Kindle freebie at time of download.
Claire Anderson, a 50-year-old widow, has turned over the reins of her Brooklyn coffee shop to her foster daughter Al and moves to Galway, Maryland, a sleepy Appalachian town, to fulfill her dream of opening an inn. It's winter and tourists are trickling in to ski. Claire enjoys the company of her first guest, James Matthews, who has come to town to check on his rental properties. Even her trusty Bloodhound, Rupert, who has been depressed since the death of Claire's husband, likes James. When James fails to come down to breakfast or check out, Claire discovers James has checked out permanently - as in he's dead. Police suspect murder but it's nearly impossible to find a motive or a good suspect. When a second death occurs, the sheriff believes Ben, a young man who works at the ski rental, is the culprit. Claire and her new friend Evelyn work behind the scenes to find out who the murderer is and why. When Claire discovers a third body and an unlikely suspect is arrested, her world is shattered. Can she figure out the truth and save her heart from being broken again? Should she accept a date with an old flame who has been cold and hot with her? There's one thing Claire does know and that is lots of baking is involved before she makes a decision!
This story was just OK for me. I didn't like that it was set in the real world with a reference to 9/11. This story had a high body count for a cozy and the motive for murder was ridiculous and very tragic. I never guessed any of it. There were no clues there at all. The writing style isn't bad but the story slogged on and on and I wasn't that into it. I skipped to the end to find out whodunit it, realized I missed a dead body and a motive. I went back later and finished the rest and it still didn't click. I didn't understand why Claire constantly referred to cream as crème, a ridiculous affectation showing she was a fancy chef maybe? Also, she refers to eyeglasses as "spectacles." Claire is 50 not 150 and her friend Emma randomly breaks out into French for no reason. Perhaps author is not a native English speaker?
I also didn't care for the older, widowed sleuth. I relate more to younger, single sleuths in their late 20s and 30s. Claire is crazy. She's mourning the loss of her husband to cancer and not fully living her life. Her daughter is the one pushing her to make a change. Claire doesn't do change easily. It takes her a bit to understand her daughter's friend's pronouns "they/them" and what that means. It's not hard to be polite and refer to someone by their preferred pronouns. It doesn't take her too long to figure it out but she kind of rolls her eyes at it. Claire also makes herself seem old and racist by confusing O.J. with Kanye on someone's shirt. While wearing Kanye is nearly as bad, 50 year olds know who Kanye is. I don't know why Claire sounds so old.
She spontaneously moves to this small town in winter and opens a B&B. She was a professional chef so she may have some business experience but she has no experience running an inn or in customer service. She doesn't have much to do, just cook and clean one guest room which seems a little unrealistic. She immediately makes a new BFF and they start nosing around. She asks nosy and intrusive questions of suspects and puts herself in danger. Her investigation is not well thought out or planned. I think she has too much time on her hands. Of course I'd want to know how a guest died so I'd probably poke around online and maybe talk to people who knew him but then I'd encourage the gossips to go to the police. GOOD cozy mystery heroines work WITH the police, not against them or ahead of them.
Rupert is a sweet doggo. He's intuitive and knows things Claire does not. I also liked Al, Claire's daughter. Al is funny and sounds like she would be fun to hang around with. She's managing the coffee shop well but is there for her mom when Claire needs her. She knows when her mom is hurting by how much her mom has baked. I appreciate the good mother/daughter relationship. I really like Al's friend Ry. They're even funnier than Al and appreciate good baked goods. I'd read a series featuring Al and Ry sleuthing and working at the coffee shop. Ev, from the post office, is Claire's new BFF. Claire trusts easily, maybe too easily, and becomes Ev's ride or die. Ev is way too nosy for my tastes especially since she works at the post office! She takes advantage of her situation sometimes and doesn't really care. She's incurably nosy and not in a good way. She thrives on gossip and knowing everything that is going on. I absolutely hate people like that. Claire's BFF in Brooklyn is similar. Emma is worse, actually. She thinks life is like Downton Abbey or another show or book. Emma loves gossip but doesn't seem interested in sleuthing the way Ev does. Only online.
James Matthews was charming, friendly and kind to Claire and Rupert. Rupert really enjoyed having a man around the house again. Claire seemed quite taken with James and happy to make a new friend. His death was shocking and devastating. A locked room murder! Who could have killed him and why?
Nina Delacroix is the first person Claire meets in town. Nina runs the only inn in town until Claire opens hers. Nina is a high maintenance and low work sort of person. She's not friendly, curious or warm in any way shape or form. She's one of those women desperate to cling to their youth and have men flatter them so they feel younger than their age. Nina and James used to be married and their split is NOT acrimonious. They seem to bring out the worst in each other and she loathes him. I can see her murdering him in revenge but not now. Why now?
Dale Duke is an acquaintance from way back when Claire and George used to come to Galway to ski. Dale is a gentle soul, kind and friendly to everyone. His nephew, Ben, works at the ski rental place too and Ben seems lost. He's living with a young woman he doesn't seem to be in a relationship with but they don't seem to get along well. Ben and Leslie have a lot of problems and maybe shouldn't be living together. Ben has issues from his past that may affect his present. Leslie is hiding something she's upset about and of course she won't share with strangers/nosy older women. She's a sneaky sort and I think she's just desperate to move on and up in life and uses any means necessary even if those means are unnecessary. We don't get to know her well enough to know if she would resort to murder though. I don't think she did it but I think she was either involved with James or suspects she knows who did it or both.
Claire flirts with two men and feels guilty about it. She's still attracted to Henry Castle, an old crush, who now looks like Robert Redford. (Eew!) He's been cold and hot with her off and on. Nothing happened with him in the past because he seemed brusque and brushed Claire off. I suspect he's a shady businessman from his personality and what Al discovers online seems to confirm it. Of course he would deny it to Claire. He wants to charm her now she's a prominent widow. Ray Hamilton is the Galway handyman. He's older, handsome and handy. Claire acts like a ninny around him. She loses her brains, her strength and common sense. It's one thing to flirt and another to act like a damsel in distress. Some of the things she could learn to do herself. Ray is a great listener and remembers what Claire tells him. He too lost a beloved spouse so they understand one another. I like him a lot but I don't think Claire should date anyone right now. She needs to grow a brain first.
Sheriff Sellers is nice but he's a country sheriff. He's portrayed as kind of slow and simple like a country sheriff should be. He does his job but there are no clues to follow. He doesn't seem overly concerned with arresting the right person. He's not too bright and acts on an anonymous tip without looking into it first.
I really should not download free cozies unless I've already read and enjoyed the author. I won't be reading any more in this series even if they are free.