Aliens vs cowboys
Raging: minus 3
Goodreads have blocked my seeing other reviews as is usual on all my review pages for a year now. 🤔 I am suggesting that you browse all the others, for details that I may have missed. At this rewrite, I can not claim to remember this story and am working from my previous reaction to it.
Goodreads also masked the ID's of commenters on all my reviews. 🤔 After I mentioned that in other reviews, they removed the masks from Powers of the Earth. How sad is this site. 🙂
That last convinced me to close my pages to comments and purge all my lurkers, but one. Goodreads will not allow me to remove my last lurker, Dr Susan Hamilton (a Maths professor at University of Tennessee ?). 🤔🤔🤔 She posted nothing for more than 2 years after her friend request. She has not responded to four requests that she unfriend me. I do not know if this is a stolen ID but why she should need to be my "friend" is beyond me. Trust me, I am the least interesting person whom I know.😊
As they say, "Write one brutal review of an 'ode to the heroes of the January 6, 2021 insurrection' and suddenly being a communist is a bad thing". How surprising. 😃
If curious, see my review of "Stowaway", a poor space adventure or Powers of the Earth (an ode to the heroes of the January 6, 2021 insurrection) and the comments of a Claes Rees, Jr/cgr710 (a self-identified NeoNazi and US patriot).
To Claes Rees, Rees, Jr/cgr710
Don't be a numpty. Be a smarty. Come and join the Communist Party.
I wonder sometimes what motivates US patriots (Tucker Carlson, Claes Rees Jr and the US Republican Party, for example) to support Putin who has threatened nuclear war against their own country. Besides the huge gold transfers, I now think that it may be the lure of acquiring their own Ukrainian slaves (I mean several of the 2 million forcibly relocated Ukrainians sent to Siberia). In any case.
Today Kherson! Tomorrow Crimea! GLORY TO UKRAINE !!! and GLORY TO THE HEROES !!!
This is a western with aliens and no clear picture of the why or even where of it. The only western stories that I have read, are science fiction novels. They are not usually the best thought out and skimp on the world building. I did not find this interesting enough to want to read any later books.
The nineteenth century general tech is combined with cold hard magic, which has limits that are fairly clear. The mention that the overlords arrived from another world raises all manner of question but of answers there are none.
The mix of races implies that more than one originates off world, which juices up the background but again no answer. That is the extent of the background. Is this Earth? Why are the various aliens on this planet? How long have they been there? As a reader, like me you will not know.
The book fell to the bane of the low end novel, ominous drum roll please --- "no serious world building". It had to be said. Once you settle your nerves, you will thank me. Forget the character work, the plot, the scene descriptions because without context, the characters will not engage you. If they do not, the book will have failed no matter how pretty the prose.
As an adventure read, it is flat. If made as a movie it would not be as entertaining as "Cowboys vs Aliens". That movie was bad (and I loved it) but this book has all of its illogic and takes more than ninety minutes to finish.
Most of current US low end science fiction is much worse than this. The streaming services offer stories that have some ideas worth exploring or characters that capture your attention. If the movie fails, you have spent only ninety minutes and did not have to decipher unedited text to be disappointed. Netflix also have a good multinational selection.
I began searching YouTube two years ago for science fiction channels. I discovered all manner of special interest channels. Finally I stumbled upon the book channels and it was love at first video. 😍😍 The varied channels address library redecorating through book challenges, in short they are a bibliophile's dream. The reader communities are thoughtful, with varied interests and tastes but above all embrace the entirety of the bookish experience. They are completely opposite to whatever Goodreads are. I recommend a visit to several book channels, for any reader and have listed some below.
In addition to the essay and documentary channels hosted by YouTube, I found through their YouTube advertisements the dedicated educational video sites.They are all good but I tried Curiosity Stream/Nebula first at a cost of about $15 USD for a yearly subscription.
Last note about Goodreads. Minimize information on your profile. Remove the lurkers (he or she who has a handful of friends and never posts anything). I had the experience regularly of two to four commenters within two or three hours on a newly posted negative Goodreads only review. 🤔
Please protect yourself. Treat Goodreads as a potentially hostile site.
My YouTube picks of the moment.
TVP News, Jacobin, Filaxim Historia, Danni and Joe, Adult Wednesday Addams, Philomena Cunk, The Researcher. 2Cellos, Philosophy Tube, May Moon Narrowboat, Vlad Vexler, Physics Girl, Alt Shift X, NFKRZ, New Economic Thinking.
Some of my favorite channels are.
Chugging Along, Ship Happens, Munecat, Novara Media, Eleanor Morton, Some More News, Tulia, Tara Mooknee, Second Thought, The Juice Media, Lindsey Stirling, Book Odyssey, Owen Jones, Philosophy Tube, Sabine Hossenfelder, Sort of Interesting, Cruising the Cut, Then & Now, Kings and Generals, Linguoer Mechanic, The Gravel Institute, Prime of Midlife, Real Time History, Aaron Bastani, Real Science, Tibees, Autumn's Boutique, Real Crusades History, Redcoat British Military History, BrandonF, Atun Shei, A Clockwork Reader, The Angry Astronaut, Hakim, Tom Nicholas, The Piano Guys, Big Maj Studios, Noah Samsen, Adult Wednesday Addams, Traveling K, Ben and Emily, Overly Sarcastic Productions, Engineering with Rosie, Three Arrows, Sarah Z, Brittany the Bibliophile, Hello Future Me, We're in Hell, Celtica, What Vivi did next, Casey Aonso, Karolina Zebrowska, Jill Bearup, Depressed Russian, Boat Time, Lilly's expat life, The Shades of Orange, Double Down News, The European, Bovington Tank Museum, Denys Davydov, With Olivia, Chloe Stafler, Real Engineering, Pro Robotics, Ryan Chapman, Books with Chloe, UA Courage, A Cup of Nicole, A Life of Lit, Useful Idiots, !Kathy's Flog in France, Camper Vibe, History Marche, Crecganford, Paleo Analysis, Caspian Report, Ancient Geographics, Quinn's Ideas, Vlad Vexler, Spacedock, The Tesla Domain, WION, DUST, Janelle Kayla, Autumn's Boutique, Rowan J Coleman, Mythic Concepts, Diane Callahan Quotidian Writer, Storyworldling, Natasha's Adventures, Trek Culture, Steve Shives, Jessie Gender, The People Profiles, Jabzy, IzzzYzzz, Zoe Baker, May Moon Narrowboat, Northern Narrowboaters, Holly the Cafe Boat, Danica Patrick.
I wish you a glorious morning, a splendid afternoon, a wonderful evening, a relaxing night and may we all keep learning.
Hope is not an expression of hopelessness.
William Wallace