert on an online game, a brief conversation about struggling with suicidal thoughts
June 3, 2020
A solid installment and enjoyable read, with some stronger emotional beats toward the end and a few fabulous twists I've been waiting for regarding some secondary characters I've had my eyes on. However, there wasn't that much of an action climax, and - perhaps my expectations have been skewed but I was expecting one, and was rather surprised when the book ended. I'm still very much looking forward to the next one. This one just read a bit more like a "middle" book in a trilogy, which... you know, it's Book 6 in a ten book series. I suppose it is the middle book. ;) I guess I've just been spoiled.
Overall rating 3.5
Overall rating 3.5
July 17, 2021
5 stars // read July 2021 (edited review)
One thing I love about this series is that just when you think you have gotten things down to a formula and have figured things out, new stuff is thrown in. We see characters mature and grow (Pet actually refrains from sticking her tongue out at someone), hints of romance (emphasis on "hints" - there's still not very much, but that's okay,) and a significant mystery surrounding Morgana is resolved (as bittersweet as it is.) But, despite the fact that it's BOOK 6 :O there's new mythological critters thrown in and new characters introduced, and even as old threads are being tied up new ones are woven in. So I really enjoyed that.
a few of my favorite moments: the character that Morgana plays as on the video game; when Zero didn't understand something about computer stuff and Pet automatically explains "yeah, it's like a security spell..." And the tie frog. The tie frog is priceless. XD
Also can we appreciate how little Korean there is? Not that I mind the Korean, I enjoy it, but the implications are interesting.
As far as any negatives, the only thing is that I don't get the title? I've understood the book titles up to this point but I'm not sure what walls it's referring to. Plus it is a little creepier than previous installments. :P
One thing I love about this series is that just when you think you have gotten things down to a formula and have figured things out, new stuff is thrown in. We see characters mature and grow (Pet actually refrains from sticking her tongue out at someone), hints of romance (emphasis on "hints" - there's still not very much, but that's okay,) and a significant mystery surrounding Morgana is resolved (as bittersweet as it is.) But, despite the fact that it's BOOK 6 :O there's new mythological critters thrown in and new characters introduced, and even as old threads are being tied up new ones are woven in. So I really enjoyed that.
a few of my favorite moments: the character that Morgana plays as on the video game; when Zero didn't understand something about computer stuff and Pet automatically explains "yeah, it's like a security spell..." And the tie frog. The tie frog is priceless. XD
Also can we appreciate how little Korean there is? Not that I mind the Korean, I enjoy it, but the implications are interesting.
As far as any negatives, the only thing is that I don't get the title? I've understood the book titles up to this point but I'm not sure what walls it's referring to. Plus it is a little creepier than previous installments. :P
July 21, 2023
If I could shut up in horrible circumstances, I'd do it a lot more often, I can tell you. Life'd be a heck of a lot more comfortable."
my Thoughts:
• this was probably my second favorite of the series so far! I wasn't super sold in the first half but the second half got me, man
• the found family vibes are so strong in this one and they make me so soft
• like Pet holding Athelas' hand because "sometimes even psychos need their hands held" PLS I'm so soft
• the tie frog is iconic
• Pet: "he's my boyfriend." JinYeong: *instant internal panic*
• there wasn't as much development of the big overarching plot in this one (like, there's some, but not as much as previous books), but the character development here was great
• "don't you threaten me with the consequences of my actions!" made me laugh out loud
• all the stuff at Morgana's house left me with my mouth open because WOW is that a cool twist
4.5 stars from me, I am loving this series so much and I'm already not ready for it to end
((content warning for gruesome murder scenes, violence, and a conversation about suicidal thoughts))
my Thoughts:
• this was probably my second favorite of the series so far! I wasn't super sold in the first half but the second half got me, man
• the found family vibes are so strong in this one and they make me so soft
• like Pet holding Athelas' hand because "sometimes even psychos need their hands held" PLS I'm so soft
• the tie frog is iconic
• Pet: "he's my boyfriend." JinYeong: *instant internal panic*
• there wasn't as much development of the big overarching plot in this one (like, there's some, but not as much as previous books), but the character development here was great
• "don't you threaten me with the consequences of my actions!" made me laugh out loud
• all the stuff at Morgana's house left me with my mouth open because WOW is that a cool twist
4.5 stars from me, I am loving this series so much and I'm already not ready for it to end
((content warning for gruesome murder scenes, violence, and a conversation about suicidal thoughts))
January 21, 2023
Bloody. Brutal. Beautiful.
I appreciate much more the interactions between (hehehe) Pet and JinYeong this time around. TBH he’s been the character I’ve struggled the most to like, but the sneaky mosquito boi is sneaking up on me and grudgingly dragging me into his camp. XD
I appreciate much more the interactions between (hehehe) Pet and JinYeong this time around. TBH he’s been the character I’ve struggled the most to like, but the sneaky mosquito boi is sneaking up on me and grudgingly dragging me into his camp. XD
Read
June 1, 2024- I am SO into this series.
- The tie frog had me laughing.
- "Don't threaten me with the consequences of my actions" is such a great line lol.
- The whole City Fae thing was very interesting.
- Everything at Morgana's house? I sort of guessed it, but I also didn't so, it was kind of surprising.
- I need to read the next one, but I'm going to try to wait a little, because I don't really know if I have the time rn. I will certainly be getting to it before too long tho.
This has been quick random thoughts with Bella.
- The tie frog had me laughing.
- "Don't threaten me with the consequences of my actions" is such a great line lol.
- The whole City Fae thing was very interesting.
- Everything at Morgana's house? I sort of guessed it, but I also didn't so, it was kind of surprising.
- I need to read the next one, but I'm going to try to wait a little, because I don't really know if I have the time rn. I will certainly be getting to it before too long tho.
This has been quick random thoughts with Bella.
September 29, 2021
One of my favorite things about this series is the dynamics between Pet and the psychos as they deal with the Behindkind and the mysteries/trouble Pet gets into. The story is told from Pet’s perspective, but each of the characters is complex and fleshed out. Gingell continues to peel back each characters’ layers and while the romantic aspect hasn’t developed beyond thoughts; we are seeing two prospective relationship partners for Pet. We see a deepening relationship with Zero, but we also have the banter with JinYeong our vampire. I waiver between these two ships and am curious to see who Pet ultimately chooses. I should note, I would be just as happy if they are remained roommates and lived happily ever after.
We see development concerning Morgana, and our leprechaun friend, Five-Four-One, is hilarious. (be sure to read the novella, Cloudy With A Chance Of Dropbears). We are seeing a power struggle to control the Behind and a lot of questions and open threads are answered in Between Walls.
Gingell has full control of this series arc and its characters. I for one, am fully enjoying the ride. I absolutely love listening to the audiobooks narrated by Zehra Jane Naqvi. Her voices for these characters and her grasp of the humor, banter, and personalities along with the building story arc making listening an absolute joy. The story is addictive, and she enhances that story.
Because of character development and world-building, I recommend this series be listened to in the order of its release. I also recommend stopping and picking up any novellas in-between as they prove to be not only entertaining but relevant.
I cannot wait to dive into the next audio Between Cases which is currently available on audio. The series is available through Kindle Unlimited and you can grab the audiobooks at a reduced cost. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer
We see development concerning Morgana, and our leprechaun friend, Five-Four-One, is hilarious. (be sure to read the novella, Cloudy With A Chance Of Dropbears). We are seeing a power struggle to control the Behind and a lot of questions and open threads are answered in Between Walls.
Gingell has full control of this series arc and its characters. I for one, am fully enjoying the ride. I absolutely love listening to the audiobooks narrated by Zehra Jane Naqvi. Her voices for these characters and her grasp of the humor, banter, and personalities along with the building story arc making listening an absolute joy. The story is addictive, and she enhances that story.
Because of character development and world-building, I recommend this series be listened to in the order of its release. I also recommend stopping and picking up any novellas in-between as they prove to be not only entertaining but relevant.
I cannot wait to dive into the next audio Between Cases which is currently available on audio. The series is available through Kindle Unlimited and you can grab the audiobooks at a reduced cost. This review was originally posted at Caffeinated Reviewer
January 19, 2023
My reviews don’t often contain what happens in stories, for risk of spoilers (especially this far into a series, where I assume you’ve read all previous books to know what’s going on): rather, I tend to focus on feelings. Emotions. What I go through as I read them.
And in this particular book, I:
* laughed out loud (I finally know what a tie frog is)
* sent a screaming opossum gif several times (because plot twists and then GENERAL UNDENIABLE PURITY THAT MY HEART COULDN’T TAKE)
* sent a picture of myself crying (as proof that this book had put me through the wringer)
* devoted many hours to finishing this book because I HAD TO KNOW MORE.
* adopted Zero because he is ✨my king✨
And I still have to know more. These books are crack. Read at your own risk, but know that it’s worth it (although real crack isn’t; say no to drugs, kids).
And in this particular book, I:
* laughed out loud (I finally know what a tie frog is)
* sent a screaming opossum gif several times (because plot twists and then GENERAL UNDENIABLE PURITY THAT MY HEART COULDN’T TAKE)
* sent a picture of myself crying (as proof that this book had put me through the wringer)
* devoted many hours to finishing this book because I HAD TO KNOW MORE.
* adopted Zero because he is ✨my king✨
And I still have to know more. These books are crack. Read at your own risk, but know that it’s worth it (although real crack isn’t; say no to drugs, kids).
June 29, 2020
This author just keeps knocking this series out of the park! Each book gets twistier and twistier!
Yet, in this book, we finally get a hint and a glimpse at clues starting to fall into place. We still don't see the full puzzle, but a few more connections were made!
This book continues everything readers love about this series. Zero, Athelas, and Jin Yeong are all back and snippier than ever. Pet hasn't lost her sass one bit. One part with a certain tie had me laughing out loud!
Can't wait until the next book!
Yet, in this book, we finally get a hint and a glimpse at clues starting to fall into place. We still don't see the full puzzle, but a few more connections were made!
This book continues everything readers love about this series. Zero, Athelas, and Jin Yeong are all back and snippier than ever. Pet hasn't lost her sass one bit. One part with a certain tie had me laughing out loud!
Can't wait until the next book!
August 4, 2025
Man that ending made me so sad! But I have so many theories!!!
December 14, 2020
What in the world?? How did I.....read 6 books of this series? Why am I so invested in it?? THIS DOESN'T MAKE SENSE!! And I know it was around the 4th book when I was sucked in...
But in all seriosity, the books are REALLY getting better. It's like...Gingell does this thing where instead of the sequels being worse, they get considerably better. There is SO much character growth, and yeah, her style is a bit hard to get into, but once you have it down, you're pulled in. The setting, also, somehow, you understand everything and just are pulled in....and the way Gingell handles all of these weird relationships and emotions in healthy ways is amazing! Very impressed at how it all is progressing. (also, romance is starting to creep in too, but the FOUND FAMILY VIBES ARE SO STRONG!) If there is any criticism...I don't know. I just can't think of any unopinionated ones, really. Her plot is begging to really flesh itself out and well...I love how these books have their standalone plot but also connect to the rest of the series.
Anyway, this book was amazing and kind of sad, too... skeptical I was at first, but this series has grown on me. Like Pet to the psychos and vice versa. :) (and the Korean is getting less as Pet understands more)
Content: Violence, again...lot of blood. And some trigger warnings about death and grief and cruelty, though I don't know how much I can say without spoiling.
But in all seriosity, the books are REALLY getting better. It's like...Gingell does this thing where instead of the sequels being worse, they get considerably better. There is SO much character growth, and yeah, her style is a bit hard to get into, but once you have it down, you're pulled in. The setting, also, somehow, you understand everything and just are pulled in....and the way Gingell handles all of these weird relationships and emotions in healthy ways is amazing! Very impressed at how it all is progressing. (also, romance is starting to creep in too, but the FOUND FAMILY VIBES ARE SO STRONG!) If there is any criticism...I don't know. I just can't think of any unopinionated ones, really. Her plot is begging to really flesh itself out and well...I love how these books have their standalone plot but also connect to the rest of the series.
Anyway, this book was amazing and kind of sad, too... skeptical I was at first, but this series has grown on me. Like Pet to the psychos and vice versa. :) (and the Korean is getting less as Pet understands more)
Content: Violence, again...lot of blood. And some trigger warnings about death and grief and cruelty, though I don't know how much I can say without spoiling.
October 1, 2022
“Why are you…always…blowing me up?”
“Your souls were lost long before you sold them to buy your lives.”
Pet learns from Athelas just how many things can be exploited as weaknesses: the very best things about you, even.
And JinYeong is warm.
When I first read this, I decided books 6-8 were kind of my least favorite block of the series (besides maybe book 2 *narrator once again fails to hide her bias and reveals how much she HATES werewolves*), and I’m pretty sure I know why.
Maybe I’ll explain that when I review one of those two.
This is my favorite of those three, though (I think). The reveal at the end is so dark, and well built up to, and…and well-written. The reveal about Morgana herself isn’t my favorite, partly because of how it’s handled. (I really don’t like when characters get angry at each other for stuff that isn’t their fault. Really don’t like it. Hate books because of it, sometimes. It’s not about the realism, because people can definitely be that irrational. I just hate that people are that irrational.) But meeting her parents, yikes. Chills, guys. But mostly the kids. That’s my favorite reveal.
Well, next to the murderer’s sense of humor, I guess. I love that a weird amount. I love Pet wondering about the choice her parents were offered.
These books give me feels, man.
Also gosh the foreshadowing gosh gosh GOSH. Why is it so good. It makes me sad. What you think is just a somewhat odd reaction the first time through is EXPLAINED PERFECTLY by a reread. I love books like this.
This is the book where I realize how much I like Zero. Yes, I have always enjoyed him, but he’s a dear in his way. He and Pet interacting makes me happy.
And it will never not be funny and a joy when Pet walks into a room of humans pointing guns at her, steps into the light, and then they all gasp like she’s Marilyn Monroe or something. “It’s you! It’s The Pet!” Making a name for herself around the neighborhood, our Pet is. Are we proud parents? Aye, sir, we are very proud parents.
“Your souls were lost long before you sold them to buy your lives.”
Pet learns from Athelas just how many things can be exploited as weaknesses: the very best things about you, even.
And JinYeong is warm.
When I first read this, I decided books 6-8 were kind of my least favorite block of the series (besides maybe book 2 *narrator once again fails to hide her bias and reveals how much she HATES werewolves*), and I’m pretty sure I know why.
Maybe I’ll explain that when I review one of those two.
This is my favorite of those three, though (I think). The reveal at the end is so dark, and well built up to, and…and well-written. The reveal about Morgana herself isn’t my favorite, partly because of how it’s handled. (I really don’t like when characters get angry at each other for stuff that isn’t their fault. Really don’t like it. Hate books because of it, sometimes. It’s not about the realism, because people can definitely be that irrational. I just hate that people are that irrational.) But meeting her parents, yikes. Chills, guys. But mostly the kids. That’s my favorite reveal.
Well, next to the murderer’s sense of humor, I guess. I love that a weird amount. I love Pet wondering about the choice her parents were offered.
These books give me feels, man.
Also gosh the foreshadowing gosh gosh GOSH. Why is it so good. It makes me sad. What you think is just a somewhat odd reaction the first time through is EXPLAINED PERFECTLY by a reread. I love books like this.
This is the book where I realize how much I like Zero. Yes, I have always enjoyed him, but he’s a dear in his way. He and Pet interacting makes me happy.
And it will never not be funny and a joy when Pet walks into a room of humans pointing guns at her, steps into the light, and then they all gasp like she’s Marilyn Monroe or something. “It’s you! It’s The Pet!” Making a name for herself around the neighborhood, our Pet is. Are we proud parents? Aye, sir, we are very proud parents.
September 4, 2022
There is so much I love about the series, and this author’s books in general; engaging characters, detailed world-building and offbeat humour, to name a few.
Though, this book is slower paced, Pet and her interactions with the three psychos continue to make me laugh. My not-so-silent chuckling has interested my youngest into wanting to read the series, too.
My only complaint is that the books are over too quickly which leave me itching to get my greedy fingers on the next one.
Though, this book is slower paced, Pet and her interactions with the three psychos continue to make me laugh. My not-so-silent chuckling has interested my youngest into wanting to read the series, too.
My only complaint is that the books are over too quickly which leave me itching to get my greedy fingers on the next one.
January 26, 2023
I am loving this series. And especially loving that I can love it wholeheartedly now that Pet’s got some solid boundaries in place. The humor kills me. So good.
October 30, 2023
Make me stoooopppppp. They're so good. Gah.
June 1, 2020
Best one thus far
I really did not want this one to be done. Pet is maturing through every experience and we get to learn so much more about Morgana and through her about Pet. P.s I want Pet and Zero but also Pet and Jinyeong
I really did not want this one to be done. Pet is maturing through every experience and we get to learn so much more about Morgana and through her about Pet. P.s I want Pet and Zero but also Pet and Jinyeong
June 2, 2020
Soooo clever. Things are starting to come together from other books and things that have been said make sense and make you stop and think 'what... does that mean that...'. I love this series and Pet and cannot wait for the next one and the next one and.... you get my point.
November 16, 2020
Re-read November 2020
Original rating 4 Stars
new rating 4.5 Stars
Original rating 4 Stars
new rating 4.5 Stars
June 20, 2020
"More of the same" from this series - meaning more of the same addictive narrative tangle, maddening character interactions, including insight into why Zero is so buttoned-up and reluctant to help humans. More world building, including significant new players and several new classes of beings. Also quite a lot more setting up of sharp-edged moving plot parts for the next book or couple of books. Pet also reluctantly starts to face how much her life (and definition of "normal") is really rather messed up, while events pile even more pressure on her stressed moral compass.
Still giggling at the conceit that everything important in the Behind-Between-Human world interaction seems to go down in Hobart ( that kind of thing is a genre conceit, after all, just not normally set in Tasmania :-P )
Main criticism: there are a couple of odd moments where Pet has a flash of insight that doesn't seem to follow from what she already knows. Or one scene where she knows what a location used to look like 30 years ago, when she's nominally 18. None of this is necessarily supernatural but it has happened often enough through the series that it's either narrative laziness, or a sort of detective superpower (and her powers seem to be considerable and ill-explored) or there's some additional weirdness we haven't got to the bottom of yet.
Still giggling at the conceit that everything important in the Behind-Between-Human world interaction seems to go down in Hobart ( that kind of thing is a genre conceit, after all, just not normally set in Tasmania :-P )
Main criticism: there are a couple of odd moments where Pet has a flash of insight that doesn't seem to follow from what she already knows. Or one scene where she knows what a location used to look like 30 years ago, when she's nominally 18. None of this is necessarily supernatural but it has happened often enough through the series that it's either narrative laziness, or a sort of detective superpower (and her powers seem to be considerable and ill-explored) or there's some additional weirdness we haven't got to the bottom of yet.
June 4, 2020
This book left me speechless. I don't even know where or how to begin. There's so many things I could mention, but they'd be massive spoilers and so I won't do that. But oh my gosh, we get some answers to some long held questions. And wow, did they blow my mind or what!
There was a ton of humor, as usual. I laughed so hard, so many times, especially about the tie. Just trust me, it's absolutely hilarious. I'm laughing again now just thinking about it. It wasn't all fun and games, though. There were serious moments, twists I didn't see coming, and some shocking revelations.
Despite a slow start, Between Walls ended up being a fantastic read. If you're a fan of urban fantasy, check this series out. Start with book one and you'll be hooked!
There was a ton of humor, as usual. I laughed so hard, so many times, especially about the tie. Just trust me, it's absolutely hilarious. I'm laughing again now just thinking about it. It wasn't all fun and games, though. There were serious moments, twists I didn't see coming, and some shocking revelations.
Despite a slow start, Between Walls ended up being a fantastic read. If you're a fan of urban fantasy, check this series out. Start with book one and you'll be hooked!
December 19, 2021
4 1/4 stars. I love this series. This book was a little slow in getting started and there wasn't a big, explosive end but it is still an important book. Pet is definitely growing up. She finds out in this book things aren't always black and white. Just because she thinks this is the way things should go, maybe, just maybe, it shouldn't. Life is complicated, particularly with the forces she is dealing with.
Her three weirdos are back. I love their interaction. There are some really funny moments dealing with Jin's tie and a frog. Somebody's caught Pet's eye. He needs to come back in the future (other than the short story).
Some mysteries are solved and there are always more questions. I want the next book! Please don't make me wait a year. Beg, piteously.
Her three weirdos are back. I love their interaction. There are some really funny moments dealing with Jin's tie and a frog. Somebody's caught Pet's eye. He needs to come back in the future (other than the short story).
Some mysteries are solved and there are always more questions. I want the next book! Please don't make me wait a year. Beg, piteously.
June 9, 2020
I love Pet, her skewed vantage point and humor make my day. I love JinYeong for the lovely hate/love relationship he... well, "enjoys" might be a strong word, but that's the one I'll use. Though I'm not sure where Pet's head is over this, I think the boy's a goner. Athelas maintains his posture of debonair and fond (if homicidal) uncle. And Zero finally manages to actually show his thawing in the form of actions. Any visit with this series brightens my day!
Some plot points are finally resolved. I had been waiting to see what the deal was with Morgana, because there obviously was one, but I have to say I didn't quite expect the one we got. Very well done. But there are still so very many questions! Argh! Waiting is such sweet agony!
Some plot points are finally resolved. I had been waiting to see what the deal was with Morgana, because there obviously was one, but I have to say I didn't quite expect the one we got. Very well done. But there are still so very many questions! Argh! Waiting is such sweet agony!
June 4, 2020
4.5. The first half felt a bit slow, but the second half was absolutely amazing. And wow ouch did the ending hit me hard. Now I’m just sad that I’ve run out of the series again. I feel like we’re getting so close to learning more about Pet, her past, who and what she is, and maybe even her name. I’m very excited. Though the majority of this book felt like build up, the plot a bit weaker, leaving me hungry for more but not completely satisfied? Ioved it, I want more, greedy me.
I was a bit disappointed by the cover art though. It didn’t follow the previous pattern which I though was stunning.
I was a bit disappointed by the cover art though. It didn’t follow the previous pattern which I though was stunning.
June 22, 2020
Oh my gosh, WR Gingell, I've followed this series from the beginning and I did not see the ending of this book coming! Wow. KInda dark, definitely unexpected, and raises all sorts of questions. Now we have to wait for the next book in the series, darn it. I like the female main character, Pet, love the world building and supporting cast, especially JinYeong and Athelas. This series is humorous, unique, a bit gruesome at times, and hard to put down. I wouldn't start with this book, to get the full enjoyment and backstory, start with the first book and work you way through. It'll be well worth it if you enjoy well-written fantasy from a fresh point of view.
May 12, 2024
In the exciting 6th book, Pet is back home but things are defiantly changing with the dynamics in the house. Pet is also getting a lot better at working the Behind. There is a Novella that takes place before this book, Cloudy with a Chance of Dropbears. That book is referenced fairly heavily in his one and talked about in all of the rest of the books as well. It introduces a new regular character. Back to the review, I love the new dynamics!
September 3, 2020
UGH. Do not like what is seeming to be a setup for a Pet/Zero romance.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 165 reviews