After Paige and Dario spend the night together, she's even more confused about what she wants, but she doesn't have long to think about it when tragedy strikes, one that will affect them all. She goes over to visit her mother, so she can think things through, and while she's there, she tries to build bridges with her sister, but things don't go to plan when Kelsey keeps making up excuses as to why she can't come over, and the truth soon comes out. Paige plans to spend a few extra days in Nebraska, when she receives a strange voicemail from Maverick, and doesn't think twice about getting on a plane, and goes to find him. She has a choice to make, one that will leave Dario behind. As they try to move on, Paige receives some unexpected news that will change all of their lives, but Dario still refuses to let her go, and offers her a deal. But how far is Paige willing to go for the perfect life she wants so bad? And just when she thinks things will be okay, Dario's past catches up with them, and the perfect life Paige was hoping for is soon shattered.