This is a hard review to write. As a white therapist for mostly black clients - many experiencing grief & loss - I read this hoping to improve my abilities in working with grief in black communities. But having finished it, I'm just not sure who the book is written for. It's too academically written for the average person to get through without difficulty, it's repeatedly and pointedly alienating for black men (despite them likely being a target demographic along with white folks), and it hardly covers grief. The main title oddly doesn't match the content.
If you've read this far in disgust/anger, I hope to try to explain: The writing issue is pretty straightforward - it's just not consumable for the average person. The sentence lengths, vocab, and frequent abstract/philosophical content was often at graduate education level. But the book's cover sells "digestible nonfiction book for the general public" vibes.
The next issue was that it simply didn't cover much about grief. I assumed from the title and synopsis that the book was for black folks processing grief & loss, and for those wanting to gain a greater understanding on the topic: teachers, social workers, allies, and medical & mental health providers. Maybe that assumption was my mistake. It was a discussion of so many ideas: systemic racism, social locations, boundaries, power, spirituality, personhood, black female bodies, trauma. Grief may have been an initial part of that group, but the others crowded it out, despite it staying in the title. It was touched on - the hospital stories, for example - but not much more. It felt like the book's title should simply be "An Antiracist Take on Oppression and Sorrow," because grief itself just isn't a key component. Maybe "Grieving While Black" was an early title and the book developed into something very different before publishing, but the title wasn't re-examined before printing.
Lastly, the parts on the struggles and traumas of black women were written in such a way that I imagine many black men who pick up the book would quickly get turned off and stop reading. Context on the black female experience is certainly vital for learning about "grieving while black," and understandable since as a black female this is the author's perspective.
But, if you write about the struggles of an oppressed group (here, black women) in ways you want their oppressors (black men & white people) to *take in* without gut rejection reactions, a writer needs to temper the discomfort from describing those realities they're asking those readers to sit in with reminders - that facing the uncomfortable realities is necessary to change behaviors and systems for the better. The black male population is a group that could absolutely use a primer on grief & loss processing concepts, since stigma persists towards their expressing emotions other than anger. But I don't see how this book can effectively reach them, because the way it is written surely can't do anything but make them feel alienated and reject the content outright. Surprisingly, it read as more alienating to black men than even to white people. I was ready to feel uncomfortable as a white person, but I wasn't prepared for how frequently I wondered "Will any black men even read past this sentence?"
I was hoping to read and learn from a book that presented grief from a black perspective in a consumable yet educational way, but this just wasn't it.