I had heard some mothers in a bookstore talking about Artemis Fowl and how good it was, so I finally gave in and bought the first book.
Summary: Artemis Fowl is a child genius/billionaire/criminal mastermind who has discovered that fairies (and the like) are real and is seeking to exploit them. He does this by kidnapping a LEPrecon (for Lower Elements Police Reconnaissance). The Lower Elements live underground, having been driven there by the Mud People (or humans).
I decided that the book was not good in the first few pages. The writing is not up to par. Some of the dialogue seems like it came from two six-year-olds arguing about whose laser gun was better, when in fact all they have are cheap squirt guns. A child’s imagination is an amazing thing, but the words they use to describe their imagination is quite another. In addition to the bad writing and dialogue, the plot is also poorly structured.
But what makes me really angry about this book is the attempt to brainwash kids through literature. I am not opposed to teaching children morals and values through stories, in fact that is the way it has been done for centuries, but this book goes above and beyond what is acceptable. The author, Eoin Colfer, is trying to teach children to take care of the environment by contrasting the ideal environmentally friendly fairy society with the evil polluting dirty dolphin and puppy killing human society. In attempting this, he appears to be repulsed by not just pollution but of the whole human race. Keep in mind that Mud People is the Fairy term for human being, a term that seems to come straight out of Nazi propaganda against Jews.
When characters in Harry Potter called Hermione a mudblood, it was clear those characters were evil. In Artemis, it is the most likeable, most good character that uses that term Mud People to describe humans.
Let me share some additional passages with you:
If the Mud People knew [about leprechauns] they’d probably take steps to stamp them out. Pg. 33
Mud People bred like rodents. Pg. 50
The Mud People destroyed everything they came in contact with. Pg. 50
The only good thing about going to the toilet was the minerals being returned to the earth, but the Mud People had even managed to botch that up by treating the …stuff…with bottles of blue chemicals. Pg. 50
She could see the pollution in [the dolphins], bleaching their skin white and giving them red sores on their backs. And although she smiled, her heart was breaking. Mud People had a lot to answer for. Pg. 68
The smell of death and pain lingered in the blood-swabbed decks. Many noble creatures had died here, died and been dissected for a few bars of soap and some heating oil. Humans were such barbarians. Pg. 105
The Mud People had greased the hinges [of the whaling boat] with whale blubber. Was there no end to their depravity. Pg. 106
Mud People have been stealing from us for millennia. Why do you think we live underground? Pg. 120
…unless the Mud People had learned to coexist with other species. And if history had taught any lessons it was that humans couldn’t get along with anyone, even themselves. Pg. 125
“…I’d say there was some human blood in you.” In describing a fairy who was a little trigger happy. Then later, he apologized because, "it had been a deeply offensive insult." Pg. 128
No one built weapons of cruelty like the Mud Men. Pg. 265
I recognize that the types of humans described in the above passages do in fact exist, but not all humans are like that, and we are getting better. But a 7 year old reading this book can't help but come away with a deep loathing for all the other humans who are killing dolphins and destroying the Earth. And again, I think that teaching kids to take good care of the other is a movie endeavor for a work of fiction. This book just appears to go way too far.
But you know what I would like to do now, I would like to debate Mr. Colfer’s accusations on humanity using the fairy world he created for her book.
First, a basic history of human-fairy relations, according to Colfer. Fairies descended from Pterodactyls, and lived peacefully on earth for many millennia until the humans evolved. The fairies called these humans, Mud People, because they lived in the mud. The humans apparently could not help but try and kill the fairies. Cuz humans are b evil by nature. Instead of fighting or teaching the humans, the fairies withdrew underground and ceded the surface to this new evil species that would spend the next thousands of years systematically destroyingand all that the Fairy folk love. The fairies live underground going deeper and deeper as we humans mine and drill more and more. The fairies only return to the surface to replenish their magic.
Now, answer me this, if you care about something, would you fight for it or would you run and hide? Me, I would fight for it, and it seems that the fairies would too. They don't want to see living creatures destroyed. That is the basis for the plot of the book, but for some reason, the fairies decided to hide, while the mud people destroy the earth that they care about so much.
I say fight, but there might be other options. Education, sharing of technology, etc. All we know is that they are not fighting or doing anything really. The fairies complain about our destruction and pollution of earth. However, the main fairy in the book at one point uses gasoline powered wings (they strap onto their backs). Now granted, they were an old pair of wings, all the newer wings are solar powered, but the fact that they had at one point used gasoline, and are still using gasoline in older modeled wings, indicates that they are partially responsible for the green house gases and other pollution associated with drilling and refining oil. They only switched to solar recently.
The main fairy also complains about the human's sewage treatment. What would the fairies propose that we do with our sewage besides treating it so it doesn't breed disease that isn't just harmful to humans. We create so much that the earth cannot biodegrade it quickly enough to keep disease from breeding in it. Now, if we had the magic power to heal, like the fairies, then maybe we could just let it return to earth naturally, and get healed from any adverse effects. However, the fairies won't share even healing magic with the mud people.
At one point, author says that no one builds weapons of cruelty like the humans, yet, throughout the book, Colfer describes fairy weapons like a “Neutrino 2000” which is a platinum nuclear handgun that has three settings, “scorched, well-done, and crisped to a cinder”. It seems like a pretty cruel weapon for just one person to weild. Not only that, but the gun will continue to work for well over a thousand years, so not only can you use it to kill many things, but should you die or lose it, it will continue to work in the hands of others for a millenium. But the worst weapon the fairies have invented which seems much more cruel than anything humans have yet created, is a “Blue Rinse”, which is a biological bomb that destroys only living tissue, leaving the landscape unchanged. Can you imagine? All the “benefits” of Hiroshima, without all the bad side effects like destroying a city. And what’s worse is that while we have used the nuclear bomb only twice, the fairies use the blue rinse “on rare occasions.” That sounds a lot more frequent than twice. I don’t know about you, but it sounds like the fairies are just as capable as humans in the production of weapons of cruelty.
But this whole review/argument is stupid. There are no fairies with magic powers, and if they do exist, they have decided not to help us. So, it is up to us humans to work things out on our own. While there have been some bad things in our past, what matters now is our present, and what we do from here on out, and I would like to say that in spite of it all, we are doing a pretty good job. Humans are good creatures, created in the image of God. We are imperfect, but on the whole, we are all striving for perfection every day. And that is all I have to say about that.