I was born a slave, sold as a slave and bred as a slave in the United States of America. My life is not unique. There are literally thousands of us. In the name of Freedom of Religion, our only choice is obey or be destroyed. Blind obedience is required to save us from eternal damnation, and if we don’t comply, we must pay Atonement, the ultimate price to save our evil souls. Many crimes flourish among our 'holy people'. The constitutional rights of the victims remain non existent. American courts continue to uphold the rights of the perpetrators, as it is all done in the name of Freedom of Religion.
Also, a bit long and repetitive. The author's lack of education shows in the grammar, spelling, sentence structure and punctuation so it was obviously not professionally edited. Words like "distain" which would Geste been caught by spell check, and "preformed" (rather than performed) which would have been caught by an editor and a big one is the phrase "child molest" rather than the proper term "child molestation" as in "he was charged with child molest" or "during the child molest". Just a lot that should not be wrong in a book that's being sold.
I command the author for her bravery in being able to escape and overcome the cult, and far trying to help others do the same. Good intentions matter in the grand scheme of things, and it's our heart and tenacity to keep trying that people will remember. In the end, that's what will help most because if will remind them you've there.
Born in Polygamy A True Crime Autobiography by Rebecca Kimbel Review This book is a very thorough personal history of polygamy’s effects on families through the generations. the book does get a little repetitive at times but explains many of the different branches of fundamentalist Mormonism very well. The book could have done with some one to edit it as it is self published Kimbel makes some weird weird authors choices like not giving us her children's names in order. If you want a more through review check out my youtube channel https://youtu.be/u52_wJOnVaE
I am still reading this book, but I wanted to review already. Thank for sharing your story Rebecca. I have read a few accounts of the Le Baron colony and Le Baron brothers. I really appreciate your perspective.
This book is in need of some heavy editing. There are many repetitive parts. I feel like, with some work, this would be an amazing book, that people would really enjoy reading.
That being said, Rebecca Kimbel shares a very interesting perspective on the Le Baron insanity. Her perspective is both personal and from the outside. I have read a few other books from women who lived in and eventually escaped from this cult during the time of the Ervil's corrupted reign, and this book fills in so many of the holes the others left!
This story of Rebecca Kimbel’s life experiences is just sad. The news that we are doing far too little to combat polygamy and all of the abuses that go hand in hand with it is devastating. Kimbel explains why we are failing in these efforts as the problem continues to grow exponentially. The book absolutely could have used a skilled editor, although the grammatical errors are understandable considering the author’s past which included a very poor education, as designed by the polygamists who enslaved and then literally sold her as a child bride. Her escape is all but miraculous and her warnings should be considered. We have ways to fix these problems and prevent ongoing abuses and we need to make inroads on that process.
Man, this was a poorly written mess and probably the worst book I’ve ever read.
The book says it is fiction, which is one thing. I don’t know if it’s supposed to be fiction or supposed to be an autobiography. My guess is a hybrid.
That doesn’t excuse the numerous historical errors and impossibilities. The countless grammar and spelling errors. The frequent perspective shift with no warning. The characters were either too over the top Disney villain at times or just fragments of people with little development.
It seems a common theme in the LeBaron books for them to be a bit of a disaster and it’s saddening.
This is a eye-opener to the true practice of polygamy. Members of the churches who practice, have practiced or condone polygamy should read this book. Especially the last chapter. The saying “absolute power corrupts abslutely” is so true. Exercising power over others can be a powerful weapon, especially within a religious setting. Shame on those who do so. A recent quip about powerful leaders highlights the mormon prophet and the catholic pope. The catholic pope is considered infallible but the Catholics don’t believe it, the Mormons consider their Prophet fallible but don’t believe it.
Horrifying, infuriating, thorough, and informative
Important data and history underpins this exhaustive narrative that crosses over others’ narratives on this subject. This woman has apparently lived enough life for two women and knows how to bounce. The text itself could use an editor to cut repetition and wrong words (“peeked” instead of “piqued”, “plane” instead of “plain”)—small distractions from this powerful testimony about the evil of ignorance and the strength of women to survive.
Not as good as I was expecting but does have potential
I read Shattered Dreams by this author's sister and thought that this would be a good progression into learning more about Polygamy and what happens. It was not. Parts of the book were difficult to follow along, and other parts felt like they taken from the other book and rewritten I'm this authors own words. I think with some additional editing and more focus, this could be a great book I'm learning about the horrors of Polygamy.
This book is brutally raw, honest and wonderfully written. The author gives you a front row seat from A-Z growing up in polygamy. NOTHING is sugar coated, glossed over, or swept under the rug. Rebecca Kimbel kicks ass in shining a super bright light on polygamy and the women and children that suffer from this lifestyle in the name of religion.
Reading this was like obtaining an education in all the facets of polygamy. I’ve read other books written about it & this book corroborates most of those stories but it also goes a lot further to explain the fact that it’s truly an organized crime sect hiding behind the title of religion. There are some syntax errors throughout the text but nothing that impedes comprehension. Very informative overall!
Words cannot describe how much emotion, information is packed in this. At a couple points I laughed, cried, and wanted to scream at the injustices these families face on a daily basis. I highly recommend this book to everyone. Thank you to the author for shinning a light on the polygamy life.
Hard read,worthwhile information. Timeline is hard to follow. Understanding the amount of information given, it is understandable. Breathing a sigh of relief I am Catholic.
Thanks you for sharing your story and history of the mistreated and the monsters in your family. Regardless of what Mormon Fundamentalists believe or preach, the wheels of karma and justice spin slowly. But spin they do.
Could not let this book defeat me, but it was huge. Answered a lot of unanswered questions about the Kunz/Le Baron and associated sides of Utah polygamy outside of the FLDS, though it was significantly repetitive at times.
Very sad content. And it is difficult to read, because it’s written like several books all combined into one, with the same story being repeated just in a slightly different way. But very very informative on Polygamy families.