The beginning story in Surviving Hiroshima is fascinating. The Palchikoff’s are an aristocratic family that are living a happy life in Czarist Russia. In the mid to late 1800s is considered the Golden Age of Arts in Russia. It’s the age of Anton Chekov, Leo Tolstoy, Fyodor Dostoyevsky, and Tchaikovsky.
WW1 happens which causes death, food shortages, and economic misery. The popularity of the Czar goes to unpopular to full out revolution. Lenin and the Bolsheviks rise. Soldiers begin to mutiny. The Czar and his family are executed. The aristocrats and the white army are running for their lives. Sergei Palchikoff and some of his comrades surrender to Japanese officials and seek asylum in Japan and they become refugees and try to make a go of it in Japan, landing in Hiroshima in 1923.
To me this is a fascinating beginning. Talk about surviving bad luck. This family survived two of the most historic events in the first half of the 20th century. But after this engaging beginning, the book really fell short. I thought the cover of the book is very deceptive with the title “Surviving Hiroshima”. We see a white woman sitting in a kimono. This is Kaleria Palchikoff, who this book is mostly based on, co-written by her son, Anthony Drago. The reason I found it deceptive is that I thought a lot of this book would be about a white family, particularly Kaleria adapting to Japanese culture. We learn that she can speak, Russian, English, and Japanese but not much else. The Father ends up teaching music, the mother has some illnesses and is able to have three kids, but no details are given on how they adapted from Russian to Japanese culture. I did not even know there were white people in Hiroshima.
There is very little detail about the family’s life in Japan before and after the atomic bomb. Did they make many friends? Did the father understand why the Bolsheviks came to power and hated the Czar? How did they feel about Stalin, Hitler, and the Japanese Emperor? How were they perceived by Japanese people? They had a son, Nikolai that left Japan and went to UCLA and ended up fighting for America against Japan. I’m not even sure who were they rooting for in the war. After witnessing, seeing the horror, and surviving the atomic bomb, how did they feel about America using such a weapon? Any survivors guilt? Did anyone have any PTSD?
When it came to going over the major events, much of the book read like a newspaper article. This was not a very psychological book. Being that the son, is a co-author, I can understand writing favorably of his family, but I never felt like I knew anybody in the Palchikoff family, especially Kaleria. I would not recommend this book to anyone researching Hiroshima, or what is it like to be a white person in Japan. It is still amazing that the family survived and overcame such horrific events.