The Body under the Bridge is the fifth book in a series about Surrey-based detective Craig Gillard, which I've read in order over the last year or so, and largely enjoyed, apart from some persistent niggles, mostly related to the characters. The mysteries are clever and the suspense works well, and there's enough variation between the plots to keep it interesting, but once again I was disappointed by the characters.
A month after the events of The Body in the Snow, Craig is ordered by his boss, Chief Constable Alison Rigby, to go all out on the investigation of a young musician who has gone missing, because her father is a high-ranking German government minister, so no expense will be spared to find her. A freak flood reveals the body of a young woman in a river who was reported missing in the 1980s - so how can she still be a teenager? And who is stalking Craig and his young wife Sam?
My main criticism of some of the previous books has been that the focus has been solely on Gillard as main character, with minimal development of the rest of his team. This begins with him being pulled away from the funeral of a colleague killed in the previous book, and despite only reading that one a few months ago, I genuinely couldn't remember what had happened to him as he left so little impression. This one attempts to fix that as there's a major subplot about DI John Perry, a pitiful character having problems at home, who seems there mainly to make Craig look super-manly by comparison.
Once again, the mystery was well done, as Louth gradually reveals clues and red herrings in equal measure, and we don't know whether the missing girl will be saved, or how she connects to the other disappearances. I do find it odd that Craig, a Detective Chief Inspector, spends so much time doing on-the-ground grunt work more usually suited to a Detective Seargent - this is sort of explained by the political pressure to have their "best man" on the job, but still felt wrong when he should've been coordinating from the top.
The aspect of this series I find most off-putting, and it was even more obvious here, is the portrayal of women. All the female characters are either bitches, sluts, idiots, ball-breakers or victims - in Sam's case a mix of all these. The only remotely sympathetic woman is Craig's colleague and friend Claire, a nice mumsy type always ready to lend him an ear or a spare bed, but she doesn't get to do any detecting herself. Craig really loves his wife but we never really get to understand why, as she's mostly comes across as a jealous shrew who objects to him spending so much time on his much-more-important -than-hers job and seems to fill hers gossiping on the phone with her girlfriends. Even Rainy, Glaswegian doctor turned cop, is portrayed as a sort of comedy thug to be scared of for her intelligence and size rather than valued as a team member.
A major sub-plot of the past couple of books has been Craig's malicious aunt Trish, who moved in over the road to torment them, and was at least interesting as a crazy-cat-lady nemesis who kept getting one over on him, but here barely features other than to become another victim and her fate is unclear as at one point it's mentioned that she died, but then perhaps not. Craig's refusal to go and feed her pets while she's in hospital dropped my impression of him another few notches.
I'm invested in this series and want to know what happens next, but would enjoy it far more if the hero were backed up by some intelligent capable female characters.
Thanks to NetGalley and Canelo for the ARC which allowed me to give an honest review. The Body under the Bridge is published on 30th April.