Dissimilar Similitudes: Devotional Objects in Late Medieval Europe

by Caroline Walker Bynum

From an acclaimed historian, a mesmerizing account of how medieval European Christians envisioned the paradoxical nature of holy objects

Between the twelfth and the sixteenth centuries, European Christians used a plethora of objects in worship, not only prayer books, statues, and paintings but also pieces of natural materials, such as stones and earth, considered to carry holiness, dolls representing Jesus and Mary, and even bits of consecrated bread and wine thought to be miraculously preserved flesh and blood. Theologians and ordinary worshippers alike explained, utilized, justified, and warned against some of these objects, which could carry with them both anti-Semitic charges and the glorious promise of heaven. Their proliferation and the reaction against them form a crucial background to the European-wide movements we know today as “reformations” (both Protestant and Catholic).

In a set of independent but interrelated essays, Caroline Bynum considers some examples of such holy things, among them beds for the baby Jesus, the headdresses of medieval nuns, and the footprints of Christ carried home from the Holy Land by pilgrims in patterns cut to their shape or their measurement in lengths of string. Building on and going beyond her well-received work on the history of materiality, Bynum makes two arguments, one substantive, the other methodological. First, she demonstrates that the objects themselves communicate a paradox of dissimilar similitude―that is, that in their very details they both image the glory of heaven and make clear that that heaven is beyond any representation in earthly things. Second, she uses the theme of likeness and unlikeness to interrogate current practices of comparative history. Suggesting that contemporary students of religion, art, and culture should avoid comparing things that merely “look alike,” she proposes that humanists turn instead to comparing across cultures the disparate and perhaps visually dissimilar objects in which worshippers as well as theorists locate the “other” that gives religion enduring power.

Genres: Art History, Nonfiction, History, Religion, Research, Medieval

352 pages, Hardcover

Published September 29, 2020

About the author

Caroline Walker Bynum is Professor emerita of Medieval European History at the Institute for Advanced Study, and University Professor emerita at Columbia University in the City of New York. She studies the religious ideas and practices of the European Middle Ages from late antiquity to the sixteenth century.

Reviews

[Carolyn · Rating 4 out of 5]

“Hence the medieval footprint in its many guises and permutations can perhaps serve as a metaphor for what all scholars pursue- with phobia as well as philia. The other we seek to know, whether text or object, is paradoxical- on the one hand, a conjuring up of an absent something that has left only a trace, yet on the other hand, a thing powerful in and of itself. After all, there would be no other to pursue if something strange- whether wonderful or fearsome- did not hover beyond, forever just out of our reach, whole although we encounter only a part. But we would have no access to that other if something, by it’s very absence, had not left behind a specific, powerful in itself, and very much present part- a vestige, or trace, or footprint.”

[Ella]

Very relevant for research and research methods, but I wasn’t a huge fan of some of the more comparative stuff.