About on par with the rest of the series.
In some ways, the books are inspiring, because of their perseverance and endurance.
It almost feels like going through a D & D book on characters, with a thorough listing of all the training possibilities for our characters to choose, but it was more interesting than just an encyclopedic entry. We got to see the possibilities.
I got tired of all the "looks of hatred" the kids gave each other, whether or not they were friends. Just stop it already.
The kids are still being tortured as part of their training. (One of the other reviewers pointed that out in the last book.) This time, a tiger attacks them if they don't run fast enough carrying someone. If they can't best their mentor, then the mentor shoots them, not to kill but to cause pain. Once again, they are all drugged for a test.
However, unlike in the last book, the instructors aren't merely performing the expected training, they advocate for the torture, saying something akin to the more popular, "No pain, no gain." Ivar says, "Pain drives the lesson home better." I think there are other instances as well.
That actually isn't true. Pain - and the associated fear of pain - can shut down cognitive ability, unless you want only the lesson of staying away. But how to perfect and hone abilities - no.
I didn't find Camu's disappearance as exciting as their other adventures in the prior books, although the descriptions of the Shelter were interesting. I expected to find Camu frozen with the dragon, and thought whatever magic had ensnared him would ensnare Camu, too. I won't tell whether that was right or not. I had considered the possibility of what had happened to him, but not in as much detail as was given.
The midterm test was not as interesting as in prior years. It felt more like a Hogwarts sorting hat.
Another reviewer brought up all the chatter during their superior's speeches, wondering how they'd get away with that. I've wondered that before, too. I think that while we can hear them, most of the other people can't. They aren't projecting their voices to the whole group. But still, I'd expect them to get in trouble for it.
But despite being unrealistic for a military group, I like those parts because that's when the funny things are often said.
One reviewer mentioned all the editing errors in this book. I thought it had more as well, but I'm usually able to overlook them and just go with the flow of the story.
Favorite quotes:
"Evil drags people after it, captures them, clouds their minds, and never leaves them." Sometimes I feel that sort of way, worrying over the choices of my loved ones with a sense of dread over dark choices in life choices, or even just entertainment. Sometimes I could feel the evil radiating off of it, and I felt I was the only one who could.
"Anyone who stops learning, stops living." Well, I'm in a great shape to keep on living then, as I'm preparing to take 3 classes this summer. Ridiculous, and not at all what I'd envisioned.