Hoffman took advantage of the success of the Hamilton musical to put out this paper and, as a result, I expected it to focus more particularly on the Federalist papers themselves and on Hamilton's overwhelming contribution to those papers, at least in terms of number written. However, Hoffman focuses more on some of the history surrounding the Constitution than the Federalist Papers themselves, making this series of lectures more of a combined history of both the Constitution and the Federalist Papers, and not doing an complete job at either. In particular, Hoffman focuses much more on Madison than Hamilton, leaving those inspired to learn more about the Papers from the musical disappointed and wondering more about Hamilton's contributions and legacy.
By themselves, the lectures are engaging and Hoffman does an adequate job providing an introduction to the main principles of the Constitution, the Amendments, and some of the arguments laid out in the Federalist Papers. However, I think this lecture series would have been better if it had been laid out over several parts. One covering the debates leading up to the Constitution, one covering the drafting of the Constitution, one covering the Federalist Papers and the need for such an interpretation immediately after the Constitutional Convention, one on the Bill of Rights and the Amendments, and one on unresolved issues. Hoffman covers these topics and many will find these essays sufficient to satisfy their interest following a viewing of Hamilton on Disney Plus, but Hoffman leaves too many hints at deeper debates and more historical points for these lectures to meet their potential.