What do you think?
Rate this book
The Story of Catherine Howard #1
Shadow of Persephone
February 1542
A young woman awaits her execution in the Tower of London, sent to death on the orders of her husband, Henry VIII.
Daughter of the nobility, cousin to a fallen Queen, Catherine Howard rose from the cluttered ranks of courtiers at the court of Henry VIII to become the King's fifth wife. But hers is a tale that starts long before the crown was placed on her head. A tale of tragedy and challenges, predators and prey; the story of a young girl growing up in a perilous time, facing dangers untold.
The fifth wife of Henry VIII would end her life on the block, like her cousin Anne Boleyn... But where did her story begin?
Shadow of Persephone is Book One in the series The Story of Catherine Howard, by G. Lawrence
The Author's thanks are due to Julia Gibbs, proof reader, and Amelie Designs, cover artist.
RUNNING TIME ⇒ 16hrs. and 17mins.
©2019 Gemma Lawrence (P)2020 Tantor
A young woman awaits her execution in the Tower of London, sent to death on the orders of her husband, Henry VIII.
Daughter of the nobility, cousin to a fallen Queen, Catherine Howard rose from the cluttered ranks of courtiers at the court of Henry VIII to become the King's fifth wife. But hers is a tale that starts long before the crown was placed on her head. A tale of tragedy and challenges, predators and prey; the story of a young girl growing up in a perilous time, facing dangers untold.
The fifth wife of Henry VIII would end her life on the block, like her cousin Anne Boleyn... But where did her story begin?
Shadow of Persephone is Book One in the series The Story of Catherine Howard, by G. Lawrence
The Author's thanks are due to Julia Gibbs, proof reader, and Amelie Designs, cover artist.
RUNNING TIME ⇒ 16hrs. and 17mins.
©2019 Gemma Lawrence (P)2020 Tantor
Audible Audio
First published February 24, 2019
503 people are currently reading
436 people want to read
About the author
G. Lawrence
50 books278 followersI am an independently published author, and proud to be so. Living in a little cottage in Wales in the UK, I love where I live as much as I love to write.
The age of the Tudors has been an obsession for me since I was a child, and many of my upcoming books will center on that time, but I also pen the odd dystopian fiction or historical fiction from other time periods. I will be releasing all my titles on amazon, for kindle and then hopefully for print later.
I studied Literature (with a capital L) at University and usually have twenty or more books I'm currently reading. Reading and writing are about mood for me, and I haven't found a genre I didn't enjoy something about so far...
You can often find me on Wattpad or Twitter when I'm not writing...
The age of the Tudors has been an obsession for me since I was a child, and many of my upcoming books will center on that time, but I also pen the odd dystopian fiction or historical fiction from other time periods. I will be releasing all my titles on amazon, for kindle and then hopefully for print later.
I studied Literature (with a capital L) at University and usually have twenty or more books I'm currently reading. Reading and writing are about mood for me, and I haven't found a genre I didn't enjoy something about so far...
You can often find me on Wattpad or Twitter when I'm not writing...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews
March 5, 2019
Gemma Lawrence has given an interesting and unusual view of Catherine Howard in this first book about her life, which starts when she was a child and sent to be brought up at the house of her grandmother, Agnes Howard, and takes us right through to her wedding to Henry VIII. Ms Lawrence gives a thorough explanation, in the back of the book, about why she sees her not as the frivolous, superficial butterfly who knew little and cared less, but as a abused, lonely child, damaged by her early experiences, who, though not academically educated, was intelligent, clever, and used those experiences to gather her wits about her for what was to come.
As with all Ms Lawrence's books, this spares no historical detail. In the first twenty per cent, when Catherine was child and the country was caught up in the saga of Anne Boleyn and Katherine of Aragon, there is much talk of what was going on at court. This is conveyed mostly in staged conversation between Agnes Howard and the Duke of Norfolk (almost like a play), and although it is interesting, and relevant to the world in which Catherine would eventually find herself, I looked forward to getting back to the story of Catherine. As the novel progresses, her own life soon takes centre stage once more, and I was completely engrossed; it was one of the those books that got better and better as it went along, and by 80% I was trying to read slowly to make it last longer
The second half of the book concerns much about when Catherine went to court, and the Anne of Cleves fiasco. This part was particularly fascinating to me, as I have only read a few accounts of the second and more fortunate Anne, the true winner in the tale of Henry VIII's six wives. I loved the court gossip; much of the tale is told in this way.
Few reliable accounts about Catherine Howard exist, and if I sometimes thought that Ms Lawrence wrote her as more mature, analytical and intelligent than one imagines her, this all made sense in the notes about her at the back, where Ms Lawrence gives a highly convincing argument for the young Howard girl having far more savvy than history would have us believe - you've won me over to your way of thinking, Gemma! If you already know the story of Catherine, it might make sense to read these first.
The novel tells us much about the lot of women in those days - even if rich, from a 'good' family and in possession of much beauty and intelligence, their lives were never their own, with their futures completely at the whim of men's wishes and politics. Those who played survived and gained some happiness were masters of the game, or simply those who were in the right place at the right time - but even clever souls like Anne Boleyn and Catherine could not get every move right. Maybe the cleverest of all were those who understood their lot and didn't try to assert themselves - like Anne of Cleves.
This was a fine book, and I am already counting the days until the release of the second part.
As with all Ms Lawrence's books, this spares no historical detail. In the first twenty per cent, when Catherine was child and the country was caught up in the saga of Anne Boleyn and Katherine of Aragon, there is much talk of what was going on at court. This is conveyed mostly in staged conversation between Agnes Howard and the Duke of Norfolk (almost like a play), and although it is interesting, and relevant to the world in which Catherine would eventually find herself, I looked forward to getting back to the story of Catherine. As the novel progresses, her own life soon takes centre stage once more, and I was completely engrossed; it was one of the those books that got better and better as it went along, and by 80% I was trying to read slowly to make it last longer
The second half of the book concerns much about when Catherine went to court, and the Anne of Cleves fiasco. This part was particularly fascinating to me, as I have only read a few accounts of the second and more fortunate Anne, the true winner in the tale of Henry VIII's six wives. I loved the court gossip; much of the tale is told in this way.
Few reliable accounts about Catherine Howard exist, and if I sometimes thought that Ms Lawrence wrote her as more mature, analytical and intelligent than one imagines her, this all made sense in the notes about her at the back, where Ms Lawrence gives a highly convincing argument for the young Howard girl having far more savvy than history would have us believe - you've won me over to your way of thinking, Gemma! If you already know the story of Catherine, it might make sense to read these first.
The novel tells us much about the lot of women in those days - even if rich, from a 'good' family and in possession of much beauty and intelligence, their lives were never their own, with their futures completely at the whim of men's wishes and politics. Those who played survived and gained some happiness were masters of the game, or simply those who were in the right place at the right time - but even clever souls like Anne Boleyn and Catherine could not get every move right. Maybe the cleverest of all were those who understood their lot and didn't try to assert themselves - like Anne of Cleves.
This was a fine book, and I am already counting the days until the release of the second part.
April 3, 2019
Excellent
This book is another excellent example of well-written historical fiction from Ms. Lawrence. Her vivid description of historical detail is engrossing and among some of the best historical fiction that I have had the pleasure to read. Catherine Howard, the fifth of Henry VIII's wives is a misunderstood woman and history, in general, is dismissive of her as a flighty, promiscuous adulterer. This book, however, presents a more even portrait while still basing the story on known historical facts. This version is much more sympathic and tries to establish the basis for her later behavior. The book is only part one of her story and ends on the day of her marriage to the King. I am very much looking forward to the next book.
This book is another excellent example of well-written historical fiction from Ms. Lawrence. Her vivid description of historical detail is engrossing and among some of the best historical fiction that I have had the pleasure to read. Catherine Howard, the fifth of Henry VIII's wives is a misunderstood woman and history, in general, is dismissive of her as a flighty, promiscuous adulterer. This book, however, presents a more even portrait while still basing the story on known historical facts. This version is much more sympathic and tries to establish the basis for her later behavior. The book is only part one of her story and ends on the day of her marriage to the King. I am very much looking forward to the next book.
February 3, 2020
This is a refreshing portrayal of Catherine. She spends her life subject to the wants of men, from her father, tutors, uncle and the king.
Catherine is depicted as a pawn to all these men who wish to further their own ambition and desire for selfish reasons giving little regard to Catherine's feelings with the exception of Henry who genuinely appears to love her which is all she's ever wanted, to be loved.
Lawrence brings Catherine to life and provides a story based on true history with fictional embellishments and the result is outstanding. I haven't seen Catherine as a victim before but this depiction gives an alternative view to those I've previously read and I'm inclined to view Catherine in a new light. Catherine is usually known as young and flighty but this book brings us her earlier life, something I'd not really read about. All throughout Catherine's life there is turmoil in England, from the execution of her cousin Anne Boleyn, the dissolution of the monasteries and other major historical events. Lawrence brings all of these to the forefront through the girls and the Dowager Duchess gossiping.
It's a striking portrayal of the Tudor court, from the people to the palaces and the clothing. I loved how the court gossip provided insight in to Anne of Cleves and how she found herself in a very beneficial position following her separation from Henry VIII.
The writing style is beautiful and descriptive but very easy to read and I found myself drawn in to Catherine's life.
I highly enjoyed this book and have already got myself a copy of the second instalment No More Time to Dance. I'm excited to continue with Catherine's story as she embarks on her journey as Henry VIII's fifth queen.
Catherine is depicted as a pawn to all these men who wish to further their own ambition and desire for selfish reasons giving little regard to Catherine's feelings with the exception of Henry who genuinely appears to love her which is all she's ever wanted, to be loved.
Lawrence brings Catherine to life and provides a story based on true history with fictional embellishments and the result is outstanding. I haven't seen Catherine as a victim before but this depiction gives an alternative view to those I've previously read and I'm inclined to view Catherine in a new light. Catherine is usually known as young and flighty but this book brings us her earlier life, something I'd not really read about. All throughout Catherine's life there is turmoil in England, from the execution of her cousin Anne Boleyn, the dissolution of the monasteries and other major historical events. Lawrence brings all of these to the forefront through the girls and the Dowager Duchess gossiping.
It's a striking portrayal of the Tudor court, from the people to the palaces and the clothing. I loved how the court gossip provided insight in to Anne of Cleves and how she found herself in a very beneficial position following her separation from Henry VIII.
The writing style is beautiful and descriptive but very easy to read and I found myself drawn in to Catherine's life.
I highly enjoyed this book and have already got myself a copy of the second instalment No More Time to Dance. I'm excited to continue with Catherine's story as she embarks on her journey as Henry VIII's fifth queen.
April 10, 2020
This is a beautiful account of the early days of Catherine Howard before she married Henry Viii its a different view of her to what I have read before and looking for to read book 2 ‘No Time To Dance’
March 9, 2024
A shocking tale of abuse and ignorance. Not exactly enjoyable but well done and interesting. Thank goodness we live in better times. Or do we?
March 11, 2019
A thought provoking book
A very talented writer and a very different view on Catherine Howard from some other books I have read. A very good read as always.
A very talented writer and a very different view on Catherine Howard from some other books I have read. A very good read as always.
July 29, 2025
As a historical fiction writer, I approached G. Lawrence's "Shadow of Persephone" with curiosity. Catherine Howard has long been dismissed as little more than a footnote in Tudor history, a pretty, foolish girl who rose too high and fell too fast. But what G. Lawrence offers here is a reckoning, a reclamation, and, most compellingly, a voice. Listening to the audiobook, narrated with haunting grace by Elizabeth Klett, I felt not just pulled into Catherine's story but held there, quietly, unflinchingly.
This is an introspective, often poetic exploration of girlhood forged in the crucible of courtly manipulation. Lawrence gives us a Catherine who is thoughtful, observant, and far more self-aware than history has allowed.
The writing is lyrical, laced with wisdom and sharp as a needle hidden in silk. One passage stayed with me: "Women can be the best and worst of friends to other women. At worst, they can be spiteful, vicious and cruel... And at their best, women are remarkable; supportive, warm..." These are not mere musings. They form the spine of Catherine's experience. In a world where women wielded influence only in whispers and glances, Lawrence lays bare the quiet warfare of courtly life—a battlefield of veiled barbs and unspoken alliances.
Elizabeth Klett’s narration is superb. She does not perform Catherine; she becomes her. The restraint in her voice during Catherine’s final days, the breath of vulnerability wrapped in moments of clarity and strength—these choices elevate the text beyond reading and into memory. Her tone carries the weight of hindsight and the freshness of youthful hope all at once.
As a writer, I was struck by Lawrence’s discipline in resisting the urge to romanticize. There is beauty here, yes, but also rot, tension, and an ever-present sense of dread. The horror of Catherine’s fate is not in the bloodshed, but in how inevitable it feels. Lawrence makes you see each misstep not as foolishness, but as the consequence of a girl playing a game whose rules were stacked against her from birth.
"Shadow of Persephone" is a triumph of empathy over judgment. It doesn’t seek to rescue Catherine Howard from her fate, but to understand her before it. For those of us who write history into fiction, this is the kind of novel that reminds us why we do it: not to change the past, but to lend it the dignity of depth.
Highly recommended in audio. Elizabeth Klett’s voice will stay with you long after the final chapter closes.
"If I could give you the world, my Catherine, I would."
(Audible)
This is an introspective, often poetic exploration of girlhood forged in the crucible of courtly manipulation. Lawrence gives us a Catherine who is thoughtful, observant, and far more self-aware than history has allowed.
The writing is lyrical, laced with wisdom and sharp as a needle hidden in silk. One passage stayed with me: "Women can be the best and worst of friends to other women. At worst, they can be spiteful, vicious and cruel... And at their best, women are remarkable; supportive, warm..." These are not mere musings. They form the spine of Catherine's experience. In a world where women wielded influence only in whispers and glances, Lawrence lays bare the quiet warfare of courtly life—a battlefield of veiled barbs and unspoken alliances.
Elizabeth Klett’s narration is superb. She does not perform Catherine; she becomes her. The restraint in her voice during Catherine’s final days, the breath of vulnerability wrapped in moments of clarity and strength—these choices elevate the text beyond reading and into memory. Her tone carries the weight of hindsight and the freshness of youthful hope all at once.
As a writer, I was struck by Lawrence’s discipline in resisting the urge to romanticize. There is beauty here, yes, but also rot, tension, and an ever-present sense of dread. The horror of Catherine’s fate is not in the bloodshed, but in how inevitable it feels. Lawrence makes you see each misstep not as foolishness, but as the consequence of a girl playing a game whose rules were stacked against her from birth.
"Shadow of Persephone" is a triumph of empathy over judgment. It doesn’t seek to rescue Catherine Howard from her fate, but to understand her before it. For those of us who write history into fiction, this is the kind of novel that reminds us why we do it: not to change the past, but to lend it the dignity of depth.
Highly recommended in audio. Elizabeth Klett’s voice will stay with you long after the final chapter closes.
"If I could give you the world, my Catherine, I would."
(Audible)
February 26, 2020
This is pretty average fiction, maybe slightly better than average Tudor fiction, though it was the first I've read specifically about Catherine Howard.
There are a few irritating narrative devices used: a first person narrator describing herself in a way no one actually talks about themselves ("my delicate cheek"), and explaining things to the reader that would not need to be explained ("But think not that she was cruel or unusual. All children were flogged when they did wrong..."--if that's not unusual, it doesn't need to be explained in anachronistic fashion. This is telling not showing, and in this instance, it's lazy storytelling.) For the first quarter of the book, most of the story is about events Catherine has no firsthand experience of and which are delivered as dialogue overheard by the narrator, or between the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk and a young Catherine Howard. It reads more like a history book (not one with a particularly interesting point of view), and less like a novel. It was a lot of exposition about Katherine of Aragon and Anne Boelyn, to the point that it seems Book 1 really should not have been about Catherine at all so we could just be there to get all the information instead of hearing it second hand.
On the other hand, Shadow of Persephone does some things remarkably well, probably nothing more than developing the menacing presence of Henry Manox in Catherine's early life, according to this interpretation. It is actually quite unsettling. It also establishes the character of Catherine as both innocent and thrill-seeking in a way that is eminently believable--I'm thoroughly convinced of her interpretation of Catherine's development as shaped by her trauma.
The book finally joins Catherine about a third of the way through when the household moves to Lambeth, and it improves considerably at that point. But it still moves slowly and depends too much on Catherine telling us what others are saying (about the negotiations for Henry VIII's fourth marriage and other world alliances) rather than what she observes. But I suppose a book is bound to drag when you take the story of a woman who died at 19 and try to stretch it into more than one novel.
There are a few irritating narrative devices used: a first person narrator describing herself in a way no one actually talks about themselves ("my delicate cheek"), and explaining things to the reader that would not need to be explained ("But think not that she was cruel or unusual. All children were flogged when they did wrong..."--if that's not unusual, it doesn't need to be explained in anachronistic fashion. This is telling not showing, and in this instance, it's lazy storytelling.) For the first quarter of the book, most of the story is about events Catherine has no firsthand experience of and which are delivered as dialogue overheard by the narrator, or between the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk and a young Catherine Howard. It reads more like a history book (not one with a particularly interesting point of view), and less like a novel. It was a lot of exposition about Katherine of Aragon and Anne Boelyn, to the point that it seems Book 1 really should not have been about Catherine at all so we could just be there to get all the information instead of hearing it second hand.
On the other hand, Shadow of Persephone does some things remarkably well, probably nothing more than developing the menacing presence of Henry Manox in Catherine's early life, according to this interpretation. It is actually quite unsettling. It also establishes the character of Catherine as both innocent and thrill-seeking in a way that is eminently believable--I'm thoroughly convinced of her interpretation of Catherine's development as shaped by her trauma.
The book finally joins Catherine about a third of the way through when the household moves to Lambeth, and it improves considerably at that point. But it still moves slowly and depends too much on Catherine telling us what others are saying (about the negotiations for Henry VIII's fourth marriage and other world alliances) rather than what she observes. But I suppose a book is bound to drag when you take the story of a woman who died at 19 and try to stretch it into more than one novel.
August 1, 2020
Lost interest.
September 17, 2019
The first half of this book was tedious and didn't feel believable. It seemed like the author was trying to cram too many historical facts into the story via the guise of a child (Catherine) listening to her elders' conversations. Everything felt contrived and almost like I was reading a nonfiction account of events surrounding Katherine of Aragon and Anne Boleyn. I almost quit reading. I'm glad I stuck with it though, because the second half of the book, as it began to center around Catherine, became much more believable and interesting and finally compelling. This was an entirely new presentation of Catherine, unlike any I had read before, and it made sense. I won't spoil it to share the details, but Gemma's writing is so convincing it's almost as if she is sharing her own intimate knowledge about a specific type of situation (read the book to see what I'm talking about) in telling Catherine's story. I don't know how else she could present such a convincing picture of who Catherine was and all the psychological nuances of what was going on and how she responded to those things (other than being a great writer I guess, lol). Still, if I had to guess, I'd think she'd experienced what she was writing about. It was so REAL. The author's notes in the back of the book were also insightful. After finishing, I hurried on to the second book! I'm glad I persevered past the first half of this one because the insight and historical detail from that point on was well worth my time.
January 26, 2020
As a heads up this book absolutely tries to shove 21st century ideas and attitudes on Tudor characters. It’s disconcerting and comes off as trying too hard. It wasn’t a bad book, but I have no interest in reading the sequel.
September 23, 2019
This was certainly thought provoking as history tends to paint Catherine Howard as flighty, empty headed, morally loose, and slutty which is extremely unfair. However, the author here takes a more enlightened outlook on Catherine Howard. In this novel she is shown to be a victim of sexual abuse as a young girl and even as a teenager. I believe she was abused in some form since men were encouraged to sexually accost and abuse women in the name of “courtly love”. Horrible and disturbing but common place in Tudor era noble households and Court.
There is a strong argument to be made that Henry Manox molested Catherine as a child, and that Francis Dereham raped her as a teenager. At the very least both are guilty of statutory rape by today’s standards. Let me be absolutely clear: BOTH of them were predators. When interrogated, the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk admitted to knowing her charges engaged in sexual activities and did nothing to stop it. She further burned all evidence trying to hide her guilt and complicity.
I believe it, since men were trusted completely and the fault was always entirely on the woman. To this day it is still like this and woman are afraid to come forward against their abusers. It’s so easy to see how Catherine’s reputation could have been tarnished and the predator believed.
During her fall from grace no evidence was found that proved Catherine Howard had an extramarital sexual relationship with either Thomas C. Or Francis Dereham. All she was accused of was made up by her enemies to unseat her as Queen. She was convicted on INTENT/Conspiracy to have a sexual relationship with Thomas and Francis, therefore potentially polluting the royal bloodline (treason).
I believe Catherine was falsely accused of adultery like her cousin Anne Boleyn was. Quite sad really. When you reflect on all of this you see that everyone in Catherine’s life had failed and abused her. Her father, grandmother, uncle, cousins, friends, allies, and the king.
History has not been kind to women.
There is a strong argument to be made that Henry Manox molested Catherine as a child, and that Francis Dereham raped her as a teenager. At the very least both are guilty of statutory rape by today’s standards. Let me be absolutely clear: BOTH of them were predators. When interrogated, the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk admitted to knowing her charges engaged in sexual activities and did nothing to stop it. She further burned all evidence trying to hide her guilt and complicity.
I believe it, since men were trusted completely and the fault was always entirely on the woman. To this day it is still like this and woman are afraid to come forward against their abusers. It’s so easy to see how Catherine’s reputation could have been tarnished and the predator believed.
During her fall from grace no evidence was found that proved Catherine Howard had an extramarital sexual relationship with either Thomas C. Or Francis Dereham. All she was accused of was made up by her enemies to unseat her as Queen. She was convicted on INTENT/Conspiracy to have a sexual relationship with Thomas and Francis, therefore potentially polluting the royal bloodline (treason).
I believe Catherine was falsely accused of adultery like her cousin Anne Boleyn was. Quite sad really. When you reflect on all of this you see that everyone in Catherine’s life had failed and abused her. Her father, grandmother, uncle, cousins, friends, allies, and the king.
History has not been kind to women.
October 25, 2024
Story of Catherine Howard #1
Shadow of Persephone
By G. Lawrence
Blurb:
February 1542 A young woman awaits her execution in the Tower of London, sent to death on the orders of her husband, Henry VIII. Daughter of the nobility, cousin to a fallen Queen, Catherine Howard rose from the cluttered ranks of courtiers at the court of Henry VIII to become the King's fifth wife. But hers is a tale that starts long before the crown was placed on her head. A tale of tragedy and challenges, predators and prey; the story of a young girl growing up in a perilous time, facing dangers untold. The fifth wife of Henry VIII would end her life on the block, like her cousin Anne Boleyn... But where did her story begin? Shadow of Persephone is Book One in the series The Story of Catherine Howard, by G. Lawrence
My Review:
I have read a few of books on Henry VIII and on each of his six wives. I very much enjoyed G. Lawrence’s telling of the early years of Catherine Howard, the 5th wife.
I enjoyed that the author interweaved the lives of Katherine of Aragon, Anne Boleyn, Jane Seymour and Anne of Cleves, as they were very much a part of the young Catherine’s life where she lived in the house of her grandmother, Agnes Howard.
The reader should definitely read the author’s account at the end of the book as to why she has portrayed Catherine in the way she has—as an abused child whose damaged experiences affected her throughout her life. I could see Catherine as the intelligent woman much more clearly than the frivolous young woman that she is often portrayed as being. I like this Catherine and feel immensely sorry for her.
Although I know the history, I’m looking forward to reading the second part of Catherine’s life and the author's interpretation of it.
I highly recommended this book if you enjoy historical fiction with a good dose of history.
Shadow of Persephone
By G. Lawrence
Blurb:
February 1542 A young woman awaits her execution in the Tower of London, sent to death on the orders of her husband, Henry VIII. Daughter of the nobility, cousin to a fallen Queen, Catherine Howard rose from the cluttered ranks of courtiers at the court of Henry VIII to become the King's fifth wife. But hers is a tale that starts long before the crown was placed on her head. A tale of tragedy and challenges, predators and prey; the story of a young girl growing up in a perilous time, facing dangers untold. The fifth wife of Henry VIII would end her life on the block, like her cousin Anne Boleyn... But where did her story begin? Shadow of Persephone is Book One in the series The Story of Catherine Howard, by G. Lawrence
My Review:
I have read a few of books on Henry VIII and on each of his six wives. I very much enjoyed G. Lawrence’s telling of the early years of Catherine Howard, the 5th wife.
I enjoyed that the author interweaved the lives of Katherine of Aragon, Anne Boleyn, Jane Seymour and Anne of Cleves, as they were very much a part of the young Catherine’s life where she lived in the house of her grandmother, Agnes Howard.
The reader should definitely read the author’s account at the end of the book as to why she has portrayed Catherine in the way she has—as an abused child whose damaged experiences affected her throughout her life. I could see Catherine as the intelligent woman much more clearly than the frivolous young woman that she is often portrayed as being. I like this Catherine and feel immensely sorry for her.
Although I know the history, I’m looking forward to reading the second part of Catherine’s life and the author's interpretation of it.
I highly recommended this book if you enjoy historical fiction with a good dose of history.
April 27, 2020
I'm a little disappointed - not sure whether it's with the writing or with myself for having read too many books about the wives. This just seemed like a series of this happened and then this happened kinda thing - I couldn't hear the voice, not the child's voice that I should hear - after all, at just 15, she was the youngest of his wives or known mistresses, and today even the thought of it would turn most people's stomachs - especially a victim of child abuse such as Catherine Howard.
Still, History is a different country.
Even if she had been older, even if she had been untouched by paedophiles, even if she had been educated and refined... even then, who refuses a king? Not sure there was, at that time, any way to say no to Henry, even for the rich. He has an axeman, they don't!
It's a good story, for all that. Anyone wanting to know more about the lives of the Howards or the rich in these times, then here is a good place to start - it covers opinion on Anne Boleyn, the most famous and fascinating of the six, and much of what follows, though I'm not sure how Catherine could contrive to be witness to any of that at such a young age (10-11 I think), but there you are. Worth a read, though a little long and if you know a lot about history at this time, you perhaps might be diappointed at not hearing a child's voice as I was. I think it's a case of my own jaded opinion though, so please give this a go. You can always give me your opinion when you disagree - I'm open to that xx
Still, History is a different country.
Even if she had been older, even if she had been untouched by paedophiles, even if she had been educated and refined... even then, who refuses a king? Not sure there was, at that time, any way to say no to Henry, even for the rich. He has an axeman, they don't!
It's a good story, for all that. Anyone wanting to know more about the lives of the Howards or the rich in these times, then here is a good place to start - it covers opinion on Anne Boleyn, the most famous and fascinating of the six, and much of what follows, though I'm not sure how Catherine could contrive to be witness to any of that at such a young age (10-11 I think), but there you are. Worth a read, though a little long and if you know a lot about history at this time, you perhaps might be diappointed at not hearing a child's voice as I was. I think it's a case of my own jaded opinion though, so please give this a go. You can always give me your opinion when you disagree - I'm open to that xx
January 17, 2024
While reading Shadow of Persephone, two words kept coming to mind: Girl Code. For the uninitiated, Girl Code is the universal but unspoken rule that, no matter the circumstance, girls—and women—will have each other’s back. Sure, women can be catty and competitive, but when a girl is in danger, her friends are there to back her up and bail her out. Lawrence’s novel opens in 1531, and we meet our heroine, Catherine Howard, who has just moved into her grandmother’s home because her father is destitute. As I read about young Catherine’s trials, I held my breath, wishing I could transcend the centuries, take the girl by the hand, and show her the way. In other words, I wished I could conjure a little Girl Code. And then suddenly, something almost magical happens: It is as though Lawrence has read my mind. Catherine is called to court to serve Henry VIII’s wife, Anne of Cleves, and in the remaining chapters of the book, Catherine not only masters Girl Code but uses it to change history. And *that* is why I love historical fiction. The facts are there for anyone to report. The art is in the telling.
May 11, 2022
A very good take on the life of Catherine Howard. In this first book we follow her from a rather young and insecure girl, to her wedding day being married off to king Henry VIII. She's still young and insecure, poor thing - and who can blame her. With a life so at the mercy of others, but still trying to be happy, to be positive and generous. Far and few between trustworthy friends, a genuine wish to fit in - and always be at the beck and call of others.
I have a greater sympathy for Catherine after reading this book. I still find her naive and somewhat silly, but she was also so young and found herself in a lot of unwanted and troublesome situations. I will now stop thinking of her as a wain and silly goose, and more consider her a swan. Scrawny and small, but grew into a prettiness that became difficult for her - as others took advantage of just that.
I liked the writing style of Gemma Lawrence, and will probably read more of her books in the future.
I have a greater sympathy for Catherine after reading this book. I still find her naive and somewhat silly, but she was also so young and found herself in a lot of unwanted and troublesome situations. I will now stop thinking of her as a wain and silly goose, and more consider her a swan. Scrawny and small, but grew into a prettiness that became difficult for her - as others took advantage of just that.
I liked the writing style of Gemma Lawrence, and will probably read more of her books in the future.
April 23, 2020
This is a beautiful portrayal of Catherine Howard and should be the go to historical fiction book about her. I have just started to understand Catherine Howard more in depth the past few years, I do not know if it is because I discovered we are cousins on two sides of the Howard clan or not but this book helped me love her even more.
In this book Catherine is how I view her in life, a sympathetic, compassionate youth who had a zest for life. Her past traumas in this book and life help shape her into the woman she becomes.
I absolutely how the author brings her to life and redeems a soul who is so misunderstood. I look forward to the sequel I will begin reading after I make some warm tea and cost myself in. I know the second book will end in tragedy but my love for this author and Catherine will live on. ebook.
Tw: Sexual Abuse, Verbal Abuse, Emotional Abuse, Rape
In this book Catherine is how I view her in life, a sympathetic, compassionate youth who had a zest for life. Her past traumas in this book and life help shape her into the woman she becomes.
I absolutely how the author brings her to life and redeems a soul who is so misunderstood. I look forward to the sequel I will begin reading after I make some warm tea and cost myself in. I know the second book will end in tragedy but my love for this author and Catherine will live on. ebook.
Tw: Sexual Abuse, Verbal Abuse, Emotional Abuse, Rape
November 22, 2021
I enjoyed this book a great deal; Catherine Howard is a historical figure not often shown sympathy or given any agency in fiction or non-fiction, but the author really excels writing engaging, dynamic characters and Catherine in particular is well developed even if she doesn't actually do much for the first two thirds of the novel. This is a bit of a weakness as most of the first part of the novel is devoted to characters telling Catherine what her queen-cousin Anne Boleyn is going through off-page. However the history lesson is done well and enjoyable to read and does work to build a sense of the relationship between Catherine and her grandmother in particular. There were some persistent typos in the e-edition I read, noticeably, lightening instead of lightning -but again, the book is such a pleasure to read this is a minor quibble.
July 27, 2020
LOVED this book!
I am amazed at the amount of research that it must have taken in the writing of this book! I loved how the author took the liberty of portraying Catherine Howard to the readers based on her extensive research and what was left to everyone's imagination where there was no historical data, and the notes she left at the end of the book explaining how and why she came to those conclusions. It was interesting, well written, and descriptive to the point you felt you were transported back in time watching the events play out before you. I am very happy that I read this book by this author and look forward to reading more by her. If you are a fan of history you will love this book!
I am amazed at the amount of research that it must have taken in the writing of this book! I loved how the author took the liberty of portraying Catherine Howard to the readers based on her extensive research and what was left to everyone's imagination where there was no historical data, and the notes she left at the end of the book explaining how and why she came to those conclusions. It was interesting, well written, and descriptive to the point you felt you were transported back in time watching the events play out before you. I am very happy that I read this book by this author and look forward to reading more by her. If you are a fan of history you will love this book!
April 17, 2019
As a novel about the life of Catherine Howard, it does it's job - which is to say, that it's not comfortable reading. Gemma does an amazing job of explaining not only what happened but also providing answers that feel convincing without reducing Catherine to her usual good-time-girl stereotype. The details are exquisite (the moment at the beginning of the book where she notes that you stand differently in badly-fitting clothes... ugh, her mind) and the writing is compelling. I can't wait to read the sequel.
April 30, 2019
A Wonderful Look into Tudor History
Author G. Lawrence did a superb job delving into the life of Catherine Howard. I have read many accounts of Catherine Howard but this book really explained the reasoning behind her actions. She has been shown as an uneducated and flirty young girl but in terms of the truth behind her actions, she was a victim of circumstance. I recommend this book to anyone that loves the Tudor era and looking into the principle players of King Henry VIII royal court!
Author G. Lawrence did a superb job delving into the life of Catherine Howard. I have read many accounts of Catherine Howard but this book really explained the reasoning behind her actions. She has been shown as an uneducated and flirty young girl but in terms of the truth behind her actions, she was a victim of circumstance. I recommend this book to anyone that loves the Tudor era and looking into the principle players of King Henry VIII royal court!
October 17, 2019
Brilliant take on Catherine Howard
This is a beautifully imagined and meticulously written and researched book on the short, sad life of Henry VIII's fifth wife. It is warm, sympathetic and vivid. A couple of minor quibbles in that Catherine uses the word "paranoid" to describe Henry, a word not coined until the early 19th century, and says at one point "it's not a done deal" which I found jarringly modern. That said, though, it didn't detract from how much I enjoyed the book and the interpretation of Catherine's early life is interesting, and, I think, valid.
This is a beautifully imagined and meticulously written and researched book on the short, sad life of Henry VIII's fifth wife. It is warm, sympathetic and vivid. A couple of minor quibbles in that Catherine uses the word "paranoid" to describe Henry, a word not coined until the early 19th century, and says at one point "it's not a done deal" which I found jarringly modern. That said, though, it didn't detract from how much I enjoyed the book and the interpretation of Catherine's early life is interesting, and, I think, valid.
Read
March 25, 2019A novel rich in political intrigue and historical details seen from the POV of a young Catherine Howard. I knew very little about Catherine Howard and her ties to her more infamous cousin, Anne Boleyn, before picking up this novel. Author G. Lawrence seems to know her stuff about this tumultuous time period and the political players; it shows in the depth of her characters. As I read the book, I said a little thanks that I get to live in a modern age where women are (for the most part) free from manipulation. The sad fact about the court of Henry VIII the author makes clear is she didn't have to invent this drama, which made me wish for a little more frivolity. I read her end notes first and appreciated knowing her approach to the story in advance. A great read about Tudor history and the wives of Henry VIII. I look forward to reading more from this author.
May 12, 2019
Well-written and believable
The author presents a compelling argument for what "Catherine's" short and tragic life may well have been like based on the simple truth that children of the Tudor-age were no different than children of today - deserving of care and protection. That young Catherine suffered abuse and exploitation by her family and the men in her life and paid the ultimate price for it, as far too many victims of abuse do, is a matter of historical record.
The author presents a compelling argument for what "Catherine's" short and tragic life may well have been like based on the simple truth that children of the Tudor-age were no different than children of today - deserving of care and protection. That young Catherine suffered abuse and exploitation by her family and the men in her life and paid the ultimate price for it, as far too many victims of abuse do, is a matter of historical record.
July 22, 2019
Tudor Court fiction at its best
This author seamlessly weaves fact and fictional speculation in a beautiful tapestry of court intrigue, fledgling feminism, and rebellion. Fans of Tudor court tales will love this as its sprawling story spans past, present, and future for the men running the show, the women behind them dutifully and furiously scheming for survival, and the mercurial king who controls all their futures. I’m a big fan and can’t wait to read the next installment!!!
This author seamlessly weaves fact and fictional speculation in a beautiful tapestry of court intrigue, fledgling feminism, and rebellion. Fans of Tudor court tales will love this as its sprawling story spans past, present, and future for the men running the show, the women behind them dutifully and furiously scheming for survival, and the mercurial king who controls all their futures. I’m a big fan and can’t wait to read the next installment!!!
May 20, 2020
A very interesting take
I've been a nerd on all things Tudor since I was a small child and have always been rather annoyed by the treatment Catherine Howard recieved in history books. I am really pleased to have read this very well written, fictional interpretation of Catherine's life, which, while fictional, was still laced with what information we do have. Where supposition was placed, it made sense.
I very much enjoyed this and look forward to reading the next one.
I've been a nerd on all things Tudor since I was a small child and have always been rather annoyed by the treatment Catherine Howard recieved in history books. I am really pleased to have read this very well written, fictional interpretation of Catherine's life, which, while fictional, was still laced with what information we do have. Where supposition was placed, it made sense.
I very much enjoyed this and look forward to reading the next one.
May 26, 2020
Both books are a worthy read
The story of Catherine was fascinating. The author definitely did her research. The story was very detailed; you felt submersed in the era. I understand for the need for the history at the beginning of the first book, but would’ve preferred it a little more concise getting to Catherine’s story faster. You won’t regret reading these books. They’re definitely a worth your time.
The story of Catherine was fascinating. The author definitely did her research. The story was very detailed; you felt submersed in the era. I understand for the need for the history at the beginning of the first book, but would’ve preferred it a little more concise getting to Catherine’s story faster. You won’t regret reading these books. They’re definitely a worth your time.
September 13, 2020
Telling the history of Henry VIII's reign through the eyes of the ill-fated teenage Queen Catherine Howard is an interesting concept. it includes episodes before she was born by recalling stories told to her by older relatives and so covers more than just Catherine's short span. By using one narrator this soliloquy can be a little one-dimensional, but it's a good story. Lots of facts, lots of interpretation, lots of artistic licence to fill in gaps.
May 30, 2021
Catherine in a wonderful perspective
I am really enjoying G. Lawrence's book ANF the first of two about Catherine Howard, 5th wife of Henry III was so well written. She brings a realistic viewpoint and portrays Catherine in a very realistic way. Very detailed in details that really bring the story to life. I can't wait to start the season one book. Highly recommend for any Tudor time fan.
I am really enjoying G. Lawrence's book ANF the first of two about Catherine Howard, 5th wife of Henry III was so well written. She brings a realistic viewpoint and portrays Catherine in a very realistic way. Very detailed in details that really bring the story to life. I can't wait to start the season one book. Highly recommend for any Tudor time fan.
July 16, 2025
Different take, an excellent read
I really enjoyed this book. At first it was quite boring with the facts but it got better throughout time. It is a different take than I have read about her. It was interesting and I can't wait to read her second book. Katherine howard has always fascinated me and I loved every moment of her. It is an interesting read and a different perspective.
I really enjoyed this book. At first it was quite boring with the facts but it got better throughout time. It is a different take than I have read about her. It was interesting and I can't wait to read her second book. Katherine howard has always fascinated me and I loved every moment of her. It is an interesting read and a different perspective.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews