I have loved the Chronicles of St Mary's series for a little while now, and have eagerly devoured all the books, and the short stories as well. I have been recommending them to my dad and colleagues, as they are so full of excellent storytelling, humour, time travel, and some really heart wrenching moments.
For me personally, this is definitely the weakest in the series, and I've been waiting for the weakest to show up. I really did think it would be before now, considering the amount of main book, and novellas there are included in this series.
This is told quite differently to the other books. There are no time travel happenings at all. This is three women (Mrs. Enderby, Mrs. Shaw and Mrs. Mack, very much insignificant and forgettable characters in the books), reminiscing about the events that happened to them on St George's Day, during the Civil War.
I found this storytelling quite difficult to keep track of, as I had no idea who was speaking at any given time. The back stories have been hinted at in one of the main books, but the three characters never had much of an impact on me, and don't have me rooting for them, or thinking about them long after the story has ended - like Markham or Peterson for example. I found it quite dull as well, apart from Max's occasionally funny quips, or Dr Bairstow's disbelief.
For me, the good stories/characters far outweigh this one, and I will continue to read the series. Hopefully this is not the start of a downward spiral for the author.