*re-listening January 2026*
*March 2024
Re-listened and can’t add anything new to my review. It was still beautiful and painful at the same time. A true masterpiece.*
Audiobook narrated by Nick J. Russo ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Where to begin?! What to say about a book that left me speechless, a book that left me feeling EVERYTHING?! My heart broke for JJ and Oak. Their story was one of the most painful I ever read, and Nick J. Russo does such a tremendous job bringing them to life!
My most cherished books are usually the most angsty ones. The ones where the mc's have to fight hard for their hea, the reward of that worth every second of their feelings of hopelessness, of their fear, their tears, their depressive thoughts, their hurt. But I don't think I ever read a book where I wondered how they would ever, EVER reach that moment of true happiness, the moment where they would finally be together and dare to be happy. This book was so, so hard. Each time JJ hurt himself, every time he allowed his inner self hatred to do things that were bad for him, I hurt. My heart broke for him multiple times, as it did for Oakland. It broke for the both of them, bled for them, and even though the ending was healing, I'm sure there will be scars left.
So, first of all: this book is not for everyone. There are a lot of triggers, and I advise you to read them - they are mentioned for a reason. They include conversion therapy, self harm, suicidal thoughts, drugs abuse, internal homophobia, external homophobia, struggles with religious faith - I'm sure I even forget some. But please, be aware of them before reading this book.
This book is the story of Jameson and Oakland, two men who fell in love with each other as teenagers. They were discovered, though, and sent to a facility that 'would make them better' - conversion therapy. That was fifteen years ago, and neither have recovered from the brain washing practices. If anything, they both suffer tremendously. Both in different ways, but fact is that they hate themselves for having 'bad desires' and they struggle with life. Both aren't living, they are just barely surviving.
Oakland has married, because he thought if he did, he would prove to himself and the world he would be healed, he wouldn't be sick anymore. But of course the marriage isn't working for obvious reasons. He drowns himself in pills and drugs and booze and can barely manage to go through daily life.
Jameson wears different masks all the time. His religious parents believe he has been healed and hope for him to find a nice girl and settle down. But in the dark alleys at night, Jameson searches for men to hurt him, to punish him for the cravings he has that are proof he's still sick. His religious upbringing makes him believe the devil is living inside him, making him do all the things he doesn't want to do. Making him sick. He hates himself for it. He harms himself and has been admitted to a mental health hospital several times for more than one suicide attempt. The one bright light in his life is Geraldine, an older lady he met through his parents, who used to attend the same church as they did. When her son is too busy, he takes care of her. Even though her mind isn't what it used to be and she confuses things and memory's, she loves 'her Jimmy' and she's one of the best things that happened to Jameson (JJ). I loved how Nicky James 'used' Geraldine to enlighten the story every now and then. She's such a special character - sweet, and in her confused mind, she sometimes says the nicest things - and so true without realizing! Or does she...?) That's why I love Nicky James's books. She is the queen of angst for a reason, but she also knows how to balance the angst with a bit of humor and sweet secondary characters. I also had a lot of love for Amanda, Oakland's (ex)wife, for how she responded when he told her the truth. She was hurt too, and yet she tried to be there for Oakland too, understanding how he was hurt and damaged with the conversion therapy, how he could hardly be held responsible for the mess that was his life.
Maybe this book was even more intense because I listened to it. Nick J. Russo did such a great job with both JJ and Oakland! The tremors in his voice when JJ was at the verge of crying brought tears to my eyes too. When JJ is unreasonably angry with himself, when he drives Oakland away because he is angry with him too, when he's looking for men to physically abuse him just so he could feel the punishment he deserves...It was so, so hard to listen to! I believe with this book, Nicky James and Nick J. Russo are a perfect match.
Some of my friends might remember I haven't been doing audio books for a very long time yet, but it's books like these where the audio adds so many extra layers to the story, that my only regret is that I haven't picked up on audio sooner. I'm not saying that every book will be better when listened to, because I doubt that too, but for some books it's just that perfect extra touch that makes you feel on a deeper level.
Highly recommended!!!
I kindly received a free copy and this is my voluntary, honest review