With the suspension of the Goodreads Choice 2021 Picture Book category, I was of mixed feelings; first, my family yearly rates all the nominees, but we had in recent years been less impressed with the nominees (which Rod Brown found were often published by Amazon subsidiaries). So I consulted a couple sources for likely Caldecott Award nominees, and I asked a few people to read them with me; in general they are so much better than, for instance, last year’s GR bunch. As my kids get older, they have mostly dropped out of the reading, but I still have anywhere from 2-4 readers with me this year.
#9 is “Watercress,” by Andrea Wang and illustrated by Jason Chin, the story of Wang’s being initially embarrassed to stop with her parents to find watercress at the side of the road. Why can’t we just buy it from the store? We look poor! Then her parents tell her of their own poverty while growing up, and the value of knowing where food comes from..
R (retired librarian): (4.5 stars). Good story. History. Illustrations are fitting.
T (electrician): (5 stars). I loved this. Sweet. Sad. Good illustrations.
Dave (teacher) (4.5 stars). Inspiring story from Wang’s life, beautiful art from Jason Chin, and I am so much a fan, each illustration thoughtful, lovely, with lots of reflective space on every page. About the power of memory, family, food.