What do you think?
Rate this book
Dauntless Path #2
The Theft of Sunlight
I did not choose this fate. But I will not walk away from it.
Children have been disappearing from across Menaiya for longer than Amraeya ni Ansarim can remember. When her friend’s sister is snatched, Rae knows she can’t look away any longer—even if that means seeking answers from the royal court, where her country upbringing and clubfoot will only invite ridicule.
Yet the court holds its share of surprises. There she discovers an ally in the foreign princess, who recruits her as an attendant. Armed with the princess’s support, Rae seeks answers in the dark city streets, finding unexpected help in a rough-around-the-edges street thief with secrets of his own.
But treachery runs deep, and the more Rae uncovers, the more she endangers the kingdom itself.
Children have been disappearing from across Menaiya for longer than Amraeya ni Ansarim can remember. When her friend’s sister is snatched, Rae knows she can’t look away any longer—even if that means seeking answers from the royal court, where her country upbringing and clubfoot will only invite ridicule.
Yet the court holds its share of surprises. There she discovers an ally in the foreign princess, who recruits her as an attendant. Armed with the princess’s support, Rae seeks answers in the dark city streets, finding unexpected help in a rough-around-the-edges street thief with secrets of his own.
But treachery runs deep, and the more Rae uncovers, the more she endangers the kingdom itself.
526 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 23, 2021
152 people are currently reading
10968 people want to read
About the author
Intisar Khanani
18 books2,500 followersIntisar Khanani grew up a nomad and world traveler. Born in Wisconsin, she has lived in five different states as well as in Jeddah on the coast of the Red Sea. She currently resides in Cincinnati, Ohio, with her husband and two young daughters. Prior to publishing her novels, Intisar worked as a public health consultant on projects relating to infant mortality and minority health, which was as close as she could get to saving the world. Now she focuses her time on her two passions: raising her family and writing fantasy.
Intisar is the author of the Dauntless Path books (beginning with Thorn) and The Sunbolt Chronicles.
To find out about new releases, giveaways, and so forth, subscribe to Intisar's monthly author newsletter.
GOODREADS FRIEND POLICY: I'm afraid I don't accept every single friend request I receive, unless we already know each other IRL, or it looks like we have tastes broadly in common. However, please feel free to follow and interact.
Intisar is the author of the Dauntless Path books (beginning with Thorn) and The Sunbolt Chronicles.
To find out about new releases, giveaways, and so forth, subscribe to Intisar's monthly author newsletter.
GOODREADS FRIEND POLICY: I'm afraid I don't accept every single friend request I receive, unless we already know each other IRL, or it looks like we have tastes broadly in common. However, please feel free to follow and interact.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 736 reviews
Read
June 27, 2021Hello friends! I am so excited to share Rae's story with you. This is a story that I've been trying to write for about ten years--as some of you who have been waiting since The Bone Knife was first indie published might be well aware of! It's been a long time coming, and I hope you'll find it well worth the wait.
Just a couple three notes to clear up any confusion that might be out there, as this story has changed shape quite a bit since it was first announced:
1. Theft is the first part in a companion duology to Thorn. While it can absolutely be read on its own, it will be best appreciated if you pick up Thorn first. There are many familiar characters and a few possible spoilers for Thorn... but, if you'd rather not, you can still very much enjoy this book on its own. Just be aware that Rae's story will only be half-told by the end of Theft.
2. This story includes some similar themes to Thorn; there are scenes of and discussion of violence against women, human trafficking, and physical and emotional abuse, as well as issues of (in/)justice raised. I do my best to treat this issues with respect. However, if you find these triggering, please proceed with caution.
3. This story also includes: an extremely pragmatic heroine, a clever street thief with secrets, at least two thief lords, a handful of remorseless slavers, and a princess with a core of steel - as well as magic, betrayal, and an ending that has had me publicly outed as "evil." If you are not a fan of cliffhangers, please be advised that this story has a pretty good one--though it isn't gratuitous. I spent more than a little while trying to find the ideal ending, so there's that. If you'd like to read both books back to back, you might still want to buy this one now, as publication of follow-up books are dependent on sales of the first (augh!).
Happy reading!
Just a couple three notes to clear up any confusion that might be out there, as this story has changed shape quite a bit since it was first announced:
1. Theft is the first part in a companion duology to Thorn. While it can absolutely be read on its own, it will be best appreciated if you pick up Thorn first. There are many familiar characters and a few possible spoilers for Thorn... but, if you'd rather not, you can still very much enjoy this book on its own. Just be aware that Rae's story will only be half-told by the end of Theft.
2. This story includes some similar themes to Thorn; there are scenes of and discussion of violence against women, human trafficking, and physical and emotional abuse, as well as issues of (in/)justice raised. I do my best to treat this issues with respect. However, if you find these triggering, please proceed with caution.
3. This story also includes: an extremely pragmatic heroine, a clever street thief with secrets, at least two thief lords, a handful of remorseless slavers, and a princess with a core of steel - as well as magic, betrayal, and an ending that has had me publicly outed as "evil." If you are not a fan of cliffhangers, please be advised that this story has a pretty good one--though it isn't gratuitous. I spent more than a little while trying to find the ideal ending, so there's that. If you'd like to read both books back to back, you might still want to buy this one now, as publication of follow-up books are dependent on sales of the first (augh!).
Happy reading!
November 17, 2025
The royal wedding is just around the corner. It's the talk of the town for all the nobles in the land but for Rae's family, it couldn't be further from their minds.
Another child has been snatched.
While child-snatching was a threat that Rae knew of before...it has never felt so real to her. Rae's best friend's sister was taken and what paltry magic they have is no match to find the missing girl.
The city guards are no help, the nobles believe that the peasants are "sadly mistaken" over the lost children and Rae cannot convince anyone otherwise. Devastated, Rae doesn't know what to do...until her cousin offers her a position in the castle.
Princess Alyrra is in need of trusted attendants and Rae's lack of connections with other royalty is what makes her perfect.
Princess Alyrra wants Rae to investigate the disappearances but quickly this mystery is becoming larger than Rae could ever imagine.
This is Intisar's second book in the Dauntless Path series however, it can (and works well) as a standalone.
And I think this one was actually better than the first (and I adored the first).
The characters feel stronger and the plot is more focused. I liked the spunk from Alyrra and Rae, and thought they were balanced well by their counterparts.
I liked how Rae worked through her disability (and not against it) and that while she was sometimes limited in what she could do, she always found ways around it.
She learned to fight because she could not run and how to use politics to her advantage when she could not fight. It really strengthened her character and endeared me to this book all the more.
All in all - this one was FABULOUS!!
I received a free copy in exchange for a honest review!
YouTube | Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Facebook | Snapchat @miranda_reads
February 14, 2021
THE THEFT OF SUNLIGHT is a vivid masterpiece. The depth of story kept me spellbound and wondering again and again how the characters could possibly escape the twists and traps before them. An epic adventure with some chilling parallels to the unseen battles fought in our present day. With a striking heroine who has a fierce passion for justice, nothing short of a dark magic ward will keep her quest from making a home in reader’s hearts.
Read
February 6, 2022“Who else have I thought less of, because of their beauty rather than their character?”
So What’s It About?
Children have been disappearing from across Menaiya for longer than Amraeya ni Ansarim can remember. When her friend’s sister is snatched, Rae knows she can’t look away any longer - even if that means seeking answers from the royal court, where her country upbringing and clubfoot will only invite ridicule.
Yet the court holds its share of surprises. There she discovers an ally in the foreign princess, who recruits her as an attendant. Armed with the princess’s support, Rae seeks answers in the dark city streets, finding unexpected help in a rough-around-the-edges street thief with secrets of his own. But treachery runs deep, and the more Rae uncovers, the more she endangers the kingdom itself.
What I Thought
The Theft of Sunlight is the start of a series branching off from Thorn, which I re-read a couple of years ago when it was published traditionally. Thorn was, admittedly, a book that was pretty much guaranteed to be a favorite of mine. I just have a Thing for fairy tale retellings/books with fairy tale vibes that are about growth and recovery and love after trauma, okay? The Theft of Sunlight tackles different issues that are equally weighty, and it does so with the same warmth and grace as Thorn while similarly managing to be what I guess I’d simply call a genuinely enjoyable reading experience.
One of the central themes of the book is the complicated relationship that the protagonist Rae has with her body due to her disability. Not only are the practical realities of navigating the world with a physical disability depicted; Khanani also does a great job reflecting on Rae’s internal experience. We see the shame and self-hatred she experiences but also her attempts to change how she feels about herself and how she loses steam on that initial resolution. This really rang true to me as someone who is constantly deciding to finally start dealing with my Issues and then balking on the follow-through.
There are a couple of really good scenes that show Rae’s complexity regarding how she perceives others perceiving her (if that makes sense). She is primed for judgement and discrimination and at one point she misinterprets her friend Bren’s actions and lashes out at him when she assumes that he is underestimating her; she also comes to the realization that she herself tends to judge and dismiss others based on their physical appearances and abilities because she is so used to that being the main metric of her own worth (from the outside world and internally as well). Some readers might want to be warned that Rae uses disparaging/ableist language about herself - “cripple” and “hobble” come up sometimes, for instance - but the journey is very much towards her coming to terms with herself as she is, and her realization of her own worth at the very end of the book is very powerful.
Rae has a great relationship with a street thief named Bren, a friendship that teeters on the verge of romance. There are some really cute touches such as his habit of stealing things from her and giving them back, and their dynamic is very endearing overall. One of the book’s most interesting choices is to depict the scene where Rae lashes out at him and hits him. This is something I’ve seen happen in other YA fantasies, and in those books it is often depicted uncritically as a Grrl Power moment that shows how tough and cool and really super feminist the main girl is. In this case, Rae is horrified by her actions and grapples with the consequences of hurting someone she cares about in a moment of her own ugly vulnerability. She has to struggle to redefine herself as a person after doing something she didn’t think herself capable of. Along with it comes the acknowledgement that women can abuse men, and there's a really interesting discussion of abuse between Rae and Bren that reminds me a lot of what psychology researchers define as the difference between situational couple violence and intimate terrorism - random violence in a moment of anger vs an ongoing pattern meant to systematically deprive the other person of their power - and the gendered dynamics that accompany these types of abuse and their repercussions for the victims. I certainly didn’t expect to see this explored when I started this book, and it ended up being one of my favorite parts of the whole thing.
One of the main themes that carries through from Thorn is a preoccupation with the question of justice and how to change the world for the better. Rae goes back and forth between the privileged world of the royals who have the power to make sweeping changes to policies and laws but may be uncaring or out of touch due do their remoteness from the issues at hand and the world of the overlooked and disempowered, people like Bren who can only resort to desperate direct action to see changes in their world. I like that Rae is just as preoccupied with these questions as Alyrra was in Thorn, and while they are very different people in many regards they both have strong compunctions and morals.
I really enjoyed seeing more of Alyrra’s story as she settles into her new role in royalty. We see her continue to struggle with her family’s abuse, and she shows the same quiet dignity and determination in facing them as ever. I’m also preeeeeetty sure that Valya isn’t dead after all, if I read the book correctly??? Her brutal execution was one of my criticisms of Thorn after all of its meditations on justice and violence, so I’m interested to see how that plays out. From the acknowledgements it also seems that Khanani was nervous about leaving the book on such a giant cliffhanger, but as far as I’m concerned it definitely works. I’ll be happy to see Rae again in the next book!
So What’s It About?
Children have been disappearing from across Menaiya for longer than Amraeya ni Ansarim can remember. When her friend’s sister is snatched, Rae knows she can’t look away any longer - even if that means seeking answers from the royal court, where her country upbringing and clubfoot will only invite ridicule.
Yet the court holds its share of surprises. There she discovers an ally in the foreign princess, who recruits her as an attendant. Armed with the princess’s support, Rae seeks answers in the dark city streets, finding unexpected help in a rough-around-the-edges street thief with secrets of his own. But treachery runs deep, and the more Rae uncovers, the more she endangers the kingdom itself.
What I Thought
The Theft of Sunlight is the start of a series branching off from Thorn, which I re-read a couple of years ago when it was published traditionally. Thorn was, admittedly, a book that was pretty much guaranteed to be a favorite of mine. I just have a Thing for fairy tale retellings/books with fairy tale vibes that are about growth and recovery and love after trauma, okay? The Theft of Sunlight tackles different issues that are equally weighty, and it does so with the same warmth and grace as Thorn while similarly managing to be what I guess I’d simply call a genuinely enjoyable reading experience.
One of the central themes of the book is the complicated relationship that the protagonist Rae has with her body due to her disability. Not only are the practical realities of navigating the world with a physical disability depicted; Khanani also does a great job reflecting on Rae’s internal experience. We see the shame and self-hatred she experiences but also her attempts to change how she feels about herself and how she loses steam on that initial resolution. This really rang true to me as someone who is constantly deciding to finally start dealing with my Issues and then balking on the follow-through.
There are a couple of really good scenes that show Rae’s complexity regarding how she perceives others perceiving her (if that makes sense). She is primed for judgement and discrimination and at one point she misinterprets her friend Bren’s actions and lashes out at him when she assumes that he is underestimating her; she also comes to the realization that she herself tends to judge and dismiss others based on their physical appearances and abilities because she is so used to that being the main metric of her own worth (from the outside world and internally as well). Some readers might want to be warned that Rae uses disparaging/ableist language about herself - “cripple” and “hobble” come up sometimes, for instance - but the journey is very much towards her coming to terms with herself as she is, and her realization of her own worth at the very end of the book is very powerful.
Rae has a great relationship with a street thief named Bren, a friendship that teeters on the verge of romance. There are some really cute touches such as his habit of stealing things from her and giving them back, and their dynamic is very endearing overall. One of the book’s most interesting choices is to depict the scene where Rae lashes out at him and hits him. This is something I’ve seen happen in other YA fantasies, and in those books it is often depicted uncritically as a Grrl Power moment that shows how tough and cool and really super feminist the main girl is. In this case, Rae is horrified by her actions and grapples with the consequences of hurting someone she cares about in a moment of her own ugly vulnerability. She has to struggle to redefine herself as a person after doing something she didn’t think herself capable of. Along with it comes the acknowledgement that women can abuse men, and there's a really interesting discussion of abuse between Rae and Bren that reminds me a lot of what psychology researchers define as the difference between situational couple violence and intimate terrorism - random violence in a moment of anger vs an ongoing pattern meant to systematically deprive the other person of their power - and the gendered dynamics that accompany these types of abuse and their repercussions for the victims. I certainly didn’t expect to see this explored when I started this book, and it ended up being one of my favorite parts of the whole thing.
One of the main themes that carries through from Thorn is a preoccupation with the question of justice and how to change the world for the better. Rae goes back and forth between the privileged world of the royals who have the power to make sweeping changes to policies and laws but may be uncaring or out of touch due do their remoteness from the issues at hand and the world of the overlooked and disempowered, people like Bren who can only resort to desperate direct action to see changes in their world. I like that Rae is just as preoccupied with these questions as Alyrra was in Thorn, and while they are very different people in many regards they both have strong compunctions and morals.
I really enjoyed seeing more of Alyrra’s story as she settles into her new role in royalty. We see her continue to struggle with her family’s abuse, and she shows the same quiet dignity and determination in facing them as ever. I’m also preeeeeetty sure that Valya isn’t dead after all, if I read the book correctly??? Her brutal execution was one of my criticisms of Thorn after all of its meditations on justice and violence, so I’m interested to see how that plays out. From the acknowledgements it also seems that Khanani was nervous about leaving the book on such a giant cliffhanger, but as far as I’m concerned it definitely works. I’ll be happy to see Rae again in the next book!
March 2, 2022
This review and others @Bookerification
Rating: 3 stars
Cover: 🌟🌟🌟🌟
A lovely design with firm ties to the previous one in this series. Whilst it does not give away much about the story, the character illustration taking up most of the cover cleverly hints at the character-driven storyline.
Writing: 🌟🌟🌟.5
Intisar Khanani's writing is vivid and easy to follow, but it lacks the enchanting and tranquil quality I loved in the preceding book. Then again, I understand that it is hard to tackle a topic as serious as human trafficking in an enchanting manner.
"People do not destroy others for no reason at all"
Storyline: 🌟🌟🌟
In the style of most fantasy books, the storyline begins with an introduction to the world, quest and main characters. The problem is that a long time is spent establishing this foundation, and I could not help but lose interest in the slow start.
Even as things seemed to pick up with the presence of crime lords and court intrigue, the storyline suffered from a lack of urgency and tension. This was not helped by how difficult the overarching quest seemed. With only a few initial leads and the main character doing very little to advance the quest herself, I fell further into a state of boredom and indifference. Even the final twists and reveals lacked impact as I simply wanted to finish the book.
Main character: 🌟🌟🌟.5
Rae is a character that is painfully realistic and complex. She is bold, clever, and a force to be reckoned with. Yet, her country upbringing and clubfoot spark a lot of bitterness and insecurities as she transitions to the royal court. I loved that Intisar did not shy away from depicting Rae's disability and thought that she explored this well. My only issue with Rae's character is that she slaps another character in response to what he says. I am a firm believer in using words to fight words and not physical violence. Fortunately, Intisar went on to explore this act in a manner I liked for the most part.
Secondary characters: 🌟🌟🌟
All the secondary characters in this story fade to the background in light of the strong focus on Rae and her journey. None made a lasting impression on me, and I struggled to remember most of them. I did, however, enjoy having some of the characters from the previous book in this story, although I felt that their subplots are partly responsible for the slow pace of the storyline.
Romance: 🌟🌟🌟
The subtle romance that runs beneath the surface of the story develops slowly and realistically. These initial sparks were easy to spot but tragically fizzled out to leave glowing embers.
"Life is always better after you’ve eaten a biscuit."
In the end, the slow-paced storyline of 'The theft of Sunlight' failed to keep me invested and engaged. While I liked the writing and the characters, these were still painfully average as nothing really stood out to me.
Rating: 3 stars
Cover: 🌟🌟🌟🌟
A lovely design with firm ties to the previous one in this series. Whilst it does not give away much about the story, the character illustration taking up most of the cover cleverly hints at the character-driven storyline.
Writing: 🌟🌟🌟.5
Intisar Khanani's writing is vivid and easy to follow, but it lacks the enchanting and tranquil quality I loved in the preceding book. Then again, I understand that it is hard to tackle a topic as serious as human trafficking in an enchanting manner.
"People do not destroy others for no reason at all"
Storyline: 🌟🌟🌟
In the style of most fantasy books, the storyline begins with an introduction to the world, quest and main characters. The problem is that a long time is spent establishing this foundation, and I could not help but lose interest in the slow start.
Even as things seemed to pick up with the presence of crime lords and court intrigue, the storyline suffered from a lack of urgency and tension. This was not helped by how difficult the overarching quest seemed. With only a few initial leads and the main character doing very little to advance the quest herself, I fell further into a state of boredom and indifference. Even the final twists and reveals lacked impact as I simply wanted to finish the book.
Main character: 🌟🌟🌟.5
Rae is a character that is painfully realistic and complex. She is bold, clever, and a force to be reckoned with. Yet, her country upbringing and clubfoot spark a lot of bitterness and insecurities as she transitions to the royal court. I loved that Intisar did not shy away from depicting Rae's disability and thought that she explored this well. My only issue with Rae's character is that she slaps another character in response to what he says. I am a firm believer in using words to fight words and not physical violence. Fortunately, Intisar went on to explore this act in a manner I liked for the most part.
Secondary characters: 🌟🌟🌟
All the secondary characters in this story fade to the background in light of the strong focus on Rae and her journey. None made a lasting impression on me, and I struggled to remember most of them. I did, however, enjoy having some of the characters from the previous book in this story, although I felt that their subplots are partly responsible for the slow pace of the storyline.
Romance: 🌟🌟🌟
The subtle romance that runs beneath the surface of the story develops slowly and realistically. These initial sparks were easy to spot but tragically fizzled out to leave glowing embers.
"Life is always better after you’ve eaten a biscuit."
In the end, the slow-paced storyline of 'The theft of Sunlight' failed to keep me invested and engaged. While I liked the writing and the characters, these were still painfully average as nothing really stood out to me.
July 21, 2023
Re-read preparatory to catching up on book 3. So so good; loved it just as much the second time around.
--
OH YES GUESS WHO GOT AN ARC OF THIS BEAUTEH
I love Intisar Khanani's books. This woman just keeps serving good stories full of adventure, fabulous characters and important themes. They aren't tropey, you couldn't summarise them with a bunch of ao3 tags; they are uniquely themselves and deeply satisfying.
THEFT OF SUNLIGHT is the first in a companion duology to THORN (and, fair warning, it comes with a wicked cliffhanger). You really ought to read THORN first (it's a wonderful retelling of The Goose Girl!) for all the background to this one, but I suspect I might like this one even more. In summary, this is the tale of Rae, a girl from a horse farm who finds herself unexpectedly navigating the deadly intrigues and secrets of a dangerous court by day, while trying to unravel the mysteries of a human trafficking ring preying on poor children in the slums with the help of a dashing thief by night.
Heck, yes. And it IS all really just as good as I made it sound.
Some other things I loved:
- Rae, our heroine, has a disability that deeply impacts how she views herself and the world around her. I'm not disabled myself so I'm not exactly the best judge, but I always try to listen to disabled friends and...I think they're going to love this book and this particular aspect just as much as I did.
- Ack, I love Intisar's romances. They're so subtle and understated and absolutely believable - in fact more often they're respect stories than love stories. I LOVE that about them, but the other thing I love is the Very Good chemistry she writes, and how compelling it is without being in the least overtly sexy.
- The themes! The book didn't feel dark - to me - but it is about human trafficking, and it does deal with that issue with the appropriate gravity, just as THORN also had a character who suffered a tragically dark fate. When I personally shy away from writing super dark or heavy content, it's usually because I feel it's hard to write about such things without being sensational or exploitative, and I feel that people who suffer terrible exploitation ought to have their dignity protected, even in fiction. Intisar is one of the few authors I know of who writes about such things without sugar-coating the effects, but also without sensationalising them, and I really loved that about this book.
THE THEFT OF SUNLIGHT is a wonderful, complex, thoughtful fantasy, one of the rare books that I would wholeheartedly recommend to both adults and teens.
--
OH YES GUESS WHO GOT AN ARC OF THIS BEAUTEH
I love Intisar Khanani's books. This woman just keeps serving good stories full of adventure, fabulous characters and important themes. They aren't tropey, you couldn't summarise them with a bunch of ao3 tags; they are uniquely themselves and deeply satisfying.
THEFT OF SUNLIGHT is the first in a companion duology to THORN (and, fair warning, it comes with a wicked cliffhanger). You really ought to read THORN first (it's a wonderful retelling of The Goose Girl!) for all the background to this one, but I suspect I might like this one even more. In summary, this is the tale of Rae, a girl from a horse farm who finds herself unexpectedly navigating the deadly intrigues and secrets of a dangerous court by day, while trying to unravel the mysteries of a human trafficking ring preying on poor children in the slums with the help of a dashing thief by night.
Heck, yes. And it IS all really just as good as I made it sound.
Some other things I loved:
- Rae, our heroine, has a disability that deeply impacts how she views herself and the world around her. I'm not disabled myself so I'm not exactly the best judge, but I always try to listen to disabled friends and...I think they're going to love this book and this particular aspect just as much as I did.
- Ack, I love Intisar's romances. They're so subtle and understated and absolutely believable - in fact more often they're respect stories than love stories. I LOVE that about them, but the other thing I love is the Very Good chemistry she writes, and how compelling it is without being in the least overtly sexy.
- The themes! The book didn't feel dark - to me - but it is about human trafficking, and it does deal with that issue with the appropriate gravity, just as THORN also had a character who suffered a tragically dark fate. When I personally shy away from writing super dark or heavy content, it's usually because I feel it's hard to write about such things without being sensational or exploitative, and I feel that people who suffer terrible exploitation ought to have their dignity protected, even in fiction. Intisar is one of the few authors I know of who writes about such things without sugar-coating the effects, but also without sensationalising them, and I really loved that about this book.
THE THEFT OF SUNLIGHT is a wonderful, complex, thoughtful fantasy, one of the rare books that I would wholeheartedly recommend to both adults and teens.
June 13, 2021
4.5 stars! rae's story was a thrilling yet suspenseful adventure that was hard to put down, a delightful sequel that led me down certain alleyways, directed by the city's perceptive children to go meet a certain "friend of a friend" again. it was refreshing and exhilarating to read rae's journey and yet so warm and comforting to see familiar faces from thorn. check out my book blog!
the previous book was alyrra's story, and it was so nice to see one of my top comfort characters of all time again! i've missed her gracious, kind ass :') and seeing her relationship with kestrin develop? [inhumane screeching] miss khanani really fed me well.
at the end of thorn, there was a short story that introduced rae's character — and was it any surprise that i fell in love with her immediately? rae is headstrong and practical, used to the world's hardships, but she never let that jade her compassionate and fierce heart.
amraeya ni ansarim, our practical and brilliant protagonist, is best summed up by the book's dedication:
she fulfills one of my most favorite caricatures of characters: hardened and prickly on the outside, but only because of their soft, burning heart on the inside. she's a noble character — not the type of hero you typically see in stories (and she knows that) but the type of hero who doesn't need nor want that recognition. she's humble, thoughtful, and holds justice in one hand and determination in the other. seeing her unravel the source of the human trafficking problem that plagues her monarchy kept me on the edge of my seat, but it was a marvel to see the character development she goes through, to see the confidence that laces her veins as the story progresses. i'm so incredibly proud of rae and every single time a person comes for her and mocks her disability, it's off with their heads. nobody is safe — mock rae? instant kill.
the plot was intricately written, though the pacing felt a bit too slow for my taste (but that's just my personal opinion! take it with a grain of salt because i'm a typically impatient person). but overall, the worldbuilding and the buildup of plot twists was incredibly well-done. i'm vastly impressed. intisar khanani worked for almost 10 years on this book and it really shows. and that ending? BRUTAL. i'm left hanging and anxious for rae; next book when?
overall, this story was thrilling and i've never gotten bored of it. it was wild, dark, and there were times when i was certain our characters wouldn't make out of certain situations without a few broken bones. yet it was celebratory and romantic! the royal wedding? [chef's kiss] one of the top scenes, hands down. every time i've reread the chapters, i would giggle and grin; too precious, too precious my alyrra and kestrin babies. and let's not forget to mention a romantic rooftop picnic with a certain thief lord. i don't remember much from that scene but screaming my lungs out from excitement is one of them. i'm never poisoned from instalove by this author and for that, i'm immensely grateful.
this was one of my most anticipated books of the year, and i am so grateful it didn't disappoint. much thanks to intisar khanani for introducing rae's strong heart and letting readers be by her side throughout her adrenaline-rush, dread-filled yet hopeful story. there's always something about this author's writing that has that old fairytale-like charm yet has a touch of spice to it that keeps me hooked in. and will probably keep me hooked in when the next book comes out! until then, i highly recommend this book and the previous book to anybody who will listen. you won't regret letting this book into your minds and hearts. happy reading!
the previous book was alyrra's story, and it was so nice to see one of my top comfort characters of all time again! i've missed her gracious, kind ass :') and seeing her relationship with kestrin develop? [inhumane screeching] miss khanani really fed me well.
Kestrin greets Alyrra with unaffected pleasure, his features mobile with emotion, utterly unlike the detached, shrewd young man I met only yesterday. She smiles in response, her whole face warming.
at the end of thorn, there was a short story that introduced rae's character — and was it any surprise that i fell in love with her immediately? rae is headstrong and practical, used to the world's hardships, but she never let that jade her compassionate and fierce heart.
amraeya ni ansarim, our practical and brilliant protagonist, is best summed up by the book's dedication:
for every girl who chooses the hard road
and uses the fire in her heart to light the way.
she fulfills one of my most favorite caricatures of characters: hardened and prickly on the outside, but only because of their soft, burning heart on the inside. she's a noble character — not the type of hero you typically see in stories (and she knows that) but the type of hero who doesn't need nor want that recognition. she's humble, thoughtful, and holds justice in one hand and determination in the other. seeing her unravel the source of the human trafficking problem that plagues her monarchy kept me on the edge of my seat, but it was a marvel to see the character development she goes through, to see the confidence that laces her veins as the story progresses. i'm so incredibly proud of rae and every single time a person comes for her and mocks her disability, it's off with their heads. nobody is safe — mock rae? instant kill.
the plot was intricately written, though the pacing felt a bit too slow for my taste (but that's just my personal opinion! take it with a grain of salt because i'm a typically impatient person). but overall, the worldbuilding and the buildup of plot twists was incredibly well-done. i'm vastly impressed. intisar khanani worked for almost 10 years on this book and it really shows. and that ending? BRUTAL. i'm left hanging and anxious for rae; next book when?
overall, this story was thrilling and i've never gotten bored of it. it was wild, dark, and there were times when i was certain our characters wouldn't make out of certain situations without a few broken bones. yet it was celebratory and romantic! the royal wedding? [chef's kiss] one of the top scenes, hands down. every time i've reread the chapters, i would giggle and grin; too precious, too precious my alyrra and kestrin babies. and let's not forget to mention a romantic rooftop picnic with a certain thief lord. i don't remember much from that scene but screaming my lungs out from excitement is one of them. i'm never poisoned from instalove by this author and for that, i'm immensely grateful.
His fingers move uncertainly on his thigh, twitching toward me, then back to curl into a fist on his leg. It's the first uncertain movement I can remember him making.
this was one of my most anticipated books of the year, and i am so grateful it didn't disappoint. much thanks to intisar khanani for introducing rae's strong heart and letting readers be by her side throughout her adrenaline-rush, dread-filled yet hopeful story. there's always something about this author's writing that has that old fairytale-like charm yet has a touch of spice to it that keeps me hooked in. and will probably keep me hooked in when the next book comes out! until then, i highly recommend this book and the previous book to anybody who will listen. you won't regret letting this book into your minds and hearts. happy reading!
August 3, 2022
I've read The Bone Knife about 10x already waiting for this book. I want it.
2022
(Omkara)
I'll try to stay clear of spoilers.
I did myself a disservice waiting so long to read this book. Mostly it was because I had caught feelings for the idea of Genno and Rae and was not looking forward to that not being the reality of things. However, I was won over by the end result so I can't be too fussed that the path I was envisioning did not come about. Mostly because the story itself took me in a completely unexpected direction, one that I appreciate more than the fleeting wish of possible romance pairs.
This book explores the dynamics of kidnapping, human trafficking, and the failure of systems of power which are imbued with that power to be systems of protection, failing to protect at all. It's an issue that most people think is over in first world countries, that there isn't someone whose been sold into sexual slavery living next door to you, or the person you're walking past on the street isn't forced into a sweatshop in most of the hours of their lives, but it exists whether we see it or not.
Rae is a country girl, and one thing I fully appreciate about this book (and in many Intisar Khanani books) is the emphasis of community. The idea that goes against western ideals of individualism and supports the idea that people are not supposed to be islands all alone and struggling through life by themselves and "getting themselves together" or "pulling themselves up by their bootstraps" or any of the other cliches that people say when they say "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger," instead of lending a helping hand. People are human, they are flawed but even the jaded characters here are capable of kindness, of lending a hand at risk of themselves. Family is emphasized with love and honor, friendships need to be built on mutual respect, people who aren't the most polished or wealthy or beautiful have value, have common sense and have wisdom to share. Its a beautiful thing to see, the respect for the humanity of people, the capability in us.
I enjoyed this book, plain and simple. Rae is smart, is used to unkindness and people underestimating her because of her clubfoot and she says fuck that to all their expectations of her limitations and does what she thinks is right. She is naive at times, but even as I struggle with that, I still can't blame her because it's her upbringing to try and believe in the best in the others or to try and help where she can. She is incredibly stubborn and I love it. Give me more stubborn, "prickly" women because all I see is strength and passion.
I devoured this book and well, the romance...while not the one I originally wanted, was the one I needed. Respectful care. Awe for the ability and strength of women. Slow burn trust. Protection that goes both ways. So maybe that old adage is true, and what you want isn't necessarily what you need and I.K. knew that better than me.
The one good thing about waiting so long to read this book though is the fact that the second one is already out and going in my cart immediately.
2022
(Omkara)
I'll try to stay clear of spoilers.
I did myself a disservice waiting so long to read this book. Mostly it was because I had caught feelings for the idea of Genno and Rae and was not looking forward to that not being the reality of things. However, I was won over by the end result so I can't be too fussed that the path I was envisioning did not come about. Mostly because the story itself took me in a completely unexpected direction, one that I appreciate more than the fleeting wish of possible romance pairs.
This book explores the dynamics of kidnapping, human trafficking, and the failure of systems of power which are imbued with that power to be systems of protection, failing to protect at all. It's an issue that most people think is over in first world countries, that there isn't someone whose been sold into sexual slavery living next door to you, or the person you're walking past on the street isn't forced into a sweatshop in most of the hours of their lives, but it exists whether we see it or not.
Rae is a country girl, and one thing I fully appreciate about this book (and in many Intisar Khanani books) is the emphasis of community. The idea that goes against western ideals of individualism and supports the idea that people are not supposed to be islands all alone and struggling through life by themselves and "getting themselves together" or "pulling themselves up by their bootstraps" or any of the other cliches that people say when they say "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger," instead of lending a helping hand. People are human, they are flawed but even the jaded characters here are capable of kindness, of lending a hand at risk of themselves. Family is emphasized with love and honor, friendships need to be built on mutual respect, people who aren't the most polished or wealthy or beautiful have value, have common sense and have wisdom to share. Its a beautiful thing to see, the respect for the humanity of people, the capability in us.
I enjoyed this book, plain and simple. Rae is smart, is used to unkindness and people underestimating her because of her clubfoot and she says fuck that to all their expectations of her limitations and does what she thinks is right. She is naive at times, but even as I struggle with that, I still can't blame her because it's her upbringing to try and believe in the best in the others or to try and help where she can. She is incredibly stubborn and I love it. Give me more stubborn, "prickly" women because all I see is strength and passion.
I devoured this book and well, the romance...while not the one I originally wanted, was the one I needed. Respectful care. Awe for the ability and strength of women. Slow burn trust. Protection that goes both ways. So maybe that old adage is true, and what you want isn't necessarily what you need and I.K. knew that better than me.
The one good thing about waiting so long to read this book though is the fact that the second one is already out and going in my cart immediately.
July 23, 2022
so...you're telling me that I have to review this book after reading it???
sdhjfjklsadfhdslk
i literally can't process my feelings still and it has been a few hours. THAT ENDING. HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO JUST MOVE ON WITH MY LIFE??!
seriously, do I have to write a review?
i don't know how to write a review anymore.
this book is hands down one of my favourite reads of 2021. i want to physically force everyone to read it. please read it. if you're reading this review, add it to your tbr. if you are a mutual and don't read it, you are dead to me.
okay. where to begin.
If you know me, you know I have a soft-spot for charming, knife-wielding boys who smirk way too much. Bren gave me major George vibes from The Song of the Lioness books, as well as Leo from The Rigel Black Chronicles fanfic. IT’S JUST SO GOOD. I swear I spent the majority of this book squealing.
The dynamic between Rae and Bren is just ahhhhhsdkfjsdkf. I love how outspoken she is. How willing she is to challenge him at every turn. It amuses Bren, just as much as it amuses me to read it. And Bren gives just as much as he takes. It's a very equal relationship, and I want to see more so bad *cries* I died during multiple scenes. If you've read this book, you know which one I'm talking about. He's always at her side when she needs him the most, yet it doesn't detract from how strong-willed and determined Rae is on her own. He compliments her perfectly, and assures her that her doubts about whether she is a good person are unfounded, and that she has a right to defend herself if she feels pushed by him or anyone else.
I cannot wait to see what the next book has in store. Especially after that ending...Also, I'm totally ready to watch Bren come up with more creative ways to escape Matsin.
I love Rae so much. She's probably one of my favourite characters of all time. It's interesting how different she is compared to Alyrra. Rae is strong, resilient, stubborn, and very determined. She speaks her mind and stands up for herself and others. Her loyalty towards her sister almost made me cry. And while she can be a bit rash, careless, and naive, she develops so much throughout this book.
One part I especially liked was Rae’s relationship with her sister Niya. Since Niya can't marry because of her secret, and Rae doesn't believe she will marry because of her disability, they promise to be there for each other. And while this made me almost cry, it was also a little sad seeing Rae adamantly denying the beauty and attraction she feels towards Verin Stonemane, Bren, and even Garrin. She equates beauty with suspicion and even cruelty. And we can see it's a defence mechanism for herself so she doesn't get hurt. Her loyalty towards Niya won't allow Rae to even imagine falling in love and being in a relationship. It takes her until the end to realize that she's never loved her body enough, that she deserves so much better, and if she wants more, she will have to fight and take it for herself. It's such a powerful scene, and almost made me cry.
Through Rae's eyes we see so much more of Tarinon. I really liked how many people we got to meet and see, and I loved her friendship with Kirrana. Melly was such a sweetheart, and I loved their moments together, especially when Melly was there to let Rae cry on her shoulder. Her back and forth banter with Filadon was great. We really get to see a side of Filadon we didn't see before, and I found it to be quite interesting. Rae doesn't let anyone stand in her way when it comes to protecting those she loves, and I loved a specific scene between the two of them near the end of the book.
As for Alyrra...We really get to see the repercussions of what happened in Thorn. Alyrra is different. Changed. Though in ways that are difficult to see from the outside. I liked being able to see Alyrra through Rae's eyes. Rae goes in not knowing much about Alyrra's past, but she quickly sees the kind of abuse she's gone through at the hands of her brother and mother. I loved seeing Alyrra come into her own and stand up for herself. She's quiet and patient, compared to Rae's fiery determination. Instead of trying to get the court to love her, she gets their support by showing them what has been done to her. It's quite a calculating move, and one that Rae played a role in unknowingly at first. The change we see in the court ladies afterwards was incredible. The way Alyrra draws power to her, it goes to show how dangerous the royal family can be.
There were scenes in this book that were super satisfying to read after Thorn. And if you've read Thorn, you will not be disappointed. Alyrra finally gets a chance to stand up against the abuse she's gone through. And while she is in a position of power and has people to support her, it's not just that.
The court has seen her family's true colours, and not by Alyrra's own hand. She had to do nothing except let her brother and mother be themselves. And then when the opportunity came along, she uses that to defend herself. It's another very powerful scene that left me sitting there in awe.
(I will admit, the one scene that surprised me was Alyrra telling Matsin to test Rae's loyalty. Considering everything Alyrra has gone through, for her to not be explicit enough in telling Matsin not to physically harm Rae didn't make much sense to me. Though, I guess it shows how naive Alyrra still is, it still felt a little off.)
Rae gets to watch all of this happen, and she's quite perceptive. She never once forgets how dangerous the royal family is, and their actions only solidify this. She doesn't just accept their kindness and help, but is constantly wary of how much power they have, and how they can use it to harm her or her family if they so choose. We get another wonderful seen near the end, and it honestly just made me fall in love with Rae even more. She's a character you can't help loving and rooting for. And I'm just so emotional.
This book is violent and dark. Even more so than Thorn was. But I think it does a really good job of showing what life is like for the people of Tarinon. There's a constant threat looming over Rae's head and it results in an intense, fast-paced book that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
I liked seeing more of Tarinon and getting to know the different thieving rings. Rae straddles both worlds, the politics of the city and the politics of the court. And as the readers we get to see how they all interconnect.
While I had an idea where things were headed at the end, I was still not expecting what actually happened. This book exceeded any and all of my expectations. It's not just well-written. Intisar has a way of weaving together all of these complex plots and forming a story that just makes sense, while also delving into deeper, social issues.
ITS JUST SO GOOD YOU GUYS. PLEASE READ IT. I'm sitting here writing this and getting emotional because it was so well done. I haven't read a book this incredible in a long time.
RATING: 5 stars
sdhjfjklsadfhdslk
i literally can't process my feelings still and it has been a few hours. THAT ENDING. HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO JUST MOVE ON WITH MY LIFE??!
seriously, do I have to write a review?
i don't know how to write a review anymore.
this book is hands down one of my favourite reads of 2021. i want to physically force everyone to read it. please read it. if you're reading this review, add it to your tbr. if you are a mutual and don't read it, you are dead to me.
okay. where to begin.
If you know me, you know I have a soft-spot for charming, knife-wielding boys who smirk way too much. Bren gave me major George vibes from The Song of the Lioness books, as well as Leo from The Rigel Black Chronicles fanfic. IT’S JUST SO GOOD. I swear I spent the majority of this book squealing.
The dynamic between Rae and Bren is just ahhhhhsdkfjsdkf. I love how outspoken she is. How willing she is to challenge him at every turn. It amuses Bren, just as much as it amuses me to read it. And Bren gives just as much as he takes. It's a very equal relationship, and I want to see more so bad *cries* I died during multiple scenes. If you've read this book, you know which one I'm talking about. He's always at her side when she needs him the most, yet it doesn't detract from how strong-willed and determined Rae is on her own. He compliments her perfectly, and assures her that her doubts about whether she is a good person are unfounded, and that she has a right to defend herself if she feels pushed by him or anyone else.
I cannot wait to see what the next book has in store. Especially after that ending...Also, I'm totally ready to watch Bren come up with more creative ways to escape Matsin.
I love Rae so much. She's probably one of my favourite characters of all time. It's interesting how different she is compared to Alyrra. Rae is strong, resilient, stubborn, and very determined. She speaks her mind and stands up for herself and others. Her loyalty towards her sister almost made me cry. And while she can be a bit rash, careless, and naive, she develops so much throughout this book.
One part I especially liked was Rae’s relationship with her sister Niya. Since Niya can't marry because of her secret, and Rae doesn't believe she will marry because of her disability, they promise to be there for each other. And while this made me almost cry, it was also a little sad seeing Rae adamantly denying the beauty and attraction she feels towards Verin Stonemane, Bren, and even Garrin. She equates beauty with suspicion and even cruelty. And we can see it's a defence mechanism for herself so she doesn't get hurt. Her loyalty towards Niya won't allow Rae to even imagine falling in love and being in a relationship. It takes her until the end to realize that she's never loved her body enough, that she deserves so much better, and if she wants more, she will have to fight and take it for herself. It's such a powerful scene, and almost made me cry.
Through Rae's eyes we see so much more of Tarinon. I really liked how many people we got to meet and see, and I loved her friendship with Kirrana. Melly was such a sweetheart, and I loved their moments together, especially when Melly was there to let Rae cry on her shoulder. Her back and forth banter with Filadon was great. We really get to see a side of Filadon we didn't see before, and I found it to be quite interesting. Rae doesn't let anyone stand in her way when it comes to protecting those she loves, and I loved a specific scene between the two of them near the end of the book.
As for Alyrra...We really get to see the repercussions of what happened in Thorn. Alyrra is different. Changed. Though in ways that are difficult to see from the outside. I liked being able to see Alyrra through Rae's eyes. Rae goes in not knowing much about Alyrra's past, but she quickly sees the kind of abuse she's gone through at the hands of her brother and mother. I loved seeing Alyrra come into her own and stand up for herself. She's quiet and patient, compared to Rae's fiery determination. Instead of trying to get the court to love her, she gets their support by showing them what has been done to her. It's quite a calculating move, and one that Rae played a role in unknowingly at first. The change we see in the court ladies afterwards was incredible. The way Alyrra draws power to her, it goes to show how dangerous the royal family can be.
There were scenes in this book that were super satisfying to read after Thorn. And if you've read Thorn, you will not be disappointed. Alyrra finally gets a chance to stand up against the abuse she's gone through. And while she is in a position of power and has people to support her, it's not just that.
The court has seen her family's true colours, and not by Alyrra's own hand. She had to do nothing except let her brother and mother be themselves. And then when the opportunity came along, she uses that to defend herself. It's another very powerful scene that left me sitting there in awe.
(I will admit, the one scene that surprised me was Alyrra telling Matsin to test Rae's loyalty. Considering everything Alyrra has gone through, for her to not be explicit enough in telling Matsin not to physically harm Rae didn't make much sense to me. Though, I guess it shows how naive Alyrra still is, it still felt a little off.)
Rae gets to watch all of this happen, and she's quite perceptive. She never once forgets how dangerous the royal family is, and their actions only solidify this. She doesn't just accept their kindness and help, but is constantly wary of how much power they have, and how they can use it to harm her or her family if they so choose. We get another wonderful seen near the end, and it honestly just made me fall in love with Rae even more. She's a character you can't help loving and rooting for. And I'm just so emotional.
This book is violent and dark. Even more so than Thorn was. But I think it does a really good job of showing what life is like for the people of Tarinon. There's a constant threat looming over Rae's head and it results in an intense, fast-paced book that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
I liked seeing more of Tarinon and getting to know the different thieving rings. Rae straddles both worlds, the politics of the city and the politics of the court. And as the readers we get to see how they all interconnect.
While I had an idea where things were headed at the end, I was still not expecting what actually happened. This book exceeded any and all of my expectations. It's not just well-written. Intisar has a way of weaving together all of these complex plots and forming a story that just makes sense, while also delving into deeper, social issues.
ITS JUST SO GOOD YOU GUYS. PLEASE READ IT. I'm sitting here writing this and getting emotional because it was so well done. I haven't read a book this incredible in a long time.
RATING: 5 stars
January 7, 2022
The Theft of Sunlight is the companion novel to Thorn that focuses on a new main character called Amraeya (or Rae for short). When I read Thorn last year I was very impressed with pretty much everything about it and I was even more impressed when this book had everything I liked about Thorn but was even better!
Plot: 5/5
Characters: 5/5
Writing: 5/5
I have so much love and respect for Rae. She was strong but not in the way I'm used to seeing in fantasy novels- her strength lay in her empathy, loyalty and moral fibre and it was refreshing to read about such a character.
The plot drew me in from the very start and dragged me deeper and deeper into the depths of its mysteries. It never gave too much away but maintained a steady trickle of breadcrumbs and breakthroughs that kept me hooked up until the very last page. There were twists that I saw coming but they were so well built up to and executed that it didn't feel predictable or boring in the slightest. I also felt that there was a very good balance of softer, emotional scenes and dramatic, action-packed, confrontational scenes that it never felt too slow paced or too overwhelming. AND THE CLIFFHANGER!!! The book ended on a cliffhanger which I usually find very frustrating but it felt like a fitting conclusion and I can only hope that we get a sequel so that I can find out what happens next!
In the acknowledgements Khanani mentions that the slavery in The Theft of Sunlight is modelled on modern day human trafficking and I definitely saw a lot of real life parallels in the book. Every day children were 'snatched' without a trace, transported and sold into slavery and everyone lived in fear- it was extremely chilling to read about. It made me so sad reading about the grief of families who had lost their children, not knowing their fates or whether they were even alive- especially knowing that there are countless real families living with that sorrow all over the world.
What was most chilling was how those in power were either completely oblivious of the problem, willingly in denial of it or trying to cover it up. I shared in Rae's shock and disgust at the utter disregard shown by those who were wealthy and privileged simply because it wasn't affecting them even though they had resources and power that could help so many but sadly, I also wasn't that surprised at all because it's the precise attitude that so many in powerful, privileged positions in our world have.
The Theft of Sunlight was an impressive and refreshing read, balancing high stakes and mystery with softness and emotion that I highly recommend!
Thank you to HarperTeen for providing me with an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Plot: 5/5
Characters: 5/5
Writing: 5/5
I have so much love and respect for Rae. She was strong but not in the way I'm used to seeing in fantasy novels- her strength lay in her empathy, loyalty and moral fibre and it was refreshing to read about such a character.
The plot drew me in from the very start and dragged me deeper and deeper into the depths of its mysteries. It never gave too much away but maintained a steady trickle of breadcrumbs and breakthroughs that kept me hooked up until the very last page. There were twists that I saw coming but they were so well built up to and executed that it didn't feel predictable or boring in the slightest. I also felt that there was a very good balance of softer, emotional scenes and dramatic, action-packed, confrontational scenes that it never felt too slow paced or too overwhelming. AND THE CLIFFHANGER!!! The book ended on a cliffhanger which I usually find very frustrating but it felt like a fitting conclusion and I can only hope that we get a sequel so that I can find out what happens next!
In the acknowledgements Khanani mentions that the slavery in The Theft of Sunlight is modelled on modern day human trafficking and I definitely saw a lot of real life parallels in the book. Every day children were 'snatched' without a trace, transported and sold into slavery and everyone lived in fear- it was extremely chilling to read about. It made me so sad reading about the grief of families who had lost their children, not knowing their fates or whether they were even alive- especially knowing that there are countless real families living with that sorrow all over the world.
What was most chilling was how those in power were either completely oblivious of the problem, willingly in denial of it or trying to cover it up. I shared in Rae's shock and disgust at the utter disregard shown by those who were wealthy and privileged simply because it wasn't affecting them even though they had resources and power that could help so many but sadly, I also wasn't that surprised at all because it's the precise attitude that so many in powerful, privileged positions in our world have.
The Theft of Sunlight was an impressive and refreshing read, balancing high stakes and mystery with softness and emotion that I highly recommend!
Thank you to HarperTeen for providing me with an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
March 4, 2022
“Sometimes, when you think things are finished, they are only just beginning.”
TW: ableism, blood, child abuse, death, domestic abuse, kidnapping, rape, sexual assault, slavery, trafficking, violence, and vomit.
I'm not sure how to review this as I have mixed feelings overall.
On the one hand, I appreciated seeing the disability rep and the fact the author used this story to tackle the issues of trafficking/moral implications of not doing what we can. And on the other hand, I just couldn't bring myself to care?
My major issues here were the characters and the pacing/length of the book.
One of the reasons I liked Thorn was because I genuinely cared for/empathized with Alyrra and admired her kindness. I wanted so badly to love Rae, but my feelings towards her only ranged between indifference and annoyance. She was headstrong to the point of blind stupidity and extremely judgmental/superficial when it came to everyone around her.
Kind of like if Scarlet from the Lunar Chronicles toned down her personality by 500% percent and drank some tea.
As for the pacing/length problems, not nearly enough happened - character or plot development wise - to justify this book being 520+ pages. It got to the point that when the book finally ended, instead of being annoyed at the cliffhanger, I was just grateful it was over because it felt like it had been dragging on for thirty years.
This wasn't bad and I still appreciate the story the author is telling, I just feel pretty mixed/indifferent about this one. If you loved the first one, I recommend carrying on because there's still a lot to enjoy here.
It just didn't work for me.
TW: ableism, blood, child abuse, death, domestic abuse, kidnapping, rape, sexual assault, slavery, trafficking, violence, and vomit.
I'm not sure how to review this as I have mixed feelings overall.
On the one hand, I appreciated seeing the disability rep and the fact the author used this story to tackle the issues of trafficking/moral implications of not doing what we can. And on the other hand, I just couldn't bring myself to care?
My major issues here were the characters and the pacing/length of the book.
One of the reasons I liked Thorn was because I genuinely cared for/empathized with Alyrra and admired her kindness. I wanted so badly to love Rae, but my feelings towards her only ranged between indifference and annoyance. She was headstrong to the point of blind stupidity and extremely judgmental/superficial when it came to everyone around her.
Kind of like if Scarlet from the Lunar Chronicles toned down her personality by 500% percent and drank some tea.
As for the pacing/length problems, not nearly enough happened - character or plot development wise - to justify this book being 520+ pages. It got to the point that when the book finally ended, instead of being annoyed at the cliffhanger, I was just grateful it was over because it felt like it had been dragging on for thirty years.
This wasn't bad and I still appreciate the story the author is telling, I just feel pretty mixed/indifferent about this one. If you loved the first one, I recommend carrying on because there's still a lot to enjoy here.
It just didn't work for me.
March 17, 2021
*deep breath*
*SCREAMS*
edit: 18/03/21 Review, as appeared on Instagram:
eARC provided by publisher via Netgalley for a blog tour organized by Qamar Blog Tours. All opinions are my own!
You ever read a book that makes you fall in love with every page you turn that by the time you get to the end, you are just in awe of everything you've just experienced? That's this book for me!
Theft of Sunlight is the first book in a duology following the events of the book Thorn, set in the sane world that Thorn is and it is one of the most fantastic books EVER! With an absolutely compelling main character you cannot help fall in love with, a mystrey that keeps you on your toes and political intrigue that induces nail-biting tension, this is a fantasy that *will* sweep you off your feet! (And then dangle you in the air because it ends on a cliffhanger, but you'll be swaying up there will all kinds of warmth and emotional attachments so like who cares you know)((I care, I do, I need that sequel like Winnie the pooh needs his honey)).
Like I said, the events of Theft of Sunlight follow the events of Thorn, but this time, we follow a character called Amareya, a village girl with a disability who ends up at the palace as Alyrra's attendant and confidant, when she decides to go into the city and figure out what she can about the kidnappings happening all around the kingdom after her best friend's sister is "snatched." She expects to uncover some answers and maybe nudge a head or two towards the investigation into these kidnapping rings. What she doesn't expect is to end up smack dab in the middle of a political conspiracy that is way over her paygrade. But she does anyway, because of two reasons — she is incredible brave and ridiculously kind. Along the way, she gets tangled with the local thieving gangs (YESS THERE ARE THEIVING GANGS, BITCHESSS!); mages, human and fae, and lord knows who else. Pick the book up to find out. For real, you are going to LOVE IT!
The star of the show, as you can tell already, is Amareya — or Rae, as everyone calls her. She is just so fucking amazing, you guys! I truly do not have words. She is sarcastic and funny and also very intuitive and intelligent. She does reckless things and makes stupid mistakes, but all because she is kind to a fault. She is also fiercely loyal — she keeps the magic in her sister secret to protect her from the circle of mages (don't ask for explanations, go read the book, shoo), and she will literally die before she gives that up. I diagnose her with a terminal case of Eldest Daughter Syndrome™ and that's essentially why she keeps getting in trouble all the time. But it's fun to follow her on the ride, nonetheless!
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Alyrra and Kestrin also make appearances in this book, and it is so fascinating seeing them from a third person's perspective! When you read Thorn, you almost feel like Alyrra is too passive. But when you read Theft, you realize that that's just because that's what she thinks of herself!! Like, at every step of the way, Alyrra is politicking without knowing that she's doing it, but she keeps downplaying it in her head because she's just like that. Of course, she's also settled into her role more comfortably now, but it was one of those tiny things that made my jaw drop when I realized it! Honestly, I am in love with this author because of it!! Like I never thought of it that way before and now I'm like 🤯
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Anyway, back to Theft! This time, we are introduced to a character from Red Hawk's theiving ring called Bren (this man is soooo the Red Hawk but we do not have canonical confirmation so *Agatha wink from Wandavision which i know what it means but idk why it means that so no spoilers pls*). Yes, he is the love interest. Yes, he has knives and he does that thing where he whips them out while wearing a cape it was very cool. Yes, he does deserve to get punched in the face once in a while. Yes, you are shipping the ship against your will. No, I do not make the rules.
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
So I'm sure you can already see how this is coming together. Rae becomes Alyrra's confidant, Rae and Alyrra begin investigating the kidnappings on the DL because governments are shit all around the globe, Alyrra puts her in touch with the Red Hawk gang so they can help her. Antics ensue. Oh, and meanwhile, Alyrra and Kestrin's wedding is happening at the palace. And her dickwad of a brother shows up. So that's another thing going on for you. Even with so much happening, it all flows rather smoothly! I mean it's a high stakes fantasy novel that takes an unexpectedly dark turn, what else did you expect, you know?
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
I have literally no complaints about the plot or the characters. I did miss the writing from Thorn because it had a more fairy tale-esque feel to it and was all lyrical and amazing. But, this is not the place for all that. WE SIMPLY DO NOT HAVE THE TIME, PEOPLE!!! I missed the writing for exactly 15% of the novel before I forgot I was sitting in a room in my body and fell headfirst into the story.
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Speaking of, THE SETTING!!! Even though we're introduced to this city in Thorn, seeing it from Rae's perspective just added so much dimension to it!! It fleshed out the dynamics of this world so well *and* it also exposed the underbelly of this city that we weren't able to glimpse in Thorn. I loved the vibe of it all. The gritty, jagged edges of the town in the dark in contrast with the airy, oppulence of the palace at day! The way the bridge between the two sides was Rae, and how she came out of her shell and grew into herself as she is forced to traverse these both worlds! Just the fantasy escapism of it all, as you read!! *chef's kiss*
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
I don't really have anything much to say because I literally do not have critiques. Yeah, the plot slows down in a middle for a bit, but that's also just like the plateau you have to write before you start hurtling your audience into a high action climax. Which, btw, WENT PLACES. I swear I do not kid when I say I was actually screaming. And Rameela was screaming with me..We had so much fun reading it!!
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
And that's how I wanna conclude this mess of a review! This book was just so much absolute, unadulterated, fantasy fun! You'll get invested, you'll make theories, you'll see some badass magic and you'll have a great time!!! All this, while reading about a non-white, disabled protagonist in a non-white country! LIKE. What more do you want, honestly?! GO PREORDER THE BOOK!! NOWWWWWWWW!!!
*SCREAMS*
edit: 18/03/21 Review, as appeared on Instagram:
eARC provided by publisher via Netgalley for a blog tour organized by Qamar Blog Tours. All opinions are my own!
You ever read a book that makes you fall in love with every page you turn that by the time you get to the end, you are just in awe of everything you've just experienced? That's this book for me!
Theft of Sunlight is the first book in a duology following the events of the book Thorn, set in the sane world that Thorn is and it is one of the most fantastic books EVER! With an absolutely compelling main character you cannot help fall in love with, a mystrey that keeps you on your toes and political intrigue that induces nail-biting tension, this is a fantasy that *will* sweep you off your feet! (And then dangle you in the air because it ends on a cliffhanger, but you'll be swaying up there will all kinds of warmth and emotional attachments so like who cares you know)((I care, I do, I need that sequel like Winnie the pooh needs his honey)).
Like I said, the events of Theft of Sunlight follow the events of Thorn, but this time, we follow a character called Amareya, a village girl with a disability who ends up at the palace as Alyrra's attendant and confidant, when she decides to go into the city and figure out what she can about the kidnappings happening all around the kingdom after her best friend's sister is "snatched." She expects to uncover some answers and maybe nudge a head or two towards the investigation into these kidnapping rings. What she doesn't expect is to end up smack dab in the middle of a political conspiracy that is way over her paygrade. But she does anyway, because of two reasons — she is incredible brave and ridiculously kind. Along the way, she gets tangled with the local thieving gangs (YESS THERE ARE THEIVING GANGS, BITCHESSS!); mages, human and fae, and lord knows who else. Pick the book up to find out. For real, you are going to LOVE IT!
The star of the show, as you can tell already, is Amareya — or Rae, as everyone calls her. She is just so fucking amazing, you guys! I truly do not have words. She is sarcastic and funny and also very intuitive and intelligent. She does reckless things and makes stupid mistakes, but all because she is kind to a fault. She is also fiercely loyal — she keeps the magic in her sister secret to protect her from the circle of mages (don't ask for explanations, go read the book, shoo), and she will literally die before she gives that up. I diagnose her with a terminal case of Eldest Daughter Syndrome™ and that's essentially why she keeps getting in trouble all the time. But it's fun to follow her on the ride, nonetheless!
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Alyrra and Kestrin also make appearances in this book, and it is so fascinating seeing them from a third person's perspective! When you read Thorn, you almost feel like Alyrra is too passive. But when you read Theft, you realize that that's just because that's what she thinks of herself!! Like, at every step of the way, Alyrra is politicking without knowing that she's doing it, but she keeps downplaying it in her head because she's just like that. Of course, she's also settled into her role more comfortably now, but it was one of those tiny things that made my jaw drop when I realized it! Honestly, I am in love with this author because of it!! Like I never thought of it that way before and now I'm like 🤯
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Anyway, back to Theft! This time, we are introduced to a character from Red Hawk's theiving ring called Bren (this man is soooo the Red Hawk but we do not have canonical confirmation so *Agatha wink from Wandavision which i know what it means but idk why it means that so no spoilers pls*). Yes, he is the love interest. Yes, he has knives and he does that thing where he whips them out while wearing a cape it was very cool. Yes, he does deserve to get punched in the face once in a while. Yes, you are shipping the ship against your will. No, I do not make the rules.
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
So I'm sure you can already see how this is coming together. Rae becomes Alyrra's confidant, Rae and Alyrra begin investigating the kidnappings on the DL because governments are shit all around the globe, Alyrra puts her in touch with the Red Hawk gang so they can help her. Antics ensue. Oh, and meanwhile, Alyrra and Kestrin's wedding is happening at the palace. And her dickwad of a brother shows up. So that's another thing going on for you. Even with so much happening, it all flows rather smoothly! I mean it's a high stakes fantasy novel that takes an unexpectedly dark turn, what else did you expect, you know?
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
I have literally no complaints about the plot or the characters. I did miss the writing from Thorn because it had a more fairy tale-esque feel to it and was all lyrical and amazing. But, this is not the place for all that. WE SIMPLY DO NOT HAVE THE TIME, PEOPLE!!! I missed the writing for exactly 15% of the novel before I forgot I was sitting in a room in my body and fell headfirst into the story.
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Speaking of, THE SETTING!!! Even though we're introduced to this city in Thorn, seeing it from Rae's perspective just added so much dimension to it!! It fleshed out the dynamics of this world so well *and* it also exposed the underbelly of this city that we weren't able to glimpse in Thorn. I loved the vibe of it all. The gritty, jagged edges of the town in the dark in contrast with the airy, oppulence of the palace at day! The way the bridge between the two sides was Rae, and how she came out of her shell and grew into herself as she is forced to traverse these both worlds! Just the fantasy escapism of it all, as you read!! *chef's kiss*
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
I don't really have anything much to say because I literally do not have critiques. Yeah, the plot slows down in a middle for a bit, but that's also just like the plateau you have to write before you start hurtling your audience into a high action climax. Which, btw, WENT PLACES. I swear I do not kid when I say I was actually screaming. And Rameela was screaming with me..We had so much fun reading it!!
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
And that's how I wanna conclude this mess of a review! This book was just so much absolute, unadulterated, fantasy fun! You'll get invested, you'll make theories, you'll see some badass magic and you'll have a great time!!! All this, while reading about a non-white, disabled protagonist in a non-white country! LIKE. What more do you want, honestly?! GO PREORDER THE BOOK!! NOWWWWWWWW!!!
September 8, 2022
I put off reading this YA fantasy novel because other reviewers had warned that there was darkness in the mystery of the child-snatching ring that the heroine investigates, and they were right about that part - but they were also right to love it, and I'm so glad I've read it now! (I'm also SO glad that the sequel is already out, because this book ends on a major cliffhanger, and I will immediately be racing to read Book 2 in the duology to get the rest of this story.)
This is a wonderfully classic YA fantasy in the vein of Tamora Pierce, Maria Snyder's Poison Study series, and Sherwood Smith's Crown Duel, and I devoured it. I loved Rae, the stubborn, determined, and clever heroine, as she moves from the countryside to the court to the docks and thieves' dens of the capital city, negotiating courtly politics and brutal danger in her quest to stop the child-traffickers who stole the younger sister of a friend. I loved her ethics and her courage as she fights to do what's right despite everything that's stacked against her. I also loved the cast of characters around her and the slow-burn romance that's been developing across this book (and which I hope will come to fruition in the second book of the duology).
The details of the child-snatching ARE dark, but they're never gratuitous, and they absolutely don't overwhelm the light of hope and courage in this story.
And I'm off to read Book 2 *now*!
This is a wonderfully classic YA fantasy in the vein of Tamora Pierce, Maria Snyder's Poison Study series, and Sherwood Smith's Crown Duel, and I devoured it. I loved Rae, the stubborn, determined, and clever heroine, as she moves from the countryside to the court to the docks and thieves' dens of the capital city, negotiating courtly politics and brutal danger in her quest to stop the child-traffickers who stole the younger sister of a friend. I loved her ethics and her courage as she fights to do what's right despite everything that's stacked against her. I also loved the cast of characters around her and the slow-burn romance that's been developing across this book (and which I hope will come to fruition in the second book of the duology).
The details of the child-snatching ARE dark, but they're never gratuitous, and they absolutely don't overwhelm the light of hope and courage in this story.
And I'm off to read Book 2 *now*!
September 30, 2021
Brilliant part 2! The diverse setting of this fantasy series is so subtly woven in, and there's so much going on. Themes of disability, self-love, violence, and more are so carefully explored. Great cast of characters! Ends on a cliffhanger!!!!
Want to read
November 16, 2016I NEED THIS NOW I'M PRETTY SURE AT THIS POINT THAT INTISAR KHANANI IS MY ACTUAL FAVE AUTHOR
January 10, 2025
I just finished this book. As such, I'm writing this review straight away because it doesn't deserve the shoddy recollection of my fading memory weeks from now.
I am in complete and utter shambles. The last 10 pages of this book had me stressed out so much my heartbeat was probably at cardio levels. Intisar Khanani - the writer that you are! Khanani is so amazing at her craft. This book, and I suspect this entire series, is so criminally underrated.
TTOS takes place in a fantasy world with heavy focus on political intrigue. Khanani is masterful at navigating court politics. She writes it in a way that somehow makes you feel like a spectator watching a very heated sports game. The players in the country of Menaiya know how to play the game well. There isn't a single uninteresting character in this book (well there is one - but that's purposeful and also I was a hater from day 1 so I'm biased) and everyone plays their part. The one person who doesn't want to play at politicking is Rae.
Rae is one of the best FMCs in a fantasy settings that I've come across in a while. She is full of dry humour, extremely witty and so unbelievably kind. Her luck in life is almost at zero constantly, but she is so filled with love for her family, friends and humanity as a whole. She empathizes with others so deeply and always tries to choose the path of least harm. Make no mistake, Rae is not a Mary Sue. There are many examples where her beliefs and morals are challenged. This woman is clever and so smart that she has people clocking her immediately as someone noteworthy despite her lower social ranking. Rae lives with a physical disability making it difficult for her to walk and keep pace with others and it's a fundamental part of her character. Khanani doesn't shy away from making Rae encounter physical and mental challenges with this in ways that is so refreshing as a reader. I could talk about this character for ages.
Those last few pages were harrowing. The content is intense, but so exciting. However, it made me really think about the normalization of suffering for the most vulnerable of society: children, women, and the working class. How easy it is for the patriarchy and the elite to continue to use our bodies for their monetary and insidious desires. How little anyone outside of their tax bracket means to them. The value of your life is nothing for people like that. This book captures that essence of our current reality in a way that reminds me that if we don't look out for each other and truly believe that I am not free until my siblings are free, then we've lost the plot too.
So if you're reading this, remember to do you part in actions that support the liberation of Palestine, Congo, Sudan and other areas of the world. We cannot normalize seeing horrors on our little screens. We cannot normalize not demanding our 'democratic' leaders to represent what we value. You do not work for them, they're supposed to work for you. If you don't have free healthcare yet, if you're worried about the rights of your body being taken away, if you are worried about your daily safety - then your country shouldn't be sending billions of your tax dollars to other countries to fund mass atrocities.
I am in complete and utter shambles. The last 10 pages of this book had me stressed out so much my heartbeat was probably at cardio levels. Intisar Khanani - the writer that you are! Khanani is so amazing at her craft. This book, and I suspect this entire series, is so criminally underrated.
TTOS takes place in a fantasy world with heavy focus on political intrigue. Khanani is masterful at navigating court politics. She writes it in a way that somehow makes you feel like a spectator watching a very heated sports game. The players in the country of Menaiya know how to play the game well. There isn't a single uninteresting character in this book (well there is one - but that's purposeful and also I was a hater from day 1 so I'm biased) and everyone plays their part. The one person who doesn't want to play at politicking is Rae.
Rae is one of the best FMCs in a fantasy settings that I've come across in a while. She is full of dry humour, extremely witty and so unbelievably kind. Her luck in life is almost at zero constantly, but she is so filled with love for her family, friends and humanity as a whole. She empathizes with others so deeply and always tries to choose the path of least harm. Make no mistake, Rae is not a Mary Sue. There are many examples where her beliefs and morals are challenged. This woman is clever and so smart that she has people clocking her immediately as someone noteworthy despite her lower social ranking. Rae lives with a physical disability making it difficult for her to walk and keep pace with others and it's a fundamental part of her character. Khanani doesn't shy away from making Rae encounter physical and mental challenges with this in ways that is so refreshing as a reader. I could talk about this character for ages.
Those last few pages were harrowing. The content is intense, but so exciting. However, it made me really think about the normalization of suffering for the most vulnerable of society: children, women, and the working class. How easy it is for the patriarchy and the elite to continue to use our bodies for their monetary and insidious desires. How little anyone outside of their tax bracket means to them. The value of your life is nothing for people like that. This book captures that essence of our current reality in a way that reminds me that if we don't look out for each other and truly believe that I am not free until my siblings are free, then we've lost the plot too.
So if you're reading this, remember to do you part in actions that support the liberation of Palestine, Congo, Sudan and other areas of the world. We cannot normalize seeing horrors on our little screens. We cannot normalize not demanding our 'democratic' leaders to represent what we value. You do not work for them, they're supposed to work for you. If you don't have free healthcare yet, if you're worried about the rights of your body being taken away, if you are worried about your daily safety - then your country shouldn't be sending billions of your tax dollars to other countries to fund mass atrocities.
August 16, 2022
"The Theft of Sunlight" was more action-packed and exciting than "Thorn" because of the mystery-solving aspect and powerful foes. (I took these villains more seriously because unlike the villains in book 1, these villains were much better at covering their tracks.) To be clear, I love both books and heroines in different ways - "Thorn" for Alyrra's enduring strength and emotionally loaded scenes and "The Theft of Sunlight" for Rae's feistiness and determination to seek justice.
This installment also had more funny moments because of the characters' refreshing candor and sharp wit. (I'm looking at you, Rae and Bren.) Also, compared to book 1, book 2 focused more on the relationships between the characters, which made me a happy reader:
1.) Rae's family - Even though there were no scenes with her parents and sisters, I still felt their presence because of Rae's deep love for them. She was constantly thinking of them, especially Niya. That letter Rae's mama wrote warmed my cold heart and made me want to hug someone, which is saying a lot because I'm not the huggy sort. I think that Rae's upbringing and supportive family were a big part of the reason why Rae's so headstrong and principled. Please give more YA heroines awesome families like this one!
2.) Rae and Bren - In this dangerous mission, Rae's the morally upright detective and Bren's the streetsmart and rule-breaking detective. It's an entertaining tandem that came with a fair amount of gripping cloak-and-dagger scenes.
3.) Rae and Allyra - This was not the typical empowering female friendship. Politics added more layers to it, which made it more complicated. The way the relationship developed was realistic and heartwarming at the same time.
4.) Allyra and Kestrin - Most of their scenes together in "Thorn" involved secrecy and mind games, which made me wish for more honest conversations. Of course I was happy to see them finally working together openly in "The Theft of Sunlight". Expect to see cute and light-hearted moments between them too!
Dear reader, I'm a dork. I feel so silly for not knowing that Rae's story will continue in the next book. In other words, I had a mini heart attack when I finished that last chapter with a cliffhanger! My ebook indicated that I still had 300 pages left to read, so I was shocked when I saw the word "acknowledgements". I rapidly went through the stages of grief and I will spend months fearing for these characters' lives because of the ominous way this sequel ended!
This installment also had more funny moments because of the characters' refreshing candor and sharp wit. (I'm looking at you, Rae and Bren.) Also, compared to book 1, book 2 focused more on the relationships between the characters, which made me a happy reader:
1.) Rae's family - Even though there were no scenes with her parents and sisters, I still felt their presence because of Rae's deep love for them. She was constantly thinking of them, especially Niya. That letter Rae's mama wrote warmed my cold heart and made me want to hug someone, which is saying a lot because I'm not the huggy sort. I think that Rae's upbringing and supportive family were a big part of the reason why Rae's so headstrong and principled. Please give more YA heroines awesome families like this one!
2.) Rae and Bren - In this dangerous mission, Rae's the morally upright detective and Bren's the streetsmart and rule-breaking detective. It's an entertaining tandem that came with a fair amount of gripping cloak-and-dagger scenes.
3.) Rae and Allyra - This was not the typical empowering female friendship. Politics added more layers to it, which made it more complicated. The way the relationship developed was realistic and heartwarming at the same time.
4.) Allyra and Kestrin - Most of their scenes together in "Thorn" involved secrecy and mind games, which made me wish for more honest conversations. Of course I was happy to see them finally working together openly in "The Theft of Sunlight". Expect to see cute and light-hearted moments between them too!
Dear reader, I'm a dork. I feel so silly for not knowing that Rae's story will continue in the next book. In other words, I had a mini heart attack when I finished that last chapter with a cliffhanger! My ebook indicated that I still had 300 pages left to read, so I was shocked when I saw the word "acknowledgements". I rapidly went through the stages of grief and I will spend months fearing for these characters' lives because of the ominous way this sequel ended!
August 15, 2022
Got kind of gruesome at the end tbh
September 11, 2021
This was a bit of a departure from previous Intisar Khanani books. But it has been a long time between drinks, she herself said she started this sequel to Thorn ten years ago.
I have enjoyed all her previous books, so I was definitely looking forward to this one. It was a departure from her previous books at the start with the introduction of a brand new character (I was never able to find a copy of The Bone Knife), so Amoris took some time to become familiar with.
It was very slow starting after an initial flurry in her home town, but when Amoris gets to the palace and becomes an attendant to the new princess (Alleyra from Thorn). The story was presented well, Amoris was a different type of heroine with a physical disabilty that did not at all diminish her gumption in any way. By the end I was at the edge of my seat, so we will have to wait for the sequel, hopefully not another ten years.
I have enjoyed all her previous books, so I was definitely looking forward to this one. It was a departure from her previous books at the start with the introduction of a brand new character (I was never able to find a copy of The Bone Knife), so Amoris took some time to become familiar with.
It was very slow starting after an initial flurry in her home town, but when Amoris gets to the palace and becomes an attendant to the new princess (Alleyra from Thorn). The story was presented well, Amoris was a different type of heroine with a physical disabilty that did not at all diminish her gumption in any way. By the end I was at the edge of my seat, so we will have to wait for the sequel, hopefully not another ten years.
January 14, 2021
I received an ARC from the publishers in exchange for a review.
The entire time I was reading this novel, I kept trying to guess which fairy tale it was a retelling of because, since it was set in the same world as Thorn, itself a retelling of "The Goose Girl," I had come to The Theft of Sunlight with the expectation that it was a fairy tale retelling as well. By the middle of the book, I'd mostly convinced myself that this was a retelling of "The Pied Piper of Hamelin."
I mean, it fit. So perfectly it was hard to not think it had to be so. Thousands of children are stolen from their towns across the country (the parallel to the Children of Hamelin was just too good to miss) by a shadowy group known as the Snatchers, who obviously had to have a powerful backer (that could fit the Pied Piper figure) that probably had some sort of axe to grind with the Royal Family of Menaiya (who could fit the figure of the burgomaster that refused to pay the Piper), and finally there's the protagonist, turnfoot Amraeya, who investigates the disappearances on behalf of her best friend and uncovers a vast web of human trafficking and child slavery that reaches the highest echelons of government. Those who read the fairy tale will recall that the way the disappeared Children of Hamelin are found is due to a child left behind because he had a crippled foot and couldn't move as fast as the rest of the children. See a parallel to Rae? I sure do!
So, with all those key elements neatly and seamlessly woven into the storyline, who'd blame me for thinking The Theft of Sunlight is a "Pied Piper of Hamelin" retelling? And the ending and the lack of confirmation in the author's note hasn't convinced me of the contrary. Hey, Intisar, if you're reading this, I do firmly believe this novel is totally worth advertising as a retelling! The idea of rehashing the tale's core plot into a story of slavery and human trafficking is actually brilliant. Please, consider labelling it as such. Besides, I've not seen yet a retelling of the Piper fairy tale that was either good or to my liking, and this is the best out there for me.
Back to the story itself, I liked Rae best. I liked that she is no self-pitying pushover, and I liked that she doesn't define herself by her disability even when the rest of the world does. I think characterisation is the strength of the novel, because all characters are well-defined and have a distinctive voice. The protagonist (and Alyrra from Thorn, too) is down-to-Earth, practical and sensible, sometimes a bit uncouth and blunt, but always genuine. The male characters are less defined, however, probably because of the POV structure. There is no romance for the lead character as yet, which I find intriguing because it doesn't distract from the plot and it leaves up in the air which of the men might end up tangled in Rae's web (I have a horse in this race, but I'm not telling yet!).
There's a detail about the writing in this book that some readers might not like: the present tense first person prose. I never cared whether the narration was in first person POV or present tense, and still don't, because I consider it a matter of personal taste, but I do know a fair number of readers that can't stand first person narration, and present tense narration even less, so I'm putting this out there for their benefit.
But the novel's one big downside, and Intisar herself acknowledges this in her author's note, is the ending. It's a brutal cliffhanger! I cannot see how the book wouldn't have ended in suspense without making it into a big fat brick over 800 pages long because the story is barely halfway through when it ends, but I do believe there was a way to soften the cliffhanger so the landing wouldn't hurt. Perhaps even add one more chapter (or lengthen the last one) so that the harsh note it ends in isn't as grating. It practically pulls you out of the story and tosses you out the window, and no reader likes that. I can only hope the wait for the sequel won't take too long, because the uncertainty about the fate of the protagonist is going to kill me otherwise.
The entire time I was reading this novel, I kept trying to guess which fairy tale it was a retelling of because, since it was set in the same world as Thorn, itself a retelling of "The Goose Girl," I had come to The Theft of Sunlight with the expectation that it was a fairy tale retelling as well. By the middle of the book, I'd mostly convinced myself that this was a retelling of "The Pied Piper of Hamelin."
I mean, it fit. So perfectly it was hard to not think it had to be so. Thousands of children are stolen from their towns across the country (the parallel to the Children of Hamelin was just too good to miss) by a shadowy group known as the Snatchers, who obviously had to have a powerful backer (that could fit the Pied Piper figure) that probably had some sort of axe to grind with the Royal Family of Menaiya (who could fit the figure of the burgomaster that refused to pay the Piper), and finally there's the protagonist, turnfoot Amraeya, who investigates the disappearances on behalf of her best friend and uncovers a vast web of human trafficking and child slavery that reaches the highest echelons of government. Those who read the fairy tale will recall that the way the disappeared Children of Hamelin are found is due to a child left behind because he had a crippled foot and couldn't move as fast as the rest of the children. See a parallel to Rae? I sure do!
So, with all those key elements neatly and seamlessly woven into the storyline, who'd blame me for thinking The Theft of Sunlight is a "Pied Piper of Hamelin" retelling? And the ending and the lack of confirmation in the author's note hasn't convinced me of the contrary. Hey, Intisar, if you're reading this, I do firmly believe this novel is totally worth advertising as a retelling! The idea of rehashing the tale's core plot into a story of slavery and human trafficking is actually brilliant. Please, consider labelling it as such. Besides, I've not seen yet a retelling of the Piper fairy tale that was either good or to my liking, and this is the best out there for me.
Back to the story itself, I liked Rae best. I liked that she is no self-pitying pushover, and I liked that she doesn't define herself by her disability even when the rest of the world does. I think characterisation is the strength of the novel, because all characters are well-defined and have a distinctive voice. The protagonist (and Alyrra from Thorn, too) is down-to-Earth, practical and sensible, sometimes a bit uncouth and blunt, but always genuine. The male characters are less defined, however, probably because of the POV structure. There is no romance for the lead character as yet, which I find intriguing because it doesn't distract from the plot and it leaves up in the air which of the men might end up tangled in Rae's web (I have a horse in this race, but I'm not telling yet!).
There's a detail about the writing in this book that some readers might not like: the present tense first person prose. I never cared whether the narration was in first person POV or present tense, and still don't, because I consider it a matter of personal taste, but I do know a fair number of readers that can't stand first person narration, and present tense narration even less, so I'm putting this out there for their benefit.
But the novel's one big downside, and Intisar herself acknowledges this in her author's note, is the ending. It's a brutal cliffhanger! I cannot see how the book wouldn't have ended in suspense without making it into a big fat brick over 800 pages long because the story is barely halfway through when it ends, but I do believe there was a way to soften the cliffhanger so the landing wouldn't hurt. Perhaps even add one more chapter (or lengthen the last one) so that the harsh note it ends in isn't as grating. It practically pulls you out of the story and tosses you out the window, and no reader likes that. I can only hope the wait for the sequel won't take too long, because the uncertainty about the fate of the protagonist is going to kill me otherwise.
April 14, 2021
4.5 stars
Headlines:
Slavery
Changing perspectives
Trust and betrayal
Oh you didn't...
I slipped into the writing of The Theft of Sunlight with such ease and comfort. It was a joy to be back into the world and to enjoy Intisar Khanani's writing. I didn't need a Thorn recap because I found it to be such a memorable read.
It was utterly clever to be back with the characters of Thorn but from a different perspective. Alyrra was not the MC but she was a huge part of the story, viewed from Rae (Amraeya) the MC's story. Rae was not from a noble family but found herself amongst the royal family. Rae was daring, brave and stupid all at once and she had a disability that was so well written. That disability didn't define her.
I may be a bit roughed up around the edges, but I'm holding together.
This was a story about slavery, with some difficult themes and sometimes some difficult scenes. I appreciated the author's willingness to take the story into this territory in YA and I was utterly gripped and cared about what was happening in these lands.
Magic remained on the agenda but it wasn't conveyed in a positive light. The plot overarching this series involving magic, curses, wards and mages has a dark vibe and I'm eager to know more.
There was a little promise of affection and romance but not much beyond suggestion, that felt the right kind of pitch but I foresee Rae's story going further. Right now I'm trying to forget where we've been left with probably a year before the next book but I will wait as patient as I can for anything Intisar writes.
I thoroughly enjoyed this second book in the Dauntless Path series and I cannot wait to read on.
Thank you to the author for the early review copy.
Find this review at A Take From Two Citie Blog.
Headlines:
Slavery
Changing perspectives
Trust and betrayal
Oh you didn't...
I slipped into the writing of The Theft of Sunlight with such ease and comfort. It was a joy to be back into the world and to enjoy Intisar Khanani's writing. I didn't need a Thorn recap because I found it to be such a memorable read.
It was utterly clever to be back with the characters of Thorn but from a different perspective. Alyrra was not the MC but she was a huge part of the story, viewed from Rae (Amraeya) the MC's story. Rae was not from a noble family but found herself amongst the royal family. Rae was daring, brave and stupid all at once and she had a disability that was so well written. That disability didn't define her.
I may be a bit roughed up around the edges, but I'm holding together.
This was a story about slavery, with some difficult themes and sometimes some difficult scenes. I appreciated the author's willingness to take the story into this territory in YA and I was utterly gripped and cared about what was happening in these lands.
Magic remained on the agenda but it wasn't conveyed in a positive light. The plot overarching this series involving magic, curses, wards and mages has a dark vibe and I'm eager to know more.
There was a little promise of affection and romance but not much beyond suggestion, that felt the right kind of pitch but I foresee Rae's story going further. Right now I'm trying to forget where we've been left with probably a year before the next book but I will wait as patient as I can for anything Intisar writes.
I thoroughly enjoyed this second book in the Dauntless Path series and I cannot wait to read on.
Thank you to the author for the early review copy.
Find this review at A Take From Two Citie Blog.
September 17, 2021
Okay, let’s get to it! This was one of my most anticipated releases of 2021 since I read Thorn in December and was blown away by it.
I wish the rating system went higher than five stars, cause this deserves so much more!
This sequel met every expectation and surpassed them all! I was hooked from the very first page until the last. There’s so much layering of court intrigue, betrayals and subterfuge! You don’t know who Amraeya can trust and who she should avoid. You’re just tense reading this as so many things unfold and Amraeya doesn’t back down. She’s such a strong, determined girl who is so relatable and down to earth. I love her so much! 🥰
This book deals with the topic of human trafficking and the slave trade. It deals with the brutality of what the basest of humans will do to each other, driven by greed and power. It shows the corruption of higher powers involved that fail to live up to their oaths to protect their citizenry. And our dear Amraeya staunchly combats all of this even though it’s all so much bigger than her. She doesn’t back down, and that’s what makes this such a powerful read.
It ends on a cliffhanger that just sucker punched me in the gut and I don’t know how I can survive until the next book releases in July of 2022!!! 😱 That seems an impossible ways off and I need answers NOW!! How will Bren react?! Who tells Alyrra what’s happened?! I need answers now!
The characters in this are all so well developed I feel like they’re real living people. The banter between Amraeya & Bren is everything!! And despite my shipping them, I love that this book doesn’t focus on romance (shocker right? Every YA book focuses too hard on romance, which often fails to win me over, and ends up taking away from the actual plot). So this was such a refreshing read that actually puts focus on the plot and I’m just in awe of it!
Seriously pick up this series! If you like well developed plots that are the focus, fully fleshed out characters, high stakes political intrigue, and a badass heroine who never gives up, then you need to read this!
I wish the rating system went higher than five stars, cause this deserves so much more!
This sequel met every expectation and surpassed them all! I was hooked from the very first page until the last. There’s so much layering of court intrigue, betrayals and subterfuge! You don’t know who Amraeya can trust and who she should avoid. You’re just tense reading this as so many things unfold and Amraeya doesn’t back down. She’s such a strong, determined girl who is so relatable and down to earth. I love her so much! 🥰
This book deals with the topic of human trafficking and the slave trade. It deals with the brutality of what the basest of humans will do to each other, driven by greed and power. It shows the corruption of higher powers involved that fail to live up to their oaths to protect their citizenry. And our dear Amraeya staunchly combats all of this even though it’s all so much bigger than her. She doesn’t back down, and that’s what makes this such a powerful read.
It ends on a cliffhanger that just sucker punched me in the gut and I don’t know how I can survive until the next book releases in July of 2022!!! 😱 That seems an impossible ways off and I need answers NOW!! How will Bren react?! Who tells Alyrra what’s happened?! I need answers now!
The characters in this are all so well developed I feel like they’re real living people. The banter between Amraeya & Bren is everything!! And despite my shipping them, I love that this book doesn’t focus on romance (shocker right? Every YA book focuses too hard on romance, which often fails to win me over, and ends up taking away from the actual plot). So this was such a refreshing read that actually puts focus on the plot and I’m just in awe of it!
Seriously pick up this series! If you like well developed plots that are the focus, fully fleshed out characters, high stakes political intrigue, and a badass heroine who never gives up, then you need to read this!
March 23, 2024
I really enjoyed the first book in this series, Thorn. I loved the character development of the main character, Alyrra and how she reluctantly takes her place in society as a selfless act to save Kestrin and the people of Menaiya. I am thankful that Alyrra (and Kestrin) were prominent characters in Theft of Darkness as I did not love the main character in this book, Rae. I liked her, and I "got" the issues she was dealing with, but I did not love her as I had loved Alyrra's character. To be fair, Rae had her strengths and weaknesses as we all do. And she clearly has character development in her future... it just takes a while to get her there. (Read on!)
Rae's Strengths: protective, loving/caring, no-nonsense, direct, observant, hard-working, and willing to admit when she is wrong
Rae's Weaknesses: due to her disability, over-compensates with anger and judgement toward others; headstrong; demanding.
Rae is a strong character who constantly has to put up with physical pain and slights from others due to her club foot. Due to this, she has a bias against "beautiful" people that she struggles to get past so we see her judging people based on this. Her story arc is clearly about her finding freedom from this, as, in the short story, The Bone Knife, Stonemane tells her she should love her body more (or something like that). During Theft, we hear this repeated in Rae's thoughts.
🚨🚨🚨Spoiler🚨🚨🚨
🟢🟢🟢End of Spoilers🟢🟢🟢
This is a heavy book at times due to the overarching theme of the difficulties of ending human trafficking. I appreciate that the author tackled this issue. However, I do feel that the intensity of Rae's mission is a bit muted due to there not really being a search for a specific person. She is on a mission to help stop the snatchers, but I guess she feels that chasing down her best friend's sister is unrealistic at this point. However, I think we needed more of a connection to a specific search of someone Rae loved in order to develop urgency in the reader.
For some reason I knew right from the introduction of a certain character that s/he was "the bad guy," so that aspect was a bit of a let down. I knew this person couldn't be trusted, but I cannot say exactly why.
Overall, a very good read, just not *quite* as enjoyable as Thorn. I look forward to the next book to see how the author wraps this story up because I sense that I will care for Rae much more in Darkness At the Door. Just a feeling.
Edit to add: That feeling proved true! Reading Theft, then right away, Darkness, was very fulfilling, and I really enjoyed Rae's character! Changed rating to 4 🌟 !
Rae's Strengths: protective, loving/caring, no-nonsense, direct, observant, hard-working, and willing to admit when she is wrong
Rae's Weaknesses: due to her disability, over-compensates with anger and judgement toward others; headstrong; demanding.
Rae is a strong character who constantly has to put up with physical pain and slights from others due to her club foot. Due to this, she has a bias against "beautiful" people that she struggles to get past so we see her judging people based on this. Her story arc is clearly about her finding freedom from this, as, in the short story, The Bone Knife, Stonemane tells her she should love her body more (or something like that). During Theft, we hear this repeated in Rae's thoughts.
🚨🚨🚨Spoiler🚨🚨🚨
🟢🟢🟢End of Spoilers🟢🟢🟢
This is a heavy book at times due to the overarching theme of the difficulties of ending human trafficking. I appreciate that the author tackled this issue. However, I do feel that the intensity of Rae's mission is a bit muted due to there not really being a search for a specific person. She is on a mission to help stop the snatchers, but I guess she feels that chasing down her best friend's sister is unrealistic at this point. However, I think we needed more of a connection to a specific search of someone Rae loved in order to develop urgency in the reader.
For some reason I knew right from the introduction of a certain character that s/he was "the bad guy," so that aspect was a bit of a let down. I knew this person couldn't be trusted, but I cannot say exactly why.
Overall, a very good read, just not *quite* as enjoyable as Thorn. I look forward to the next book to see how the author wraps this story up because I sense that I will care for Rae much more in Darkness At the Door. Just a feeling.
Edit to add: That feeling proved true! Reading Theft, then right away, Darkness, was very fulfilling, and I really enjoyed Rae's character! Changed rating to 4 🌟 !
March 10, 2021
Thank you to NetGalley, HarperTeen, and the author- Intisar Khanani for the ebook arc of The Theft of Sunlight. I received the arc free of charge and it was my choice to read and review.
Wow, Intisar has done it again guys!
I was skeptical because I loved Princess Alyrra from Thorn so I wasn't sure about starting with a new character. Boy was I wrong! Rae is my new favorite. Plus, she and Alyrra get to interact closely so *thumbs up*
The Theft of Sunlight is the first book in a companion duology to Thorn and can be read on its own. But, as the author suggests: "it will be best appreciated if you pick up Thorn first. There are many familiar characters and a few possible spoilers for Thorn... but, if you'd rather not, you can still very much enjoy this book on its own."
This one was a slower burn than Thorn but I appreciated the depth that the slow burn brought to the plot and character development. By the halfway mark, I could not put it down and had to finish it.
If you like firey female characters who may seem like they are in the background but get up to all sorts of mischief-for the right reasons-and who fight against injustice, you'll love Rae-the MC of The Theft of Sunlight.
I also love the banter between characters that Intisar writes and this one was no exception. The chemistry is palpable but subtle at the same time, and it doesn't take centerstage or develop too quickly which I really appreciate.
Just like Thorn, I'll be recommending Theft A LOT!
TW: scenes of and discussion of violence against women, and issues of (in/)justice raised, and kidnapping of children (classified as YA so despite heavy themes, details are not shared in an "adult" way)
Wow, Intisar has done it again guys!
I was skeptical because I loved Princess Alyrra from Thorn so I wasn't sure about starting with a new character. Boy was I wrong! Rae is my new favorite. Plus, she and Alyrra get to interact closely so *thumbs up*
The Theft of Sunlight is the first book in a companion duology to Thorn and can be read on its own. But, as the author suggests: "it will be best appreciated if you pick up Thorn first. There are many familiar characters and a few possible spoilers for Thorn... but, if you'd rather not, you can still very much enjoy this book on its own."
This one was a slower burn than Thorn but I appreciated the depth that the slow burn brought to the plot and character development. By the halfway mark, I could not put it down and had to finish it.
If you like firey female characters who may seem like they are in the background but get up to all sorts of mischief-for the right reasons-and who fight against injustice, you'll love Rae-the MC of The Theft of Sunlight.
I also love the banter between characters that Intisar writes and this one was no exception. The chemistry is palpable but subtle at the same time, and it doesn't take centerstage or develop too quickly which I really appreciate.
Just like Thorn, I'll be recommending Theft A LOT!
TW: scenes of and discussion of violence against women, and issues of (in/)justice raised, and kidnapping of children (classified as YA so despite heavy themes, details are not shared in an "adult" way)
Want to read
June 4, 2020Wishlist | Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Pinterest
#0.5 The Bone Knife - ★★★★
#1 The Theft of Sunlight - Anticipating in 2021
#0.5 The Bone Knife - ★★★★
#1 The Theft of Sunlight - Anticipating in 2021
August 8, 2021
I loved being back in this world, but it ends on a cliffhanger and that made me so :-/
You can watch me discuss the book in my July wrap up: https://youtu.be/f6wmudTzrno
You can watch me discuss the book in my July wrap up: https://youtu.be/f6wmudTzrno
October 9, 2022
4.5 stars
October 20, 2022
Getting to the last page and realizing I'll get no closure with this utterly agonizing cliff hanger......
As each page I turned brought me closer to the end of this book, the situation went from bad to worse to wow, that's going to need more than a Band-Aid.
Why? Why did this author make me love these characters and then leave me abandoned, for God only knows how long, until she finishes the trilogy?!? I was hoping this book came out a few years ago, so we might be a little closer to the next, but nope. It came out this year.
But I will be patient. I will display these books, with their absolutely stunning covers, on my bookshelf proudly. Because these stories are captivating and the writing is utterly atmospheric. Every description of spiced potatoes, flatbread, embroidered silk, mint tea, and velvet lined slippers is so very lovely. Not to mention, I'm feeling a little cheated in the fact that my wedding only lasted one day.
I totally saw betrayal coming a mile away, but I don't even care. This book was so good. I like how Thorn was more of a fairy tale retelling, yet The Theft of Sunlight was like a fast paced mystery. I enjoyed Rae's perspective just as much as I did Alyrra's. I can't wait to see whose perspective the third book will be in. I'd actually love for it to jump between multiple point of views. And considering where this book left off, I think it'll have to.
After reading The Bone Knife, I thought for sure Stonemane was going to be Rae's love interest. While I do like his character, we saw so little of him. And then came Bren and his and Rae's banter is perfection. I can't wait to find out right along with Rae if he is indeed the man in charge. The fact that Rae thinks she'll never have love because of her foot, means she better get a happily ever after. She is such a brilliant character, so full of anger and self doubt, yet willingly to fiercely fight for those who have no one left to fight for them.
Intisar Khanani, you have created characters that I find incredibly dear. I am ridiculously invested in this world. Somehow this author has managed to take difficult subjects like abuse, corruption, poverty, self-worth, child-trafficking, and greed with an astounding amount of grace. Even in this ugly world, I still see things like kindness, courage, friendship, loyalty, and people willing to fight on behalf of those who can't. The finale can't come soon enough.
*Upon a second re-read, I desperately want to try almond milk with orange water and I 100% agree with Melly, life is absolutely better after tea and biscuits.
Favorite Quotes:
My body tightens again, as if anger were a thing I'm use to cradling within me. I can't seem to find a way to lay it down. To let go of the resentment within me. Why must I always be made aware of how others see me? I don't want to keep carrying this sense of being judged and found lacking. I don't want to be made to feel less just because my foot is turned one way instead of another. It still bears me forward every day of my life.
“People are stupid wherever you go. That doesn't mean you should never leave home.”
I trust you to stand by the values and principles your father and I taught you, to do what is right- not just what is easy and desirable, but what is ethically right. I trust you to take care of those around you, to fight for those who need you, fiercely protective sister and friend that you are. But Rae, I also urge you to take care of yourself.
This is the difference between me and the foreign prince, for his is a practiced violence, and mine was a single act regretted. That I am not the same as him for all that I was willing to let my anger ride me as it does him. I am, and can, and will be different. I do not have to let this break me.
"I like to push people. I especially like to push you, Rae, because you're clever and you push back."
I will not go willingly into this nightmare of his making. I will not accept the darkness and violence of the thieves and sailors, the slavers who surround me. I will learn every aspect of what they do and then I will undo them, destroy them, whether the law aids me or not. This I promise myself in the darkness of the hold.
As each page I turned brought me closer to the end of this book, the situation went from bad to worse to wow, that's going to need more than a Band-Aid.
Why? Why did this author make me love these characters and then leave me abandoned, for God only knows how long, until she finishes the trilogy?!? I was hoping this book came out a few years ago, so we might be a little closer to the next, but nope. It came out this year.
But I will be patient. I will display these books, with their absolutely stunning covers, on my bookshelf proudly. Because these stories are captivating and the writing is utterly atmospheric. Every description of spiced potatoes, flatbread, embroidered silk, mint tea, and velvet lined slippers is so very lovely. Not to mention, I'm feeling a little cheated in the fact that my wedding only lasted one day.
I totally saw betrayal coming a mile away, but I don't even care. This book was so good. I like how Thorn was more of a fairy tale retelling, yet The Theft of Sunlight was like a fast paced mystery. I enjoyed Rae's perspective just as much as I did Alyrra's. I can't wait to see whose perspective the third book will be in. I'd actually love for it to jump between multiple point of views. And considering where this book left off, I think it'll have to.
After reading The Bone Knife, I thought for sure Stonemane was going to be Rae's love interest. While I do like his character, we saw so little of him. And then came Bren and his and Rae's banter is perfection. I can't wait to find out right along with Rae if he is indeed the man in charge. The fact that Rae thinks she'll never have love because of her foot, means she better get a happily ever after. She is such a brilliant character, so full of anger and self doubt, yet willingly to fiercely fight for those who have no one left to fight for them.
Intisar Khanani, you have created characters that I find incredibly dear. I am ridiculously invested in this world. Somehow this author has managed to take difficult subjects like abuse, corruption, poverty, self-worth, child-trafficking, and greed with an astounding amount of grace. Even in this ugly world, I still see things like kindness, courage, friendship, loyalty, and people willing to fight on behalf of those who can't. The finale can't come soon enough.
*Upon a second re-read, I desperately want to try almond milk with orange water and I 100% agree with Melly, life is absolutely better after tea and biscuits.
Favorite Quotes:
My body tightens again, as if anger were a thing I'm use to cradling within me. I can't seem to find a way to lay it down. To let go of the resentment within me. Why must I always be made aware of how others see me? I don't want to keep carrying this sense of being judged and found lacking. I don't want to be made to feel less just because my foot is turned one way instead of another. It still bears me forward every day of my life.
“People are stupid wherever you go. That doesn't mean you should never leave home.”
I trust you to stand by the values and principles your father and I taught you, to do what is right- not just what is easy and desirable, but what is ethically right. I trust you to take care of those around you, to fight for those who need you, fiercely protective sister and friend that you are. But Rae, I also urge you to take care of yourself.
This is the difference between me and the foreign prince, for his is a practiced violence, and mine was a single act regretted. That I am not the same as him for all that I was willing to let my anger ride me as it does him. I am, and can, and will be different. I do not have to let this break me.
"I like to push people. I especially like to push you, Rae, because you're clever and you push back."
I will not go willingly into this nightmare of his making. I will not accept the darkness and violence of the thieves and sailors, the slavers who surround me. I will learn every aspect of what they do and then I will undo them, destroy them, whether the law aids me or not. This I promise myself in the darkness of the hold.
August 19, 2022
I loved this book so much, it’s a story about a young woman who is often overlooked and underestimated but she is capable of so much more than anyone gives her credit for and it resonated with me deeply.
Rae isn’t like the usual fantasy heroines we see, she doesn’t have secret magic powers, she’s an average girl who has a family and doesn’t have a tragic backstory. She is however a young woman who will protect those she loves and will fight for the people who no one else will fight for. I think this made her so much more relatable and real because she could be any of us. She is smart and resourceful and she perseveres no matter what obstacles are put in her path. She is kind and empathetic but also knows that not everyone is trustworthy and is cautious about who she trusts.
I assure you I am well aware of what I am capable of
She also has a disability and it affects her mobility which means she is often underestimated and overlooked, she is seen as less capable but I really loved how she didn’t allow that stop her from protecting her loved ones and seeking justice. Her internal conflict was so relatable as someone who also has a mobility disability, I really felt for her, how she will sometimes push herself too far and that fear of being looked down on or pitied if someone finds out about her disability, how her disability is the only thing anyone sees. I loved her arc and how she realises her disability may affect some things that she can do but it doesn’t define her and only she decides who she is.
I also completely fell in love with Bren from the first moment we meet him. From his first conversation with Rae I loved their interactions and how he looked out for Rae right from the beginning without making her feel helpless or self-conscious about her disability. He never thinks less of Rae because of her disability and I just loved that so much. He sees her for who she really is and not just a helpless girl. I loved their banter and sass and how they worked together. It was such an interesting dynamic between them as Bren is a thief and Rae doesn’t always approve of things in his life but she accepts him for who he is. Some of my favourite scenes were between them two.
She has more power than the stories grant her.
It was also great to see Thorn again and especially see her happy with Kestrin and how she dealt with her family. I loved seeing their wedding celebrations and it reminded me of a big fat desi wedding! The beautiful clothes and all the functions and food and traditions. I just loved seeing it in the book. It was also a great contrast between the rich and the poor and how different the lives of nobles are compared to the average citizen.
There is also discussions of the violence women face and how they have to adjust the way they live and how they don’t always feel safe. Even Thorn has to deal with this and it was chilling because it was her brother and he was enabled by those around him who didn’t hold him accountable, instead ignoring what he did to her. The comparisons to how this happens a lot in our society was easy to see and I could relate to how Thorn and Rae felt.
While this is a character driven book where we see everything from Rae’s point of view we also got to explore a lot more of the world outside and the politics of the nobles too and how the nobles ignored what was happening to the children as it didn’t affect them directly. We see how it affects Rae and the frustrations she feels and it makes her more determined to help, it was interesting to see Thorn as her ally but she was also limited in many ways because of the politics at play. The end of this book and the plot twists and revelations shook me, I was not expecting them at all. And then the book ends in a cliffhanger which has me dying for the next book!
As much as we ask for help. We have to help ourselves.
I highly recommend this wonderful story with a main character you will fall in love with and root for and I cannot wait for the sequel as there are things which were alluded to in this book that I think will come into play in the sequel, especially the fae angle! Everyone please go read this book!
Rae isn’t like the usual fantasy heroines we see, she doesn’t have secret magic powers, she’s an average girl who has a family and doesn’t have a tragic backstory. She is however a young woman who will protect those she loves and will fight for the people who no one else will fight for. I think this made her so much more relatable and real because she could be any of us. She is smart and resourceful and she perseveres no matter what obstacles are put in her path. She is kind and empathetic but also knows that not everyone is trustworthy and is cautious about who she trusts.
I assure you I am well aware of what I am capable of
She also has a disability and it affects her mobility which means she is often underestimated and overlooked, she is seen as less capable but I really loved how she didn’t allow that stop her from protecting her loved ones and seeking justice. Her internal conflict was so relatable as someone who also has a mobility disability, I really felt for her, how she will sometimes push herself too far and that fear of being looked down on or pitied if someone finds out about her disability, how her disability is the only thing anyone sees. I loved her arc and how she realises her disability may affect some things that she can do but it doesn’t define her and only she decides who she is.
I also completely fell in love with Bren from the first moment we meet him. From his first conversation with Rae I loved their interactions and how he looked out for Rae right from the beginning without making her feel helpless or self-conscious about her disability. He never thinks less of Rae because of her disability and I just loved that so much. He sees her for who she really is and not just a helpless girl. I loved their banter and sass and how they worked together. It was such an interesting dynamic between them as Bren is a thief and Rae doesn’t always approve of things in his life but she accepts him for who he is. Some of my favourite scenes were between them two.
She has more power than the stories grant her.
It was also great to see Thorn again and especially see her happy with Kestrin and how she dealt with her family. I loved seeing their wedding celebrations and it reminded me of a big fat desi wedding! The beautiful clothes and all the functions and food and traditions. I just loved seeing it in the book. It was also a great contrast between the rich and the poor and how different the lives of nobles are compared to the average citizen.
There is also discussions of the violence women face and how they have to adjust the way they live and how they don’t always feel safe. Even Thorn has to deal with this and it was chilling because it was her brother and he was enabled by those around him who didn’t hold him accountable, instead ignoring what he did to her. The comparisons to how this happens a lot in our society was easy to see and I could relate to how Thorn and Rae felt.
While this is a character driven book where we see everything from Rae’s point of view we also got to explore a lot more of the world outside and the politics of the nobles too and how the nobles ignored what was happening to the children as it didn’t affect them directly. We see how it affects Rae and the frustrations she feels and it makes her more determined to help, it was interesting to see Thorn as her ally but she was also limited in many ways because of the politics at play. The end of this book and the plot twists and revelations shook me, I was not expecting them at all. And then the book ends in a cliffhanger which has me dying for the next book!
As much as we ask for help. We have to help ourselves.
I highly recommend this wonderful story with a main character you will fall in love with and root for and I cannot wait for the sequel as there are things which were alluded to in this book that I think will come into play in the sequel, especially the fae angle! Everyone please go read this book!
April 28, 2021
Full Review on The Candid Cover
The Theft of Sunlight by Intisar Khanani is an intriguing companion novel to Thorn, the first book in the Dauntless Path series. The main character is fierce and exciting to read about and the story is full of adventure. Fans of the series will not be disappointed in this spin-off.
This story set in Menaiya, the same world as Thorn. It can, however, be read as a standalone, as it is about a whole new character and her experiences in the kingdom. Although, there may be some backstory about the characters and the way this world ticks that are missed. The Theft of Sunlight follows the storyline of “the snatchers” from the first book.
❀ FIERCE MAIN CHARACTER
Rae is a very likeable main character that is enjoyable to read about. She has a disability that impedes her ability to walk, yet she perseveres. Her bravery and determination are admirable and her ability to defend herself is incredibly fierce. This was my favourite aspect of the novel.
❀ ALYRRA IS CONFIDENT AND POISED
There are some scenes where we see glimpses of Alyrra from the first book. This is both exciting and interesting, as we see her role as princess through Rae’s perspective. Alyrra is more confident and poised in this story, which is a huge testament to her coming of age in Thorn. It is really enjoyable to see her assertive.
❀ NOT AS MAGICAL AS THORN
In comparison to Thorn, the magical aspect of the book is not as pronounced. There are scenes that involve mages and some terrifying moments aided by the use of magic. In general, though, the feel of the story is less magical. This did not affect my enjoyment of the novel, but I was just craving more of the fairy tale feel of the first book.
❀ A SERIES NOT TO BE MISSED
If you enjoy YA fantasy, Dauntless Path is a series that should not be missed. The characters and the world are so fantastic and the wiring is lovely. Unfortunately, The Theft of Sunlight ends on a wicked cliffhanger, so this book will leave you wanting more.
The Theft of Sunlight by Intisar Khanani is an intriguing companion novel to Thorn, the first book in the Dauntless Path series. The main character is fierce and exciting to read about and the story is full of adventure. Fans of the series will not be disappointed in this spin-off.
This story set in Menaiya, the same world as Thorn. It can, however, be read as a standalone, as it is about a whole new character and her experiences in the kingdom. Although, there may be some backstory about the characters and the way this world ticks that are missed. The Theft of Sunlight follows the storyline of “the snatchers” from the first book.
❀ FIERCE MAIN CHARACTER
Rae is a very likeable main character that is enjoyable to read about. She has a disability that impedes her ability to walk, yet she perseveres. Her bravery and determination are admirable and her ability to defend herself is incredibly fierce. This was my favourite aspect of the novel.
❀ ALYRRA IS CONFIDENT AND POISED
There are some scenes where we see glimpses of Alyrra from the first book. This is both exciting and interesting, as we see her role as princess through Rae’s perspective. Alyrra is more confident and poised in this story, which is a huge testament to her coming of age in Thorn. It is really enjoyable to see her assertive.
❀ NOT AS MAGICAL AS THORN
In comparison to Thorn, the magical aspect of the book is not as pronounced. There are scenes that involve mages and some terrifying moments aided by the use of magic. In general, though, the feel of the story is less magical. This did not affect my enjoyment of the novel, but I was just craving more of the fairy tale feel of the first book.
❀ A SERIES NOT TO BE MISSED
If you enjoy YA fantasy, Dauntless Path is a series that should not be missed. The characters and the world are so fantastic and the wiring is lovely. Unfortunately, The Theft of Sunlight ends on a wicked cliffhanger, so this book will leave you wanting more.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 736 reviews