Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Feminism for the Americas: The Making of an International Human Rights Movement

Rate this book
This book chronicles the dawn of the global movement for women’s rights in the first decades of the twentieth century. The founding mothers of this movement were not based primarily in the United States, however, or in Europe. Instead, Katherine M. Marino introduces readers to a cast of remarkable Latin American and Caribbean women whose deep friendships and intense rivalries forged global feminism out of an era of imperialism, racism, and fascism. Six dynamic activists form the heart of this from Brazil, Bertha Lutz; from Cuba, Ofelia Domíngez Navarro; from Uruguay, Paulina Luisi; from Panama, Clara González; from Chile, Marta Vergara; and from the United States, Doris Stevens. This Pan-American network drove a transnational movement that advocated women’s suffrage, equal pay for equal work, maternity rights, and broader self-determination. Their painstaking efforts led to the enshrinement of women’s rights in the United Nations Charter and the development of a framework for international human rights. But their work also revealed deep divides, with Latin American activists overcoming U.S. presumptions to feminist superiority. As Marino shows, these early fractures continue to influence divisions among today’s activists along class, racial, and national lines.

Marino’s multinational and multilingual research yields a new narrative for the creation of global feminism. The leading women introduced here were forerunners in understanding the power relations at the heart of international affairs. Their drive to enshrine fundamental rights for women, children, and all people of the world stands as a testament to what can be accomplished when global thinking meets local action.

366 pages, Paperback

First published August 1, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
47 (44%)
4 stars
37 (35%)
3 stars
14 (13%)
2 stars
6 (5%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
Profile Image for fausto.
138 reviews58 followers
April 7, 2022
I would say that this is one of the most important women's history books to be published in recent years. Marino's book is not only impeccable on its academic rigurosity and brillinat analysis, but also on the important disvoeries she make arpund one of the most ignored chapters of international feminist mobilizations.
Feminism for the Americas tells the story of panamerican feminism, that is, an internacional feminist movement around all parts of America and the Caribbean searching for a postcolonial movement in order to organized civil-rights and improvements for women around the continent.

Frictions around race and class are the most salient part of the whole narrative, around different protagonists trying to put their own agendas on panamerican feminist organizations. Two salient factions are visible, the first one, was dominated by american and white-latinamerican feminists who argued that elite white women of the American continent most direct and rule panamerican feminism. The second group, also lead by mostly elite white women from Latin american countries, were trying to put issues of race and specially class on the panamerican feminist agenda, mostly for their identification as comunists.

This book is the most read for any understanding of women's mobilizations around all America from the 1920's-1950's, a time lap that has always been considered to be a point of stagnation of feminists mobilization. Marino's book destroy that myth and put Latin-american women's organizations and protagonists at the center.
Profile Image for Maria Gutierrez-Vera.
42 reviews
February 20, 2024
4/5

Collective biography of six forgotten Latin American pioneering feminists. This falls outside of my late 20th c. Los Angeles focus, but I enjoyed Marino's construction of feminist political history, and am impressed at how she reconstructed narratives and interpersonal relationships through personal manuscripts and archives. Greatly valuable for its reading of conflict and tensions inside a political organization/group.
Profile Image for Ash.
30 reviews1 follower
April 24, 2023
This book is super valuable in how it restores Latin American feminism to its rightful status, but god I hated reading it. I wrote a whole book review on this for class so I’ll leave this one with the bare minimum. Yeehaw.
Profile Image for Ivette .
176 reviews10 followers
December 18, 2021
Sin duda, Katherine, ha hecho su investigación, sin embargo, hay varios puntos que me han dejado mal sabor de boca.

-El enfoque de las mujeres que escribe son de cierto perfil y deja de lado por completo a las mujeres de la periferia, logrando que se siga haciendo una línea de alabo a Estados Unidos.

- La autora es Estadounidense y vaya que se nota en la manera de escribir y realizar una reflexión "objetiva" sobre la "historia latina".

- Se puede percibir el prejuicio americano sobre los movimientos sociales-feministas en América Latina.

Sin duda, leerlo me ha dado datos, aunque rescato más la bibliografía utilizada, más que el contenido.

Y, por supuesto, esperaba que por ser editorial CIDE, fuera diferente.
1 review
July 31, 2026
Katherine M. Marino, Assistant Professor of History at UCLA, published this very enjoyable women’s history book in 2019. It tells the story of six women from the Americas – Doris Stevens of the United States, Marta Vergara of Chile, Paulina Luisi of Uruguay, Bertha Lutz of Brazil, Clara González of Panama, and Ofelia Domínguez Navarro of Cuba – whose alliances and political organizing led to the explicit inclusion of language protecting women’s rights in the United Nations Charter in 1945 in San Francisco. By foregrounding the role of Latin American women in this political effort, which lasted several decades, Marino debunks the myth that (North) American women were always the main actors in a prolonged battle to weave a definition of human rights coterminous with women’s rights into the fabric of global society.

The book is very impressive for its geographic scope. It manages to narrate the diplomatic history of an entire hemisphere in the period leading up to the Cold War through the lens of a relatively small network of diplomatic allies who served on commissions, coincided at conferences, exchanged letters, and sometimes even forged friendships at different moments and points across the Americas. Feminism for the Americas is truly a “hemispheric” history that reframes the three decades or so leading up to the Cold War as a sort of golden age for Pan-Americanism as well as for a strand of post-suffrage feminism that the author calls feminismo americano.

How did Latin American feminists exercise international influence in a way that American feminists did not during the pre-Cold War period? The feministas americanas remained united on many of the points that divided (North) American feminists in the post-suffrage era. As is well-known, after American women won the right to vote in 1919-20, Alice Paul drafted the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) in 1923 and dedicated much of the rest of her life to getting it passed into law. At the same time, the American women’s movement suffered a dramatic division that separated those who prioritized passage of the ERA as a political goal and those who prioritized other goals, such as the passage of social and economic legislation protecting workers, women, and children (the social or “social justice” feminists).

According to Marino, however, the feministas americanas had no qualms about bringing their national political agendas, which generally defended the need for social and economic rights (particularly maternity legislation) to be written into law, into harmony with the Latin American internationalist goal of passing something called the Equal Rights Treaty, which would have safeguarded the sovereignty of Latin American nations in the face of the threat of foreign intervention. Marino describes feminismo americano as a movement that “incorporated feminist labor concerns with equal rights demands and knit crucial connections between feminism, socialism, antifascism and anti-imperialism” (5). From the point of view of Latin American feminists, meddling in the affairs of foreign nations was a problem, but meddling in the national “social body” to ensure that the rights of mothers were written into law and protected was just fine.

Due to the volatility of the national debate in the United States over the ERA, however, not all (North) American feminists were willing to support the Equal Rights Treaty. This meant that where feminismo americano defended a platform that included social, political, economic, and civil rights, (North) American feminism did not. Marino mentions that this lack of support from (North) American feminists was probably due to disagreement about the ERA, but she does not go into details.
Marino is right that (North) American women were not as influential as Latin American women as far as the United Nations charter is concerned. I do wonder, however, if there were other areas of international relations where (North) American women did have a significant impact. For example, how did (North) American women contribute to the establishment of the United Nations’ concept of poverty and the emergence of the politics of development? Did their contributions to social reform campaigns during the Progressive Era or to Roosevelt’s New Deal programs have any long term impact on the world stage? We know, for example, that Eleanor Roosevelt, despite her inexperience, was influential in the drafting of the first international bill of rights (see Mary Ann Glendon’s A World Made New: Eleanor Roosevelt and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights).

The difference is that Eleanor Roosevelt did not exercise this influence specifically in the role of “feminist”. Indeed, as Marino indicates, Roosevelt had altogether abandoned the label “feminist” by that time, claiming that feminism no longer existed in the United States (204). Instead, Roosevelt embraced something called the “new humanism”. My sense is that (North) American social feminists actually did share most of the ideological convictions of the Latin American feminists, but could not say so outright lest they add fuel to the ERA debate-fire.

Feminism for the Americas thus left me wanting to know more about the genealogy of the social definition of feminism embraced by the Latin American diplomats featured in the book. Marino traces the diplomatic roots of the inclusion of maternity rights in the U.N. charter, but she does not address why these rights were so important in ideological and social terms to the women who defended them in San Francisco in 1945. I’m sure there is more interesting history here.
Profile Image for Cindia Arango.
8 reviews1 follower
March 22, 2023
The book discusses how feminism in the Americas originated as an international human rights movement. The author narrates different activities, alliances, and discrepancies that six women leaders had (from Cuba, Panama, Brazil, Chile, and Uruguay) who promoted debates and demands at the continental level from congresses, letters, public opinion, and confrontations. However, the book stands out because the research starts with the women themselves. However, they were women with class privileges, economic positions, and public participation. Among others, the author seeks to re-evaluate the general idea that in Latin America, there were no feminist movements or organizations that connected with the feminist movements in the United States or Europe. Even more, the existence of some feminist movements in Latin America reflected the contentious movements in the US and Europe. The author suggests that the deep relationships between the feminist leaders of the early twentieth century should be reviewed and begin to trace the existing networks.

Indeed, the author goes further by suggesting that in Latin America, there was notorious leadership with the promotion of Pan-American feminism that had to face not only Catholicism but also challenges of recognition that Latin American discourses were equally valid. Even Pan-American feminism faced historical omissions within the same international feminist movement. This book also calls for recognition of the Latin American feminist movement as an active part of the international human rights movement.

One of the most problematic aspects of Pan-American feminism was considering the notions of race, class, and nationalism in a unified way. Moreover, according to the author, this differentiation was also reflected in the internal fissures that the feminist movement had in Latin America. It was not a homogeneous movement. This fragmentation is evidenced through the book when Marino explains the disagreements about racism, elitism, and even the definition of feminism. In other words, the idea of Pan-American feminism was a way of reaffirming political and economic autonomy for Latin America from the women who advocated common points such as the right to vote or labor exploitation. However, they failed to have a conceptual, epistemological, and practical unity on sensitive issues such as racism and class. Understanding these dissimilarities is essential to maintain sight of who were the women who were portrayed in this story.

This book is an illustrative example of the intersection of primary sources as beautiful as photographs and fragments of letters, newspapers, and speeches. I loved the fragments of correspondence that crossed national borders. From the exciting moment of being able to travel and access the vast archival sources from various countries to how the author crosses the correspondence and relives these letters' routes.
Profile Image for Jennifer.
90 reviews65 followers
March 24, 2019
Excellent recovery of women's history and feminism in Latin America that doesn't flinch from the hard truths of racism, beliefs in national and language superiority, and classism. Highly readable. Read for LATIN AMERICA and the WORLD grad class.
Profile Image for Amelia.
238 reviews
October 23, 2022
Very informative and opened my eyes on the feminist movement.
Profile Image for Dorismar.
6 reviews
February 23, 2022
Great introduction to the general history of feminism in Latin America. Thankful to have read it for class as I now have a better understanding of the power of feministas. I uncovered a lot of truths that are generally not discussed in the U.S, like the incredible contributions of feministas in the human rights movement etc.
Profile Image for Aidan.
105 reviews
March 16, 2024
9/10

This book came into my possession in a very random way. This past summer, my brother and dad went on a trip to Mexico city. At some point while there, they breakfasted with Katherine Marino and ended up ordering this book to support her. I took this book to Philadelphia with me and decided it'd be a fitting read for women's history month!

The stories and histories uncovered in this book are fascinating. Marino takes the reader through almost half a century of American feminism spanning from after the first World War to the creation of the United Nations and new world order.

The characters are what shined the most for me in this book. Each of the women chronologized in this history were really women. They were complex and nuanced. They were not superheroes, nor villains. And Marino captures the fully humanity of these women expertly. The issue of women's rights as an intersectional cause is one with deep roots. Every woman has a unique relationship with world politics, their own country, and their personal identity of womanhood. From this, many branches of ideologies, twisting between each other, come forth.

This was one of the most informative reads on a topic I had never known before. I think the story of these women is revolutionary and necessary to understand the current state of feminism today. I would recommend to anyone seeking to expand their knowledge of how Latin American women changed the world and directly impacted generations to come.
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews