A 3.5 star read for me!
I will be the first to admit that this book had an abundance of lessons hidden within its pages. The facets of hope for a better future, the idea that love can conquer loneliness, and the importance of having someone, anyone to turn to in times of need were readily apparent. With this said, this book was somewhat...well...boring. I found this book to be one of those reads that while a quick look into the fabric of mankind in itself is not overwhelmingly memorable. I did enjoy this book, but I will admit that I didn't love it.
Andrew is a man who finds himself between a rock and a hard place when a misunderstanding makes his single life, filled with previous tragedy of a lost love, a thing only he knows. Everyone at his job thinks he is happily married with a wife and two kids, living the proverbial "perfect" life with family fights, family memories, and love shared in abundance. What they don't realize is that Andrew is and has been perpetually single for over 20 years. He has no wife, no kids, and in fact no friends except his friends in his model train discussion group. He is seemingly alone which is why loneliness is painted as an instrumental theme within this novel. He, of course, falls in love with the new woman at his work who thinks he is married as well.
Peggy was, to me, definitely the best part of this novel. A strong woman with even stronger convictions, Peggy knows what she wants and goes after it. She isn't afraid to get her hands dirty or show vulnerability which made me love her. She is the comedic relief within this novel, a necessary aspect when dealing with the heavy themes of depression, loneliness, lost love, and death. Andrew's job itself revolves around death and dying, so the use of Peggy acts a foil for the dreary mood of these parts of the book. I believe the author did a fantastic job in incorporating her into the novel. With this said, I felt that I couldn't root for Peggy and Andrew to get together completely because she was indeed still married to her (absolutely awful, alcoholic, mean-hearted) husband. I feel as though her character was not the type to cheat, so I could not root for them completely. Did I want them together in theory? Heck yes. Did I expect them to get together? Honestly no. I guess what I can say is that incorporating a character such as Peggy, while ticking off the box for a romantic interest, doesn't really resolve these ideas of loneliness that the author perpetrated in the description of his novel. I, however, loved Peggy's character for who she was as a person even if I couldn't root for her and Andrew completely. I can only hope that after the divorce they find a way to be together. I feel as though both Andrew and Peggy deserve the happiness they could bring each other, so I feel better saying that the future is a definitive possibility for them.
While this book does deal with the sad aspects of death, suicide, loneliness, and lost love, it also has a semblance of hope as well. There are many individuals on this planet who do die alone or who die without being with the person they thought they would spend the rest of their life with. This is a sad yet true statement within the world we live in. What this story portrayed was that even if life isn't necessarily a smooth, straight path, sometimes there are ways to find hope in the darkest moments. The back of this book says "Sometimes you need to risk everything...to find your something." I feel as though this was put to draw a correlation with the romantic facets of the story, but I think this story is much deeper than that. I think an individual's "something" can be their job that they love and the way it affects others. I think a "something" could be the most best-est chocolate chip cookies in the whole wide-er-est world that help bring others together. I think someone's "something" could be having the strength, the determination, the independence to live peacefully on one's own with friends but not necessarily lovers. I think the author could have shown this more clearly because every time I thought Andrew was going to create himself into an independent, strong-willed man, he seemed to rely on love whether it be Peggy's or Diane's love. I think love is important (I'm a hopeless romantic, so I always will!!!), but I also think loneliness, pain, and emotion are sometimes things that can only be dealt with personally. These emotions are not felt by a LACK of someone but are felt because an individual chooses to focus on this lack.
I know it seems that I am dissecting this book to the extreme, but I will say that I did enjoy the ending of this book. The idea of Andrew choosing to find a new place to live, start working at the charity Peggy thought of, and basically restart his life in an effort to grow as a human is something I believe people often have to do. It shows he was human in that he was willing to try again. I thought the charity idea was beautifully done as well, so that part just made me happy, to be honest. I think it showed the empathy, emotional maturity, and love that Andrew was developing for others but most importantly for himself. It was towards the end that I saw development in Andrew. While there were glimpses of it throughout the novel, it was only at the end that I was fully convinced he would change for the better.
Overall, I think this was an okay book. While I did enjoy parts of it (Peggy and Beryl were fantastic characters, and I did want Andrew to be happy in the end.), I also felt like the majority of the novel I was just reading rather absently. I hate to say that I was somewhat bored, but I felt that perhaps I was at times. With this said, for this to be Richard Roper's debut, I think he created a story worthy of being told. Maybe I just wasn't quite the right reader for it to be a 5 star read. As a book that deals with loneliness, love, and hope, I believe it can be a good read. I just don't think it is the best, and that's okay.