You probably know that having young children memorize new words or relegating vocabulary instruction to one time of day is not the way to go, but you may not know what else to do to support students' vocabulary development. In this guide, Tanya Wright shows you how to make word learning more meaningful and engaging as you incorporate teaching about words across the day. Young children love to learn and use new words; the key is to tap into their natural curiosity and excitement. Tanya shows you how to create opportunities for children to think about and use words in meaningful contexts during read aloud, content-area learning, reading instruction, and writing instruction-all day long! Classroom videos of teachers and children learning about words bring the ideas to life, and a friendly "What We Know" feature highlights important research that informs the practice.
The actual content is 2- or 3-stars: I found it a bit underwhelming. But the 1-star rating is because this is the worst designed book I've read in years. It is a paperback and is about double the width of a normal paperback, which makes it extremely awkward to hold it open with your hands as you would a normal book. It really needs to be propped on a flat surface because it is so floppy and unwieldy.
Then they've made these inexplicable choices to put white text in call out boxes that are a melange of light pastels and whites: in other words white text on white boxes. Even with my glasses and in bright light I found it hard to read. Not hard as in "I couldn't read" but as in "this takes way more focus and concentration and effort than reading should for an expert reader".
Between those two things reading this was an extremely unpleasant experience: it required ideal conditions both for propping the book open and for lighting to be able to make out the text.
On to the actual content: I didn't have many (any?) takeaways from this. I'm sympathetic to the challenge of books like this because the target audience could be anything from a physics relief teacher suddenly asked to start teaching English Language Arts for K-3 to a someone who's followed a fair amount of the ideas and research in the area.
Here's what I mean: early on there are several pages on how do we learn new words anyway? "We need repeated exposure to words in meaningful contexts", "we learn words that are relevant and useful", "we learn words when we have opportunities for active processing" (i.e. more than just passively receiving a definition).
That's followed by when do we learn new words? "We learn new words when we engage in conversation" and "we learn new words when we read" and "we learn new words when we learn new things".
I'm not saying there's nobody out there who needs to hear that. There are definitely vocabulary lessons that do a poor job of using those principles -- memorising lists of definitions that seem to have nothing do with one another and are never used outside of that memorisation and weekly quiz.
So what should we do better? "Explain word meanings in context" (during read-alouds). I suppose some teachers might not do this? Surely anyone who has ever been a parent realises they need to do this? In the author's defense, they do offer a bit more than this. You need to read the book before to get a feel for what things might need to be explained, so you can prep a child-friendly explanation, perhaps even source a picture (which often helps immeasurably, it is one thing to say "a capybara is a cousin of the mouse but big like a dog and lives in rivers in South America" and another to supplement that with a picture of a capybara).
But at this point we're 42 pages into a book that's only 120 pages long and (while struggling with the aforementioned terrible design choices) I'm still searching for something to takeaway.
An awful lot of the book is like this. "Find time to read aloud often" (at least once per day in a K-3 classroom); "Read only part of the text ... there is no rule that you need to read an entire text in one sitting"; "Encourage families to read aloud"; "Include a variety of texts in the classrooms" (a variety of genres, authors, topics, etc); "Extend reading beyond the school day ... take your class to the school library".
Perhaps I'm being unfair by cherry picking things -- and to be fair the last 20 pages does have better topics on introducing morphology and strategies for unknown words -- but overall I found a lot of this book pretty obvious stuff.
Maybe that means I'm more of an expert in vocabulary development than I thought?
My biggest takeaway from the book was the concept of "text sets" which is the idea that we should curate multiple readings in the same area instead of across several areas. That is, instead of reading books on coral reefs, wolves, glaciers, and birds -- which will share little or no common vocabulary -- we should pick a set of books on the same narrow subject so they will reuse vocabulary and concepts (less pre-teaching, seeing the same word in different contexts helps add nuance and embeds it, etc).
Taking a step back from vocabulary per se, this same idea "go for depth instead of breadth" seems to be a common suggestion in many areas where too many parts of schooling feel the need to introduce a million topics but all at a superficial level such that none of them really leave a residue of thought. It doesn't help that virtually all standardised curriculum/standards push teachers in this direction with their surfeit of "required" topics.