First off, I have to say that I did enjoy this book, to an extent. Puzzling Ink has tremendous potential for a new series. Most of the characters are charming and easy to like, even if they are a little rough around the edges. I loved Quinn’s mom and dad; they added humor and quirkiness to the story. I like having the crossword puzzles be the main character’s focus, and it gives the story a unique twist. However, there are some glaring issues with this story.
Quinn really isn’t all that liable. Describing her as having “a mild case” of OCD is like describing Buckingham Palace as quaint. In reality, Quinn’s OCD would be a significant problem, and not just when she was feeling stressed. Unfortunately, having her OCD be the storyline’s main focus made it challenging to get into the puzzle (mystery) aspects. The constant dialogue about counting, color coding, and general habits, with the rubber band snapping and so forth was distracting at best and added very little understanding to the character, to those with OCD, or the story.
The murder investigation was not as prominent as it should have been, and there was little interaction with any real suspects. Evidence is also lacking distinction. The killer is barely in the story, and what twists and turns there are don’t add any action or drama to the plot. I think the puzzles should have been more of a factor, as I felt it would have made a solid foundation for future installments. However, I can live with all of the issues I listed above, but the fact that not all of the questions were answered, even those that seemed to be important to the investigation, is where I have to draw the line. It is imperative in a cozy book, no matter that it is part of a series, that in the end, all questions brought up as evidence or possible motives have to be resolved. In this book, some questions were left open, with no relevance to future books.
Overall, I felt Puzzling Ink was a puzzle of its own and could have been much better, but I also see the potential for future books that hopefully will address the issues of this first one. I know that Ms. Clark is a talented writer with a sense of humor, so I know she can make the next book far better than this one.