A journalist finds himself embroiled in a disastrous government campaign as well as a sweeping romance in this landmark English translation of Ethiopia’s most famous novel.
An engrossing political thriller and a tale of love and war for readers of John Le Carré and Philip Kerr.
December 1981, Ethiopia. Tsegaye Hailemaryam, a well-known journalist for the state-run media, has just landed in Asmara. He is on assignment as the head of propaganda for the Red Star campaign, a massive effort by the Ethiopian government to end the Eritrean insurgency. There, amid the city’s bars and coffeehouses buzzing with spies and government agents, he juggles the demands of his superiors while trying to reassure his fiancée back home that he’s not straying with Asmara’s famed beauties.
As Tsegaye falls in love with Asmara—and, in spite of his promises, with dazzling, enigmatic local woman Fiammetta—his misgivings about the campaign grow. Tsegaye confronts the horror of war when he is sent with an elite army unit to attack the insurgents’ mountain stronghold. In the aftermath, he encounters betrayals that shake his faith in both the regime and human nature.
Oromay became an instant sensation when first published in 1983 and was swiftly banned for its frank depiction of the regime. The author vanished soon thereafter; the consensus is that he was murdered in retaliation for Oromay. A sweeping and timeless story about power and betrayal in love and war, the novel remains Girma’s masterpiece.
This book is about a TV journalist called Tsegaye who goes to Eritrea to report on a campaign (called Oromay) which was organized by the Derg government to wage an organized offensive against the force of Sha’biya (ሻብያ) with the aim of eliminating them for once and for all. Derg was the Provisional Military Government of Ethiopia from 1974 to 1987. Sha’biya was a military organization which was fighting for the independence of Eritrea. It was led by the current President of Eritrea Isayas Afeworki .
Tsegaye joined the Oromay campaign as an organizer and leader of the journalist crew which were assigned to work there for a brief period of time. Besides the historic aspect, the book has a romantic story which I don’t want to mention and spoil it to whomever is reading this.
Although the book was fiction, it vividly describes the historical record of what the then Eritrea looked like under the Ethiopian federation. It also talks a lot about the Derg government and the historical events took place during this campaign led by President (dictator) Mengistu Hailemariam. Reading this book, I was amazed by how the author was able to create such a fantastic story; then blend it with a historical reality and present it.
I read the book in Dec. 2020 right after the intense fighting between the Ethiopian Federal government led by PM Abiy Ahmed and TPLF was concluded. This recent war has a lot in common with the Oromay campaign which the book described in detail. We Ethiopians have a lot to learn from this book. This is one of the best amharic novels I read. I highly recommend it!
In the landscape of African literature, few novels have achieved the legendary status of Oromay. Published in Ethiopia in 1983, Baalu Girma's masterpiece caused such a stir that it was banned within days, and the author disappeared six months later – presumably murdered by the very regime he dared to criticize. Now, forty years later, this powerful work finally reaches English readers through a masterful translation by David DeGusta and Mesfin Felleke Yirgu.
The Story: Where Personal and Political Collide
Set against the backdrop of Ethiopia's 1981-82 Red Star Campaign to quell the Eritrean insurgency, Oromay follows Tsegaye Hailemaryam, a state journalist tasked with heading propaganda efforts in Asmara. What begins as a seemingly straightforward assignment evolves into a complex web of love, loyalty, and betrayal that challenges everything Tsegaye believes about both his country and himself.
Writing Style and Narrative Structure
Girma's prose is remarkable for its ability to shift seamlessly between intimate personal moments and sweeping political drama. His writing style combines journalistic precision with poetic flourishes, creating a narrative voice that feels both immediate and timeless. The author demonstrates particular skill in using weather and landscape as metaphors for the political climate:
"
The palm fronds sway in the wind, their sound a dirge:
"A mother's children Driven apart by Misunderstandings and mistakes The peacekeepers are gone only madmen remain"
The novel is structured in five parts, each building tension while peeling back layers of deception. Girma employs multiple perspectives, though primarily following Tsegaye, and occasionally breaks the fourth wall with an omniscient narrator who identifies as "the author." This technique, while potentially jarring in less skilled hands, adds depth to the story's exploration of truth and perspective.
Character Development and Relationships
Tsegaye Hailemaryam
The protagonist's journey from confident government propagandist to disillusioned witness of war's horrors is masterfully rendered. His character development feels organic, driven by both external events and internal conflicts, particularly in his relationships with:
- Roman Hiletework: His fiancée in Addis Ababa, representing stability and tradition - Fiammetta Gilay: The captivating Asmara woman who challenges his worldview - Colonel Wolday: A childhood friend whose fate becomes entwined with larger themes of loyalty and sacrifice
Supporting Characters
The novel's secondary characters are equally well-drawn, from the manipulative Silay Berahi to the complex Director Betru Tessema. Each brings their own motivations and secrets to the story, creating a rich tapestry of human nature under pressure.
Themes and Symbolism
Love and Betrayal
The central romance between Tsegaye and Fiammetta serves as a microcosm for the larger political conflicts. Their relationship highlights how personal and political betrayals mirror each other, while questioning whether true loyalty is possible in a world of shifting allegiances.
Truth and Propaganda
Girma's background in journalism shines through in his exploration of truth versus narrative. The novel constantly questions who controls the story and how "facts" can be manipulated for political ends.
Identity and Belonging
Through its exploration of the Eritrean conflict, the novel delves deep into questions of national and personal identity. Characters struggle with competing loyalties to region, nation, ideology, and personal relationships.
Historical Context and Relevance
While firmly rooted in 1980s Ethiopia, Oromay resonates with contemporary readers through its exploration of universal themes. The novel's depiction of government propaganda and media manipulation feels particularly relevant in our era of "fake news" and information warfare.
Critical Analysis
Strengths
- Masterful integration of personal and political narratives - Complex, believable characters - Rich atmospheric detail of Asmara - Nuanced exploration of war's moral complexities - Sophisticated use of multiple narrative techniques
Areas for Improvement
- The omniscient narrator device occasionally breaks immersion - Some political discussions can feel didactic - Certain minor characters could be more fully developed - The pacing in the middle section occasionally lags
Translation Quality
DeGusta and Yirgu deserve high praise for their translation work. They successfully capture both the lyricism of Girma's prose and the complexity of his political discourse, while maintaining readability for English-speaking audiences. Their careful handling of Amharic and Italian phrases adds authenticity without confusion.
Impact and Legacy
The tragic circumstances surrounding Oromay's publication and Girma's subsequent disappearance have certainly contributed to its legendary status in Ethiopian literature. However, the novel's enduring power comes from its artistic merit rather than its historical significance. It stands as both a crucial document of its time and a timeless exploration of human nature under pressure.
Final Verdict
Oromay deserves its reputation as Ethiopia's greatest novel. Despite some minor flaws, it succeeds brilliantly as both a political thriller and a profound meditation on love, loyalty, and truth. The English translation finally allows a wider audience to appreciate this masterpiece of African literature.
It is a wonder to me that this book is not more widely acclaimed and well known to an international readership and I consider myself blessed and lucky to have randomly picked it up in a Waterstones. It manages to deliver a thrilling and yet contemplative story, based in the period of Derg Communist rule in which war has broken out between the aspiring Eritrean independence movement and the Ethiopian government. We take the perspective of Tsegaye, a surprisingly compassionate, self aware and humble member of the Derg media establishment on his through the war in Asmara.
The author himself, was a member of the Derg establishment who served in a similar role to Tsegaye, and he was killed for his work by the government. As with Egyptian literature which is politically subversive and obviously based on the life experiences of the author: one is left to wonder to what degree the work is fictional.
Irrespective of this however, the story is deeply profound, containing meditations on love, a contemplation on the savagery and brutality of war and conflict, an examination Ethiopian and Eritrean politics. It also is in many ways, a spy thriller which is written compelling and presents a series of fascinating characters.
For someone like me who is fascinated by the beauty of Ethiopian and Eritrean culture, it also increased my yearning to visit this beautiful land and see the churches, the coffee ceremonies and maybe even the bars. However, sadly, as in the time of the book which was written in the 80s, this region is still engulfed in the brutality of war between brothers and sisters, encouraged by regional and international powers.
Oromay is not “an engrossing political thriller and a tale of love and war for readers of John Le Carré and Philip Kerr“. It is a beautifully written ode to (then) Ethiopia (more precisely Eritrea, even more precisely Asmara) and its people. It is a criticism of war, inefficient government and the nature of power. For me, this book is a mood, a feeling. A feeling of dread, of joy and wonder, a feeling of sea breeze and warmth. Pain and love, hope and fear.
This was billed a piece of dissident fiction, but tbh I don't know what The Derg were thinking getting so upset about it, they come across as pretty good guys.
Oromay helped me realise that what is best in life is drinking whisky in hotel bars, the forward march of socialism, and sacred Ethiopian unity.
The translation was kind of weird at time but I learned a ton about Ethiopia and it prompted me to go to chercher which I haven’t been to in so long and forgot I love it so that rocked. Interesting
The book didn’t go where it seemed it would at the beginning and at points it felt like you were willing it to. But I enjoyed this, particularly the descriptions of Asmara and the Nakfa mountains. The chapter of the battle has stuck with me - written so emotionally and short in contrast to the rest of the book. Also introduced me to Ethiopia and Eritrea’s recent history which I knew nothing about.
Anti-war romance thriller. I liked it, although it’s pretty sexist and you’re left pitying the man even though he’s the one that royally fucked up. Odyssey for the truth from a journalist turns into an exposé into the harsh reality of war. Beautiful depictions of Massawa and the highlands.
I noticed this book in the "new fiction" section at my local library, but when I picked it up and read the blurb, I realized it is not new; it is newly translated into English from Amharic. Girma was an Ethiopian writer and the book was written in 1983. This is a very intense and disturbing portrayal of the Red Star campaign by the Ethiopian government to end the Eritrean insurgency in 1981. It is told by Tsegaye Hailyemaryam, a journalist who is in charge of propaganda for the Ethiopian government. He is sent to Asmara in Eritrea with other government workers and agents for what is supposed to be a 3 month campaign. Tsegaye believes in the cause for a united Ethiopia but soon finds himself embroiled in bureaucracy, corruption, double agents, assassinations and the horrors of war. Plus he falls in love with an Eritrean woman which makes everything more complex. Just a few months after arriving in Eritrea, he is a broken man. When the book was published in 1983, it was immediately banned by the ruling Derg dictatorship. Within a year, Girmu was "disappeared." It is presumed that he was kidnapped and murdered by the regime. Reading this on the book's cover is what compelled me to take the book home. I am not sorry that I did. I opened the book with very little knowledge of the history of these 2 countries or Eritrea's fight for independence. Now I know a little more especially after googling. Like any good piece of historical fiction, I was able to think about other historical events (such as the Vietnam War and Alexei Navalny) and even views of current events. This is not an easy read, and it was made more difficult because all the characters have Ethiopian names that were so unfamiliar to me. After reading the first 50 pages (in which many characters are introduced), I made myself a cheat sheet which listed them with their roles. This definitely helped. I am glad I discovered this "new book." Historical fiction has always been a favorite and this one took me someplace I had never been before.
This story is so impactful, especially after I learned about what happened to Baalu Girma and what is assumed about his disappearance. His bravery and dedication to writing and publishing Oromay is profound and reminds me how important writing is, in spite of consequences. I wonder how this reading experience would affect me if I read Omar El Akkad's novel One Day, Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This next or in conjunction with Oromay.
My biggest annoyance was how the male characters/culture promotes loving a woman only based on her beauty alone. Perhaps this is an aspect that is "of-its-time," but it still annoyed me. At least it didn't describe the landscape like a woman's body as David Diop's narrator does in At Night All Blood is Black, which also annoyed me. Now I'm just complaining, so let's get back to Girma's novel.
If you're unaware of Ethiopia and Eritrea's 30-year war (1961-1991) during which Eritrea was fighting for independence from Ethiopia, then this fictionalized account of the war in 1981 will provide you with some insight about what happened. I'm ashamed to admit that prior to reading this novel I didn't know anything about the Eritrean-Ethiopian War. The writing in the novel isn't lyrical, and I get the impression that the Girma's original version in Amharic was lyrical but that the translaion wasn't able to capture Girma's lyricism. Of course, that's me speculating. If anyone has any insight about the writing and/or the translation, I'd love to hear from you.
If you're interested in the history of the Eritrean-Ethiopian War, historical fiction, translated fiction based on real events, and/or reading controversial texts, then this could be for you!
I read the hardcover and listened to the audiobook at the same time (both from the library), and it was a fantastic reading experience!
Do you really suppose history will remember him, this foot soldier? Not really. Yes, battles will be chronicled, and from that history will be written. It will be in the news, on television and even in books. People will talk about it in bars and coffeehouses. However, the focus will be on the progress of the war, the strategy and tactics, with maybe a mention or two of the commanding officer and how bravely, courageously and strategically he coordinated his troops to wage the battle. But when it comes to the regular people, the foot soldiers, it is a different story. For them, history is unforgiving and merciless.
I stumbled across this at the library, and it really intrigued me. Admittedly, I've been trying to avoid war-themed books for the last couple of months, but I had to make an exception for this. And I'm glad I did.
While I can't exactly compare with the actual original text, I really enjoyed this translation. I could tell there was a lot of hard work behind it, and interest in the story and its author. As for the story itself, I really, really liked it. I'm admittedly not too familiar with Ethiopian and Eritrean history, so this was interesting both for the story and for its historical context.
Even without the proper background knowledge, this was a funny yet devastating satire that really does deserve a spot with the big political satires on the international top lists.
When I figured out this book had a translation available I instantly ordered this book. Oromay’s main plot point is about complex nuanced relationship between Ethiopia and Eritrea, and the insurgency rising within Eritrea. It follows Tsegaye Hailemariam a journalist within the Derg regime and is role during a secret covert mission called Oromay. Reading this book and learning just a little more about my parents/grandparents life during the Derg regime was all I wanted but I left with so much more reading this book. Such an important book and even more impactful learning that Bailuu Girma was abducted by the Derg and presumed dead after writing Oromay.
4.5 stars (Absolutely solid, and a stunning depiction of the war sequences towards the end - but man do those sequences HURT.)
Sitting here now, 43 years after the fact, and having read this story after first reading the front jacket blurb and the opening “translator’s note,” it is a little hard to put together the entirety of this story with the real-life actions that were to follow. I mean, maybe it raises some questions towards the end? - because, for the most part, it seems like our pro-campaign protagonist is exactly the type of hero the government would absolutely endorse. Sure, things change a bit in him after the war sequences - the 1-2 parts of this book completely break our protagonist emotionally and make him a shell of a man, but none of it really seems to come across entirely as anti-Derg. (I will admit, I came into this with no knowledge about the Ethiopian history described here, so clearly I may be missing something.) Even at the end, when he’s broken and this 2-3 month span has completely shredded his faith in humanity (because war is, in fact, horrible), he never seems to have lost faith in the campaign. Hell, if anything, he seems even more certain that the insurgents need to be put down (see his angry retort in the airplane on the way back). … I guess maybe the issue was with the idea that he had lost faith in humanity?
Our story mostly follows Tsegaye, a journalist who is the “head of propaganda” (not subtle) for the Red Star campaign, a campaign by the relatively new post-revolution government to end the Eritrean insurgency. He joins a ton of the big names in the government, all of whom are sent to the city of Asmara to undertake these actions - end the insurgency, combine Ethiopia into 1, and, in his case, record these events and broadcast them to the entire country to show them the progress.
Most of the story is focused on this - Tsegaye falling in love with the city and falling in love with a woman in the city (despite his assurances to his fiancée back home that it wouldn’t happen), while being in the backdrop of this campaign. His superiors are demanding, this equipment is delayed, there are concerns about numerous traitors in the mix, and war is just around the corner - but even as he deals with this, and seems to forget his fiancée, he can’t help but fall in love with everything. His enthusiasm for the campaign in unwavering (probably important for someone heading propaganda). This all happens over the span of like 1-2 months - the campaign is very aggressive.
It is only about 70% into the novel when the story shifts - they get called to the warfront for actual battles against the insurgents and Tsegaye, eager for his go at entrenched journalism, demands to be placed with one of the most dangerous missions. It is here that he, first-hand, sees victory, the agony of loss, and then the apparent futility of sacrifice (including his over-eager colleague).
This is what breaks him. He went in eager, a believer, even proud of those willing to lay down their lives for this war to unite Ethiopia - but to see his colleague, and so many soldiers, sacrifice themselves for them to earn a victory, only to learn a few days later that they would be retreating against the rebounding insurgency attacks because of lack of reinforcements, just shatters the glass world he’s been living in. I mean, we saw shades earlier - right after his colleague was killed, he lost it at the soldiers who were being good humans to the injured insurgents around, and he has to be talked off the cliff (paraphrased: they were just trying to kill you and now you’re being nice to them?) and reminded that even these insurgents are people who are just following orders of their commanders. But this, this retreat - he’s forced to go, but the army stays behind, refusing to retreat - shows him what he now views as the truth of humanity, and it is not a pleasant one. All these sacrifices, seemingly for nothing. There’s also a throwaway line later, seemingly glossed over, when someone is talking about this campaign to gain Nakfa - which to this point was ’THE’ victory they needed to quell the insurgents, which is why he demanded to be there, to record this historical moment - and this person is like “there are numerous Nakfas."
...Okay, now that I think about it, maybe that is exactly what the government didn’t like about this story…
Of course, things also progress from there - he goes back to Asmara, where he’s now got to deal with his growing feelings (of various ilk) with the girl he met, but also with his fiancée, who has shown up. The campaign isn’t over, the war isn’t over - though he’s seen enough - and, unfortunately for him, his involvement in things also isn’t over quite yet. Because as much as the war scene broke his faith in the good of humanity, there’s still some hope for himself that needs to be shredded. You don’t walk away from this being the same person you were when you arrived.
The last 30% of the book - and, honestly, it is brilliantly done how short this war/post-war stuff is relative to the much longer sequences focusing on the city and hope and propaganda - is a complete tonal shift from the stuff in Asmara (even when there is death and betrayal and uncertainty). That short sequence when he witnesses that battle first hand, when he sees the death and destruction and people killing people - is just a total gut punch. It is brilliantly written in the most horrific way, and you can totally understand why he walks away with this lack of faith in humanity. There are numerous times where he wonders what it will take to get humanity to a point where war no longer exists, and when he watches this, he wonders that but also seems to realize that that will never happen. That last 30% goes HARD and definitely hurts - not even necessarily because you lose characters you associate with or are attached to, but just because of how brutally painful and honest the writing is.
There’s also something to be said, I guess, for the head of propaganda indirectly coming to learn what exactly propaganda means.
This is an absolutely brilliantly written story that packs a punch even if you know nothing about the true historical situation going on at the time (though, thanks to the internet, it is easy enough to read about it) and does a damn good job of really capturing that “realities of war” moment when Tsegaye finally makes it there. This starts off as a story you read, but ends up being a story you feel.
Easy read throughout the first 250 pages because of the spy and romance elements. However, the last 100 pages are some of the most heartwrenching descriptions of the pointlessness of war. The novel really comes together at that point. Plus it was cool to learn more about the history and geography of both Ethiopia and Eritrea.
A small minus: a lot of the dialogue between Tsegaye and Fiammetta is awkward to my ears, so much so that I wondered if it is the fault of the translation.
This is a thrilling tale of politics, love and war. It was first published in 1983 but was immediately banned. Then in 1984 Baalu Girma vanished and was never seen again, in all likelihood he was killed in retaliation for this novel.
This is in many ways passionate and alarming portrayal of the Red Star campaign by the Ethiopian government to end the Eritrean insurgency in 1981, seen through the eyes of Tsegaye Hailyemaryam, a journalist who heads propaganda for the Ethiopian government.
Essentially set in Ethiopia, this is a story of tension and mistrust, and political exploits, with an overlay of universal themes and a love element thrown in.
It is a riveting read, informative about time and place and proves a valuable read to gain understanding of the country and people. It feels like an important novel.
One of my favorite things about reading historical fiction is that I get to learn new things without feeling like I'm studying. Under the Udala Trees taught me about the civil war in Nigeria, Brotherless Night taught me about the civil war in Sri Lanka, and Oromay taught me about the history of Eritrea and Ethiopia. When I finish these books, I feel better about myself for being slightly more educated, and knowing a bit more about the world.
It's a 3.5 rounded down because at some point I got pretty bored, but on the other hand I'll probably still recommend this to the right people because there aren't many Amharic-to-English translations of fiction and it's therefore an important window to keep open. It was also unlike any other book I've read; the dialogue was in English but very obviously not originally in English, and I could feel the cultural gap through the pages.
4.5 stars!! Truly delightful cover and contents of the book great too lol! I liked the juxtaposition of politics and war with the live stories. A really interesting insight into another topic that I don’t know so much about (my Eritrea knowledge is mostly post revolution). I thought it was v clever how the book was seemingly giving the propaganda message but then exposing it at the same time (not sure how to describe this literary device sorry). Translation really good which I imagine is no easy feat from Amharic. Small pet peeve that the female characters were quite one dimensional but it was written in the 80s I guess.
Side note is it bad to say that the book was better knowing that the author got killed by the govt after writing it? #resistance
It was well written with a good story line and exposes a lot about ethiopian and eritrean politics during that specific time but too political for my taste and found it hard to keep up and follow the story through but overall an ok book.
I enjoyed Oromay as a window into Ethiopia in the Derg years, and for its colorful, loving depictions of Asmara, however I couldn't help but feel like the translation was a bit stilted. I would suspect the book comes across much better in the original Amharic.
Most of the novel's plot revolves around Tsegaye's romance with an Eritrean woman and an intrigue involving Eritrean insurgents, both of which tended to meander in the middle chapters. Thankfully, Oromay picks up towards the end: the dual climax of the battle to capture Nakfa and the Eritrean plot's dramatic end were very gripping. Easy reading, but wouldn't necessarily recommend unless you have a particular interest in Ethiopia.
I knew nothing about the history of Ethiopia & Eritrea before this book, now know a bit more and want to research even more I got lost with different characters Really did not like the narrator, his behaviour towards women
one of the best books ive ever read. so poignant and impactful, especially considering when it was released. i love how every character is essential to the plot and how they all link together.
An amusing and interesting novel about a journalist caught up in Ethiopia’s “Red Star” propaganda campaign to try and squash the 1981 Eritrean uprising. At the same time, the journalist has left his fiancée behind in their hometown whilst he is involved with covering the war from the city of Asmara. He meets and falls for a local woman. He also insists on accompanying the soldiers into war along with his film team, only to discover that war is not as glamorous as his propaganda paints it to be. There is bureaucracy, posturing, naïveté, and deceit, deliciously drawn and well narrated. I learned that the author was “disappeared” following the publication of this novel, and that was likely no accident…. My thanks to the author, publisher, @HighBridgeAudio, and #NetGalley for making the English translation available and for early access to the English audiobook for review purposes. Publication date: 27 May 2025.
Recently translated to English from Amharic, "Oromay" is the true story told from the perspective of Tsegaye, head of propaganda/journalism for national unification campaign in the 80s. Upon release, "Oromay" was banned in Ethiopia and Baalu Girma was fired from his government role. The book is critical of the Ethiopian government and shines light on the strategies it used to eliminate rebel forces in Eritrea. I enjoyed reading a book from such a real and unique perspective and the plot lines about Tsegaye's love affairs kept things interesting!
an incredible book filled with such lush scenery, political intrigue and wise words. genuinely enjoyed this much more than anticipated. loved that there was a switch in pov & also the interjections by the author. finding out about his unfortunate fate was heartbreaking.
the only thing i didn’t love was the portrayal of the female characters/how much the infidelity was trivialised.