The gist: The rug has been pulled from below Lady Caitlin’s feet. Her disgraceful father has gambled her inheritance away even though it wasn’t rightly his to gamble away. The house had belonged to her mother and was supposed to go directly to Caitlin. Now she has to try to get the house back, but the only way to get it back is to make a deal with the new deed owner. Harlow is the Duke of Dangerfield and he HATES Caitlin’s father with a passion. It gave his heart great pleasure to take the house from Caitlin’s father. The fire in Caitlin’s eyes when she storms into his den of debauchery, however, has a fire igniting deep in his belly. He’s looking forward to having both the estate AND Caitlin.
Okay, so here’s the deal. I really liked Caitlin and Harlow, but the story was just so-so for me. It was going ALRIGHT, but then something completely unexpected happens. I don’t want to say what because I don’t want to spoil it, but the story just kind of gets a little bit ridiculous. I also had some issues with the historical aspects of the story. The most notable historical issue I had with the story is that Caitlin’s father never seems to be in the picture. He’s an earl and somewhat impoverished thanks to his poor gambling skills. He refused to give Caitlin a proper Season because he deemed it too expensive, but giving her a proper Season could have set him up nicely since she was incredibly beautiful and could have made a quite prosperous match. So anyway, he refused to give her a Season and evidently just left her to live by herself in the country estate. She’s a virginal, proper lady, yet he seems to just leave her to her own devices. I like that Caitlin is unconventional for a Lady of the ton and I don’t have a problem with THAT, but it’s just completely unrealistic that she’s allowed to roam around the countryside unchaperoned and I have a problem with THAT. The “something unexpected” is a medical situation and Caitlin is brought to Harlow’s house instead of her own. Not only that, but she STAYS at his house while she recuperates, all while her father has apparently no role in her care or anything. Then, when Caitlin and Harlow decide they want to get married, once again her father isn’t asked his permission or anything along the lines. It was just weird.
I did feel a connection to both Caitlin and Harlow. When they had a big misunderstanding that hinders their getting closer to each other, my gut was clenching and I just wanted them to COMMUNICATE (which is the prime reason for anguish in romance novels) and be together already. I was happy with their happily ever after, but the ridiculousness that happens dimmed it for me a bit.
The book also needed a quick proofread as there were quite a few typos that drove me a little nuts.
Overall, the book wasn’t AWFUL but it wasn’t GREAT either. I am intrigued enough to read at least the next book in the Wicked Wagers series, though.