An Extravagant Death

Charles Lenox Mysteries #11

by Charles Finch

In what promises to be a breakout in Charles Finch's bestselling series, Charles Lenox travels to the New York and Newport of the dawning Gilded Age to investigate the death of a beautiful socialite.

London, 1878. With faith in Scotland Yard shattered after a damning corruption investigation, Charles Lenox's detective agency is rapidly expanding. The gentleman sleuth has all the work he can handle, two children, and an intriguing new murder case.

But when Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli offers him the opportunity to undertake a diplomatic mission for the Queen, Lenox welcomes the chance to satisfy an unfulfilled to travel to America. Arriving in New York, he begins to receive introductions into both its old Knickerbocker society and its new robber baron splendor. Then, a the death of the season's most beautiful debutante, who appears to have thrown herself from a cliff. Or was it murder? Lenox’s reputation has preceded him to the States, and he is summoned to a magnificent Newport mansion to investigate the mysterious death. What ensues is a fiendish game of cat and mouse.

Witty, complex, and tender, An Extravagant Death is Charles Finch's triumphant return to the main storyline of his beloved Charles Lenox series—a devilish mystery, a social drama, and an unforgettable first trip for an Englishman coming to America.

Genres: Mystery, Historical Fiction, Fiction, Historical Mystery, Historical, Audiobook, Crime

304 pages, Kindle Edition

First published February 16, 2021

About the author

Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads' database with this name. See this thread for more information.

My name is Charles Finch - welcome! I'm the author of the Charles Lenox series of historical mysteries, as well as a recent novel about expatriate life in Oxford, THE LAST ENCHANTMENTS. I also write book reviews for the New York Times, USA Today, and the Chicago Tribune and essays in many different places.

Like most people on this website, I'm a huge reader. My taste is all over the place, though I tend to really like literary and mystery fiction. Some of my favorite writers: George Orwell, Henry Green, Dick Francis, Anthony Trollope, David Lodge, PG Wodehouse, Bill Bryson, Roberto Bolano, Jonathan Franzen, Shirley Hazzard, Leo Tolstoy, AR Ammons, Philip Larkin, Edgar Bowers, Laurent Binet, Laurie Colwin, Jane Austen, Arthur Conan Doyle, Philip Roth, Henrik Ibsen, Geoff Dyer, the list could go forever...

A bit about myself: I was born in New York City, and since then I've lived all over the place, in America, England, France...at the moment I'm in Chicago, where I just recently moved. I spend most of my time here writing, reading, walking my dog, and trying not to let my ears freeze off.

You can find me on Facebook (facebook.com/charlesfinchauthor) where my reader are always giving fantastic book reviews, or Twitter (twitter.com/charlesfinch) which I don't like quite as much, though it's okay. I'll also try to blog here. Please let me know what I'm doing wrong, since I have remedial goodreads skills...

Reviews

[Charles Finch · Rating 5 out of 5]

I give this book a very unbiased five stars :) Out in February!

[PamG · Rating 4 out of 5]

An Extravagant Death by Charles Finch is a historical mystery set in 1878 and 1879 and is set in London, New York, and Rhode Island. Queen Victoria is on the throne and Benjamin Disraeli is the Prime Minister. Despite this novel being the fourteenth book in the series, I had no problem connecting with the characters and the time.

The protagonist, Charles Lenox, is the leading and most distinguished detective in England. He had once been a Member of Parliament, but now has his own detective agency. He has just wrapped up a case that involved corruption within Scotland Yard. When called to the Prime Minister’s office, he is asked to undertake a diplomatic mission for the Queen. After some thought and persuasion, he accepts and arrives in New York. After meeting with both the police and members of society, he heads to Boston, but is stopped in route and asked to go to Newport, Rhode Island. A debutant is dead. Is it suicide, an accident, or murder?

Charles is an engaging character and definitely someone you want to succeed. His flaws only served to endear him to this reader. He also showed growth and some character change during the course of the story. The secondary characters had varying degrees of depth, but it was sufficient for their roles in the story line.

The author does a fantastic job of giving the reader a strong sense of time and place. The cultural elements seemed accurate and made the reading experience an immersive one. However, this is not a thriller. It takes a while to get to the debutant’s death, but I did not mind the slower pace. I was having too much fun enjoying the society of 1878 in London and New York. Themes included political maneuvering, social classes, treatment of others, old money versus new money, differences between England and America, death, grief, and much more.

Overall, this book is entertaining, humorous at times, and a well-done historical mystery. This is the first novel that I have read by this author. I definitely want to read more of this series. If you like historical mysteries, then you may enjoy this one as much as I did.

I received a copy of this book from the St. Martin’s Press – Minotaur Books and Charles Finch in a Goodreads Giveaway. Opinions are mine alone and are not biased in any way. Publication date was February 16, 2021.

[Diane S ☔ · Rating 4 out of 5]

I usually have little trouble reading and keeping up with multiple books at the same time. This proved an exception, I readabout 20 percent and just wasn't getting into the book. I've read this series off and on over the years and enjoy the character of Lennox, us this one takes him to America and the wealthy enclave of so called cottages in Newport. So, I started over and read it straight through. That worked. This is a series that is slow moving but very atmospheric. The Gilded age is a fascinating one and coming from England the ostentatious appearance of wealth is one Lennox finds disconcerting.

When a young debutante is found dead at the bottom of the cliff stairs, Lennox with his reputation of detective extrodinaire, is asked to investigate. In the age before DNA, computers etc, all crimes are challenging to solve. There is much back and forth talking to the various old monied aristocrats, which provides some extraordinary looks at the opulent sceneries.

This is a whodunnit of the old kind, where the killer is fairly obscure till the end. Of course, it didn't turn out quite that easily for Lennox, nor did he find satisfaction in the revelation. Plus, I should mention, I didn't guess the person and was quite shocked by the reveal.

[Jenny · Rating 4 out of 5]

There are books that are really good. There are books that are really really good. Then - there are those very few books that are so good you want to reading slowly, savoring each page but yet can’t wait to turn that page to experience the new pleasure to be found there.
This is my third Charles Finch novel and I am anxiously awaiting many more.
In An Extravagant Death, super sleuth Sir Charles Lenox crosses the Atlantic using his extraordinary skills to investigate the murder of socialite Lily Allingham.
Only the request from the British Prime Minister could dislodge Sir Charles from his home, wife and daughters.
But the important request and Charles’ love of travel impel him to sail first to New York and then to Newport in the heydays of the Guilded Age.
In Newport Sir Charles learns of the 40 plus room “cottages”, the 60 foot yachts, the grand halls and the Astor’s “season” ending soirée.
But it is the famous Forty Steps along the Cliff Walk that is the most compelling area of Newport for this is where Lily Allingham’s body was found. Applying his masterful sleuthing skills, Sir Charles solves the mystery of Lily’s death.
Mix together a compelling mystery, a detective of extraordinary skill, vivid descriptions and unique characters and you have a real dilemma: when you turn the last page, do you celebrate the conclusion of a really fine mystery novel or does the finality of the novel wound you?
I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley. #NetGalley #AnExtravagantDeath

[Julie · Rating 3 out of 5]

I didn't enjoy this book as much as previous entries in the series. The location change didn't work for me, and I found I missed the usual cast of characters. The narrator's American accents left something to be desired. There were sections where I was drawn in, however there were also others that appeared to go overly long without action or resolution and I found I got distracted. The description of Newport, Rhode Island was interesting and I enjoyed the author's observations of some of the cultural differences between England and America.

[Vintagebooklvr · Rating 4 out of 5]

An enjoyable and well written story. And not a bad mystery either. Charles Lenox has left his usual stomping grounds of Great Britain for a tour through America before he is called to investigate a murder in Newport, RI. Finch has described in lavish detail the unbelievable opalescence of the U.S. Gilded Age at one of the heights of the dazzling display: the summer season and particularly the most fabulous and exclusive party of them all, that held by the Astors. I loved the amount of detail in the description but some may find it slows the middle of the book.

One of the strengths of this series is the complex recurring characters Finch has created and how they change through experience and time. Lenox once thought politics was what he wanted to do and detecting was a side line until he could be elected as a MP but once he achieved this dream for a few years he returned to detecting. Now, married to his early love and a father his priorities have changed once more, particularly after a life changing event in this case. Evolution and substantial aging of characters does not always occur in series and it is enjoyable to read this done well.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

[Jane · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 stars

You can read all of my reviews at Nerd Girl Loves Books.

This is the eleventh book in this series, but it's the first one that I've read. Despite that, I didn't have a hard time understanding what was going on. The mystery is a stand-alone and there is enough backstory throughout the book for me to get an understanding of the main characters.

The book starts out with private investigator Charles Lenox finishing up a lengthy investigation that uprooted crooked police officers. The trial is around the corner and because of various political pressures, the prime minister wants Charles to write out his testimony to be read at trial and be out of the country to avoid taking the stand. Charles initially refuses, but eventually relents and heads to America to represent Queen and country.

Once in New York City, Charles is swept up with invitations to attend society functions with both the old money and new money set. As he begins his trip to Boston to meet more people of consequence, his train is stopped and he is asked to go to Newport to investigate the death of the season's most beautiful debutante. Charles reluctantly makes his way to Newport, where he is sucked up into the world of the uber wealthy, and all that goes with it. Charles methodically investigates the case, carefully eliminating one suspect after another, until he discovers the killer.

This is a fun mystery with plenty of intrigue. It was interesting to read about the wealthy people and all of the trappings that go along with having money and being interested only in a person's standing in society. As I said before, there was enough backstory that I felt I understood Charles' character. The author did a good job of interspersing minor characters throughout the story and giving them just enough depth to add to the story, rather than detract. The mystery was interesting and the ending was pretty surprising. If there are more books in this series, I will definitely read them.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and St. Martin's Press. All opinions in this review are my own.

[eyes.2c · Rating 5 out of 5]

Vanderbilts, Astors, Stuyvesants! Lenox moves to American High Society!

An extravagant death! An interesting title and one worth contemplating post read. I think the clue to many things, including Charles last investigation, possibly pave the way for a turn of the page for Charles Lenox’s future.
It’s 1878 and Charles has been involved in a highly profiled dark investigation. Charles is now probably the most preeminent detective England.
Having been requested by the Prime Minister (Disraeli) to leave the country for a period whilst the trial is underway, Lady Jane encourages him to do what he’s always planned to do—travel.
Charles arrives in New York and through a set of circumstances ends up investigating the death of a young socialite, the fêted Lily Allingham, in Newport, near the famed Forty Steps along the Cliff Walk. The Cliff Walk is where the crème de la crème have their summer ‘cottages’. Charles’ impressions of the very rich in this part of the United States as contrasted to the titled but often much poorer aristocracy of England are noteworthy.
The glimpses of life led by the wealthy upper crust of New York, the absolute extravagance of their lifestyles is eye opening. And we learn something more about the circles Lady Jane can move in.
The food descriptions at Caroline Astor’s annual Newport Ball are staggering BTW.
With the help of the very earnest and pleasant ‘Teddy Blaine’, scion of a wealthy Newport family Charles moves forward with his investigations.
The resolution of Lily’s murder is somewhat of a shock, twisted and yet not, when you reflect.

A St. Martin's Press ARC via NetGalley

[Gail C. · Rating 4 out of 5]

A well written historical mystery, in a style reminiscent of the golden age of mysteries only this one takes place in the 1870’s in America. It still offers a sense of the English style of writing, featuring the famous English detective Charles Lenox in the ninth book of the series. This one is very much a standalone with Lenox traveling to America at Prime Minister Disraeli’s request.

Through Lenox, the reader has the opportunity to see a very young, very wealthy part of the United States as he is asked to investigate the murder of a young woman which took place during an elaborate balls given by one of the monied New York families who have a summer “cottage” on Newport, RI. These cottages are actually the huge estates built by wealthy families, some descended from the “Knickerbocker’s”, those families who are related to the original dutch who represent “old” money; and the “new” money families who owe much of their wealth to success in business and industry.

Although Lenox is asked to travel to America to keep him out of the limelight of a trial taking place in England, before he can get settled into his travel routine he is approached by the patriarch of one of the wealthy families to investigate the murder of young debutant Lily Allingham. Lily has been sought after by numerous young men as a bride because of her extreme beauty, and her body is found at the base of a cliff on his property.

At the same time he is making his way to Newport, Lenox is approached by Teddy (Theodore) Blaine, the youngest son of yet another extremely wealthy family. Teddy professes to be interested in becoming a detective and asks to be allowed to accompany Lenox as he investigates. Teddy soon makes his value know in terms of gathering information, and later demonstrating how much easier it is to get some doors to open just because of his family name.

Throughout the book, which can easily be read separate from the other books in the series, Leno makes observations, often of the difference between American society and that of the English. These observations include the differences in the show of wealth, the more casual manner of Americans, particularly those of the working class.

The entire book is a well crafted mystery that moves at a steady pace toward a satisfying conclusion. In the grand mystery style, there is not an overt amount of blood and gore, but rather a story that moves at a gentle pace that gives the reader time to sit and relax as they try to solve the puzzle. For anyone who enjoys books written in the style of Agatha Christie, with a good mystery, a logical conclusion, and pace that allows them to breathe, this is one not to be missed. My thanks to St. Martin’s Press, Minotaur Books; and NetGalley for providing me an advance copy of this book for review. The opinions stated here are entirely my own. Full review scheduled for publication at MysteryandSuspense.com on 1/20/21

[Barb in Maryland · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5 stars
Well, first off, ignore the blurb! Which is what I did. As a long-time fan of the series, the mere fact of a new Charles Lenox mystery was enough to have me diving right in.

Once again the author gives us an elegant, restrained, but never dull or boring, mystery. Lenox finds himself in the United States as the result of some political maneuvering by Prime Minister Disraeli. Lenox has a tour of the States planned, the first leg of which would take him from New York City to Boston. His reputation as a detective causes a detour to Newport, Rhode Island, where he is pressed into investigating the death of a young woman, a society debutante.

There is so much to enjoy here: the descriptions of NYC in 1878 (no skyscrapers!) and Newport (those elaborate 'cottages' of the rich); Lenox's outsider's take on the uneasy meshing of New York's old, Dutch ancestry, upper-crust (known as the Knickerbockers) and the newly rich, whose vast wealth has it base in trade (the Astors) or industry (the Vanderbilts); Lenox's letters home are so warm and loving.

The mystery was fairly straightforward: who killed Lily Allingham? One of her many suitors? An Outsider? A madman? As the obvious suspects are ruled out, who is left? I had a vague notion of who was the baddie, but that person's motive was a shocker. The final confrontation between Lenox and Person X was also a shocker.

I really enjoyed catching up with Lenox, the mature detective, after spending the three previous books with Lenox, the young, would-be detective. I am eager to find out what the author has next planned for his loyal readers.

ETA: I visited Newport a number of years ago and enjoyed gawking at the extravagant 'cottages'. Lenox was there in 1878, so he missed the Vanderbilt's 'Breakers' (1895) and 'Rosecliff' (1902, source of the cover illustration). However, he would have recognized 'Chepstow' (1860) and 'Kingscote' (1839, one of the first 'cottages').

[Sophia · Rating 5 out of 5]

After being the driving force behind the bust of biggest corruption scandal of the year, Charles is tired. He simply wants to spend time with his family and recuperate, but his life turns surreal when he ends up among the Knickerbocker Set and Nouveau Riche of New York and Newport during the glittering Season of America’s Gilded Age... Just in time for murder.

An Extravagant Death is the fourteenth of the Charles Lenox historical mystery series that each present a fresh mystery while the story of the characters progresses forward through the whole series making them best read in order.

In An Extravagant Death, Charles leaves his own world and the author nailed it when he not only presented a different country and society through Charles’ eyes, but painted America’s Post-Civil War and Gilded Age so detailed that I felt I was there seeing it all beside Charles. It was intriguing seeing Charles trying to solve a mystery when some of the culture layered with upper American society was quite confusing to him. I enjoyed glimpses of their way of life particularly the old Dutch wealthy Knickerbockers who were the American blue bloods next to the new Money Aristocracy like the Astors and Vanderbilts.

This book, like the ones before, is a wonderful dichotomy of Charles’ personal journey and his detective work. One could feel his weariness. He’s burnt out when he takes the Prime Minister’s not so subtle hints to make himself scarce during the firestorm he stirred up when he exposed the rot within Scotland Yard. He is of two minds about wanting to follow his dream and travel, but feeling that he needs to be home to see his two little girls growing up and spending time with his wife. There is an edginess to him as he works to solve the case as a result and a bittersweet tone to the whole story.

As to the mystery, Charles must get past the blank faces and closed doors of those who know more than they realize, don’t want their secrets drawn out, or are wary of the Englishman whose not one of them. Oddly enough, I figured out the who, why, and how quite early. Not because I’m brilliant, but simply because I latched on the person early on and saw only mounting evidence as collaboration. The part that surprised me was at first I was sad because I didn’t want it to be this person, but later saw that I was not feeling all that bad about it. In fact, I kinda wished for a nasty end for this villain.

The last few chapters had me with my heart in my throat and I couldn’t have put the book aside for anything. Things were left in an interesting spot. I’ll be curious to see what comes next. It feels like either the end or a new season of the series is upon us. In any event, I can heartily recommend this one to Historical Mystery lovers who like a smart, gentleman-detective and a fab cast of characters surrounding him.

My thanks to Net Galley for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

[Judy Lesley · Rating 5 out of 5]

What a real pleasure this novel was to read. I found a combination of many things I enjoy all wrapped up in a book so well written that I hesitated to put it down. The reason for Charles Lenox to be traveling to America was a trifle thin but it was acceptable. The descriptions of New York City in 1878 were interesting to read but what had me fascinated were the descriptions of the people who made Newport, Rhode Island their home both as summer and year round residents. The contrasts could not have been sharper. Having been fortunate to visit Newport and the summer cottages of the incredibly wealthy Americans of those times I can say that Charles Finch brought it all back to me with his writer's talent for detail. It is hard to imagine a "cottage" with 90 rooms until you stand outside it and understand what opulence was for those who were super-rich.

Lenox is aboard a train for another city on his trip when that train is stopped on the tracks so a message can be delivered. Lenox is needed in Newport to investigate the death of a beautiful, young socialite found dead on the sand at the edge of the William Stuyvesant Schermerhorn IV's property. Schermerhorn's son was expected to have become engaged to Miss Lily Allingham, the murdered woman. Wealth and social standing will figure greatly in this crime and turn out to both help and hinder the investigation mounted by Charles Lenox.

Descriptions of both New York City and Newport from 1878 are integrated so well into the fabric of this criminal investigation that it made this book a pleasure to read. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press Minotaur Books for an e-galley of the book.

[Emma Rose · Rating 5 out of 5]

A real triumph, oh, how completely dazzling! I read this in one sitting, through breakfast and lunch, in the feverish state that only unputdownable books can conjure up. An absolute treat.

Charles Lenox, acclaimed Victorian detective, would like to spend more time with his family - his lovely wife Jane, his sparkling daughter Sophia and his new baby, Clara, but those plans of domestic bliss are thwarted when Benjamin Disraeli (amazing portrayal of a rather forceful but charming PM) himself asks him to pay a visit to America, as a service to the Queen. There, Charles is quickly thrown into Newport's height of splendour where he meets old and new money and navigates an upper crust distraught by the murder of its most beautiful débutante, Lily Allingham.

I can't tell you how much I loved An Extravagant Death. It has everything this series does best. But first, if you're reading this - please don't pick up this book as a starting point if you haven't read the others. You can read books out of order sometimes in a series and it hardly matters but you can't do that here. It will spoil too many things and a lot of elements (secondary characters and Lenox's character arc) will make zero sense to you.

1/ I read a lot about Victorian England and this, I can say with absolute certainty, is the greatest series when it comes to learning about that time. This book is no exception. The research is excellent and it's not just broad strokes - intricate, small, tiny details (like the kind of taps you'd find in one of Lady Astor's many bathrooms, hot, cold, and salted, if you care to know). The kind of detail like knowing what fabric a piece of clothing is made of is not just here as a nod to history, it genuinely brings History to life. It's just gorgeous.

2/ OH MY GOD GILDED AGE NEWPORT. The abundance of riches in this book is completely over-the-top insane, I was in HEAVEN. If you're looking for description of all the details of extravagant parties and a catalogue of what money can buy - look no further. Lenox has to infiltrate the circle of millionaires of the nineteenth century and most of the book is spent with Charles having to pick up his jaw from the floor and I was in much the same state! I'm completely obsessed now. It's one thing to have characters wear expensive jewellery, it's quite another when our hero realises the very ballroom he's in carries no less than six paintings by Rubens. Yet throughout the book, it was completely like Lenox to see both the glamour and its problems, what makes America attractive, and its pitfalls, this was done so well and the social commentary is top-notch as usual. The comparisons with England at the same time are SO interesting. I'm completely obsessed now and must read everything I can about the the Knickerbockers and the arrival of new money, the Vanderbilts, the Astors and of course those glorious mansions (they call them cottages, a choice of vocabulary that's greatly commented upon in the book!). This is the world of Edith Wharton's The Buccaneers and Lisa Kleypas's Lillian and Daisy in The Wallflowers.

3/ Yes, there's a murder but this book is SO COSY. Every single dish is described (and let me tell you, there are many, it's completely glorious), there are scenes that last several pages that are written solely for Lenox to sit in his study and just enjoy a meal, picking up a cooing baby, scenes where he and Dallington stay at a club and are brought food IN THE LIBRARY because in clubs you can stay ALL DAY if you want to, a scene all about the sheer bliss that are dolphins. What I mean is - it's a WORLD, not just an investigation, and Charles Finch is incredible at making you feel like you're right there with the characters through tiny details that make them seem so human and just full of the need to just be content (when Lenox goes to America, he carries a small list of all the states and ticks every one once he's seen them for example, it's just lovely and something I can totally picture myself doing in the future!)

4/ The humour of this book is just perfect. Not PG Wodehouse stitches but genuine chuckles. It's truly lovely. Even though there's an investigation going on, this tells you that, somehow, you're safe. Levity brings down the tension considerably so you can really enjoy the plot. At some point, there's a clear reference to a Jane Austen creation that was such good insight into a new character it had me laugh and laugh. This humour comes with infinite pearls of wisdom, too, about privilege, about the status of women, remarks which speak to how great a social study this actually is - fear not, you're in good hands.

5/ Which brings me to the writing. Excellent and FREQUENTLY gorgeous. Where else will you find a home compared to a 'a ship built to sail to the stars' (this one made me sigh, I reread it several times).

6/ The gallery of characters is so well-drawn. I cared for each and every single one of them and had no trouble remembering who was who. Charles meets a past flame, Kitty, and she was easily my favourite one, she'd had a remarkable journey since we last saw her and their scenes showed how two ex lovers can interact with all the nostalgia, longing, but also, ultimately peace and acceptance, that is so true in real life. I was deeply moved. We also meet Disraeli, mentioned previously, and Caroline Astor and both come with the aura you associate with Historical Figures and leave a lasting impression.

7/ The plot itself was easy to follow yet full of twists - I didn't guess the culprit and their motives came as a complete SHOCK. The ending is left ambiguous as well - I wonder if this is Lenox's last case (say it ain't so?). If it is, though, you'll see why.

What a beautiful, beautiful new book in this already amazing series. One of my favourites for sure. I'm left completely satisfied - the plot is wrapped, the characters I love are safe and happy for now and this left me wanting to know everything I can about this period of time. The best books do.

-

My endless thanks to NetGalley and St Martin's Press for this advanced copy. I've read all of the Lenox books in the series and will buy a copy when it's released (HAVE YOU SEEN THIS COVER) but it's pretty special to be able to read a book almost 4 months before its publication.

[Barbara Rogers · Rating 5 out of 5]

Series: Charles Lenox Mysteries #14
Publication Date: 2/16/21
Number of Pages: 304

WOW! Talk about a book that was impossible to put down – this was definitely it. We are finally back to Lenox’s current timeline and I’m happy about that. I loved all of the books about his earlier life, but I’m happy to be back in his normal timeline now. It seems that no matter how far Charles travels, he finds himself investigating a murder – this time it is while he is visiting the United States. I believe this might be my favorite book of the series so far and I’m really looking forward to many more because I’m so excited to see where Charles’s future lies. One of the things I love best about the series is that Charles seems so very real �� as does the history in the book.

Charles has just wrapped up a very high-profile case that has taken down half of Scotland Yard as well as being rife with political implications. When Lenox is summoned to appear before the Prime Minister, Benjamin Disraeli, he is sure things are not going to go well for him. The Prime Minister asks Lenox to leave England – and tells him that the Queen will bestow a knighthood on him. No, Charles isn’t being banished, but it sort of feels like it. He declines the offer because he really wants to assure that the men from Scotland Yard are convicted, and his testimony should assure it. However, Disraeli keeps sweetening the pot until Lenox agrees – but adds a few terms of his own.

Lenox’s tour of America has hardly begun before he is waylaid on his train and is demanded to appear in Newport to solve a murder. Charles is traveling in the name of the Queen of England and he’s incensed that someone would dare demand – for it was a demand and not a request – that he appear before them and solve a murder. He declines but is eventually convinced to at least check it out – out of curiosity if nothing else.

When Lenox arrives, the body of the beautiful young woman is still lying on the beach where she was found. The police are there as is the coroner and a number of onlookers. The scene is totally trampled and the locals don’t seem to know how to investigate a murder – especially a murder among society’s elite.

Charles’s investigation keeps him among the richest and most powerful people in America. One of them murdered that young woman – but there are few clues, no witnesses, and no really good motives. So, what could that lovely young woman have done to cause someone to murder her?

Each lead seems to take him nowhere – and he keeps circling and circling – with no results. Until, finally, he knows the answer, but doesn’t want to believe it. It is really an exciting tale that puts Charles in danger of losing his life. Will he live long enough to see the murderer caught? Oh! My!

I absolutely loved this book and could happily read it again and again. I loved seeing a young America through an Englishman’s eyes. The descriptions of Lenox’s impressions are wonderful – especially the descriptions of the hope that was so clearly on display among the upstart Americans. It just made me long for those hopeful times. I also loved the insights on the aftermath of the Civil War even twenty years later. I think the author did an outstanding job of conveying that rich sense of history and the hope of a young American nation.

I also loved Charles’s career crisis thoughts – maybe it was a mid-life crisis. I will be so excited to read the next books and find out what the future holds for Charles, Lady Jane, and the rest of the recurring characters. The ONLY thing that I didn’t love was the references to how old Lenox was. The story treated him as if he were eighty rather than forty-nine – and he reinforced that. I know that fifty back then was ‘older’ than fifty today, but goodness – I can’t believe it was that different.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Daniel Shindler · Rating 4 out of 5]

It is early 1878 in this long running series and the acclaimed Detective Charles Lenox has just concluded a difficult case that has exposed corruption within Scotland Yard. With the trial of the Scotland Yard officers approaching, political tensions are high and Prime Minister Disraeli summons Lenox. Disraeli needs to advance his own agenda, which would necessitate Lenox’ leaving London and traveling to America. Lenox is reluctant to leave his family but he has always had a long repressed desire to travel and the Prime Minister is relentlessly insistent. Soon thereafter, Lenox is bound for America on a ceremonial tour.His first stop is in New York City, where he meets members of New York’s Gilded Age society. On the way to his next city, his train is stopped and a member of the wealthy New York elite implores him to travel to Newport, Rhode Island,the summer social center of the wealthy. A beautiful debutante has been murdered close to his property. The local police are not equipped to properly carry out the investigation quickly and discreetly.Lenox’ services are necessary.

In delving into this puzzle, Lenox moves among the American elite with aplomb and discernment. He offers reactions to the new and bold American wealth and contrasts it to the more restrained English, Victorian society. He meets a host of people, many of whom are actual historical personages, as he wends his way to a solution.

In this series, Charles Finch has created a sophisticated confluence of characters and setting with overtones of both Sherlock Holmes and Golden Age crime. In this book, the characters we have come to love are tangential to the plot. Instead, the opulence, wealth and energy of the emerging American society are center stage. Finch depicts both the wealthy and less privileged through the prism of this mystery.

One of the strengths of this series is the depiction of Lenox as he moves through different stages of his life. He is now approaching fifty and is a different person than he was when we first meet him.There are foreshadowings of a change in his life story that will keep his fans anxiously awaiting the next book.

[Kate Baxter · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 / 5.0 Stars

This fourteenth book in series, is yet another brilliant addition to the Charles Lenox mysteries by talented writer, Charles Finch. The depth of Finch's historical research appearing in each story is tremendous and spot on. The books usually hold more than just one mystery, and this one was no exception. The richness of descriptive detail transports the reader to a different time and place wrapping them in a richly woven blanket of observation and sensation. The subtle clues are all there but not easily discerned, thus pulling the reader along through all the various cat and mouse moments and red herring. The energy builds up gradually over the course of the story to a striking moment and gently eases off toward a satisfying conclusion.

It is a marvel how Mr. Finch weaves the delicate dance of Parliamentary politics into his story, thus bringing characters of history to life. His portrayal of Prime Minister Disraeli, the man of great intellect and political maneuvering, is nothing short of brilliant. His description of an 1878 transatlantic voyage is marvelous, (of note: an escorting pod of dolphins alongside ship). The descriptions of the various strata of the American people of late nineteenth century, whether it's of the aspiring new immigrant class, the nouveau riche or the well established scions of wealth, were rich and historically accurate in the telling - even amusing at times.

Yet, beyond the usual tension and machinations of a fine mystery, Finch also brings to bear a wonderful depth in his characters. As we hear the tender ruminations of Lenox regarding his young family or observe his irritations as a detective thwarted by those in power and wealth, we appreciate the humanity of his character. We grin at the playful exchange of emotion and banter between Lenox and his brother or his wife, Lady Jane. Our hearts melt at the tender moments shared between father and precocious child #1.

All in all, this was a most enjoyable read and this reader for one, eagerly awaits the next installment in this richly told tale.

[Linda Galella · Rating 3 out of 5]

As I’ve mentioned in a few of my recent reviews, I found a short stack of books on my guest room book shelf that had no designation. Unfortunately, I came to find out that they were GR ARC’s that I’d misplaced. My humblest apologies for the terrible delay in writing this review…

Being a big fan of historical fiction and historical mysteries, I was looking forward to reading “An Extravagant Death”, by Charles Finch. This is my first experience with this author, some of which was quite enjoyable. Finch’s prose is atmospheric and well balanced between informative and descriptive. I enjoyed the social entanglements that reach across the pond, linking gentry from disparate countries and families. Main character, Charles Lenox’s wife is a brilliant character that facilitates this aspect with aplomb. The integration of key historical figures with the series regulars is deftly accomplished.

A.E.D. is book 14 of a 15 book series and altho’ there are ongoing personal life storylines from book to book, this book is easily read as a standalone novel. Finch provides enough backstory to catch first timers, (or those who opt not to read every consecutive book), up to speed.

For me, the pacing of this story is burdensome. There’s a loooong setup to getting Lenox over in America. Most of it has very little bearing on the story; perhaps tying up loose ends from the previous volume? It’s about 10 chapters before the murder takes place and then we’re finally on to investigation. Of course, Lenox is alone and needs to gather an American team to help out. His reputation has preceded him and he’s got help in short order…

Short order is also how long it took for me to figure out whodunit. This was far from a Sherlock Holmes experience for me. With so many 4 & 5 star reviews I’m wondering if this title was a fluke and not comparable to his earlier installments. I didn’t hate it so I’m willing to try another before declaring “An Extravagant Death” 📚

[Susan · Rating 4 out of 5]

After taking Scotland Yard down for corruption, Charles Lennox is sent to America by Prime Minister, Disraeli, so not to embarrass people in his cabinet. Of course the offer is sweet with a knighthood and an appointment by the Queen to investigate law enforce agencies. So Lennox takes off and ends up investigating a murder of a young, beautiful girl with ties to the rich and famous in Rhode Island.

It's only a few years after the Civil War and feelings are still running rampant. Lennox is shocked by the conspicuous consumption of the Americans and the display of wealth. The young girl has been courted by several members of the rich and famous and Lennox has numerous suspects to pick from. The rich are rushing to cover up the murder.

Luckily, Lennox is married to Lady Jane so gets an invitation to the fabled Astor Ball. People are so envious but the events at the Ball almost kill Lennox. This was a tightly plotted mystery full of historical details that were quite fascinating. I was entranced from beginning to end. Thanks to Net Galley for a copy of this book in exchange for a fair review.

[Allison · Rating 4 out of 5]

The latest installment in the Charles Lenox Mysteries transports Great Britain’s premier detective to Gilded Age America in the late 1870s. When the season’s most beautiful and sought after debutante is found dead of apparent suicide at the base of a cliff in Newport, Rhode Island, Lenox is called upon to investigate. He finds himself in the extravagant world of the Knickerbockers, the Astors, and the Vanderbilts. I love a good detective story set in the eras before modern science and forensics, and this series always delivers. The pace of this one is slower, but this is an atmospheric, descriptive read. The tale gave me a glimpse of the lines drawn between old and new money, the stark class divides, the cultural differences between England and America in the Victorian era, and the political and social machinations of a young, evolving nation. This is an absorbing whodunnit with a wonderfully engaging protagonist and a great, classic reveal at the end.

[Deanna · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars

It’s nice to be back in the forward thread of this series that’s a favorite of mine.

I was restless for a while in this one because it’s another Charles-goes-to-America story, and my preference is for these atmospheric historic English novels to stay in England, and because I wasn’t sure the crime that drives the plot was going to turn out to meaty enough to fit the rest of the story.

But I was won over by the later enrichment of the plot, the satisfaction of quality time spent with some but not all of the favorite characters of the series, and the reliable quality of the writing. We end with some significant internal challenges for our protagonist and intriguing questions about where the series is likely to go in the future.

[Kat · Rating 5 out of 5]

An Extravagant Death is the fourteenth book in Charles Finch's addictive Charles Lenox Mysteries series. This series is one of the primary reasons I became a big fan of historical mysteries. I've only read the previous three books, which were prequels to the main series, and they were enough to get me hooked! This installment returns us to the primary storyline. If you haven't read any of them, this mystery stands perfectly on its own. However, I'm pretty sure that, like me, you will start collecting all the books you've missed!

Gentleman detective Charles Lenox has just finished a corruption investigation surrounding Scotland Yard, and he's now getting ready for the trial of that case. Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli doesn't want Lenox in London during the trial, and he offers him a trip to America in the guise of a diplomatic mission for the Queen. Lenox doesn't want to leave his beloved wife Lady Jane and their two darling little girls, but he does long to travel and gives in to Disraeli's wishes. Lenox travels from London to 1878's Gilded Age, New York. It's the time of old Knickerbocker society and new wealth. While on the way to visit his next American city, his train is stopped; a wealthy Newport man begs the esteemed detective to travel to his home to investigate the death of a young woman on his property. In Newport, Lenox begins to hunt the killer. Was it a random attack, or is the murderer one of Newport's own wealthy elite?

Out of the four Charles Lenox books I've read, this one was my favorite! Lenox is no stranger to high society in London, but seeing the difference between London society and the decadence of New York and Newport through his eyes is a lot of fun. When he hears about the cottages in Newport, he's dumbfounded to find that the huge glittering mansions surrounding him are the "cottages"! We also see the differences between the haves and have-nots in the people who are assisting Lenox in his investigation: O'Brien, a young Irishman assigned to Lenox as a valet who works to support his family, and Teddy Blaine, the son of an extremely wealthy man, who wants to be a detective and whom Lenox takes under his wing. I enjoyed the tender moments between Lenox and his family. The mystery, though, is of course the main attraction. Every time I was absolutely sure whodunit, I was wrong! It's fascinating to watch Lenox work through the clues and red herrings. The next Charles Lenox mystery cannot come quickly enough for me!

I received an ARC of this book courtesy of the publisher and NetGalley. I received no compensation for my review, and all thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.

[Lou Kemp · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a more personal book from Finch.
It initially read as usual with the insertion of light historical education as the clues were strewn in front of the reader, and sprinkled with the usual minute details of Lenox's personal life. Especially poignant; his desire to hold his new daughter, but society dictated a limit to that fatherly urge.
Once Lenox landed in America, the newness of the land, its people, and its mores became part of the plot, and in some instances clues, to the murder of a "once in a century" beauty. Later he finds a direct connection between himself and the murder of a woman he had never met.
If you like to guess who-dun-it, you might be able to before the finale. What you cannot guess is the connection between the murderous act and its affect on Lenox. After he is wounded, the whirlwind arrival of Graham to sit at Lenox's side is welcome, even more so than who the reader might expect to have traveled 6 days across the Atlantic to his side.
My only complaint is Lenox's supposition as to why the murderer had turned out to be so vicious and evil. The parents could not have accounted for this level of depravity, and Lenox blaming them could have been purposeful--- assuming most observers seeing the situation during the 1870's.
I'm taking bets whether the monumental decision Lenox makes while recuperating from the attack will hold. My bet is no, because plots depend on murders or they just become straight fiction which this author is not known for.
The Lenox series is a cozy, in a true cozy historical timeframe, but the layers supporting the plot elevate this to something more.

[Bev · Rating 4 out of 5]

Charles Lenox and his detective agency are just coming off a big case--a corruption case that has rocked Scotland Yard and put the aristocratic backers of some of the Yard men involved. While Prime Minister Disraeli wants the corrupt men brought to justice, he wants to mitigate the damage to the government as much as possible. His solution, have Lenox's evidence given in a written affidavit rather than live and person (for a drier, less sensational effect). He plans to send Lenox to the United States with all the pomp and circumstance of the Queen's representative. The reason for the trip shall be that Britain is looking to set up reciprocal relationships with the police forces and detectives of other countries to share practices and to give assistance when possible.

Lenox has barely begun his tour in the States when a request comes from one of the wealthiest families in the wealthy enclave in Newport, Rhode Island. A beautiful young woman named Lily Allingham has been found dead on the beach below the "cottage" owned by William Stuyvesant Schermerhorn IV. It would be most convenient if the woman had committed suicide, but the wound in her head and the position of the body seem to rule out anything but murder. Lily was in her last season as a debutante with her choice of beaus and had been expected to announce her engagement very soon. The front-runners in the marriage race were Schermerhorn's son and a nephew of "the" Vanderbilt. Had she turned one of them down and received a killing blow in a moment of outrage? Or are there others with a reason to kill the almost too beautiful woman?

Lenox will need to find out who knew Lily best and examine the timeline for a society ball before he can find the answer. His task is made more difficult because he is out of his element and without his usual helpers. A young scion of another of the leading families fancies himself as an amateur detective and lends Lenox a hand. But it's just not the same as having Dallinger or Graham at his side. And how much real help can the young man give anyway?

It was interesting to see Lenox in a different setting and watching him adapt from Victoria's England to the Gilded Age in the States. But I have to admit I'm not overly fond of stories that take the detective out of his usual environs. Especially when they don't have any of their usual companions around--he didn't even get to take Lady Jane along. After having read one of the prequel novels, I was very excited to get back to the "current" Lenox. I like him better as a seasoned detective even though it was nice to see his beginnings in the trade--and, to be honest, I enjoyed the stories where Graham was more Lenox's right-hand man rather than following his career in Parliament and only appearing occasionally.

The plot is a good one. Mystery fans with a lot of reading under their belts may see the particular twist coming, but Finch handles it well and readers who haven't encountered that type of solution before will be surprised. I'm not sure that I like the overall ending, however. The culprit has escaped justice and though Lenox is assured that s/he will be no further threat, I do wonder if we'll see them crop up again at a later date.

I appreciate Finch's research and the way he uses it to bring the times and places alive. We definitely get a feel for the opulence that existed during America's Gilded Age. And he underlines the differences between the U.S. and Britain during the same time period without making too much of them and without making the reader feel like they are sitting through a history lesson. Highly enjoyable read.

First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting portions of review. Thanks.

[Brittany Shields · Rating 5 out of 5]

My favorite part of this book was seeing America circa 1878 through the eyes of an Englishman (Charles Lenox). Part historical fiction, part Sherlock Holmes, and a dash of wit, this book was a fun read for me. I love a good mystery and enjoyed learning some cultural differences between Britain and America during this time period as well as just some interesting facts.

It begins with Charles Lenox being asked by a superior to go to America so that he's out of the country while a trial is underway for the corruption in the Scotland Yard that he was part of uncovering. Being well-known in America, he is roped into investigating a suicide/murder case in ritzy Newport, Rhode Island.

I was not aware of the opulent summer "cottages" of Newport so it was really interesting to google these. And now I'm obviously going to go visit and tour them in person. They would have cost hundreds of millions of dollars to build today. (And these were second homes!!) You can actually walk the infamous Cliff Walk where the case in question took place so that would be pretty cool.

I love the historical parts of this story and all the descriptions of New York during this time period. It was well-written and reminiscent of Arthur Conan Doyle or Agatha Christie's mysteries. Lots of little clues to pick up on that you'll probably miss and then once you know whodunit you'll want to go back and read it again to see what you missed. This seemed like a wrap up book for the series a little bit so I'm not sure where the next one will go if there is, indeed, another one to come.

I've never read anything by Charles Finch before so reading this was jumping ahead of a lot of Charles Lenox's life and career. However, it didn't take away from being able to understand and still enjoy this book. I would like to go back and read some of the earlier books so hopefully knowing the future won't ruin any of them for me.

I can't speak too much about character development considering this is book #11. One could argue that Charles Lenox and his wife lacked depth in this book but I'm sure people who've read all the other books would see things differently. I thought Lenox was likable. He meets up again with a woman he had fallen in love with earlier in his life (who is now married to her second husband). I'm assuming that takes place in one of the earlier books. Since I hadn't followed his journey to his current wife and read much about their relationship, part of me held my breath hoping he wasn't going to be unfaithful while away from his wife. But thankfully, he stayed true. Well done, sir.

So anyway. If you are a fan of mystery novels, I would definitely give this one a try!

P.S. A few things I learned while reading this book:

- 'Godmanchester' is pronounced 'Gumster'
- Shrapnel was invented by Lt. Henry Shrapnel
- Saltboxes are a type of house common in colonial America
- Hearing something 'through the grapevine' came to be a thing because there was a tavern during the Civil War called the Old Grapevine where officers often dined and spies were usually lurking around to gather information
- The history behind the 'white elephant' gift exchange
- At this point in history, Trinity Church in New York was the tallest building in the city
- New York City used to be called New Amsterdam and began with Dutch settlers

**Received an ARC via NetGalley**

See more of my reviews at www.shelfreflection.com!

[Jan · Rating 5 out of 5]

I have not read any of the previous books in the series so I have no bias in reading this except that I geek history and this is set mainly in Newport, RI and NYC in 1878. Due to other circumstances, the very British Lenox is sent to the states without his wife and children but with astounding credentials and winds up becoming involved in a murder investigation halfway between NYC and his destination. Fortunately his assigned valet is well able to help him with the due diligence he would be unable to do quietly and that the local police are glad for his aid because the moneyed class is as intolerant of police in Newport as they are in Britain. He also has the aid of a past acquaintance as well as a new and eager one, both of whom are both moneyed and familiar with the milieu. Good sleuthing by all! I found it quite enjoyable.
I requested and received a free ebook copy from St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books via NetGalley. Thank you!

[Kathy · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is one of my favorite historical fiction series and have read all of the books, but this latest book is the very best. It is a splendid book on many levels. Briefly, it's 1878 and Lenox is asked by Disraeli to perform a job for him in America. "It would be the Queen's pleasure to give you a knighthood, too, if you want it." This is not something Lenox covets and he is currently busy with the admiration of his second baby girl with no wish to leave her side.
Well, he does end up being pressed further by Disraeli and makes the journey. His time in America takes up the bulk of the book and the places he visits and people he meets make for a brilliant portrait of the era.

[Monnie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh my - what a delightful book! I requested it from NetGalley just because I suspected it would be a nice change of pace for me - a detective story, yes, but set in London in the late 1870s. What I got was history blended with superb (for the times) detective work interspersed with decidedly British witticisms that made me smile throughout. Alas, I didn't read any of the 13 preceding novels featuring detective Charles Lenox, but for sure I don't intend to miss another one. And for those who, like me, aren't familiar with the character, I assure you I had no trouble following this one.

Lenox is living in London with his wife, Lady Jane, and young daughters Sophia and Clara (to put the setting in perspective, the Prime Minister, with whom Lenox is well acquainted, is Benjamin Disraeli). It is Disraeli, in fact, who challenges Lenox's comfort level: He asks him to leave his successful detective agency and travel to America to make nice and share his considerable detective expertise with police in several major U.S. cities. Reluctant at first despite his longing to travel, Lenox caves in and sets off by boat - arriving first in New York, where his insights on New York society are a real treat.

But on his way to Boston, the train is stopped so Lenox can be handed a personal letter asking him to stop in Newport, Rhode Island, to look into the death of a beautiful young debutante. At first blush, it's thought that she committed suicide; but some insiders, including the young woman's best friend, are convinced she was murdered. In hoity-toity Newport, Lenox gets an up-close-and-personal look at how society of the era operates as he tries to figure out what happened and, more importantly, who did it.

Needless to say, Lenox gets there - but there's many a slip between cup and lip, and one of them threatens his very existence (as well as provides fodder for the next book). My overall assessment? Thoroughly entertaining, and I thank the publisher for providing me with a pre-release copy to read and review.

[Jim Teggelaar · Rating 5 out of 5]

Classy Charles Finch takes his gentleman detective Lenox to America. A smallish, quiet mystery full of charm and terrific prose. Finch has top shelf all to himself right now in the Crime section.

[LJ · Rating 4 out of 5]

First Sentence: It was a sunny, icy late morning in February of 1878, and a solitary figure, lost in thought, strode along one of the pale paths winding through St. James's Park in London.

British Enquiry Agent, Charles Lennox, solved a case that brings down Scotland Yard with the three top men headed to trial. Prime Minister Disraeli determines it best that Lennox is not in England during the trial and sends him to the United States with the Queen's Seal on a tour of the East Coast law enforcement agencies. 1878 Newport, Rhode Island; a place of extreme wealth and self-indulgence. A place of new money, and a focus on marrying well. The murder of a young woman of the first diamond doesn't fit into this scenario. Lennox's help is requested.

Finch does an excellent job of providing a summary of Lennox's background, folding in that of his wife, Lady Jane, in the process. However, it is confusing that the case for which Lennox is being lauded falls into a huge gap: When did Lennox and Jane have a second child? When did Polly and Dallington, Charles' partners in the agency, get married? And most of all, what was the case that brought down Scotland Yard? Either this reviewer blanked out this information, or Finch and/or his publisher just decided to skip a book and these annoying little details.

In Lenox getting to know New York, Finch presents the stark contrast between the wealthy and the laboring class very well, demonstrating compassion but not dismissiveness or pity. Lenox's excitement is tangible as he crosses the border from New York to Connecticut, consulting his little book of maps showing the thirty-eight states, until one learns the origin of the word "shrapnel," and later the term "I heard it through the grapevine." Those small bits of information lend richness to the story.

Just as with the contrast in settings, Finch displays the contrasts in characters and their lives with the working class and merchants of the town, to the very wealthy "cottage" owners such as the Vanderbilts and Mrs. Astor. As is often true, some of the most interesting characters are those of ex-soldier James Clark, and Fergus O'Brian, the Irish valet,

It is interesting to see Lenox dogged determination and attention to detail as he investigates every aspect and every possible suspect. The details of how and why Lily, the victim, was killed are laid out perfectly and done in a scene of edge-of-seat suspense rather than the more pedestrian style of Christie. The final chapters are heart-warming, especially the requests he makes on behalf of others.

"An Extravagant Death" is just shy of being excellent, in part due to a scene at the end. The mystery is well done with some secondary characters nearly stealing the show. It will be interesting to see where the series goes from here.

AN EXTRAVEGEANT DEATH (EnqAgent-Charles Lenox-Newport, RI/NYC-1878) – G+
Finch, Charles – 14th book in series
Minotaur Books, Feb 2021, 277 pp

[Pat Dupuy · Rating 5 out of 5]

Charles Lenox has always been a thoughtful, curious, introspective person. When Disraeli, no less, invites him to leave England for a while, Lenox has the opportunity to explore a new land, the United States. After being wined and dined in New York City he is enroute to Boston for more of the same when his detective skills are urgently requested by one of the fabled 400. After verifying the truth of the matter Lenox boards a private train to Newport where he attempts to solve the puzzle of the violent death of a young society beauty, much sought after by all the rich young men. Lenox is alternately fascinated and repelled by the ostentatious "cottages," the extreme wealth of Newport's summer population, and how much power that wealth commands. As Lenox works through the case in his professional capacity, he also attempts to sort through his personal life. This is a wonderfully involved mystery and a fascinating look at New York society when Caroline Astor ruled.