小說 魔法少女☆小圓

by Hajime Ninomae, Magica Quartet

Genres: Light Novel, Manga

240 pages, Paperback

First published May 8, 2012

Reviews

[Laura · Rating 3 out of 5]

2.8
comprei esse livro faz um tempinho e parei no quinto capítulo quando comecei a ler. terminei ele hoje e ainda não tenho um sentimento fixo: gosto muito do anime e senti que ele seguiu bastante da cronologia da história, apesar de ser um pouco maçante para quem já viu (a história da novel não tem plot adicional). veremos..
acréscimo: os erros da falta de uma revisão séria matam muito plmds

[Cactuar Tamer · Rating 2 out of 5]

So, I'm three chapters in at this point and I'm just going to go ahead and write this review. I doubt I'll have much cause to change it.

This book is... breathtakingly mediocre, and the more I read of it the more disappointed I get, because it could have been so much more.

Unfortunately, I can't really recommend this if you've already seen the television show, unless you fancy a book that differs only very superficially from a line-by-line retelling of ever scene in the show, exactly as it happened on screen.

I think this decision to be so unwaveringly "loyal" to the source material is what really kills this book. There was so much opportunity in writing a novel of this series to show us things that happened but couldn't get that much attention in the show, a chance to flesh out a lot of minor features and to get inside the heads of characters like Mami, Kyouko, Sayaka... maybe even Kyuubey!

...Which brings me to my second big complaint. The author has really limited themselves and the story by deciding to go tell the entire thing exclusively from Madoka's First Person perspective. The narrative has been bent to accommodate that to some extent... scenes for which she was not present are relayed to her as expository dialog and things that were originally other characters' internal thought processes are said out loud so that Madoka, and by extension, the reader, may perceive them.

The limited perspective is possibly the worst thing about the book, after all, as I think I could have born a bland retelling if I at least got the opportunity to inhabit the heads of various characters while doing it.

Some nice vignettes not present in the original have been added, such as an extended conversation between Madoka and her father, which do add flavor, but it isn't quite enough to overcome the book's problems.

In the end there's nothing really all that bad about the book itself, but there's nothing good about it either.

[Natiori Hen · Rating 4 out of 5]

Eu daria 3.5
Tudo é muito expositivo. A madoka é fofinha e tal, mas dá um pouco de raiva dela as vezes.
A parte narrada pela Homura é o que salva toda a história, na minha opinião.

[Pedro · Rating 5 out of 5]

uma experiência tão boa quanto assistir ao anime.

[Jess · Rating 5 out of 5]

This novel is a nice complement to the anime, since it follows it thoroughly but with extra emotions.

[Ana · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.8⭐️

[Dmitria Guimarães · Rating 4 out of 5]

sem querer comprei a edição em livro…super mal revisado (cheio de erro de concordância verbal e typo), fora isso d boas

[Patchara · Rating 4 out of 5]

ฉบับนิยายดำเนินเรื่องเหมือนในอนิเมะทุกอย่าง แต่พอเล่าเรื่องจากมุมมองของมาโดกะแล้วรู้สึกว่าเรื่องเวทมนตร์ไม่ใช่จุดเด่นของเรื่องอีกต่อไป มันไม่ใช่นิยายสาวน้อยเวทมนตร์ด้วยซ้ำ แต่เป็นดราม่าของเด็กผู้หญิงช่วงมัธยมต้น ซึ่งเป็นวัยเปลี่ยนผ่าน จะเป็นเด็กก็ไม่ใช่ จะเป็นสาวก็ไม่เชิง