It is a textbook; how much am I supposed to like it?
#1: It is way to freaking expensive! It should be half the damned price it was. And, sadly, there was a 9th ed. just out when we got this but that would've been even more expensive.
Anyway, we read about 4/5th of this book before we moved on to other grammar topics (TG) so I am counting it as read. Looking back through the index I think I will go ahead and finish the rest, also, as it could be useful.
I think it was a fairly effective text for standard grammar and Reed-Kellogg diagramming, but, honestly, I haven't read/used any other grammar texts so I have no standard of comparison.