I had no idea of the magnitude of the threat against Lincoln as he traveled to his inauguration. There is, of course, no way now for anyone to evaluate how accurate they were, but reports from Pinkerton and other sources placed the number of conspirators in the hundreds, perhaps thousands -- many of whom would have been the police (particularly in Baltimore) charged with protecting the president elect. Widmer traces the decisions Lincoln and his staff/associates made in an effort to make it to DC alive. To our modern sensibilities, it beggars belief how unprotected Lincoln was in his day to day activities. His train would make a scheduled stop in some city and there would be thousands and thousands of people waiting to see and hear them, and there was virtually no separation between them and Lincoln. He'd have to make his way through masses of people, any one of whom might have wanted him dead. People would climb onto the stage as he was delivering a speech and make comments about how tall he was.
As Widmer narrates Lincoln's trek to DC, he uses the opportunity to digress into the major trends that were taking place or that already begun and were now shaping events: the discovery of coal and oil deposits, the spread -- in the North, not matched in the South -- railroads, education, the telegraph (Some worried that it was actually driving them apart. In 1858, three days after the first Atlantic Cable connected New York and London, the New York Times asked if the news would become “too fast for the truth?”). This does occasionally slow the narrative down, of course, but more importantly, it does provide a better understanding of the time. The anger, the disruptive nature of technology, the furious polarization, the urge for power.
It is striking -- and more than a little disturbing -- how closely some things resembled our own time. The book was published in 2020, which means that he was writing it during the Trump years. Likely, the events of that period influenced how Widmer perceived things, and certainly how he might have chosen to describe them. For all that, the echoes are powerful. For example, one of the key fears Lincoln's people and others had involved the certification of electoral votes in Congress:
They [the votes] might be waylaid, or stolen by the armed militias who were increasingly seen marching around Washington, reporting to no one in particular. During the count, if it got that far, the Southern masters of Congress might declare a certificate unacceptable, simply because it looked wrong. Or they could appoint a committee to investigate voting discrepancies in November. Such a committee might take a very long time to reach a verdict—plenty of time for the Confederacy to establish itself.
Complicating things further, the person responsible then (as now) for delivering the EC votes was the Vice President, in this case John Breckinridge of Kentucky. Breckinridge was a strong supporter of slavery. As Widmer notes, "He had been the South’s candidate in the election, and he was the very person who would gain the most if the boxes were destroyed, or stolen, or simply misplaced." Breckinridge did his Constitutional duty. Sometime after the certification, Massachusetts senator Henry Dawes wrote, “We owe much to Mr. Breckinridge for the dignity and propriety of his conduct, though his heart was so thoroughly with the rebels he was among the earliest to join their army.”
The press was factious and irresponsible, politicians were hungry for attention and fame, citizens were all too easily manipulated And then, of course, there was the widespread sense (not at all irrational) that the American Experiment was nearing its end. The lessons of history were hard to ignore. Every democracy ever known had failed, beginning with the Greeks twenty-four centuries earlier. They had succumbed, one by one, to all the well-known vices of the people: corruption, greed, lust, ethnic hatred, distractibility, or simply a fatal indifference. Needless to say, the South was more than eager to break up the "United" states. Widmer quotes William Tecumseh Sherman's diary, where he "confessed his anguish at seeing Americans indulging in a 'glorious rejoicing at the downfall of our own country.' "
As others have noted, the book can be repetitious, but I took that to be a minor flaw. All in all, "Lincoln on the Verge" a very worthy contribution to the literature of the Civil War, filled with insight into Lincoln's personality and his development as a politician, and fascinating details, like: the NY Times describing New Jersey as “the South Carolina of the North;” that Wisconsin alone had 38 local time zones before railroad expansion made that situation unworkable; that Lincoln's train was greeted with enthusiastic crowds, rifle volleys, and cannon fire -- including... A few young movers and shakers, showing a little too much leadership, took it upon themselves to fire a celebratory cannon as Lincoln’s train approached. The only problem was that they managed to fire it directly into his train, taking out a section of the forward car, shattering three windows “into atoms,” covering passengers with broken glass, and terrifying everyone.