4.5 rounded up to 5.
The subtitle sold this book to me, I admit it. 🙂 “An Inklings Novel.” Who among the readers of C.S. Lewis and Tolkien would hesitate to take the opportunity to drop in on a meeting at the Bird and Baby Pub, chit-chatting about books with men who, though long-dead, are dear, dear friends to us in spirit?
Admission #2 – The description of what this book is about threw me for a loop. Is it fantasy? Historical fiction? A mishmash of the two? What is it? I like to know what I’m getting into 🙂 – and this sounded different, that’s for sure.
And it was different – in a truly wonderful way, as if I’d tried a flavor of ice cream unlike any other. Replete with conversations between the main characters and the Inklings (in their houses, out-of-doors, in pubs), this novel feels so authentic – incredibly so. My favorite parts included the Inklings members; I felt that these were the best-written and most interesting. I am so glad there were so many of these parts! As a long-time reader of C.S. Lewis and Tolkien, I relished the way Downing depicted them so realistically. I also loved the incredible notes and source materials sections the author included.
I wasn’t ever completely “sold” on the main characters’ quests… Even at the end, the “why” seemed missing for Laura, and I would have liked that to be more conclusive. Yet… maybe that was part of the point – that all stories throughout time are interwoven, and we sometimes do not know why certain things happen to us. But God uses them in His great, all-encompassing story.
I would highly recommend the novel to any teen or adult who enjoys C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, or Charles Williams.