Review for The Nightblade epic vol 1. By Garrett Robinson.
As a whole, this book was a nice read. I felt excited to read the book after the first chapter, mostly because it and every other chapter is so short that it's easy to read quickly. One trick I noticed the author using is hinting that there is going to be a big reveal or mystery at the end of each book and then leaving the answer at the beginning of the next book. This would be annoying, if it weren't for the fact that this was an anthology or if the questions raised at the start of the book weren't answered. Luckily both this things are fulfilled, and being able to get the answers immediately at the beginning of the next book and letting that decide how that story will play out allowed me to get back into the reading flow and heightened my connections with the world and characters.
One problem with the book (This might not apply if you haven't watched the author on YouTube or his tumblr on twitter) is that it didn't live up to the marketing of the rest of the series as an LGBT+ friendly series. There isn't any hatred or discrimination targeted towards any one from that group, but there also wasn't any character from that group in the book at all. I'm aware the author decided to make the series more LGBT+ friendly as the series went on, but the lack of any of those types of character is jarring if you follow the author on social media.
A small breakdown of each book, with spoilers for all.
Nightblade.
Introduces the world of Underrealm as well as the main character Loren who wants to be a master thief but doesn’t want to kill or hurt any innocents. A plan thrown into chaos when she decides to flee her village, join up a criminal mage, join a caravan of murderous merchants after the mage abandons her, tries to join a thieves guild after she betrays the caravan and steals away the leaders daughter - only to make an enemy of them too and be stuck inside a city where everyone is hunting her down.
A good opening to the series, with enough hints to the world, magic, and the intentions of characters to make you crave he next book. Which is conveniently in the volume.
Mystic.
Described by the author as being weaker than the first, I think he's wrong. Mystic picks up where Nightblade left off, with Loren and the Mystic in question trying to find their friends that were waiting for them at the end of the first book. The plot snowballs from there, as Loren leaves the Mystic at the urging of their mage friend, only to be pursued by another Mystic, captured by both of them, and be stuck inside another city, this time under siege. Another fun book, this is where you start to get a feeling for the world of Underrealm, where the first book was mainly focused on establishing characters. Even as the world grows, so do the characters, as Loren is challanged by each of her friends and enemies on her no killing stance, and forced to deal with the fact that this might not be viable in the world. And you watch as one character starts to fall to darkness in order to get what they need.
Dark fire.
Loren and her group of good friends + one captive bad friend, get into another fight, this time with a group of mystics and are forced to go on the run. Luckily for them, there is a path they can take that is danger free. Unluckily, that is a lie. There is danger, like, so much danger. Satyrs, harpies, cults are in the cards for Loren. This is the book that pushes her no killing rule to the limit, and how this ties into the twist at the end of the book regarding something that happened at the beginning of the first book is quite the gut punch. This book suffers the most from the what I see as the main problem with the first three books, being there isn't an overarching goal, or at least one that relates to Loren's desire to be a theif. In the first book its fine because Loren has begun to make herself known to the world and learns a neat trick for escaping, but in the second book she doesn't get anything like that, and in this book it feels like she's just reacting to dangers as they come up and not learning how to be a thief. Despite this, Dark fire itself is a fine book.
I would definitely recommend this book and the series so far.