Tuesday, February 20, 2018
6:22 PM
I really wanted to give this a better rating because there are moments in the story that I started to get into it...where I really started to enjoy it. The problem I am having is that there were a lot of moments where I was left very confused. I think it’s a timeline issue; there weren't any clues to let me know if I was back in the main character Rhonda's memories, or if I was hearing about a moment in her current situation. I truly wish the author would remake this book with the past in italics. For much of the story I was floundering to catch up. I admit, this may be on me- I've never read 'stream of consciousness' before.
Another issue I had was the editing. It felt like this was a second draft, with ideas that should have been removed or reworded...along with the other editing error, like run amok splicing commas. The story was fully outlined and fleshed out, but there were still parts that didn't fit or make sense. Take this sentence: "Holding him by the arms in an iron grip, he shook him violently as he walked over, closing in on him." I'm having a very hard time understanding how you can walk over to somebody when you are already holding them in an iron grip. From that same chapter this character lunged a kitchen knife into the other character's shoulder and the victim dies from the punctured organs. A shoulder wound that somehow this punctured the person's organs... fatally? (If I say any more or use the character's names, I fear I'll give too much away). So many bits just didn't line up as I tried to imagine them, making reading this story a struggle.
Another editing issue that didn't make sense to me was the relationships that begin the story. The first one that really bothered me was her opening reason for choosing Sam, her husband who she never felt any passion for, over Chris her amazing lover. The reasoning was that Sam was stable and would provide a secure life whereas Chris was bohemian and would not. But then you read on and find that Chris was a doctor, even while they dated. And Sam was fired from a low level job and had never worked again, relying on Rhonda to provide for them. Which, according to the book, she does not mind at all since she makes a sufficient income as a flower attendant….??!! That was only the beginning of the logic that the book presented to me.
Finally, the reader is introduced to an autistic child. The author labeled the child as such by his inability to hold eye contact, but the child had no qualms whatsoever with being held and smothered in hugs by a stranger. Odd, because autistic children resist hugging and other types of physical contact.
But I digress.
Listed above are issues I had a very hard time getting around which made this a long, slow read for me. But there were good parts too. The mood of the story stayed consistent, the voice never changed - although it also never sounded like it belonged to any one character, either- and since the book was written in what sounded to me like a British-based vernacular, there were new concepts introduced to me. Would you believe that living landlocked in America, I had never heard of the term "offing"? Well, now I have. And, there were some really great lines in this book: "In wakefulness she slept. In sleep, she woke up." That's deep. Another line I love (referring to a tree) "It didn't stoop because it didn't know how to." And then there was: "He wooed her tenderly without a touch." Yum, right?
It was for the lines that seemed totally quote-worthy that I really had wished I could rate this book higher.