What do you think?
Rate this book
Quicksilver & Brimstone
The Great Pantomeus has spent five hundred years brewing up the perfect revenge. What Matthew Nightingale doesn't know, is that he's part of the plan...
A crazed, near-immortal alchemist locked away in an underground chamber is the last thing Matthew expects to find on a school trip to the British Museum. But the hasty pact he makes with the terrifying stranger completely backfires when Pantomeus breaks free and Matthew is plunged headlong into a mind-boggling world of secret societies, alchemy, and revenge.
Caught in the middle of a centuries-old feud between ageless Masters, Matthew now has only one way to escape Pantomeus’ murderous plans – join the secret Order of the Crucible of the Crimson Lion and become an alchemist himself. Only, it isn't gold that Matthew makes in the Order, but friends, and soon he is whizzing through portals, discovering incredible inventions and powerful arcana while the Science of the Impossible plunges him into a mesmerizing world.
But the ancient Order has secrets of its own, and when Matthews discovers a barefoot girl of a mysterious race kept hidden away in a dusty old mansion, and the link between the legend of the Knight-Sorcerer and Pantomeus, he knows no one is safe. Something terrible is going on in the Order, and it's up to him to find the truth. But can he save his new friends and stop Pantomeus in time before he loses everything he holds dear?
A crazed, near-immortal alchemist locked away in an underground chamber is the last thing Matthew expects to find on a school trip to the British Museum. But the hasty pact he makes with the terrifying stranger completely backfires when Pantomeus breaks free and Matthew is plunged headlong into a mind-boggling world of secret societies, alchemy, and revenge.
Caught in the middle of a centuries-old feud between ageless Masters, Matthew now has only one way to escape Pantomeus’ murderous plans – join the secret Order of the Crucible of the Crimson Lion and become an alchemist himself. Only, it isn't gold that Matthew makes in the Order, but friends, and soon he is whizzing through portals, discovering incredible inventions and powerful arcana while the Science of the Impossible plunges him into a mesmerizing world.
But the ancient Order has secrets of its own, and when Matthews discovers a barefoot girl of a mysterious race kept hidden away in a dusty old mansion, and the link between the legend of the Knight-Sorcerer and Pantomeus, he knows no one is safe. Something terrible is going on in the Order, and it's up to him to find the truth. But can he save his new friends and stop Pantomeus in time before he loses everything he holds dear?
- GenresFantasy
211 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 17, 2020
7 people are currently reading
48 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews
December 17, 2020
Turning Ink into Gold
Elizabeth Eckstein’s The Crucible of the Crimson Lion series is off to an amazing start.
I was lucky enough to win this book in a giveaway and I really can’t say I’m generally into MG/YA books. The only other I have read recently is The Book of Dust by Philip Pullman (I make an exception for him). I have to say, after reading this, I feel like I may be missing out. This is not just a book for children or young adults, even though the main characters are teenagers themselves, I was absolutely able to relate to them on a human level.
I agree with the comparisons others have made, in terms of Harry Potter meets Da Vinci Code, but don’t go in expecting a carbon copy or an extension of these. There are similarities, yes, and yes, it is very much a good Vs evil narrative, but this story stands out in its uniqueness and its heart.
Elizabeth does a great job of easing the reader into the imaginative world she has created and, despite a number of elaborate processes or inventions, it never once feels jarring or contrived. The writing flows beautifully and the descriptions are deep but crisp. Many of the ideas are brilliant, and I do wonder how many more of these concepts she has hidden away for future adventures.
I also have to mention the illustrations, which the author draws herself. One per chapter, placed perfectly, give yet more insight into the world. I can only speak about them with envy, as they are so well crafted and wonderfully detailed, they belong on walls and mantels rather than hidden between pages.
To summarise, I will use my own reading habits. I tend to get most of my reading done just before I go to sleep, and this book made me want to get into bed earlier, just for a little extra time in the world of alchemy.
I can highly recommend Quicksilver & Brimstone, my only qualm being, how long I’ll have to wait for book 2!
Elizabeth Eckstein’s The Crucible of the Crimson Lion series is off to an amazing start.
I was lucky enough to win this book in a giveaway and I really can’t say I’m generally into MG/YA books. The only other I have read recently is The Book of Dust by Philip Pullman (I make an exception for him). I have to say, after reading this, I feel like I may be missing out. This is not just a book for children or young adults, even though the main characters are teenagers themselves, I was absolutely able to relate to them on a human level.
I agree with the comparisons others have made, in terms of Harry Potter meets Da Vinci Code, but don’t go in expecting a carbon copy or an extension of these. There are similarities, yes, and yes, it is very much a good Vs evil narrative, but this story stands out in its uniqueness and its heart.
Elizabeth does a great job of easing the reader into the imaginative world she has created and, despite a number of elaborate processes or inventions, it never once feels jarring or contrived. The writing flows beautifully and the descriptions are deep but crisp. Many of the ideas are brilliant, and I do wonder how many more of these concepts she has hidden away for future adventures.
I also have to mention the illustrations, which the author draws herself. One per chapter, placed perfectly, give yet more insight into the world. I can only speak about them with envy, as they are so well crafted and wonderfully detailed, they belong on walls and mantels rather than hidden between pages.
To summarise, I will use my own reading habits. I tend to get most of my reading done just before I go to sleep, and this book made me want to get into bed earlier, just for a little extra time in the world of alchemy.
I can highly recommend Quicksilver & Brimstone, my only qualm being, how long I’ll have to wait for book 2!
October 13, 2020
An adventure into a secret alchemical society that is a must-read for lovers of the YA Fantasy genre. The Crucible of the Crimson Lion is well-written, face paced and exciting. The amount of detail and imagination the author poured into the Alchemic world is reminiscent Hogwarts. The story follows a young boy whose inquisitiveness lures him into a magical world that tests his friendship, intelligence, and confidence. The overall story is well-plotted and follows many twists and turns that keep pages flowing. Reader’s are sure to love the amazing illustrations the author has added, which bring to life the magical world she's guiding us through. I highly recommend this book, aside from the incredible alchemic elements which I loved, I also enjoyed the character development and friendship. Great job!
January 24, 2021
My second review of the year is of “Quicksilver and Brimstone”, Book One of “The Crucible of the Crimson Lion” series, by Elizabeth Eckstein. Wow! What an outstanding book it was!!!
I feel compelled to begin this review with a “thank you.” I wish to thank the wonderful author, Eckstein, for giving me something back that has been lost for some five decades: my childhood. I remember being a child, and enthralled with the likes of “The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe,” “Peter Pan,” and “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.” In other words, it was a time when I was captivated by true literary classics for children. It was a simple time, when books were for pure enjoyment, not analysis, and I still believed that perhaps animals could talk, fantastical beasts such as unicorns existed, and boys could fly. I had forgotten what that was like. Eckstein, in her marvelous novel, “Quicksilver and Brimstone”, brought me back to that time, and it was delightful!
But my gratitude towards Eckstein extends even beyond bringing me back on a nostalgic journey to my early years. I owe Eckstein for restoring my faith in the whole sub-genre of intrusion fantasy. I had given up on literally HUNDREDS of intrusion fantasy novels, many dispatched to an uncertain fate (after barely escaping dreaded “DNF” status) banished to my donation bin, destined for dusty used bookstore shelves. Ever since the “Harry Potter” series, I had largely abandoned that sub-genre, never finding another work that could measure up for me. Until, that is, reading “Quicksilver and Brimstone”! This book is a simply stupendous work of intrusion fantasy & YA fiction! I believe is destined for greatness, as is its tremendously talented author.
“Quicksilver and Brimstone” is an incredibly enchanting, wonderfully magical adventure. The setting of the novel appears to be late 1980s London, England. The plot centres on a lad named Matthew. Matthew is a latchkey boy, who the antagonist - the creepy and despicable Pantomeus - describes as “invisible”. This is appropriate, as Matthew’s mother is an absent parent, only providing the basic necessities of life. While not cruel, Matthew’s mother is largely uninterested in her son’s day-to-day activities. She works long hours to provide for Matthew, and allow him to have an education, however that is the extent of her parenting abilities. So, Matthew is largely invisible to his own mother, much less anyone else. At school he is nondescript and considered nonconsequential, rather than unpopular. On a field trip to the museum, Matthew’s inquisitiveness – or at least so it seems - leads him to Pantomeus. This is where the story become truly interesting.
Eckstein masterfully takes the reader down the rabbit-hole, into a fascinating world, blending alchemy, mind-boggling mechanical inventions, and strange creatures into a surreal, yet somehow extremely grounded and substantive reality. To be clear, the book is focused on alchemy, from the perspective that during the famous Enlightenment era of the 17th century, science and magic divided. Magic became vilified, and considered witchcraft. The new emerging discipline of science, approached nature from an intellectual standpoint. Essentially, Eckstein - in a very clever and original manner – purports that the practice of alchemy never completely disappeared during “The Age of Reason”. Rather, alchemy was still practiced, in secret, by a hidden society, down through the ages.
Quicksilver and Brimstone has all the elements of a bestselling YA fantasy novel, that can be enjoyed by children and adults alike. It is extremely well written, with beautifully eerie passages like: “Scrabbling like a drunken cat, he grabbed hold of his workbench, his breath coming in shallow rasps…Then suddenly with a ripping twang, his numb hand jutted forward, his fingers fixed around it and he wrenched his arm up and let precisely seven drops of the vile liquid dribble into his gaping mouth. Tarry, black, and heavy as lead, the potion would’ve made anyone else retch, but he didn’t taste a thing. His tongue had shrivelled up eons ago, and all that was left now was a parched thing, like a bit of leather or bark. Like the rest of him – a ruin.”
The action is fast-paced, and highly engaging. There are lots of unexpected surprises, and truly heartwarming moments, especially between protagonist Matthew, and his newly acquired friend, Simon. Simon, and the secondary characters, are exceptional in their own right, and Pantomeus in particular makes an excellent villain. All the other characters in the story are easy to relate to, and the innocence yet ingenuity, and courage of young Matthew and Simon make them easy to root for. The world-building and alchemic system are second-to-none! The detail and creativity displayed by Eckstein is astounding! No disrespect to Rowling, but this book exceeds the Hogwarts universe in terms of intricacy and believability. The concepts Eckstein uses are fresh, and never seem derivative, yet somehow so familiar and comforting. She creates is a true sense of newness and wonder, yet a sense of familiarity in the reader, that I have never experienced before in reading another book.
This novel is truly brilliant in all facets, yet Eckstein provides another aspect that completely outdoes any comparatives. She does her own illustrations, and they are magnificent!!! They bring the characters to life, and enhance the novel in a whole new way that could not be accomplished without such amazing artistry.
I rate Quicksilver and Brimstone a resounding five PLUS stars!!!I have no doubt that this book will end up becoming one of the best books I have EVER read – it’s that good. I cannot wait to see what Eckstein has in store for us readers in installment two in “The Crucible of the Crimson Lion”!
Make room intrusion fantasy royalty J.K. Rowling and Philip Pullman! There’s a new Queen aspiring to the throne, and her name is Elizabeth Eckstein! All hail!!!
I feel compelled to begin this review with a “thank you.” I wish to thank the wonderful author, Eckstein, for giving me something back that has been lost for some five decades: my childhood. I remember being a child, and enthralled with the likes of “The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe,” “Peter Pan,” and “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.” In other words, it was a time when I was captivated by true literary classics for children. It was a simple time, when books were for pure enjoyment, not analysis, and I still believed that perhaps animals could talk, fantastical beasts such as unicorns existed, and boys could fly. I had forgotten what that was like. Eckstein, in her marvelous novel, “Quicksilver and Brimstone”, brought me back to that time, and it was delightful!
But my gratitude towards Eckstein extends even beyond bringing me back on a nostalgic journey to my early years. I owe Eckstein for restoring my faith in the whole sub-genre of intrusion fantasy. I had given up on literally HUNDREDS of intrusion fantasy novels, many dispatched to an uncertain fate (after barely escaping dreaded “DNF” status) banished to my donation bin, destined for dusty used bookstore shelves. Ever since the “Harry Potter” series, I had largely abandoned that sub-genre, never finding another work that could measure up for me. Until, that is, reading “Quicksilver and Brimstone”! This book is a simply stupendous work of intrusion fantasy & YA fiction! I believe is destined for greatness, as is its tremendously talented author.
“Quicksilver and Brimstone” is an incredibly enchanting, wonderfully magical adventure. The setting of the novel appears to be late 1980s London, England. The plot centres on a lad named Matthew. Matthew is a latchkey boy, who the antagonist - the creepy and despicable Pantomeus - describes as “invisible”. This is appropriate, as Matthew’s mother is an absent parent, only providing the basic necessities of life. While not cruel, Matthew’s mother is largely uninterested in her son’s day-to-day activities. She works long hours to provide for Matthew, and allow him to have an education, however that is the extent of her parenting abilities. So, Matthew is largely invisible to his own mother, much less anyone else. At school he is nondescript and considered nonconsequential, rather than unpopular. On a field trip to the museum, Matthew’s inquisitiveness – or at least so it seems - leads him to Pantomeus. This is where the story become truly interesting.
Eckstein masterfully takes the reader down the rabbit-hole, into a fascinating world, blending alchemy, mind-boggling mechanical inventions, and strange creatures into a surreal, yet somehow extremely grounded and substantive reality. To be clear, the book is focused on alchemy, from the perspective that during the famous Enlightenment era of the 17th century, science and magic divided. Magic became vilified, and considered witchcraft. The new emerging discipline of science, approached nature from an intellectual standpoint. Essentially, Eckstein - in a very clever and original manner – purports that the practice of alchemy never completely disappeared during “The Age of Reason”. Rather, alchemy was still practiced, in secret, by a hidden society, down through the ages.
Quicksilver and Brimstone has all the elements of a bestselling YA fantasy novel, that can be enjoyed by children and adults alike. It is extremely well written, with beautifully eerie passages like: “Scrabbling like a drunken cat, he grabbed hold of his workbench, his breath coming in shallow rasps…Then suddenly with a ripping twang, his numb hand jutted forward, his fingers fixed around it and he wrenched his arm up and let precisely seven drops of the vile liquid dribble into his gaping mouth. Tarry, black, and heavy as lead, the potion would’ve made anyone else retch, but he didn’t taste a thing. His tongue had shrivelled up eons ago, and all that was left now was a parched thing, like a bit of leather or bark. Like the rest of him – a ruin.”
The action is fast-paced, and highly engaging. There are lots of unexpected surprises, and truly heartwarming moments, especially between protagonist Matthew, and his newly acquired friend, Simon. Simon, and the secondary characters, are exceptional in their own right, and Pantomeus in particular makes an excellent villain. All the other characters in the story are easy to relate to, and the innocence yet ingenuity, and courage of young Matthew and Simon make them easy to root for. The world-building and alchemic system are second-to-none! The detail and creativity displayed by Eckstein is astounding! No disrespect to Rowling, but this book exceeds the Hogwarts universe in terms of intricacy and believability. The concepts Eckstein uses are fresh, and never seem derivative, yet somehow so familiar and comforting. She creates is a true sense of newness and wonder, yet a sense of familiarity in the reader, that I have never experienced before in reading another book.
This novel is truly brilliant in all facets, yet Eckstein provides another aspect that completely outdoes any comparatives. She does her own illustrations, and they are magnificent!!! They bring the characters to life, and enhance the novel in a whole new way that could not be accomplished without such amazing artistry.
I rate Quicksilver and Brimstone a resounding five PLUS stars!!!I have no doubt that this book will end up becoming one of the best books I have EVER read – it’s that good. I cannot wait to see what Eckstein has in store for us readers in installment two in “The Crucible of the Crimson Lion”!
Make room intrusion fantasy royalty J.K. Rowling and Philip Pullman! There’s a new Queen aspiring to the throne, and her name is Elizabeth Eckstein! All hail!!!
December 20, 2020
Absolute Alchemy!
This YYA author does incredible storytelling AND incredible original illustrations. I’ve never come across an author who’s so good at doing both at once. The genius of this book is how it ushers the reader into a Secret Society, emphasizing alchemy instead of the usual magic-wand-type tropes. The artwork puts Harry Potter to shame. Story is totally original and heartwarming. My 8-year-old is probably just about at this reading level. It’s perfect for ages 9 to 99. ;) :)
This YYA author does incredible storytelling AND incredible original illustrations. I’ve never come across an author who’s so good at doing both at once. The genius of this book is how it ushers the reader into a Secret Society, emphasizing alchemy instead of the usual magic-wand-type tropes. The artwork puts Harry Potter to shame. Story is totally original and heartwarming. My 8-year-old is probably just about at this reading level. It’s perfect for ages 9 to 99. ;) :)
July 17, 2020
I remember fondly the feeling of enchantment that a good adventure story instilled in me as a child. Elizabeth Eckstein has rekindled that feeling after some 30 years of my bumbling through adult life. From start to finish, a rich tapestry of narrative and world-building that brings to mind elements of His Dark Materials, Harry Potter, the Da Vinci Code and Stranger Things. The reader is transported to an indeterminate time (very much resembling the late 80s) where secret societies of ancient alchemists move undetected amongst us. One of the best aspects of the book is discovering all the fantastical creatures, tinctures, compounds and steampunk-like mechanical constructs from this world as the story unfolds. Using alchemy, rather than magic, also makes for a more interesting plot - things cannot be solved with the mere wave of a wand. The beautiful illustrations were an unexpected bonus. I don't want to give away any spoilers so let me just say buy this for your kids (and then afterwards read it yourself - don't worry I won't tell).
November 20, 2020
A fun read, with lots of wacky characters and delicious descriptions!
I knew from page one that this was going to be an immersive read, full of mystery and magic. Matthew is a likeable character, and his mild-mannered normality is fantastically contrasted with the crack-pot alchemists he unwittingly falls in with.
A sense of crumbling, ancient magic creeps through the pages, giving the story a dark yet cosy feel. The illustrations perfectly suit the mysterious, zany world Eckstein creates.
I enjoyed this book, even though I’m not its target audience. Younger readers I think will delight in the absurd alchemists, creepy castles, and magical wonder that characterise the story.
I knew from page one that this was going to be an immersive read, full of mystery and magic. Matthew is a likeable character, and his mild-mannered normality is fantastically contrasted with the crack-pot alchemists he unwittingly falls in with.
A sense of crumbling, ancient magic creeps through the pages, giving the story a dark yet cosy feel. The illustrations perfectly suit the mysterious, zany world Eckstein creates.
I enjoyed this book, even though I’m not its target audience. Younger readers I think will delight in the absurd alchemists, creepy castles, and magical wonder that characterise the story.
November 3, 2020
Fantastical!
What a marvelous, fantastical tale! The scope of imagination in this book is absolutely amazing. Seriously. And don't even get me started on the illustrations! Gorgeous!
The main character, Matthew, is a charmingly average boy, reminiscent of Smalls from the sandlot. His newfound friend and partner in crime (or should I say alchemy) is equally engaging in his own, fastidious way. An excellent pairing.
Overall, this was a great middle grade story! Would definitely recommend.
What a marvelous, fantastical tale! The scope of imagination in this book is absolutely amazing. Seriously. And don't even get me started on the illustrations! Gorgeous!
The main character, Matthew, is a charmingly average boy, reminiscent of Smalls from the sandlot. His newfound friend and partner in crime (or should I say alchemy) is equally engaging in his own, fastidious way. An excellent pairing.
Overall, this was a great middle grade story! Would definitely recommend.
July 8, 2021
Exciting world
The world building in this book is incredible. I loved the mysterious order of alchemists, their various devices and objects they used to help them get around and study. The different types of alchemists and their degrees of knowledge were all so well worked out and fascinating.
The author is great at description and I could see, feel and smell the different fantastic locations where the various scenes too place.
I loved the idea of Simon, but I would have liked more reason behind his approaching Matthew. I also liked the bully storyline, but wish it had been woven into the main plot so that I got a better impression of who Matthew and Simon were, the difference between their ordinary lives and the alchemist lives, and how they grew throughout the book. Matthew seemed very passive in that everything happened to him, and I didn’t get a good grasp of him as a character.
The author is also a talented artist and I loved her illustrations throughout the book. I hope there are more books exploring the fascinating world of the alchemists.
The world building in this book is incredible. I loved the mysterious order of alchemists, their various devices and objects they used to help them get around and study. The different types of alchemists and their degrees of knowledge were all so well worked out and fascinating.
The author is great at description and I could see, feel and smell the different fantastic locations where the various scenes too place.
I loved the idea of Simon, but I would have liked more reason behind his approaching Matthew. I also liked the bully storyline, but wish it had been woven into the main plot so that I got a better impression of who Matthew and Simon were, the difference between their ordinary lives and the alchemist lives, and how they grew throughout the book. Matthew seemed very passive in that everything happened to him, and I didn’t get a good grasp of him as a character.
The author is also a talented artist and I loved her illustrations throughout the book. I hope there are more books exploring the fascinating world of the alchemists.
January 11, 2021
This fantasy novel was a brilliant read. Beautiful writing and Matthew is a character we can all root for. The pacing is excellent, with plenty of twists and turns but without it becoming overwhelming. I also really liked the character of Simon and how their friendship develops. The alchemists and their order were written with flair, with enough distinctives between them. The scenes detailing the gruesome antagonist were particularly vivid. I can see how other readers noted the ending may have been a bit rushed, but for me it was a thrilling and satisfying dash to the climax of the story.
This novel was exciting from start to finish and was like a cross between Harry Potter and The Magician's Nephew. I highly recommend for older children and adults and I'm looking forward to reading any other books in the series, or from the author in general.
This novel was exciting from start to finish and was like a cross between Harry Potter and The Magician's Nephew. I highly recommend for older children and adults and I'm looking forward to reading any other books in the series, or from the author in general.
October 30, 2020
I must start by saying how beautifully written this book was. The description was simply marvellous and created a truly magical world to lose yourself in. I'd go as far as to say it's one of the best descriptions I've come across. The story itself was brilliant - fast paced and exciting. I had no idea what direction it was going to take, which kept me wanting to turn the pages. I was not disappointed with how the plot progressed.
The book left me thinking how amazing it would have been to read as a child. I know I would have loved every page and the magical world inside would have greatly appealed to my over-active imagination. As an adult I still adored this book and found the innocence of the characters furthered the story.
The book left me thinking how amazing it would have been to read as a child. I know I would have loved every page and the magical world inside would have greatly appealed to my over-active imagination. As an adult I still adored this book and found the innocence of the characters furthered the story.
July 18, 2020
I loved this book so much! I loved the characters, I loved the world, and I just wanted to join that Order. The pacing was great. I got sucked in immediately and it kept on building up until I couldn’t put it down. There is a lot of detail in the world, but it doesn’t bog you down. I just felt like looking around at everything. The descriptions are amazing, everything feels so fantastical, and yet so real at the same time. I loved Matthew and Simon. I felt like I wanted to be their friend. And Veronica … wow! I could identify with every single character, even the main antagonist. I’m so glad this is a series, I just want this story to carry on and on and on.
January 8, 2021
Quicksilver & Brimstone is a fun, whimsical adventure and the start to a promising fantasy series.
It jumps right into the action in the first chapter when our protagonist Matthew encounters a formidable alchemist. From then on, it continues with a fast pace, making it easy to fly through the pages. Along the way, we meet a lot of fun and interesting characters as well. (I do wish the book had sometimes taken its time to show the relationship between Matthew & his mother and his life outside of the magical world in more detail but that is pretty much my only complaint.)
What stands out most about Quicksilver & Brimstone, though, is its intricate world-building. It brings to the page an immersive world and it is clear a lot of time and attention was put into this. Even though there is a lot of information to take in it is always conveyed in an engaging and intriguing way and never feels like info-dumping.
Overall, I very much enjoyed this novel and look forward to the next installment!
It jumps right into the action in the first chapter when our protagonist Matthew encounters a formidable alchemist. From then on, it continues with a fast pace, making it easy to fly through the pages. Along the way, we meet a lot of fun and interesting characters as well. (I do wish the book had sometimes taken its time to show the relationship between Matthew & his mother and his life outside of the magical world in more detail but that is pretty much my only complaint.)
What stands out most about Quicksilver & Brimstone, though, is its intricate world-building. It brings to the page an immersive world and it is clear a lot of time and attention was put into this. Even though there is a lot of information to take in it is always conveyed in an engaging and intriguing way and never feels like info-dumping.
Overall, I very much enjoyed this novel and look forward to the next installment!
April 11, 2021
A Mechanical Narnia!
This was a page turner, and one I really didn't want to put down!
Eckstein's writing is brilliantly imaginative, but also clear and concise, which is quite a feat considering the vibrant world she immerses you in. I was never confused with where I was or who was who.
With mechanical workings, elixirs, alchemists and a myriad of wondrous new words, I was positively enthralled from beginning to end.
It felt a little like Narnia, of which I am a big fan, with distinguished characters, underestimated heroes, and a brilliantly classic villain.
I'll be getting my copy of the sequel for sure!
This was a page turner, and one I really didn't want to put down!
Eckstein's writing is brilliantly imaginative, but also clear and concise, which is quite a feat considering the vibrant world she immerses you in. I was never confused with where I was or who was who.
With mechanical workings, elixirs, alchemists and a myriad of wondrous new words, I was positively enthralled from beginning to end.
It felt a little like Narnia, of which I am a big fan, with distinguished characters, underestimated heroes, and a brilliantly classic villain.
I'll be getting my copy of the sequel for sure!
February 19, 2021
Fast moving and with strong character and world building. This is exciting story laced with clever details and sly humor. It reminded me of Robin Jarvis and for me there's not much higher praise you can get than that.
October 17, 2021
Like Frankenstein meets The Mystery of Black Hollow Lane
Or “if John Bellairs wrote Journey to the Center of the Earth”
Secret societies, arcane knowledge, and lonely kids just trying to fit in—this story had the intrigue of Black Hollow Lane but with scenery sometimes beautiful but sometimes grim and with a voice whose style is more elevated and poetic, like C. S. Lewis’s The Magician’s Nephew or Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. It has the same sense of wonder as The Magician’s Nephew (the first book in The Chronicles of Narnia where the protagonist takes a portal between worlds and awakens The White Witch from stasis out of fear and curiosity). It has gorgeous prose and the idea of forgotten science being perverted that Frankenstein touched on.
This story is about a twelve-year old boy who ends up at the wrong place at the wrong time, or is it the right time?
Simon finds himself a pawn between an ancient order of forbidden scientists, and one outcast mad scientist who would do anything to bend the world to his will.
Characters
Matthew gives in to curiosity and is set on a task by a creepy old man he encounters on a school field trip. Matthew’s loneliness, reactions to his dilemmas and his wonder were all relatable. It was refreshing for a book about school-aged kids to be set in a typical public school versus an elite institution. Being away from ones parents seems like an overdone attempt to remove support structure with little effort, much like the ubiquitous orphans of Disney. I appreciated that in the case of Matthew and Simon their parents, given the opportunity for free childcare that would look good on a CV or university application, then jumped on the opportunity for what seems like a prestigious, secret society.
Simon is an excellent friend, though they do have to work through challenges to their relationship. I think that aspect as well was refreshing because in real life kids don’t always get along and sometimes have to deal with a sense of betrayal or falling outs with their friends. He was an excellent supporter character who behaved very differently from Matthew; sometimes in kid books I feel like the supporting characters are just extensions of the main character with no personality or motivations of their own.
Master Hobble reminds me of an elderly physicist I once knew. He is very proper and cerebral, wants to encourage new minds, and sometimes is a little out of touch with his adulthood versus the challenges of children. He is very competent and moral—he does not fall into the trope of being a dumb, unhelpful adult, which is right up there for me with everyone’s an orphan: overdone and tiresome. The adults were well-developed and interesting.
Setting
Gwylfan Abbey in Wales stole my heart. I have dreamed of visiting Wales for so long, and the author let me live that dream, though I hope one day to have the kind of visit that involves cameras and passports.
The technology reminded me of Stargate—arcane sci-fi used to travel and escape the normal world to places just beyond that were top secret and yet not magical. I also compared it to if John Bellairs wrote Jules Verne’s The Journey to the Center of the Earth, because Bellairs’ compelling, mysterious middle-grade fiction reminded me of this author’s pacing, but paired with the creative prose of Jules Verne. I’ve recently started reading The Journey to the Center of the Earth again after reading it years ago. I had forgotten over the years that it too deals with lost science as the inciting incident is finding and deciphering a coded missive from a long-lost alchemist.
Emotional Impact
With Master Class’s comparison of Middle-Grade versus young adult, it’s my opinion that this is solidly middle-grade based off the protagonist’s age, the third-person writing, and the social challenges he faces. The stakes are high, but as appropriate for his age, it’s hard for him to see past the big picture, and he blames himself a bit for the hold the mad scientist has on him.
While there are some creepy moments, I do think that this book is age appropriate as a mother myself. It may be a bit before I introduce my little ones to this world, but I think they will thoroughly enjoy a trip on the copper line.
Conclusion
I really related to the character, enjoyed the prose, found the technology delightful, and found the pacing leaving me wanting more.
I highly recommend this book. I love that it didn’t focus on magic but technology, and as a former child who wasn’t allowed to read Harry Potter growing up, I think my mom would have let me read this book and that I would have loved it. I read the first edition with the gorgeous illustrations.
Or “if John Bellairs wrote Journey to the Center of the Earth”
Secret societies, arcane knowledge, and lonely kids just trying to fit in—this story had the intrigue of Black Hollow Lane but with scenery sometimes beautiful but sometimes grim and with a voice whose style is more elevated and poetic, like C. S. Lewis’s The Magician’s Nephew or Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. It has the same sense of wonder as The Magician’s Nephew (the first book in The Chronicles of Narnia where the protagonist takes a portal between worlds and awakens The White Witch from stasis out of fear and curiosity). It has gorgeous prose and the idea of forgotten science being perverted that Frankenstein touched on.
This story is about a twelve-year old boy who ends up at the wrong place at the wrong time, or is it the right time?
Simon finds himself a pawn between an ancient order of forbidden scientists, and one outcast mad scientist who would do anything to bend the world to his will.
Characters
Matthew gives in to curiosity and is set on a task by a creepy old man he encounters on a school field trip. Matthew’s loneliness, reactions to his dilemmas and his wonder were all relatable. It was refreshing for a book about school-aged kids to be set in a typical public school versus an elite institution. Being away from ones parents seems like an overdone attempt to remove support structure with little effort, much like the ubiquitous orphans of Disney. I appreciated that in the case of Matthew and Simon their parents, given the opportunity for free childcare that would look good on a CV or university application, then jumped on the opportunity for what seems like a prestigious, secret society.
Simon is an excellent friend, though they do have to work through challenges to their relationship. I think that aspect as well was refreshing because in real life kids don’t always get along and sometimes have to deal with a sense of betrayal or falling outs with their friends. He was an excellent supporter character who behaved very differently from Matthew; sometimes in kid books I feel like the supporting characters are just extensions of the main character with no personality or motivations of their own.
Master Hobble reminds me of an elderly physicist I once knew. He is very proper and cerebral, wants to encourage new minds, and sometimes is a little out of touch with his adulthood versus the challenges of children. He is very competent and moral—he does not fall into the trope of being a dumb, unhelpful adult, which is right up there for me with everyone’s an orphan: overdone and tiresome. The adults were well-developed and interesting.
Setting
Gwylfan Abbey in Wales stole my heart. I have dreamed of visiting Wales for so long, and the author let me live that dream, though I hope one day to have the kind of visit that involves cameras and passports.
The technology reminded me of Stargate—arcane sci-fi used to travel and escape the normal world to places just beyond that were top secret and yet not magical. I also compared it to if John Bellairs wrote Jules Verne’s The Journey to the Center of the Earth, because Bellairs’ compelling, mysterious middle-grade fiction reminded me of this author’s pacing, but paired with the creative prose of Jules Verne. I’ve recently started reading The Journey to the Center of the Earth again after reading it years ago. I had forgotten over the years that it too deals with lost science as the inciting incident is finding and deciphering a coded missive from a long-lost alchemist.
Emotional Impact
With Master Class’s comparison of Middle-Grade versus young adult, it’s my opinion that this is solidly middle-grade based off the protagonist’s age, the third-person writing, and the social challenges he faces. The stakes are high, but as appropriate for his age, it’s hard for him to see past the big picture, and he blames himself a bit for the hold the mad scientist has on him.
While there are some creepy moments, I do think that this book is age appropriate as a mother myself. It may be a bit before I introduce my little ones to this world, but I think they will thoroughly enjoy a trip on the copper line.
Conclusion
I really related to the character, enjoyed the prose, found the technology delightful, and found the pacing leaving me wanting more.
I highly recommend this book. I love that it didn’t focus on magic but technology, and as a former child who wasn’t allowed to read Harry Potter growing up, I think my mom would have let me read this book and that I would have loved it. I read the first edition with the gorgeous illustrations.
August 5, 2021
I absolutely loved this book! First, the book itself is gorgeous. Eckstein's cover, illustrations, all of it. You can tell she spent a lot of time on this. Second, the world building is top notch. Everything from mesmerizing contraptions like the Galactascope and taxipods, to wonderfully detailed locations like Drogunn Manor, Pharos, and the Athenaeum Metaphysicae, to even odd potions, plants, and creatures like snotbeans and Transylvanian bloodflies... it was all so imaginative and detailed (I especially loved all of historical and mythological references). I had several favorite characters (especially Master Ragnardt) and all of them were very colorful and well developed. In short, it is difficult for me to get lost in a book, but for this book, it was hard for me to get out of it. Honestly, the setting of her story was so interesting I could have read the entire thing regardless if there was any plot or not. I simply wanted sit in the gadget-filled libraries and explore the grand halls she created.
Third, the plot itself was well paced and not once did I get bored (I read it in 3 days which is very quick for me). In many ways the story had a detective/exploration feel to it as Matthew and Simon searched for clues and answers regarding the main antagonist, Pantomeus. There aren't a whole lot of climactic action scenes and a large portion of the book is spent introducing the boys to various parts of the alchemist's world. Some may see that as a negative, but I didn't. It was incredibly engrossing and the end of every chapter left me eager to start the next one. I also greatly enjoyed the ending.
In summary, if you enjoy lighthearted, YA fantasy, with incredibly rich worldbuilding and a solid plot, this book is for you. I can't recommend it highly enough. I will definitely be reading this to my children.
Third, the plot itself was well paced and not once did I get bored (I read it in 3 days which is very quick for me). In many ways the story had a detective/exploration feel to it as Matthew and Simon searched for clues and answers regarding the main antagonist, Pantomeus. There aren't a whole lot of climactic action scenes and a large portion of the book is spent introducing the boys to various parts of the alchemist's world. Some may see that as a negative, but I didn't. It was incredibly engrossing and the end of every chapter left me eager to start the next one. I also greatly enjoyed the ending.
In summary, if you enjoy lighthearted, YA fantasy, with incredibly rich worldbuilding and a solid plot, this book is for you. I can't recommend it highly enough. I will definitely be reading this to my children.
January 5, 2021
Hey.
Have you read Harry Potter?
Then this is a splendid Harry Potter fanfic.
It didn’t set the world on fire for me, but then I’m an ageing 46 and a 1/2 year old child...
I managed to note that page 187 did not hold any exclamation marks (the first page I could claim that was the case with...), but Harry and Ron, sorry, Matthew and Simon gadded about in a place they barely knew but understood so well.
Oh, and Hermione (sorry, Veronica...) comes to the rescue...
There’s an air of old English standard about the style and I can see St. Trinians and Molesworth here (Simon is a prig...) but there are glaring gaps between chapters and the editing has hammered the flow. Not sure the word Crikey turned up enough but there was definitely a gosh or two.
Second book in a row with Golems in - are they a thing again?
Much younger audiences will forgive the missing storyline and some of the jumps in assumption the reader has to make, much less than YA. I would say this was Candy-floss reading. Not very filling but sweet and a little sickly.
Enjoyable but not going to set the world on fire.
Have you read Harry Potter?
Then this is a splendid Harry Potter fanfic.
It didn’t set the world on fire for me, but then I’m an ageing 46 and a 1/2 year old child...
I managed to note that page 187 did not hold any exclamation marks (the first page I could claim that was the case with...), but Harry and Ron, sorry, Matthew and Simon gadded about in a place they barely knew but understood so well.
Oh, and Hermione (sorry, Veronica...) comes to the rescue...
There’s an air of old English standard about the style and I can see St. Trinians and Molesworth here (Simon is a prig...) but there are glaring gaps between chapters and the editing has hammered the flow. Not sure the word Crikey turned up enough but there was definitely a gosh or two.
Second book in a row with Golems in - are they a thing again?
Much younger audiences will forgive the missing storyline and some of the jumps in assumption the reader has to make, much less than YA. I would say this was Candy-floss reading. Not very filling but sweet and a little sickly.
Enjoyable but not going to set the world on fire.
June 22, 2021
The pacing is excellent, the characters are likeable and the world-building is well thought out. The various different contraptions, potions and devices used in this world of alchemy all seem original, interesting and unique. I particularly liked the paraports and the potential behind them, with higher ranks having the privilege of travelling to more private places.
Matthew and Simon have a great friendship arc in this book, and it's interesting to see this develop as the plot progresses. The villain is narcissistic, grandiose, and makes the reader root for Matthew and Simon in their quest to save their fellow Alchemists.
All in all, a great book, and one I thoroughly enjoyed.
Matthew and Simon have a great friendship arc in this book, and it's interesting to see this develop as the plot progresses. The villain is narcissistic, grandiose, and makes the reader root for Matthew and Simon in their quest to save their fellow Alchemists.
All in all, a great book, and one I thoroughly enjoyed.
October 29, 2021
At first I was excited to get my hands on it, but as I read the amount of detail became exhausting.
I wanted to like it, the characters did pose interest it just, weighted me down.
I would put it to the level of description much like unabridged Tolkien only modern and more, rough? Not a negative nor a super positive ether. It currently makes the story curious.
I only got to page 70 ish before I gave up, I could only read a few pages at a time before I ha dro stop and take a breath.
Overall, if you like a lot of descriptions it is for you, if not then I would at least read the sample.
I wanted to like it, the characters did pose interest it just, weighted me down.
I would put it to the level of description much like unabridged Tolkien only modern and more, rough? Not a negative nor a super positive ether. It currently makes the story curious.
I only got to page 70 ish before I gave up, I could only read a few pages at a time before I ha dro stop and take a breath.
Overall, if you like a lot of descriptions it is for you, if not then I would at least read the sample.
May 29, 2021
Adventure awaits here for readers in YA
Eckstein captures any readers attention with her expansive vocabulary, wonderful writing, amazing world building and best of all, illustrations throughout the book drawn by her!
This book gives a very Harry Potter/ Narnia type vibe as it follows Matthew on his quest through a new magical side to the world.
If your young reader is looking to find a good read, this is sure to be a book they won't be able to put down. I highly recommend this!
Eckstein captures any readers attention with her expansive vocabulary, wonderful writing, amazing world building and best of all, illustrations throughout the book drawn by her!
This book gives a very Harry Potter/ Narnia type vibe as it follows Matthew on his quest through a new magical side to the world.
If your young reader is looking to find a good read, this is sure to be a book they won't be able to put down. I highly recommend this!
May 13, 2021
A great story!
Elizabeth Eckstein's writing is wonderful. Great prose, imaginative setting, and characters that really come to life on the page. I would definitely read more of Elizabeth's work!
Elizabeth Eckstein's writing is wonderful. Great prose, imaginative setting, and characters that really come to life on the page. I would definitely read more of Elizabeth's work!
May 18, 2021
Inventive fun whatever your age
What a wonderful adventure! This is a charming book, inventive and well-written enough to keep an adult thoroughly entertained or, I'm sure, a child absolutely captivated. If you like Harry Potter you'll really enjoy this.
What a wonderful adventure! This is a charming book, inventive and well-written enough to keep an adult thoroughly entertained or, I'm sure, a child absolutely captivated. If you like Harry Potter you'll really enjoy this.
August 14, 2021
Brilliantly imaginative & exciting read
If you like fantasy, don’t miss Quicksilver & Brimstone, The Crucible of the Crimson Lion, Book 1. When 12 year old Matthew wanders off during a school tour and encounters The Great Pantomeus in the museum, he is immediately entangled in the hidden world of alchemists, with a secret society, a villainous opponent, monsters, magic, ingenious devices, and lots more.
Do you remember walking into a sweet shop (or toy shop) as a child and being awed by the dazzling array of goods on offer which made you feel you had entered fairyland? I had that same feeling so many times in this book, stepping into the world of the Crimson Lion. The world is intricate and layered, the world-building excellent, complex but handled so skilfully by the author that the reader is not overwhelmed by information but is totally immersed in the world. There are so many imaginative inventions mentioned in passing that you long to find out more. I don’t want to give spoilers so suffice it to say the Matthew is a likeable hero, the danger is real, the world fascinating, the adventure gripping, and excellently told. Also I really want a Electrospectromemorellum (but you’ll have to read the book to find out what that is!)
A really nice touch is that the story is illustrated by the author. I loved illustrations as a child – and I still do. Looking forward to the next in the series, and highly recommend this one.
If you like fantasy, don’t miss Quicksilver & Brimstone, The Crucible of the Crimson Lion, Book 1. When 12 year old Matthew wanders off during a school tour and encounters The Great Pantomeus in the museum, he is immediately entangled in the hidden world of alchemists, with a secret society, a villainous opponent, monsters, magic, ingenious devices, and lots more.
Do you remember walking into a sweet shop (or toy shop) as a child and being awed by the dazzling array of goods on offer which made you feel you had entered fairyland? I had that same feeling so many times in this book, stepping into the world of the Crimson Lion. The world is intricate and layered, the world-building excellent, complex but handled so skilfully by the author that the reader is not overwhelmed by information but is totally immersed in the world. There are so many imaginative inventions mentioned in passing that you long to find out more. I don’t want to give spoilers so suffice it to say the Matthew is a likeable hero, the danger is real, the world fascinating, the adventure gripping, and excellently told. Also I really want a Electrospectromemorellum (but you’ll have to read the book to find out what that is!)
A really nice touch is that the story is illustrated by the author. I loved illustrations as a child – and I still do. Looking forward to the next in the series, and highly recommend this one.
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews