What do you think?
Rate this book
Watson and Holmes
A SOLDIER TIRED OF WAR
Born into wealth and privilege, Jenny Watson left her parents' way of life behind when she volunteered to go fight the Shifters. After giving up her commission, she arrives in Linden hoping to make a fresh start and to put her medical degree to good use. But when her friend and fellow passenger is murdered, Jenny finds new purpose working with Detective Sharlotte Holmes.
A DETECTIVE ITCHING FOR TROUBLE
Sharlotte Holmes has lived in a three mile radius her entire life, content to pursue her varied interests and wholly unconcerned with the burden the outside world would place on her great intellect. But when Jenny's past comes back to haunt her, Sharlotte may have to choose between staying in her comfort zone and getting answers.
EXPERIENCE SHERLOCK HOLMES LIKE NEVER BEFORE
Born into wealth and privilege, Jenny Watson left her parents' way of life behind when she volunteered to go fight the Shifters. After giving up her commission, she arrives in Linden hoping to make a fresh start and to put her medical degree to good use. But when her friend and fellow passenger is murdered, Jenny finds new purpose working with Detective Sharlotte Holmes.
A DETECTIVE ITCHING FOR TROUBLE
Sharlotte Holmes has lived in a three mile radius her entire life, content to pursue her varied interests and wholly unconcerned with the burden the outside world would place on her great intellect. But when Jenny's past comes back to haunt her, Sharlotte may have to choose between staying in her comfort zone and getting answers.
EXPERIENCE SHERLOCK HOLMES LIKE NEVER BEFORE
258 pages, Paperback
Published May 23, 2020
1 person is currently reading
46 people want to read
About the author
E.B. Dawson
36 books145 followersI grew up in Southeast Asia. My first experience with America was when I was six years old. Sometimes I amuse my friends by telling them stories of my first impressions of this country (clean bathrooms, Toy Story, Taco Bell, getting lost in department stores).
My family moved to California when I was eleven and completely changed the course of my life. On the outside I'm a well-adjusted American adult, but in all honesty some days I still wake up to the sound of the grass being cut by machetes.
I have traveled a fair amount and lived in four separate countries. I see the world very differently from most people that I know. And because I am an analytical introvert I try to understand everything in my life. I pour this into my writing.
Everything I write is deeply personal to me. People who know me well recognize the shadows of people I've met, experiences I've had, and emotions I've walked through in my writing. My goal is not just to entertain and explore imaginary worlds, but to take the reader on a journey that explores difficult questions and instills some sort of hope.
My family moved to California when I was eleven and completely changed the course of my life. On the outside I'm a well-adjusted American adult, but in all honesty some days I still wake up to the sound of the grass being cut by machetes.
I have traveled a fair amount and lived in four separate countries. I see the world very differently from most people that I know. And because I am an analytical introvert I try to understand everything in my life. I pour this into my writing.
Everything I write is deeply personal to me. People who know me well recognize the shadows of people I've met, experiences I've had, and emotions I've walked through in my writing. My goal is not just to entertain and explore imaginary worlds, but to take the reader on a journey that explores difficult questions and instills some sort of hope.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews
May 20, 2020
The basic idea of a gender-swapped Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson in space (or rather, on another planet, in this particular case) is one of those concepts that *sounds* great on paper but could easily end up as nothing more than a failed gimmick. Honestly, given all the forced and tiresome retellings out there these days, if this story had been released by an author I'd never read before, I probably wouldn't have bothered to try it. However, having read excellent sci-fi retellings of classic tales from E.B. Dawson before, I was optimistic that this book would satisfy me. In the end, it blew all my expectations out of the water.
Unlike so many Holmes retellings, Watson and Holmes is not obnoxiously caught up in its own cleverness (looking at you, BBC Sherlock). Dawson doesn't merely turn the key and step away to allow this promising concept to drive itself off a cliff. She puts in the effort to carefully flesh out both the characters and the setting so that they don't have to lean too heavily on the Holmes-reboot concept in order to be successful. The story stands confidently on its own original merits.
Furthermore, Watson and Holmes both feel like real people. In fact, this may be my favorite alternative version of these two fictional icons. The reversal of the common order of the names is fitting, as Jenny Watson is at the forefront of the story. She's a strong and competent character with believable emotional scars due to her combat experience. Unlike the original Dr. Watson, she does not spend the entire story merely oohing and aahing at Holmes' cleverness, but unlike various other incarnations of Watson I've encountered, she doesn't have an abrasive relationship with Holmes either. The close friendship of the two characters, always a highlight of the original stories, is captured perfectly here. Sharlotte Holmes is a refreshing take on the great detective. Dawson avoids a threadbare trope adopted by so many mystery writers (whether they're adapting Holmes or not) and doesn't make Sharlotte a vaguely-likable snot. Sharlotte is delightfully quirky, but entirely sympathetic. As for the fact that these versions of Watson and Holmes are female, this doesn't feature as a plot point in the book at all, which I applaud. This story is a masterclass in how to write gender-swapped characters, in my opinion. There aren't any irritating nudge-nudge-wink-wink references to it or tasteless digs at men. The characters' gender is simply a natural part of who they are.
The world-building, always a highlight of Dawson's books, is superb yet again in Watson and Holmes. I felt immersed in the extraterrestrial world of the story and could clearly visualize the various alien creatures that populated it. The mystery element, always a tricky part when writing a Holmes adaptation, is handled beautifully. The big reveal at the end came as a genuine surprise to me, and yet enough clues to it had been seeded throughout the earlier portions of the book for it to make sense. Holmes fans will find plenty of Arthur Conan Doyle Easter eggs scattered throughout the book, but it can easily be enjoyed by those who have never picked up a Holmes book, as well. My favorite element, however, was the brilliant and hilarious dialogue. (Well, that and Terrence. You will love Terrence.) I found myself frequently highlighting both funny and profound lines alike as I read.
In short, this is my favorite book from E.B. Dawson yet, and one of the best Sherlock Holmes adaptations I've had the pleasure to read. Highly recommended to all fans of science fiction and/or old-fashioned mystery-adventure.
Unlike so many Holmes retellings, Watson and Holmes is not obnoxiously caught up in its own cleverness (looking at you, BBC Sherlock). Dawson doesn't merely turn the key and step away to allow this promising concept to drive itself off a cliff. She puts in the effort to carefully flesh out both the characters and the setting so that they don't have to lean too heavily on the Holmes-reboot concept in order to be successful. The story stands confidently on its own original merits.
Furthermore, Watson and Holmes both feel like real people. In fact, this may be my favorite alternative version of these two fictional icons. The reversal of the common order of the names is fitting, as Jenny Watson is at the forefront of the story. She's a strong and competent character with believable emotional scars due to her combat experience. Unlike the original Dr. Watson, she does not spend the entire story merely oohing and aahing at Holmes' cleverness, but unlike various other incarnations of Watson I've encountered, she doesn't have an abrasive relationship with Holmes either. The close friendship of the two characters, always a highlight of the original stories, is captured perfectly here. Sharlotte Holmes is a refreshing take on the great detective. Dawson avoids a threadbare trope adopted by so many mystery writers (whether they're adapting Holmes or not) and doesn't make Sharlotte a vaguely-likable snot. Sharlotte is delightfully quirky, but entirely sympathetic. As for the fact that these versions of Watson and Holmes are female, this doesn't feature as a plot point in the book at all, which I applaud. This story is a masterclass in how to write gender-swapped characters, in my opinion. There aren't any irritating nudge-nudge-wink-wink references to it or tasteless digs at men. The characters' gender is simply a natural part of who they are.
The world-building, always a highlight of Dawson's books, is superb yet again in Watson and Holmes. I felt immersed in the extraterrestrial world of the story and could clearly visualize the various alien creatures that populated it. The mystery element, always a tricky part when writing a Holmes adaptation, is handled beautifully. The big reveal at the end came as a genuine surprise to me, and yet enough clues to it had been seeded throughout the earlier portions of the book for it to make sense. Holmes fans will find plenty of Arthur Conan Doyle Easter eggs scattered throughout the book, but it can easily be enjoyed by those who have never picked up a Holmes book, as well. My favorite element, however, was the brilliant and hilarious dialogue. (Well, that and Terrence. You will love Terrence.) I found myself frequently highlighting both funny and profound lines alike as I read.
In short, this is my favorite book from E.B. Dawson yet, and one of the best Sherlock Holmes adaptations I've had the pleasure to read. Highly recommended to all fans of science fiction and/or old-fashioned mystery-adventure.
December 3, 2022
Imagine a Sherlock Holmes retelling. Now imagine it’s set . . . in space . . . on the city planet of Linden (instead of London). Then picture that there are several alien cultures (I loved them all and how distinctive they were!). And Holmes and Watson are young women. I know! I adore the original Holmes stories, so I was worried some of this would bug me, but it all worked perfectly and was SO much fun!
Dr. Jenny Watson (who has a past) and Sharlotte Holmes (who is brilliant) are such great characters and I really enjoyed following both of them through this cyberpunk setting and delightful story. It’s just great sci-fi! I rarely read this genre, but every time I pick up an E.B. Dawson science fiction story, I know it’s going to blow me out of the water, and this one did, in the best way. I love E.B. Dawson’s writing and worlds SO much. Although, for some reason, I don’t think I expected this one to be so FUN, but it was and I loved that!
I love how there are mysteries and sci-fi plots of Shifters and a sinister organization called Moriarty (and the suspense at the end—aaahh!), but that it’s also filled with adventure and friend moments like apartment squabbles and going for noodles together—and oh, yes, Terrence the potted-plant robot was hilarious. XD It’s a perfect mix of cozy fun, character moments, and mystery/suspense.
The plot kept me guessing the whole way, so it’s very much its own story, but I also loved all the nods to the original Holmes stories. Lestrade can’t stand Sharlotte, which is always hilarious. XD Mrs. Hudson’s an anxious but gentle alien lady who’s slightly eccentric (but not nearly as much as Sharlotte). And there are great moments like this note Sharlotte sends Jenny: “221 B Baker Street, Doyle District. 900 square feet. You’ll have to sign the lease because my credit is rubbish. Landlady keeps giving me the shifty eye. I don’t think she really believes you’re a doctor. Come as soon as you can?-Holmes”
I loved getting to know both Jenny and Sharlotte. Their dialogue is zippy and the absolute best—I kept laughing or wanting to quote it. (I would quote the ENTIRE FIRST FOUR PAGES OF CHAPTER FOUR here to make a point if I could because that was one of the BEST conversations and entirely typical of Sharlotte especially. XD) They make a fun pair, especially with their banter, and they’re just fabulous as best friends—even when Sharlotte does stuff that gets on Jenny’s nerves, in the best Holmes-vs.-Watson way. XD They remind me of the originals in some ways, but I’ve also never met characters quite like these, and it’s the best.
In short, this is an unexpected and completely delightful book, filled with memorable characters, suspenseful moments, lots of humor, a unique sci-fi setting, and references to one of the greatest detective series of all time. What is not to love? I highly recommend checking this one out! (The audiobook is also fabulous!)
Dr. Jenny Watson (who has a past) and Sharlotte Holmes (who is brilliant) are such great characters and I really enjoyed following both of them through this cyberpunk setting and delightful story. It’s just great sci-fi! I rarely read this genre, but every time I pick up an E.B. Dawson science fiction story, I know it’s going to blow me out of the water, and this one did, in the best way. I love E.B. Dawson’s writing and worlds SO much. Although, for some reason, I don’t think I expected this one to be so FUN, but it was and I loved that!
I love how there are mysteries and sci-fi plots of Shifters and a sinister organization called Moriarty (and the suspense at the end—aaahh!), but that it’s also filled with adventure and friend moments like apartment squabbles and going for noodles together—and oh, yes, Terrence the potted-plant robot was hilarious. XD It’s a perfect mix of cozy fun, character moments, and mystery/suspense.
The plot kept me guessing the whole way, so it’s very much its own story, but I also loved all the nods to the original Holmes stories. Lestrade can’t stand Sharlotte, which is always hilarious. XD Mrs. Hudson’s an anxious but gentle alien lady who’s slightly eccentric (but not nearly as much as Sharlotte). And there are great moments like this note Sharlotte sends Jenny: “221 B Baker Street, Doyle District. 900 square feet. You’ll have to sign the lease because my credit is rubbish. Landlady keeps giving me the shifty eye. I don’t think she really believes you’re a doctor. Come as soon as you can?-Holmes”
I loved getting to know both Jenny and Sharlotte. Their dialogue is zippy and the absolute best—I kept laughing or wanting to quote it. (I would quote the ENTIRE FIRST FOUR PAGES OF CHAPTER FOUR here to make a point if I could because that was one of the BEST conversations and entirely typical of Sharlotte especially. XD) They make a fun pair, especially with their banter, and they’re just fabulous as best friends—even when Sharlotte does stuff that gets on Jenny’s nerves, in the best Holmes-vs.-Watson way. XD They remind me of the originals in some ways, but I’ve also never met characters quite like these, and it’s the best.
In short, this is an unexpected and completely delightful book, filled with memorable characters, suspenseful moments, lots of humor, a unique sci-fi setting, and references to one of the greatest detective series of all time. What is not to love? I highly recommend checking this one out! (The audiobook is also fabulous!)
June 13, 2020
Watson and Holmes is a wonderful blend of hard-hitting Sherlock-style action with heartwarming friendship, and so many nods to the original books and other Holmes culture that I kept on grinning through the entire story. I love me some Sherlock Holmes, and Sharlotte did not disappoint—neither did Jenny Watson. To be honest, I was a little afraid that Holmes’s and Watson’s friendship would not translate as well into a genderbent format, but I need not have worried. The part contained in “Her Last Bow” punched me in the gut as much as the original book did.
I particularly liked that Sharlotte was represented as less of a machine and more of a human. Don’t get me wrong—she still kept exasperating hours and the reader-annoying habit of not letting anyone in on her plans until after they were in motion—but she did care Watson. Jenny was also a multilayered character with a high-society background running from memories of the front.
The worldbuilding of Linden honestly reminded me of Zootopia. Each sector had its own culture and ways and language, and I loved the unique approach Dawson took towards showing how Linden had a little of everything. It wasn’t just one giant conglomerate of alien species intermingling throughout the entire city.
I truly enjoyed Watson and Holmes.
* I received a free advanced review copy of this book, therefore the opinions given are my own.
I particularly liked that Sharlotte was represented as less of a machine and more of a human. Don’t get me wrong—she still kept exasperating hours and the reader-annoying habit of not letting anyone in on her plans until after they were in motion—but she did care Watson. Jenny was also a multilayered character with a high-society background running from memories of the front.
The worldbuilding of Linden honestly reminded me of Zootopia. Each sector had its own culture and ways and language, and I loved the unique approach Dawson took towards showing how Linden had a little of everything. It wasn’t just one giant conglomerate of alien species intermingling throughout the entire city.
I truly enjoyed Watson and Holmes.
* I received a free advanced review copy of this book, therefore the opinions given are my own.
April 27, 2020
I am still really excited about this story... it's very well written, the descriptions explode all over the page... it was endearing and hilarious.
I am a painfully slow reader... but I would read this one again...and again... and again. Holmes' monologues were spot on, and Watson's back story was intriguing and...aliens!
I could babble on... but if you like quick adventure, I highly recommend Watson and Holmes!
I am a painfully slow reader... but I would read this one again...and again... and again. Holmes' monologues were spot on, and Watson's back story was intriguing and...aliens!
I could babble on... but if you like quick adventure, I highly recommend Watson and Holmes!
April 27, 2020
I LOVE this story. There is so much complexity and beauty. The visual descriptions are gorgeous, and the twists and turns are just awesome.
One of my favorite things about this story is how the author can paint such vivid cultures with just a few clear descriptions. They stand out as being both alien and yet intensely realistic. We've seen her flex these skills in multiple other stories, so it shouldn't have been as big of a surprise as it was, but I just love it.
The aliens aren't the only wonderful detail here. The two female leads have a strong and enduring friendship that I find simply beautiful. Seeing Watson and Holmes in such a complex, in depth light is just beautiful. I love their friendship, but I also adore their individual personalities.
Also, there is a plant. Terrence. He is the best. I love him. And I want a plushie.
I feel like everything E.B. Dawson puts to paper just keeps getting better and I can't wait to see this hit the world in all it's beauty and brilliance!
One of my favorite things about this story is how the author can paint such vivid cultures with just a few clear descriptions. They stand out as being both alien and yet intensely realistic. We've seen her flex these skills in multiple other stories, so it shouldn't have been as big of a surprise as it was, but I just love it.
The aliens aren't the only wonderful detail here. The two female leads have a strong and enduring friendship that I find simply beautiful. Seeing Watson and Holmes in such a complex, in depth light is just beautiful. I love their friendship, but I also adore their individual personalities.
Also, there is a plant. Terrence. He is the best. I love him. And I want a plushie.
I feel like everything E.B. Dawson puts to paper just keeps getting better and I can't wait to see this hit the world in all it's beauty and brilliance!
April 30, 2020
Another excellent addition to E.B. Dawson’s repertoire of fantastic fiction! Her recreation of the Watson and Holmes dynamic in a sci-fi world is not something you want to miss. Jenny Watson is haunted by her fears and anxiety and ready to escape the war against the fearsome Shifters. Sharlotte Homes is a quirky and unpredictable detective. Together they form a team determined to make a difference in Linden while solving baffling cases and struggling to pay the bills.
I continue to love Dawson’s ability to create unique cultures in her stories and the detailed worlds that she designs for them to exist within. Sharlotte and Jenny are both well-developed characters that you can invest in, and their interactions bring them into contact with the various races that co-habit the city. I loved how this book was divided into five sections. Each served as a mini-arc within the overall plot and contributed a critical piece of information that pulled you further into the mystery. The story builds in intensity and leads to an exciting, suspenseful, and emotional end.
I continue to love Dawson’s ability to create unique cultures in her stories and the detailed worlds that she designs for them to exist within. Sharlotte and Jenny are both well-developed characters that you can invest in, and their interactions bring them into contact with the various races that co-habit the city. I loved how this book was divided into five sections. Each served as a mini-arc within the overall plot and contributed a critical piece of information that pulled you further into the mystery. The story builds in intensity and leads to an exciting, suspenseful, and emotional end.
August 11, 2020
I Love , LOVE , LOVED this book, I am never disappointed when it comes to E.B Dawson's writing, she is absolutely amazing!!
THIS book is such a gem, the characters, the setting, the tip of the hat to Conan Doyle, it was all so perfect!!
More coherent review to come, till then just go read Watson and Holmes , it's really the nicest thing you can do for yourself if you like anything Sherlock Holmes!
THIS book is such a gem, the characters, the setting, the tip of the hat to Conan Doyle, it was all so perfect!!
More coherent review to come, till then just go read Watson and Holmes , it's really the nicest thing you can do for yourself if you like anything Sherlock Holmes!
August 1, 2024
I am a huge fan of Sherlock Holmes so when I saw there was a science fiction retelling of the classic detective I knew I had to read it. The fact that the main characters were also women was just icing on the cake.
Charlotte Holmes feels like somone you'd know. The friendship between Jenny and Charlotte is believable and feels familiar like a friendship you wish you could have. It's one of those true friendships that goes beyond the standard "lets hangout."
At first I wasn't sure what to make of the male narrator for female main characters, but as the story progressed his full voice talent came into play, and I believe the best man was chosen for the job.
If you love the Sherlock Holmes stories and are open to new takes on the characters, or if you're just looking for a good sci-fi mystery, then this book should be next on your TBR list
Charlotte Holmes feels like somone you'd know. The friendship between Jenny and Charlotte is believable and feels familiar like a friendship you wish you could have. It's one of those true friendships that goes beyond the standard "lets hangout."
At first I wasn't sure what to make of the male narrator for female main characters, but as the story progressed his full voice talent came into play, and I believe the best man was chosen for the job.
If you love the Sherlock Holmes stories and are open to new takes on the characters, or if you're just looking for a good sci-fi mystery, then this book should be next on your TBR list
July 20, 2021
While Arthur Conan Doyle's original stories tend to have an intellectual focus in which the characters are often used as devices to serve the plot, Dawson's reimagining focuses on the people and relationships that drive the story.
Doing justice to the world of Sherlock Holmes is a difficult task, but Dawson rises to the challenge and improves upon some of the backstory and characters in the original work. While I never felt like the original Watson lived up to his full potential as a character, Jenny Watson is an interesting person in her own right. The story is as much about her as it is about Holmes. Jenny is a very active participant in the story rather than a simple observer, and her skills and experiences are necessary to the plot. While John Watson's military history seldom figures into the original stories, Jenny's history on the battlefield (and the still-ongoing war) is a crucial element of the story. I also really enjoyed the author's reimagining of a couple other canon characters. Mrs. Hudson is wonderful. I also really appreciated how the beginning of the story makes a lot more sense of how Watson and Holmes end up sharing a flat.
I really liked how Dawson adapted the characters to the change in gender and surroundings. Watson and Holmes could have just been the original characters stuck inside girl's bodies, but Dawson has taken care to make them truly feminine. I also appreciate how Holmes's skills and areas of expert knowledge are conformed to a sci-fi landscape with advanced technology and a mosaic of alien cultures and languages.
I really enjoyed exploring the setting of Linden. The concept of a vertically organized city is fascinating, especially considering the way the unusual physical nature of the setting plays into the culture and interactions between the different alien species.
A couple elements kept me from giving the story a fourth star. While I did like Sharlotte Holmes for who she was, I was a little disappointed that she wasn't closer in personality to the original character. I would have liked to see Holmes's weaknesses and annoying characteristics come out a little more strongly than they did. The second thing was that I had a bit of trouble following the mysteries. Many of the important clues are related to facets of alien culture and physiology that I wouldn't have picked up on with out the characters pointing them out. While these facts highlight the alien cultures in cool ways, I didn't find that the mystery gave me very many "aha" moments. While these things affected my personal enjoyment, they aren't necessarily bad; they just didn't line up with what I expected. It depends what you're looking for.
Doing justice to the world of Sherlock Holmes is a difficult task, but Dawson rises to the challenge and improves upon some of the backstory and characters in the original work. While I never felt like the original Watson lived up to his full potential as a character, Jenny Watson is an interesting person in her own right. The story is as much about her as it is about Holmes. Jenny is a very active participant in the story rather than a simple observer, and her skills and experiences are necessary to the plot. While John Watson's military history seldom figures into the original stories, Jenny's history on the battlefield (and the still-ongoing war) is a crucial element of the story. I also really enjoyed the author's reimagining of a couple other canon characters. Mrs. Hudson is wonderful. I also really appreciated how the beginning of the story makes a lot more sense of how Watson and Holmes end up sharing a flat.
I really liked how Dawson adapted the characters to the change in gender and surroundings. Watson and Holmes could have just been the original characters stuck inside girl's bodies, but Dawson has taken care to make them truly feminine. I also appreciate how Holmes's skills and areas of expert knowledge are conformed to a sci-fi landscape with advanced technology and a mosaic of alien cultures and languages.
I really enjoyed exploring the setting of Linden. The concept of a vertically organized city is fascinating, especially considering the way the unusual physical nature of the setting plays into the culture and interactions between the different alien species.
A couple elements kept me from giving the story a fourth star. While I did like Sharlotte Holmes for who she was, I was a little disappointed that she wasn't closer in personality to the original character. I would have liked to see Holmes's weaknesses and annoying characteristics come out a little more strongly than they did. The second thing was that I had a bit of trouble following the mysteries. Many of the important clues are related to facets of alien culture and physiology that I wouldn't have picked up on with out the characters pointing them out. While these facts highlight the alien cultures in cool ways, I didn't find that the mystery gave me very many "aha" moments. While these things affected my personal enjoyment, they aren't necessarily bad; they just didn't line up with what I expected. It depends what you're looking for.
January 8, 2021
Sherlock Holmes in a cyberpunk setting? Sherlock and Dr. Watson as women? As much as the concept intrigued me, I'll admit there was a little doubt that it could be pulled off well.
I'm happy to say that doubt was proved wrong. Sherlock--sorry, Sharlotte--is still quirky and brilliant, and the banter between her and Jenny Watson is quite amusing. And what a sweet friendship! (Okay, I'm a sucker for that in pretty much any story.)
The main thing that bothered me was how easily each mystery wrapped up. It felt like the story passed over a lot of potential for complexity. But maybe that could be where a sequel comes in.
Which brings me to my final note... *hopeful expression*
E.B. Dawson, if you're reading this, just know that I wouldn't mind taking another trip to Linden...
I'm happy to say that doubt was proved wrong. Sherlock--sorry, Sharlotte--is still quirky and brilliant, and the banter between her and Jenny Watson is quite amusing. And what a sweet friendship! (Okay, I'm a sucker for that in pretty much any story.)
The main thing that bothered me was how easily each mystery wrapped up. It felt like the story passed over a lot of potential for complexity. But maybe that could be where a sequel comes in.
Which brings me to my final note... *hopeful expression*
E.B. Dawson, if you're reading this, just know that I wouldn't mind taking another trip to Linden...
June 5, 2020
This is one of the most beautiful books I have read.
Dawson takes a familiar story and makes it fully her own. Everything great about Sherlock Holmes is there, but also new. The fast pace, the cultural diversity, the clever and unusual detective, the war-worn but warm-hearted doctor, the mystery, the friendship: These are staples of Sherlock Holmes, but Dawson doesn't just repackage them. She transforms them into a story that touches themes relevant for the 2020s and takes you through the full range of emotions.
My favorite aspects:
- Terrence, the sentient plant. He is precious and I want one.
- Even though I'm familiar with Conan Doyle's Sherlock, I was still taken by surprise at many points.
- The friendship between Jenny and Sharlotte was incredible. I've rarely seen female friendship captured so well on the page, but this one was as real and genuine as my best friendships.
- The coziness. This book goes to some dark, scary places, but the warm, safe moments balance it well. The ending made me feel safe and comforted.
- The twist. That twist. It was SO GOOD I couldn't stop grinning.
- Crocheted friendship beanies.
- Mrs. Hudson
If you like mysteries, cyberpunk, female friendships, or just plain well-told stories, go read Watson and Holmes immediately.
Dawson takes a familiar story and makes it fully her own. Everything great about Sherlock Holmes is there, but also new. The fast pace, the cultural diversity, the clever and unusual detective, the war-worn but warm-hearted doctor, the mystery, the friendship: These are staples of Sherlock Holmes, but Dawson doesn't just repackage them. She transforms them into a story that touches themes relevant for the 2020s and takes you through the full range of emotions.
My favorite aspects:
- Terrence, the sentient plant. He is precious and I want one.
- Even though I'm familiar with Conan Doyle's Sherlock, I was still taken by surprise at many points.
- The friendship between Jenny and Sharlotte was incredible. I've rarely seen female friendship captured so well on the page, but this one was as real and genuine as my best friendships.
- The coziness. This book goes to some dark, scary places, but the warm, safe moments balance it well. The ending made me feel safe and comforted.
- The twist. That twist. It was SO GOOD I couldn't stop grinning.
- Crocheted friendship beanies.
- Mrs. Hudson
If you like mysteries, cyberpunk, female friendships, or just plain well-told stories, go read Watson and Holmes immediately.
September 3, 2021
I was honestly at a loss to review this story in my usual way, because I have been thoroughly immersed in the Sherlock Holmes universe (ie. London) for so long. While movies like the one with Robert Downey Jr. and TV series like the Cumberbatch one or The Irregulars aren't exactly my cup of tea, I did enjoy them all in their own ways, and the original books as well as the Enola Holmes stories have long been favourites of mine.
Now please don't misunderstand, I'm getting to the point here and the point isn't that Watson and Holmes is unoriginal. It's anything but. However, it is stretched very cleverly over the framework of Conan Doyle's characters, settings and mysteries, and as such most of the "review" I could give boils down (or ... Doyles down? No Edpool, don't force it) to either listing the Sherlock Holmes references (Linden is London! That Leemex character is the pygmy! Lestrade is Lestrade!) or else listing the variations (Sherlock and Watson are women! Sharlotte's violin is purple! Watson fought in a space war against shapeshifting [SPOILERS REDACTED] monsters instead of in Afghanistan which absolutely isn't timely right now anyway so move on!) and that doesn't do the story justice.
Because I really enjoyed the parallels, the divergences, and the Watson and Holmes narrative purely on its own merits. The sheer mass of human and alien cultures in Linden set the mega-city up as a character in its own right just as (see, here I go again) it is in the best Sherlock Holmes tales. The focus on Watson, who I (like many I'm sure) have always considered the more relatable and sympathetic character and therefore have always rather liked more than Holmes, was well done. I loved seeing Watson re-assume her army persona and resume the war she had previously left in turmoil and trauma. The plot twists and the action, all woven around a clever series of mysteries, were very enjoyable. The Falls, and Moriarty ... it's quite inescapable but damn it, it's well done.
If you hate Sherlock Holmes with a passion, this book isn't for you. Why would you even be looking at it? If you love Sherlock Holmes, or are otherwise kind of meh about the whole sub-genre but you like a good science fiction yarn with strong world-building, excellent characters and a rolling, highly entertaining plot, this is well worth a look. There's just not much more I can say.
So let's consult the meters, shall we?
Sex-o-meter
There's a little bit of match-making, and you can always depend on Watson to have a relationship befuddlement or two, but Watson and Holmes generally doesn't have time for that sort of bullplop. There are mysteries to solve, dastardly plots to unravel and, in short, the game being afoot to worry about. A Mrs. Hudson out of a possible Irene Adler (the saucy adaptations version of Irene Adler) for Watson and Holmes.
Gore-o-meter
Some solid battlefield, jungle and street mayhem in this story, a few grisly murders and such, as one would expect. But overall it's not such a gory outing. Two flesh-gobbets out of a possible five.
WTF-o-meter
Again, it's hard for the WTF-o-meter to quantify the raw WTFs per million in this book because of the interference we're getting from the high levels of Doylian radiation coming off the source material. *whangs the WTF-o-meter a couple of times with a violin bow* Yeah ... nah, it's just giving a consistent reading of "Basil Rathbone out of a possible Rathil Basbone" and that's - to be honest that's just not a thing.
My Final Verdict
Watson and Holmes was a very enjoyable read. What else can one say? I had a lot of fun recognising the references and geeking out over the sci-fi construct they were slathered over. Cool setting and backstory, great aliens and tech, this has everything I like in a sci-fi combined with a lot of what I like in a mystery. And Dawson's next trick was apparently doing the same for Moby Dick, so fuck it all. Four stars.
Now please don't misunderstand, I'm getting to the point here and the point isn't that Watson and Holmes is unoriginal. It's anything but. However, it is stretched very cleverly over the framework of Conan Doyle's characters, settings and mysteries, and as such most of the "review" I could give boils down (or ... Doyles down? No Edpool, don't force it) to either listing the Sherlock Holmes references (Linden is London! That Leemex character is the pygmy! Lestrade is Lestrade!) or else listing the variations (Sherlock and Watson are women! Sharlotte's violin is purple! Watson fought in a space war against shapeshifting [SPOILERS REDACTED] monsters instead of in Afghanistan which absolutely isn't timely right now anyway so move on!) and that doesn't do the story justice.
Because I really enjoyed the parallels, the divergences, and the Watson and Holmes narrative purely on its own merits. The sheer mass of human and alien cultures in Linden set the mega-city up as a character in its own right just as (see, here I go again) it is in the best Sherlock Holmes tales. The focus on Watson, who I (like many I'm sure) have always considered the more relatable and sympathetic character and therefore have always rather liked more than Holmes, was well done. I loved seeing Watson re-assume her army persona and resume the war she had previously left in turmoil and trauma. The plot twists and the action, all woven around a clever series of mysteries, were very enjoyable. The Falls, and Moriarty ... it's quite inescapable but damn it, it's well done.
If you hate Sherlock Holmes with a passion, this book isn't for you. Why would you even be looking at it? If you love Sherlock Holmes, or are otherwise kind of meh about the whole sub-genre but you like a good science fiction yarn with strong world-building, excellent characters and a rolling, highly entertaining plot, this is well worth a look. There's just not much more I can say.
So let's consult the meters, shall we?
Sex-o-meter
There's a little bit of match-making, and you can always depend on Watson to have a relationship befuddlement or two, but Watson and Holmes generally doesn't have time for that sort of bullplop. There are mysteries to solve, dastardly plots to unravel and, in short, the game being afoot to worry about. A Mrs. Hudson out of a possible Irene Adler (the saucy adaptations version of Irene Adler) for Watson and Holmes.
Gore-o-meter
Some solid battlefield, jungle and street mayhem in this story, a few grisly murders and such, as one would expect. But overall it's not such a gory outing. Two flesh-gobbets out of a possible five.
WTF-o-meter
Again, it's hard for the WTF-o-meter to quantify the raw WTFs per million in this book because of the interference we're getting from the high levels of Doylian radiation coming off the source material. *whangs the WTF-o-meter a couple of times with a violin bow* Yeah ... nah, it's just giving a consistent reading of "Basil Rathbone out of a possible Rathil Basbone" and that's - to be honest that's just not a thing.
My Final Verdict
Watson and Holmes was a very enjoyable read. What else can one say? I had a lot of fun recognising the references and geeking out over the sci-fi construct they were slathered over. Cool setting and backstory, great aliens and tech, this has everything I like in a sci-fi combined with a lot of what I like in a mystery. And Dawson's next trick was apparently doing the same for Moby Dick, so fuck it all. Four stars.
September 29, 2020
As an ardent Sherlock Holmes fan, I found this retelling to be fun, heartwarming, and nostalgic. The characters of Jenny Watson and Sharlotte Holmes are sweet and charming, their chemistry instantly reminiscent of the canon characters. I really appreciated that the characters felt like their canon counterparts as I am very picky when it comes to how these characters are interpreted. I am also very hesitant on the gender-swapping idea, as making Holmes a female usually does not lend itself well (IMLTHO), but Dawson pulls it off splendidly. Sharlotte is every bit as unusual and eccentric, and she is unabashedly so, which is the crux of the character. Yet she doesn’t come across as arrogant or overdone, like she is overcompensating, which often times is how intellectual and cerebral female characters are written. She is simply herself, who just so happens to be the greatest detective with a tactical and analytical mind!
Yet I think what impressed me the most about this rendition of the stories was the incredible world-building involved. Placing these well loved characters within a science fiction setting really opened up opportunities to create tantalizing and unique adventures for them to find themselves in, and I loved the world of Concordia and it’s giant city of Linden, that complex metropolis of a planet with a variety of cultures and alien beings. You are really immersed within this world, feeling not only that it is rich and multi-faceted, but at the same time old and worn, like you are transversing the streets of old London, feeling the weight of city life and the hustle and bustle of its people. It feels both “Victorian” and otherworldly all at once. It feels like an alien planet that is lived in, reminiscent of Star Wars in that way, and I enjoyed exploring the whole world through Jenny Watson’s eyes, and her coming to love all its eccentricities and obscurities - not unlike her roommate, the great Sharlotte Holmes. And each of the alien species that lived in Linden were very distinct and felt real, each with their own society structure and culture. I loved that Mrs. Hudson was one such species, a Ttoo, which made her character original and fun as well as endearing and sweet.
The mysteries and the overarching mystery of the enigmatic organization “Moriarty” were also well done and engaging. What I think I loved the most was how much this book delved into the Watson character as a military man/woman, and how the great war with the horrific Shifters effected her as a character. I felt the war trauma and the personal stakes involved for Jenny were very moving, and that is the part of the Watson character that really hasn’t been explored before. You truly felt the struggles and the horror of war through her eyes, and that made the threat feel tangible and serious, and not just mindless sci-fi action violence. It had a weight and ramifications for all the characters and the galaxy. And most importantly, showing how it shapes Jenny Watson, and how her friendship and life that she builds with Sharlotte is that steadying point that gives her renewal and strength.
So, if you are someone who loves the canon as much as I do, I highly recommend this collection of stories, as you’ll find new and unexpected ways to look at the characters and enjoy a meaningful and exciting science fiction adventure!
Yet I think what impressed me the most about this rendition of the stories was the incredible world-building involved. Placing these well loved characters within a science fiction setting really opened up opportunities to create tantalizing and unique adventures for them to find themselves in, and I loved the world of Concordia and it’s giant city of Linden, that complex metropolis of a planet with a variety of cultures and alien beings. You are really immersed within this world, feeling not only that it is rich and multi-faceted, but at the same time old and worn, like you are transversing the streets of old London, feeling the weight of city life and the hustle and bustle of its people. It feels both “Victorian” and otherworldly all at once. It feels like an alien planet that is lived in, reminiscent of Star Wars in that way, and I enjoyed exploring the whole world through Jenny Watson’s eyes, and her coming to love all its eccentricities and obscurities - not unlike her roommate, the great Sharlotte Holmes. And each of the alien species that lived in Linden were very distinct and felt real, each with their own society structure and culture. I loved that Mrs. Hudson was one such species, a Ttoo, which made her character original and fun as well as endearing and sweet.
The mysteries and the overarching mystery of the enigmatic organization “Moriarty” were also well done and engaging. What I think I loved the most was how much this book delved into the Watson character as a military man/woman, and how the great war with the horrific Shifters effected her as a character. I felt the war trauma and the personal stakes involved for Jenny were very moving, and that is the part of the Watson character that really hasn’t been explored before. You truly felt the struggles and the horror of war through her eyes, and that made the threat feel tangible and serious, and not just mindless sci-fi action violence. It had a weight and ramifications for all the characters and the galaxy. And most importantly, showing how it shapes Jenny Watson, and how her friendship and life that she builds with Sharlotte is that steadying point that gives her renewal and strength.
So, if you are someone who loves the canon as much as I do, I highly recommend this collection of stories, as you’ll find new and unexpected ways to look at the characters and enjoy a meaningful and exciting science fiction adventure!
April 5, 2021
As a fan of Conan Doyle, this story of Watson and Holmes intrigued me and it was great. Watson and Holmes is a science fiction setting in another place and time. The worlds are described in detail and pieces of the various beings are interwoven in the stories. As with Doyle's telling we start with short mysteries solved by Ms Holmes yet in a twist, each lends a thread to a larger conspiracy that Holmes discovers. Lastrade is still in the police force and shows up from time to time to help in the final take down.
Jenny Watson is a medic injured in the war of Shifters. She carries a scar from that war when she fought the enemy. She relocates to the planet Concordia and falls in with Sharlotte Holmes. Watson learns more of her new city as she works alongside Holmes. And there is a lot to learn. There are a multitude of species leaving on various levels of the city who engage in a variety of different work/support. With this is a variety of languages which Holmes has mastered and she has developed her own support network to help in her work. Watson learns of these different species.
Once the "grand scheme" is identified, Watson returns to the planet where the Shifter war continues and Holmes goes off planet for the first time. Watson and Holmes meet up with Major Mark Philips who becomes a great resource and support for Watson when they head off to investigate the laboratory where they suspect the Shifters were created. Holmes is lost and presumed dead when they encounter Shifters. Watson and Philips make it to the Lab and learn more of the activity going on. They also discover the villain that is Dr. Jack Bennett the charming nephew of the fortune teller who reads for Mrs. Hudson.
Watson and Philips return to Linden and track down Bennett. New twists and turns with Holmes arriving with a solution. Bennett is captured, Lastrade has everything in hand and Watson is returned to Baker Street.
E.B. Dawson is an amazing writer and the premises of Holmes and Watson in another dimension is great. The language is concise, clear, descriptive. The cases presented are simple and yet somewhat complex. I enjoyed following the format of Doyle, a series of short stories. The change to these small cases leading to a larger conspiracy and how it ties back to Watson' military history was a great change up. Dawson stays in the mode of Doyle yet makes the story her own. I look forward to reading more of her stories and hopefully more Watson and Holmes.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Jenny Watson is a medic injured in the war of Shifters. She carries a scar from that war when she fought the enemy. She relocates to the planet Concordia and falls in with Sharlotte Holmes. Watson learns more of her new city as she works alongside Holmes. And there is a lot to learn. There are a multitude of species leaving on various levels of the city who engage in a variety of different work/support. With this is a variety of languages which Holmes has mastered and she has developed her own support network to help in her work. Watson learns of these different species.
Once the "grand scheme" is identified, Watson returns to the planet where the Shifter war continues and Holmes goes off planet for the first time. Watson and Holmes meet up with Major Mark Philips who becomes a great resource and support for Watson when they head off to investigate the laboratory where they suspect the Shifters were created. Holmes is lost and presumed dead when they encounter Shifters. Watson and Philips make it to the Lab and learn more of the activity going on. They also discover the villain that is Dr. Jack Bennett the charming nephew of the fortune teller who reads for Mrs. Hudson.
Watson and Philips return to Linden and track down Bennett. New twists and turns with Holmes arriving with a solution. Bennett is captured, Lastrade has everything in hand and Watson is returned to Baker Street.
E.B. Dawson is an amazing writer and the premises of Holmes and Watson in another dimension is great. The language is concise, clear, descriptive. The cases presented are simple and yet somewhat complex. I enjoyed following the format of Doyle, a series of short stories. The change to these small cases leading to a larger conspiracy and how it ties back to Watson' military history was a great change up. Dawson stays in the mode of Doyle yet makes the story her own. I look forward to reading more of her stories and hopefully more Watson and Holmes.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
July 18, 2021
This is a very clever futuristic retelling of the classic Sherlock Holmes story and with female leads in Jenny Watson and Sharlotte Holmes. We first meet Watson and in fact she features in most of the story, hence, the switch in the title, I presume. She’s just arrived in a strange fantasy world called Linden where humans cohabit with other ‘people’ from distant planets. She’s an army medic having finished her tour and seeking a calmer, safer life in Linden.
Naturally, this isn’t likely and within moments of the start, Watson is thrown into action. A few other strange happenings occur before we meet Holmes. And what a great resemblance she is to her literary namesake. All the intelligence, arrogance, lack of empathy and absent-mindedness that we’ve come to know through all the various versions of the genius investigator.
Dawson writes a clever story with good pace and suspense that leaves us guessing. I found both Watson and Holmes to be tremendous creations and I so hope we see another story involving them.
My only reservations about this story is that Sharlotte discovers things which we the reader don’t get to see. In a visual medium like TV, these can be revealed in a playback style retelling, but it didn’t work in this written form. As a result, I felt at a disadvantage (a bit like Watson) and it took a little away from the story especially at the end.
A worthy read.
Naturally, this isn’t likely and within moments of the start, Watson is thrown into action. A few other strange happenings occur before we meet Holmes. And what a great resemblance she is to her literary namesake. All the intelligence, arrogance, lack of empathy and absent-mindedness that we’ve come to know through all the various versions of the genius investigator.
Dawson writes a clever story with good pace and suspense that leaves us guessing. I found both Watson and Holmes to be tremendous creations and I so hope we see another story involving them.
My only reservations about this story is that Sharlotte discovers things which we the reader don’t get to see. In a visual medium like TV, these can be revealed in a playback style retelling, but it didn’t work in this written form. As a result, I felt at a disadvantage (a bit like Watson) and it took a little away from the story especially at the end.
A worthy read.
December 12, 2020
I really enjoyed this sci-fi reimagining of Sherlock Holmes. There are lots of nods and Easter eggs for those familiar with the canon, but it still has a fresh feel and can be enjoyed without having read Sherlock Holmes before. The world building with the different sectors of Linden and their alien inhabitants was really cool – each group had their own distinct values and culture. The grumpy leemex in place of the Baker St irregulars was one of my favorite twists on the original. I was intrigued at the exploration of Watson’s background as a solider/medic, which is only incidental in the canon but here becomes a major focus of the story, with believable character stakes. I really enjoyed the friendship between Jenny and Sharlotte and its growth throughout the novel. The banter is so fun! The shifters are terrifying and Mrs. Hudson reimagined is just awesome, as is Terrence. I would like a Terrence please. I could carry on about more awesome aspects of this book, but you should go buy it and find out for yourself.
April 5, 2021
I probably shouldn’t have attempted to read this re-imagining of my hero. Even set in a sci-fi scenario, reading the characters’ names as Jenny Watson and Sharlotte Holmes did make me shudder. I read enough to know that the author did a good job with this. But making them female just didn’t feel comfortable to me because this duo has been in my mind for so many years now and there is no acceptable substitute, no matter what world they are placed in. Again, it was done well. It’s just my mind didn’t want it that way.
But I did see the author’s skill in world-building and descriptions that painted a realistic vision in my mind as I read. As strange as it sounds, I probably would have enjoyed the book more if the characters had totally different names so that my brain would stop comparing! Grab your copy and see what you think.
But I did see the author’s skill in world-building and descriptions that painted a realistic vision in my mind as I read. As strange as it sounds, I probably would have enjoyed the book more if the characters had totally different names so that my brain would stop comparing! Grab your copy and see what you think.
July 8, 2022
Oh My Goodness. This Book is Amazing!
If you love Sherlock Holmes, Watson and sci-fi--you have to read this book. E.B. Dawson captured the essence of Holmes and Watson perfectly and added a super fresh twist on the characters and setting.
If you love Sherlock Holmes, Watson and sci-fi--you have to read this book. E.B. Dawson captured the essence of Holmes and Watson perfectly and added a super fresh twist on the characters and setting.
April 6, 2021
Great read had all the Sherlock Holmes elements
August 15, 2022
I'm not sure how I feel about this book. There's plenty about it to like, but there also was some stuff I wasn't too thrilled about. But first, the positives. I loved the entire set-up, both the gender-bending of our two leads and the whole cyberpunk in space atmosphere. Sharlotte and Jenny were intriguing, well-developed characters, and I could read an entire book of nothing but their dialogue with each other, it's that engaging. I know the author was setting out to portray a strong female relationship, and she definitely did a great job with that. All the cool space stuff is fun too, like the different alien races and technology.
However, there were things I didn't like. With regards to the genre, the book is not really a mystery. The revelations aren't foreshadowed enough so that the reader can try to figure out what was going on for themselves. Instead, the stories read more like thrillers with surprise villains (and very random surprise villains, at that). It's not necessarily a bad thing, but I found it somewhat disappointing that the whole mystery portion was lacking. Also, I was reading the paperback version, which had some formatting errors like missing paragraph indents and awkward spacing. I'm sure other people wouldn't be bothered by this, but it took me out of the story every time I came across one. Basically, I think Watson and Holmes has a brilliant set-up and characters, but could have used a more polished execution. But, if a sequel ever came out, I'd definitely read it. I'm still pretty interested in what happens to Sharlotte and Jenny, as well as the rest of their world.
However, there were things I didn't like. With regards to the genre, the book is not really a mystery. The revelations aren't foreshadowed enough so that the reader can try to figure out what was going on for themselves. Instead, the stories read more like thrillers with surprise villains (and very random surprise villains, at that). It's not necessarily a bad thing, but I found it somewhat disappointing that the whole mystery portion was lacking. Also, I was reading the paperback version, which had some formatting errors like missing paragraph indents and awkward spacing. I'm sure other people wouldn't be bothered by this, but it took me out of the story every time I came across one. Basically, I think Watson and Holmes has a brilliant set-up and characters, but could have used a more polished execution. But, if a sequel ever came out, I'd definitely read it. I'm still pretty interested in what happens to Sharlotte and Jenny, as well as the rest of their world.
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews