What do you think?
Rate this book
Amish Greenhouse Mystery #3
The Robin's Greeting
A Season of Hope Is Coming
For the past two years Belinda King, along with her two grown daughters and teenage son, has been struggling to keep the family greenhouse running. Despite disconcerting events that have threatened to put them out of business, they have survived two growing seasons. And now Belinda can focus on the two suitors vying for her attention. Herschel Fisher, a new acquaintance, makes her feel relaxed, and Monroe Esh, an admirer from her past, reminds her of her youth.
But just when Belinda thinks she can choose between her suitors, life throws more trials her way. Her son, Henry, becomes bitter about the idea of her dating anyone. Her daughter-in-law finds her missing mother. Belinda gets sick. And attacks on the greenhouse start again.
When can Belinda hope to experience the peace and love her weary heart longs for?
For the past two years Belinda King, along with her two grown daughters and teenage son, has been struggling to keep the family greenhouse running. Despite disconcerting events that have threatened to put them out of business, they have survived two growing seasons. And now Belinda can focus on the two suitors vying for her attention. Herschel Fisher, a new acquaintance, makes her feel relaxed, and Monroe Esh, an admirer from her past, reminds her of her youth.
But just when Belinda thinks she can choose between her suitors, life throws more trials her way. Her son, Henry, becomes bitter about the idea of her dating anyone. Her daughter-in-law finds her missing mother. Belinda gets sick. And attacks on the greenhouse start again.
When can Belinda hope to experience the peace and love her weary heart longs for?
320 pages, Paperback
First published March 1, 2021
159 people are currently reading
2712 people want to read
About the author
Wanda E. Brunstetter
216 books2,331 followersNew York Times bestselling and award-winning author, Wanda E. Brunstetter is one of the founders of the Amish fiction genre. She has written close to 90 books translated in four languages. With over 10 million copies sold, Wanda's stories consistently earn spots on the nations most prestigious bestseller lists and have received numerous awards.
Wanda’s ancestors were part of the Anabaptist faith, and her novels are based on personal research intended to accurately portray the Amish way of life. Her books are well-read and trusted by many Amish, who credit her for giving readers a deeper understanding of the people and their customs.
When Wanda visits her Amish friends, she finds herself drawn to their peaceful lifestyle, sincerity, and close family ties. Wanda enjoys photography, ventriloquism, gardening, bird-watching, beachcombing, and spending time with her family. She and her husband, Richard, have been blessed with two grown children, six grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren.
To learn more about Wanda, visit her website at www.wandabrunstetter.com.
Wanda’s ancestors were part of the Anabaptist faith, and her novels are based on personal research intended to accurately portray the Amish way of life. Her books are well-read and trusted by many Amish, who credit her for giving readers a deeper understanding of the people and their customs.
When Wanda visits her Amish friends, she finds herself drawn to their peaceful lifestyle, sincerity, and close family ties. Wanda enjoys photography, ventriloquism, gardening, bird-watching, beachcombing, and spending time with her family. She and her husband, Richard, have been blessed with two grown children, six grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren.
To learn more about Wanda, visit her website at www.wandabrunstetter.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 188 reviews
March 7, 2021
I thought that the ending of this book was beautiful. Everything came together as it should. The first two books in this series bought suspense and mystery that wasn't solved until near the ending of the third book. As a reader I enjoy when an author will make me wait for answers until the final book in the series. This mystery was so worth the wait.
I enjoyed the characters too. The woman were all strong characters and especially Belinda. She had been handed a lot of stressful situations from the beginning but she wasn't a quitter. Belinda had a strong faith in God and tried to set examples for her older children. The characters were forgiving and showed love to others in need. I was brought to tears when the message of Salvation was shared with not one but two characters .
I was shocked twice by things that happened near the end. I didn't guess who the person was that had been harassing the King family through out the series.
Belinda King is a middle-aged Amish widow. She is really quite surprised when two Amish men compete for her attention. She doesn't make a rush decision but spends time with each man. In the end she makes a choice . She prays for God's guidance and listens to her heart. Who will she pick to spend the rest of her life with? Or will she decide against both of them and run her greenhouse on her own?
I would recommend this book to readers of Amish Fiction and cozy mystery. There are three books to this series and I would suggest that readers start with book one because each book carries on from where the last book left off.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. A favorable review was not requested. All opinions expressed here are my own.
I enjoyed the characters too. The woman were all strong characters and especially Belinda. She had been handed a lot of stressful situations from the beginning but she wasn't a quitter. Belinda had a strong faith in God and tried to set examples for her older children. The characters were forgiving and showed love to others in need. I was brought to tears when the message of Salvation was shared with not one but two characters .
I was shocked twice by things that happened near the end. I didn't guess who the person was that had been harassing the King family through out the series.
Belinda King is a middle-aged Amish widow. She is really quite surprised when two Amish men compete for her attention. She doesn't make a rush decision but spends time with each man. In the end she makes a choice . She prays for God's guidance and listens to her heart. Who will she pick to spend the rest of her life with? Or will she decide against both of them and run her greenhouse on her own?
I would recommend this book to readers of Amish Fiction and cozy mystery. There are three books to this series and I would suggest that readers start with book one because each book carries on from where the last book left off.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. A favorable review was not requested. All opinions expressed here are my own.
March 5, 2021
The third and final book in the Amish Greenhouse Mystery was a super ending to this series. I will miss the characters from these three books.
I love how Brunstetter wraps it up and how it all played out.
I loved the robin through up the whole story.
This was a sweet read.
I gave The Robin's Greeting 4 stars and I recommend it.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are our own.
I love how Brunstetter wraps it up and how it all played out.
I loved the robin through up the whole story.
This was a sweet read.
I gave The Robin's Greeting 4 stars and I recommend it.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are our own.
January 15, 2022
I received this book by accident and did not expect to like it as much as I did. It was a light read, and I do wish the characters were more developed, but I learned a lot about Amish culture which was very interesting. The ending escalated ~very~ quickly. Can't wait to try Belinda's Savory Baked Beans!
October 12, 2021
After the tragic deaths of her husband Vernon, son Abe, and son-in-law Toby, Belinda's daughter Sylvia moves back in with her two children to assist in the greenhouse business. Someone is targeting the family and its business in a series of vandalism incidents. Son Henry is determined to get to the bottom of it. Belinda's daughter Amy is expecting a child. Sylvia plans to wed Dennis soon which will leave Belinda short-handed at the greenhouse. She may be forced to sell, perhaps moving to New York where son Ezekiel and wife Michelle live. Meanwhile two men vie for Belinda's heart. Belinda dated Monroe years ago but chose Vernon over him. Monroe, now a successful businessman, tries to win Belinda, but his bragging attitude annoys everyone. Widower Herschel owns a bulk goods store in a nearby community. He owns the farm Amy and Jared rent, and they help the relationship blossom by inviting all to their home at opportune times. Henry is the only child holding out on giving a blessing to his mother's courting. Both men pursue Belinda, and she knows when it is time to commit to the one God intends to be her second husband. Other story lines involve Maude, a woman living in a run-down home, who stole a couple of chickens from the family and Virginia, the red-haired English woman across the street who spies on the family and hates the smells of the country. Virginia would rather be back in Chicago with her friends, but her husband's job brought them here. I have not read earlier installments in the series, but I enjoyed this. Despite the series declaration this is a "mystery," the mystery elements are far smaller than the romantic ones. The plot bogs down in some places. As in most Christian fiction, several Bible verses are shared as characters share their faith with others. I received this book in a GoodReads giveaway. Reviews are not required but honest ones are appreciated.
December 4, 2020
I love how this story completes the trilogy for this series.
The Robins Greeting continues on with the story of Belinda and her 4 children, Ezekiel, Sylvia, Amy and Henry. The family continues to struggle in the aftermath of the death of three of their loved ones while still trying to uncover the mystery if the vandalism at the greenhouse.
I really enjoyed this conclusion to the story!
Thanks so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.
The Robins Greeting continues on with the story of Belinda and her 4 children, Ezekiel, Sylvia, Amy and Henry. The family continues to struggle in the aftermath of the death of three of their loved ones while still trying to uncover the mystery if the vandalism at the greenhouse.
I really enjoyed this conclusion to the story!
Thanks so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.
May 18, 2021
I was so disappointed by this book. And the author. I do not enjoy, even a little bit, writing negative reviews. Wanda E. Brunstetter is not only a well-known Amish writer but also well thought of. The publisher is Shiloh Run Press which is owned by Barbour Publishing, an Ohio-based Christian publisher, which began Shiloh Run Press to publish both genre fiction and nonfiction, the latter focused on the Christian living category. Source: https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/b... ~ Jan 07, 2014] I fault the writer, the editor(s) and the publisher. Even Beta readers should have caught many of the problems I found.
Contrived sentences/paragraphs rather than writing that flows. Stilted. On page 9 a conversation takes place that is just *not* the way people would talk, including Amish folk.
In Chapter 6 a character says "I haven't seen anyone else with chickens in our area..." Really. If the person does not live in town -- and doesn't -- many people have chickens. Especially the Amish. They would see buying eggs in town as foolish. Exception would be old folks who are not living in the dawdi house. This is supposed to be a rather typical Amish community.
Confusing use of italics and not kept standard throughout the book. Example, from page 124: "Your gebackne buhne are appeditlich ." Here are THREE Pennsylvania dutch words yet only one is italicized in the book as shown in the example.
Reference to an Amish family living on a street yet they did not live in town. Someone like a Beta Reader or Editor should have changed this to *road*. Another example is eating in the dining room. Only if the Amish home was a bed & breakfast would they have a dining room. Show me interiors of a typical Amish home with a dining room. Check out the Amish America website. Interiors of Amish homes are often shown.
In Chapter 26 the weather is warm. All the barn doors are closed to keep the flies from getting inside and pestering the horses. This only makes sense to a writer not familiar with animals kept inside a barn. Flies are attracted to manure. Barn doors are not air tight. And the animals need air. Plus the smell is significantly heightened with no air moving within the building. Stalls are cleaned -- yes, but that doesn't mean that the animals 'wait' for outdoor bathroom facilities.
In Chapter 30 the person has had a knee replacement and says after being home several days from the hospital "I'll start physical therapy soon." Obviously no one in this writing/publishing team has ever had a knee replacement or cared for someone who did. Physical therapy begins before you get out of the hospital and takes place every day thereafter. At first with someone coming in to teach the patient and caregiver. If you want to walk again normally, immediate and consistent physical theory MUST start immediately and be faithfully done.
In Chapter 34 a person or person had cleared a driveway which supposedly was impassable. However, earlier in this same scene Hershel and Monroe both were able to drive their buggies up this "impassable" driveway.
Yes, I know some people have no problem with the above. But some do. It halts our thoughts and the book becomes choppy. Add passages that sound like the first writings of the scene by the author and never updated so that the scene unfolds smoothly.
I wanted to like this book. I could not.
Contrived sentences/paragraphs rather than writing that flows. Stilted. On page 9 a conversation takes place that is just *not* the way people would talk, including Amish folk.
In Chapter 6 a character says "I haven't seen anyone else with chickens in our area..." Really. If the person does not live in town -- and doesn't -- many people have chickens. Especially the Amish. They would see buying eggs in town as foolish. Exception would be old folks who are not living in the dawdi house. This is supposed to be a rather typical Amish community.
Confusing use of italics and not kept standard throughout the book. Example, from page 124: "Your gebackne buhne are appeditlich ." Here are THREE Pennsylvania dutch words yet only one is italicized in the book as shown in the example.
Reference to an Amish family living on a street yet they did not live in town. Someone like a Beta Reader or Editor should have changed this to *road*. Another example is eating in the dining room. Only if the Amish home was a bed & breakfast would they have a dining room. Show me interiors of a typical Amish home with a dining room. Check out the Amish America website. Interiors of Amish homes are often shown.
In Chapter 26 the weather is warm. All the barn doors are closed to keep the flies from getting inside and pestering the horses. This only makes sense to a writer not familiar with animals kept inside a barn. Flies are attracted to manure. Barn doors are not air tight. And the animals need air. Plus the smell is significantly heightened with no air moving within the building. Stalls are cleaned -- yes, but that doesn't mean that the animals 'wait' for outdoor bathroom facilities.
In Chapter 30 the person has had a knee replacement and says after being home several days from the hospital "I'll start physical therapy soon." Obviously no one in this writing/publishing team has ever had a knee replacement or cared for someone who did. Physical therapy begins before you get out of the hospital and takes place every day thereafter. At first with someone coming in to teach the patient and caregiver. If you want to walk again normally, immediate and consistent physical theory MUST start immediately and be faithfully done.
In Chapter 34 a person or person had cleared a driveway which supposedly was impassable. However, earlier in this same scene Hershel and Monroe both were able to drive their buggies up this "impassable" driveway.
Yes, I know some people have no problem with the above. But some do. It halts our thoughts and the book becomes choppy. Add passages that sound like the first writings of the scene by the author and never updated so that the scene unfolds smoothly.
I wanted to like this book. I could not.
January 31, 2021
The Robin’s Greeting is a fitting conclusion to the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series. The chronicle of the King family continues as each family member seeks to move forward with their lives two years after the devastating tragedy that shook their family. The plot flows smoothly and steadily as they face relationship challenges and the return of threats and vandalism to their property. Although I guessed the identity of the culprit after the first book, it was still interesting to see how the mystery satisfyingly unfolds. One big revelation took me completely by surprise! I appreciated the spiritual truths that permeated the story relating to salvation and forgiveness, and I loved the endearing characters in this series as God worked transforming their lives and healing relationships. The sweet middle-age romantic triangle is entertaining and at times humorous! This book works well as a stand-alone since Ms. Brunstetter once again provides rich details from previous books to bridge the stories. I do, however, recommend reading all three books in order to get the full effect of the story. I loved this book and the series and highly recommend it especially for lovers of Amish fiction.
I received a copy of this book in ebook form from the publisher through netgalley. All opinions are my own.
I received a copy of this book in ebook form from the publisher through netgalley. All opinions are my own.
March 4, 2021
The Robin’s Greeting is the conclusion to the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series with many unexpected revelations. The King family is growing but still experiencing vandalism at their greenhouse, new life, challenges and romance filled the story along with finding forgiveness. The King family are protective of one another, especially Henry when Belinda had two suitors. Who’s going to be the lucky one or will she remain a widow?
The final few chapters are filled with twists and turns with some I anticipated and others totally a surprise. The ending seemed rush but maybe some of the characters will be continued in another series since we initially meet the King Family in The Prayer Jars series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. I have shared my own thoughts.
The final few chapters are filled with twists and turns with some I anticipated and others totally a surprise. The ending seemed rush but maybe some of the characters will be continued in another series since we initially meet the King Family in The Prayer Jars series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review. I have shared my own thoughts.
March 19, 2021
The Robin's Greeting is another beautiful story. It continues the King Family's story and how they get past the loss of their three love ones. This book focuses on Belinda and her two suitors. But there seems that there is more to the mystery of who is vandalizing the greenhouse.
There are quite some events that happen for Belinda's two grown daughters. Henry still seems to be grieving the loss of this father and older brother and brother-in-law Toby. But will he find some happiness in this life?
Michelle and her husband seem to come down to spend time with his family. Will Michelle find her mother? There seem to be complete surprises at every turn. Virginia seems pretty upset with her neighbors that live across the street. Will the Martin's ever warm up to the Kings or the Amish?
Virginia seems lonely and upset to be still living in the Amish country. Is there a reason for the Martins to have gotten the house next door and close the greenhouse? Who could be the one that is vandalizing the greenhouse and making Henry go looking for the person responsible for all the attacks on the King's greenhouse? Oh, how this ends and surprises at the end.
Suppose you want to find out how Michelle becomes Belinda King's daughter-in-law. How she became Amish, you should read "The Prayer Jars" series. Its first book is called "The Hope Jar." I have reviewed each one of these books.
Wanda does it again with this book. This series is just as good as "The Prayer Jars." I enjoyed each one of these books in this series, "Amish Greenhouse Mystery." Will they solve the mystery that is going on at their greenhouse? What up with Maude coming to the greenhouse and up to the King's place? I enjoyed the titles of each of these books as well.
There are quite some events that happen for Belinda's two grown daughters. Henry still seems to be grieving the loss of this father and older brother and brother-in-law Toby. But will he find some happiness in this life?
Michelle and her husband seem to come down to spend time with his family. Will Michelle find her mother? There seem to be complete surprises at every turn. Virginia seems pretty upset with her neighbors that live across the street. Will the Martin's ever warm up to the Kings or the Amish?
Virginia seems lonely and upset to be still living in the Amish country. Is there a reason for the Martins to have gotten the house next door and close the greenhouse? Who could be the one that is vandalizing the greenhouse and making Henry go looking for the person responsible for all the attacks on the King's greenhouse? Oh, how this ends and surprises at the end.
Suppose you want to find out how Michelle becomes Belinda King's daughter-in-law. How she became Amish, you should read "The Prayer Jars" series. Its first book is called "The Hope Jar." I have reviewed each one of these books.
Wanda does it again with this book. This series is just as good as "The Prayer Jars." I enjoyed each one of these books in this series, "Amish Greenhouse Mystery." Will they solve the mystery that is going on at their greenhouse? What up with Maude coming to the greenhouse and up to the King's place? I enjoyed the titles of each of these books as well.
May 1, 2021
I love mysteries, so I was thrilled to learn that author Wanda E. Brunstetter was writing an Amish mystery series. Let me tell you, I haven't been disappointed! The three books in the the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series have centered around the King family, and we've watched them endure overwhelming tragedy, numbing grief, and repeated threats to their livelihood. Now, two years after the tragic accident that claimed three members of their family, it appears that a brighter future is ahead. Finally, after being the glue that has held all of them together, the matriarch, Belinda King, is being courted by two men. Can her teenage son accept another man in their lives? Will Belinda be able to love again, after losing the love of her life?
Brunstetter fully understands the Amish way of life, and her introduction of mystery and suspense adds a pleasing element to her writing. The Robin's Greeting reveals the identity of the person responsible for vandalizing the King's greenhouse over the past two years, and I was totally surprised! I was also amazed to learn that there was a connection between the King family and the English neighbor who had always been so antagonistic toward them.
The Robin's Greeting is the perfect way to wrap up the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series, and I recommend it to all who enjoy reading about family, faith, and the Amish way of life.
I received a copy of this book from the author. There was no obligation for a positive review. These are my own thoughts and opinions.
Brunstetter fully understands the Amish way of life, and her introduction of mystery and suspense adds a pleasing element to her writing. The Robin's Greeting reveals the identity of the person responsible for vandalizing the King's greenhouse over the past two years, and I was totally surprised! I was also amazed to learn that there was a connection between the King family and the English neighbor who had always been so antagonistic toward them.
The Robin's Greeting is the perfect way to wrap up the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series, and I recommend it to all who enjoy reading about family, faith, and the Amish way of life.
I received a copy of this book from the author. There was no obligation for a positive review. These are my own thoughts and opinions.
December 8, 2020
Love the third book in this series called the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series! It has been interesting to follow along with Belinda and her children through the tragedy of losing their three family members in the first book of the series and how the family dynamic has evolved as they work through their grief and learn to live their lives on a daily basis.
In this book, Belinda (the mom) is still being pursued by Monroe Ash. Monroe has had a "crush" on Belinda since before she married Vernon (her husband who was killed in the accident). Along with Monroe, Hershel Fisher also becomes an admirer of Belinda's and wants to pursue her.
While all of this is going on, there are still continued threats being made against Belinda and her family and their livelihood which is the greenhouse. Her teenage son and her two grown daughters have been working alongside Belinda at the greenhouse trying to make a living for the family. In this third book of the series, the person who has been making the threats is finally revealed. For me it was a huge surprise but a nice surprise as a result of the circumstances which prevail once everything is revealed.
Thanks to the publisher, Shiloh Run Press and Net Galley for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book. This is my honest and unbiased opinion. GREAT book!
In this book, Belinda (the mom) is still being pursued by Monroe Ash. Monroe has had a "crush" on Belinda since before she married Vernon (her husband who was killed in the accident). Along with Monroe, Hershel Fisher also becomes an admirer of Belinda's and wants to pursue her.
While all of this is going on, there are still continued threats being made against Belinda and her family and their livelihood which is the greenhouse. Her teenage son and her two grown daughters have been working alongside Belinda at the greenhouse trying to make a living for the family. In this third book of the series, the person who has been making the threats is finally revealed. For me it was a huge surprise but a nice surprise as a result of the circumstances which prevail once everything is revealed.
Thanks to the publisher, Shiloh Run Press and Net Galley for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book. This is my honest and unbiased opinion. GREAT book!
March 6, 2021
The Robin's Greeting is the third book in a series that ties the whole story up nicely. I enjoyed reading the previous two books, and this book didn't disappoint. Belinda, the mother in the story has found that two men are interested in her, even though as a recent widow she has no desire to marry anyone. As time goes on and she spends time with both men, she begins to have feelings toward one man, and he has fallen in love with her. During all of this time, somebody is leaving threatening messages and vandalizing their property. Who is it that wants them to close their greenhouse and move away? The answer was surprising, and the story a great one. Good , clean story!
February 22, 2021
Ever wonder what an Amish mystery series is like..? In the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series, you will find a story that will captivate you until the series finale! This particular book wraps up the mystery of who is trying to destroy the greenhouse business owned by Belinda King.
In book one, Belinda and her family endure a horrible tragedy on the same day of her birthday celebration. Three members of the King family are killed in a buggy accident. From what I understand, buggy accidents in rural towns that house Amish settlements are, unfortunately, common. I have been to Lancaster County, PA numerous times and have seen cars speed by horse drawn carriages at frightening speeds. There seems to be no patience and road rage can be common.
In this last book of the series, we find Belinda King at the point where two of her family members are healing from their loss, remarrying and moving on with their lives. But the question remains, will Belinda be left alone running the family business with her grieving son, Henry, or will she be able to move on with her life like the rest of the family?
The German meaning of the name “Henry” means “the ruler of the home” and that is his current position. Although Henry is still a teenager, he is forced into a position of head of the house when he hasn’t yet recovered from the death of his family including his father. Henry loves to watch birds. With his binoculars, he enjoys a respite from both his grief and hard work in the family business by watching these engaging creatures from the loft in the barn.
A robin represents Springtime, new beginnings, and also good luck. The title of each book is a clue to the reader of what lives inside the story and this novel is no exception. In this book, a robin is within the text during the winter months and is flying into a window in the kitchen. The poor thing is on the brink of hurting itself as though the new beginning of the story is killing itself and won’t survive. The King family cannot continue to watch this self-destructive act and so a family member pulls the window shade down trying to hide it. This situation happens at the time when there is damage to the greenhouse and threats from a mysterious adversary.
There are two surprises that take place in the narrative. In the first one, Virginia and Earl Martin have moved into the house across the street from the greenhouse relocating from Chicago, IL. Virginia is a prickly character whose mental state sways from indifference to judgmental when she isn’t included. As the story progresses, the reader begins to gain access to her troubling demeanor swaying from utter annoyance with her to gradually gaining insight and then eventual understanding of her cantankerous behavior. Therefore, when her husband Earl becomes the guilty party in his attempt to destroy the greenhouse, the reader can understand his rationale and become sympathetic to it.
In the second surprise, Ezekiel King has married a woman who used to be English. Ezekiel is Belinda’s oldest son who is a preacher and lives in Clymer, New York. His wife's name is Michelle which in Hebrew or French means “a gift from God”. Michelle is one of one of Virginia’s three children which were taken away from her in their childhood because of abuse! I didn’t see that coming… As the slow reuniting with her children progresses, it causes Virginia (the prickly one) to become a Christian. Her husband Earl eventually follows her lead after his repentance to Belinda King. Two surprises!
Monroe Esh, Belinda’s old beau, is pushing her into marriage. He is an agitator that is both controlling and arrogant. Belinda, our main character, is maddeningly passive and takes this self-centered man’s behavior in stride. Nobody in the family really likes Monroe! However, Belinda continues to be kind to him. Her son Henry, refuses to accept Monroe believing he is one of the suspects trying to destroy the business. The name Monroe means “near the water, or swamp” and his behavior resembles a swamp creature. His presence in the story is transitional ~like swampland which is a complex symbol of Monroe’s character.
Herschel Fisher, an older widow, has also taken a liking to Belinda. The name Herschel means “deer”. In Christian fiction, the deer is a symbol of piety, devotion and of God taking care of his children (iow: mankind). Herschel is patient and kind. He tries to friend Henry, and help with the greenhouse. Eventually, he and Belinda fall in love and get married.
There were a few places in the narrative where the timing seemed off to me. I found a few misspelled words, but for the most part the story worked! I have to say I read a lot of Amish fiction written by Wanda Brunstetter. They are simple stories that always include a happy ending! I give this one a 4 ½ out of 5 stars
In book one, Belinda and her family endure a horrible tragedy on the same day of her birthday celebration. Three members of the King family are killed in a buggy accident. From what I understand, buggy accidents in rural towns that house Amish settlements are, unfortunately, common. I have been to Lancaster County, PA numerous times and have seen cars speed by horse drawn carriages at frightening speeds. There seems to be no patience and road rage can be common.
In this last book of the series, we find Belinda King at the point where two of her family members are healing from their loss, remarrying and moving on with their lives. But the question remains, will Belinda be left alone running the family business with her grieving son, Henry, or will she be able to move on with her life like the rest of the family?
The German meaning of the name “Henry” means “the ruler of the home” and that is his current position. Although Henry is still a teenager, he is forced into a position of head of the house when he hasn’t yet recovered from the death of his family including his father. Henry loves to watch birds. With his binoculars, he enjoys a respite from both his grief and hard work in the family business by watching these engaging creatures from the loft in the barn.
A robin represents Springtime, new beginnings, and also good luck. The title of each book is a clue to the reader of what lives inside the story and this novel is no exception. In this book, a robin is within the text during the winter months and is flying into a window in the kitchen. The poor thing is on the brink of hurting itself as though the new beginning of the story is killing itself and won’t survive. The King family cannot continue to watch this self-destructive act and so a family member pulls the window shade down trying to hide it. This situation happens at the time when there is damage to the greenhouse and threats from a mysterious adversary.
There are two surprises that take place in the narrative. In the first one, Virginia and Earl Martin have moved into the house across the street from the greenhouse relocating from Chicago, IL. Virginia is a prickly character whose mental state sways from indifference to judgmental when she isn’t included. As the story progresses, the reader begins to gain access to her troubling demeanor swaying from utter annoyance with her to gradually gaining insight and then eventual understanding of her cantankerous behavior. Therefore, when her husband Earl becomes the guilty party in his attempt to destroy the greenhouse, the reader can understand his rationale and become sympathetic to it.
In the second surprise, Ezekiel King has married a woman who used to be English. Ezekiel is Belinda’s oldest son who is a preacher and lives in Clymer, New York. His wife's name is Michelle which in Hebrew or French means “a gift from God”. Michelle is one of one of Virginia’s three children which were taken away from her in their childhood because of abuse! I didn’t see that coming… As the slow reuniting with her children progresses, it causes Virginia (the prickly one) to become a Christian. Her husband Earl eventually follows her lead after his repentance to Belinda King. Two surprises!
Monroe Esh, Belinda’s old beau, is pushing her into marriage. He is an agitator that is both controlling and arrogant. Belinda, our main character, is maddeningly passive and takes this self-centered man’s behavior in stride. Nobody in the family really likes Monroe! However, Belinda continues to be kind to him. Her son Henry, refuses to accept Monroe believing he is one of the suspects trying to destroy the business. The name Monroe means “near the water, or swamp” and his behavior resembles a swamp creature. His presence in the story is transitional ~like swampland which is a complex symbol of Monroe’s character.
Herschel Fisher, an older widow, has also taken a liking to Belinda. The name Herschel means “deer”. In Christian fiction, the deer is a symbol of piety, devotion and of God taking care of his children (iow: mankind). Herschel is patient and kind. He tries to friend Henry, and help with the greenhouse. Eventually, he and Belinda fall in love and get married.
There were a few places in the narrative where the timing seemed off to me. I found a few misspelled words, but for the most part the story worked! I have to say I read a lot of Amish fiction written by Wanda Brunstetter. They are simple stories that always include a happy ending! I give this one a 4 ½ out of 5 stars
February 24, 2021
The Robin's Greeting by Wanda E. Brunstetter
The Robin's Greeting is the stunning conclusion to the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series, book 3 of 3.
Belinda King is the owner of an Amish greenhouse, where she, her youngest son Henry and her oldest daughter Sylvia, works, to support the family since Belinda's husband Vernon, her son Abe and son in law Toby (Sylvia's husband) were all killed in a tragic buggy accident on Belinda's birthday.
The whole family has had to adapt and go on with their lives, doing their best for each other and for their neighbors.
Belinda is content to work in the greenhouse and look after her family and spend lots of time with her grandchildren. But, God and two very distinctive men have different ideas.
Monroe Esh dated Belinda before she chose to marry Vernon. He has decided that Belinda is the only woman for him, he boasts all the time, how rich he is because he owns several Amish-made furniture stores in the area and how perfect he is for her.
Herschel Fisher is a few years older than Belinda, a widower who has only recently decided that he likes Belinda, very much and wonders if she might like him as well. He owns a bulk food store in another town but finds the time to check in on the family and their greenhouse to see if they need anything done or that he can help them with.
Both men set out to charm Belinda, who isn't sure she wants to remarry but continues to see both men casually, to find out if either relationship will go onward, or not.
There is a vandal that has been making threats against the family and the greenhouse, with incidents getting more and more vicious as time goes on. Henry wants to call the sheriff in and let him investigate the situation and take care of it for them, but Belinda wants to pray more and is hoping that the vandals will either tire of their harassment of her family or feel guilt over their actions and come forward and confess. Belinda can't figure out who would hate her family so much, that they would do a lot of bad things to her family and their livelihood.
Henry has been thought to be the culprit in the past because he has a lot of anger towards the accident that caused the passing of his beloved father and brother and brother-in-law. But as time continues on, Belinda realizes that there is no way that Henry could be the one responsible. Henry has a list of possible culprits, maybe Maude, the virtual homeless vagrant woman who helps herself to his mam's garden and even their chickens!
Henry informs his mam that he is going to investigate all of the shenanigans that are going on at their place, especially since the miscreant is getting braver, going as far as into their barn and phone shack to leave derogatory messages for his family to find. Belinda doesn't want to mention the antics to her eldest son Ezekiel, because she is afraid that he'd worry and want to leave his very successful beekeeping supply business in New York and move home to Pennsylvania to take care of the greenhouse and his mam and younger siblings.
This novel was pure bliss to read, Wanda E. Brunstetter is a brilliant writer who is able to capture the pureness of Amish living and develop a fascinating story that you are entertained by from the very first page. Highly recommended.
My heartfelt gratitude to #ShilohRunPress and #Barbour for the complimentary copy, I was under no obligation to post a review.
The Robin's Greeting is the stunning conclusion to the Amish Greenhouse Mystery series, book 3 of 3.
Belinda King is the owner of an Amish greenhouse, where she, her youngest son Henry and her oldest daughter Sylvia, works, to support the family since Belinda's husband Vernon, her son Abe and son in law Toby (Sylvia's husband) were all killed in a tragic buggy accident on Belinda's birthday.
The whole family has had to adapt and go on with their lives, doing their best for each other and for their neighbors.
Belinda is content to work in the greenhouse and look after her family and spend lots of time with her grandchildren. But, God and two very distinctive men have different ideas.
Monroe Esh dated Belinda before she chose to marry Vernon. He has decided that Belinda is the only woman for him, he boasts all the time, how rich he is because he owns several Amish-made furniture stores in the area and how perfect he is for her.
Herschel Fisher is a few years older than Belinda, a widower who has only recently decided that he likes Belinda, very much and wonders if she might like him as well. He owns a bulk food store in another town but finds the time to check in on the family and their greenhouse to see if they need anything done or that he can help them with.
Both men set out to charm Belinda, who isn't sure she wants to remarry but continues to see both men casually, to find out if either relationship will go onward, or not.
There is a vandal that has been making threats against the family and the greenhouse, with incidents getting more and more vicious as time goes on. Henry wants to call the sheriff in and let him investigate the situation and take care of it for them, but Belinda wants to pray more and is hoping that the vandals will either tire of their harassment of her family or feel guilt over their actions and come forward and confess. Belinda can't figure out who would hate her family so much, that they would do a lot of bad things to her family and their livelihood.
Henry has been thought to be the culprit in the past because he has a lot of anger towards the accident that caused the passing of his beloved father and brother and brother-in-law. But as time continues on, Belinda realizes that there is no way that Henry could be the one responsible. Henry has a list of possible culprits, maybe Maude, the virtual homeless vagrant woman who helps herself to his mam's garden and even their chickens!
Henry informs his mam that he is going to investigate all of the shenanigans that are going on at their place, especially since the miscreant is getting braver, going as far as into their barn and phone shack to leave derogatory messages for his family to find. Belinda doesn't want to mention the antics to her eldest son Ezekiel, because she is afraid that he'd worry and want to leave his very successful beekeeping supply business in New York and move home to Pennsylvania to take care of the greenhouse and his mam and younger siblings.
This novel was pure bliss to read, Wanda E. Brunstetter is a brilliant writer who is able to capture the pureness of Amish living and develop a fascinating story that you are entertained by from the very first page. Highly recommended.
My heartfelt gratitude to #ShilohRunPress and #Barbour for the complimentary copy, I was under no obligation to post a review.
January 6, 2021
I was going to wait until closer to the publication date but I couldn't help myself. I just had to open it and start reading! Oh my!
Y'all! This book is full of surprises!
Brunstetter has once again woven another tale about Sylvia, Henry and Belinda. I hate saying goodbye but their story is so fascinating and to see what God has orchestrated for this family is truly amazing!
I've made some wonderful friends from the first book in this series and new ones in this last book.
My heart in a way goes out to Virginia. You see, when I first met her I didn't like her for more reasons than one. I can relate to her on one thing and that's our legs. I have a bum leg too and I felt the pain that Virginia experienced. It's not fun. It hurts!
The mystery that made this series was a good one. I was very surprised when I found out who done it. I never never expected it to be him. Just wow!
Brunstetter sure knows how to keep us in suspense! I never saw that one coming. Blew me away!
I'm gonna end my review with a favorite Bible verse John 3:16
For God so loved the world that He gave His only Son that whosoever believes in Him will have ever lasting life. That's a wonderful promise. Ain't so?
I am sad to see this series end but as always I'm looking forward to see what Brunstetter comes out with next!
Definitely 5 stars on this sweet book. Kept my attention the whole way through.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own..
Y'all! This book is full of surprises!
Brunstetter has once again woven another tale about Sylvia, Henry and Belinda. I hate saying goodbye but their story is so fascinating and to see what God has orchestrated for this family is truly amazing!
I've made some wonderful friends from the first book in this series and new ones in this last book.
My heart in a way goes out to Virginia. You see, when I first met her I didn't like her for more reasons than one. I can relate to her on one thing and that's our legs. I have a bum leg too and I felt the pain that Virginia experienced. It's not fun. It hurts!
The mystery that made this series was a good one. I was very surprised when I found out who done it. I never never expected it to be him. Just wow!
Brunstetter sure knows how to keep us in suspense! I never saw that one coming. Blew me away!
I'm gonna end my review with a favorite Bible verse John 3:16
For God so loved the world that He gave His only Son that whosoever believes in Him will have ever lasting life. That's a wonderful promise. Ain't so?
I am sad to see this series end but as always I'm looking forward to see what Brunstetter comes out with next!
Definitely 5 stars on this sweet book. Kept my attention the whole way through.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own..
February 27, 2021
The Robin’s Greeting by Wanda E. Brunstetter is the third and final Amish Greenhouse Mystery. It can be read as a standalone for those new to the series. The Robin’s Greetings continues the story of the Belinda King and her four children along with their families (Ezekiel, Amy, Sylvia, and Henry). They miss their loved ones who died two years prior in a terrible accident, but they are ready to move forward. Amy and Jared are happily married while Sylvia is courting Dennis. Belinda misses Ezekiel and his family, but she knows they are doing well in Clymer, New York where Ezekiel is now a minister. I thought The Robin’s Greeting was well-written with developed characters and steady pacing. I have enjoyed getting to know the King family and I have been dying to find out if I have correctly identified the guilty party. It is nice to see Sylvia finding love once again. There were some unexpected revelations near the end of the book (many of you will go “Oh, that’s right” like I did). I did find the ending a little rushed, but that did not hinder my enjoyment. I found it to be touching and uplifting. I also liked how the robin theme was prevalent through the whole story (a robin symbolizes happiness, hope, and new beginnings). The Robin’s Greeting was a sweet book and a charming series. Wanda E. Brunstetter did not disappoint with this heartwarming tale.
Want to read
March 18, 2021The Robin's Greeting is the third and final story written by Wanda Brunstetter in her Amish Greenhouse Mystery series. The author has done an amazing job winding up this series with this wonderful story. As we pick the story back up the vandalism to Belinda King's property continues. As her family tries to figure out who is behind the destruction their suspect list grows. While the story plays out Belinda finds herself being counted by two Amish men. Who Belinda chooses may surprise you. But the real conclusion to the identity of the person threatening the King family is definitely not a person I had on my list. There are many surprises throughout this story and the likeable characters bring this story to light. The author has once again delivered another fantastic series for her readers enjoyment.
I did receive a complimentary copy of this book to read and review through Barbour Publishing at the authors request. I was not approached to post a favorable response just an honest one. All opinions are my own. I have rated this story with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.
I did receive a complimentary copy of this book to read and review through Barbour Publishing at the authors request. I was not approached to post a favorable response just an honest one. All opinions are my own. I have rated this story with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.
March 25, 2021
I was drawn to “The Robin’s Greeting” by its description as an “Amish Greenhouse Mystery,” since I enjoy plants. The mystery here is that Belinda King’s greenhouse has been the victim of vandalism, and the King family has received threatening messages. In a quaint Amish community, who could be doing this?
Belinda is also dealing with loneliness after her husband’s death, but she has two suitors. Will she choose Herschel or Monroe? Complicating the situation is the fact that her teenage son, Henry, doesn’t want Belinda to get involved again with any man.
There are other characters woven in; “English” neighbors Earl and Virginia, the raggedy older Maude who lives nearby, and Belinda’s grown and married children. All these characters combine to create the cozy Amish community “feel” that makes books like this popular.
Wanda Brunstetter has plenty of experience with the Amish and writes well. I felt the ending here was too rushed and that several storylines were tied up a bit unrealistically, but hey — it’s fiction. Good book if you enjoy Amish novels.
Belinda is also dealing with loneliness after her husband’s death, but she has two suitors. Will she choose Herschel or Monroe? Complicating the situation is the fact that her teenage son, Henry, doesn’t want Belinda to get involved again with any man.
There are other characters woven in; “English” neighbors Earl and Virginia, the raggedy older Maude who lives nearby, and Belinda’s grown and married children. All these characters combine to create the cozy Amish community “feel” that makes books like this popular.
Wanda Brunstetter has plenty of experience with the Amish and writes well. I felt the ending here was too rushed and that several storylines were tied up a bit unrealistically, but hey — it’s fiction. Good book if you enjoy Amish novels.
May 5, 2021
I will say of the Lord, He is my refuge and my fortress; my God; in him will I trust.
I have really enjoyed this series. All centered around the King's family tragedy and bird watching. Belinda King who lost her husband two years ago and trying to maintain the family business. Her two daughters have found that God sees them with their marriage and upcoming marriage. Henry, the youngest son is still fighting anger of what happened to his father and brothers. He takes solace in bird watching and the lessons that God is teaching him. Belinda has two suitors vying for her hand in marriage. The two men are as different as night and day and tension rises as one pushes for her to make up her mind.
I was surprised by the English neighbors of the Kings and how their story comes more into light. Tragedy will happen but God who gives hope did for the Kings. How important it is to be aware of God's goodness and sharing that with others.
A special thank you to Barbour Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
I have really enjoyed this series. All centered around the King's family tragedy and bird watching. Belinda King who lost her husband two years ago and trying to maintain the family business. Her two daughters have found that God sees them with their marriage and upcoming marriage. Henry, the youngest son is still fighting anger of what happened to his father and brothers. He takes solace in bird watching and the lessons that God is teaching him. Belinda has two suitors vying for her hand in marriage. The two men are as different as night and day and tension rises as one pushes for her to make up her mind.
I was surprised by the English neighbors of the Kings and how their story comes more into light. Tragedy will happen but God who gives hope did for the Kings. How important it is to be aware of God's goodness and sharing that with others.
A special thank you to Barbour Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
April 8, 2021
The Amish Greenhouse trilogy was exciting. My suggestion is to read the three books in succession as you won't want to wait to find out the mysterious troublemaker. Needless to say, I was shocked when it was revealed in The Robin's Greeting.
The series takes place roughly over a two-year time period. You follow the King family as they work through their grief after losing several loved ones in a single accident. You will need plenty of tissues and be prepared to stay up late with each book.
The Robin's Greeting ties every loose end up and you are left with hope and love. If you are experiencing grief as I am this series is perfect. You realize your feelings are normal and happy days will come again. It just takes time.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher, Barbour Publishing, Inc., through Netgalley. All opinions expressed in the above review are entirely my own.
The series takes place roughly over a two-year time period. You follow the King family as they work through their grief after losing several loved ones in a single accident. You will need plenty of tissues and be prepared to stay up late with each book.
The Robin's Greeting ties every loose end up and you are left with hope and love. If you are experiencing grief as I am this series is perfect. You realize your feelings are normal and happy days will come again. It just takes time.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher, Barbour Publishing, Inc., through Netgalley. All opinions expressed in the above review are entirely my own.
Read
March 2, 2021this book is wonderful i loved following the lives of the King Family. Was so happy to read that Belinda had choose Herschel Fisher to marry. Henry is like alot of kids that don't want a step parent when it came to his mom courting and getting remarried. was thrilled about Sylvia and Dennis getting married so glad she found true love again after the death of her husband. it did take me by surprise at who was causing all the problems for them at the green house i wouldnt never had thought of him. along with the surprise that virginia was Michelle's mother so many life lessons in this book i hate that it is the last of the series to sum up another great book Wanda E.Brunstetter congrats can not wait for the next one
March 8, 2021
Rating: 5 Stars!! (Wish i could rate it 10 Stars!!)
Review:
Another great book in this series about a family that owns an Amish Greenhouse in Strasburg, PA!!
The characters were so interesting to read about and The setting is still so beautifully discribed!! I loved that this one ended with revealing Belinda's TRUE Suitor and the person who had been terrorizing the family in this series!!
I do wish there was a spinoff series about Amy and Jared, Sylvia and Dennis cause i'd love to see how their life is going now!!
Can't wait to read more by this author in the future!!
Review:
Another great book in this series about a family that owns an Amish Greenhouse in Strasburg, PA!!
The characters were so interesting to read about and The setting is still so beautifully discribed!! I loved that this one ended with revealing Belinda's TRUE Suitor and the person who had been terrorizing the family in this series!!
I do wish there was a spinoff series about Amy and Jared, Sylvia and Dennis cause i'd love to see how their life is going now!!
Can't wait to read more by this author in the future!!
March 13, 2021
I have read all three books in the Amish Greenhouse Mysteries series. Each book is a wonderful read but to fully understand the backstories in each, they should be read in order. The King family has suffered misfortune and heartbreak but find the faith and strength to continue their greenhouse business. The Robin's Greetings will bring the family's story full circle, exposing those who continue to harm the family. A beautiful series with well written and developed characters. A book written by Wanda Brunstetter is guaranteed to be a 5 star read that can be shared with everyone you know.
March 25, 2021
The set finale gave us answers we’ve all been looking for and not disappointing us in any way. To finish up the story on an Amish family and the tragedy that strikes this family and how they overcome such through faith, love and walking by Gods side, the author created a masterpiece that kept me turning the pages for more and loving each character in their own way. A fantastic series to read and you’ll learn so much on Amish living.
I was given a copy of this book from the publisher. This review is my own and not required.
I was given a copy of this book from the publisher. This review is my own and not required.
March 21, 2021
This was the best of all the series I have read from Wanda Brunstetter. I cried, I laughed. I tried to be a detective to discover the perpetrator and I was so shocked to learn of the person responsible. I love how Wanda brings the gospel of Jesus Christ into her books. Keep on writing, Wanda!
April 29, 2021
Belinda King and her children suffered the loss of 3 men in their life, but their lives have continued on despite someone threatening them. With the help of friends things are getting better!
March 2, 2021
Ms. Brunstetter knocked it out of the ballpark with this conclusion to The Amish Greenhouse Mystery Series. It had me guessing till the end of who was vandalizing the King greenhouse and property. I never saw that one coming as well as a few other gobsmacking moments that I won’t mention as I don’t want to post any spoilers. All I can say is wow with my mouth ajar. It was a stunning conclusion and I will be sad to see this series end but happy with resolutions to mysterious happenings. I also learned to care about Virginia in this book and getting to know what caused her to be the way she was. I loved the hope and changes that were made in some lives because they came to acknowledge they needed Christ. Witnessing the healing that takes place in the King family after major losses was like watching friends grow and finding happiness. I think this is the authors best work yet. I was blessed to read this series.
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishing. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
I received a complimentary copy from Barbour Publishing. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
July 27, 2021
The addition of Virginia made this just an okay read for me and the whole Virginia and Michelle fiasco at the end just reminded me why I don't read nearly as many Amish books as I used to. I'm always looking for the complete Amish experience without the many non Amish characters that infiltrate these books nowadays!
July 16, 2024
This third book of the trilogy is the best one. A couple of mysteries that started in the first book carried through to the last one, and the answers were surprising. Another big surprise was how and why the relationship between the Plain people and the unfriendly English neighbour across the street changed quite dramatically. It was a pleasant read.
April 28, 2023
This book is great! I absolutely love the faith and family content. Scripture and salvation in Jesus were included clearly in this book. ❤️
Displaying 1 - 30 of 188 reviews