3 ⭐
Storm it Gancho, it’s good to finally have some new Stormlight material! It’s been… weeks since I last held a Sanderson book in my filthy lowlander mitts and I was starting to get the shakes like Teft after a couple of days without Firemoss!
Dawnshard, not to be confused with Dawnshart (an early-hours fart that takes a sinister turn), is a Stormlight novella set between the 2 behemoths, Oathbringer and Rhythm of War. We follow Rysn and the crew of the Wandersail, along with Lopen, Huio, Cord and a number of other very interesting characters as they embark on an expedition to the Storm-shrouded island of Akinah with the official assignment of ensuring the island has not fallen into enemy hands after a previous expedition to the island ended in the strange disappearance of a ship and it’s crew. Rysn and the Windrunners both have differing unofficial motives for travelling to the island but you can read about that yourself. Whilst I wouldn’t say this is mandatory reading before ROW, I will say that the characters in this novella won’t have nearly as much depth to you if you go in without having read this.
****SPOILERS BEYOND THIS POINT****
The character work is great, as usual for Sanderson. The choice of POV characters was unexpected but worked really well.
Rysn is, as far as I can tell, a nuanced and accurate representation of someone with a physical disability. Her insecurities and everyday challenges as well as the ways in which people without a disability interacted with her all seemed really well done. She’ll be a very interesting character to watch going forward.
I enjoy Lopen’s joviality and larrikinism. Particularly in novellas, I don’t have an issue with Sanderson going down the more lighthearted comedic route but it’s all pretty cheesy humor. You know the kind that gets like a one-syllable, almost obligatory humph sort of laugh. One thing I find quite amusing is people’s differing opinions on Lopen compared to Lift. I would say they’re about the same level of relentless when it comes to cracking wise (which I don’t have a problem with as I’m probably the same type of unbearable) yet people seem to love Lopen and hate Lift. If anything, I would say Lift’s balance between humour and heartfelt moments makes her much more interesting than ‘The Lopen’.
I’m a sucker for a Hive-Mind species so I loved the introduction of the Sleepless. They were largely the driving force behind the mystery element in this novella and I found everything about their species and motivations on Roshar to be really interesting. It’s a real shame that was destroyed by the Dumpster Fire that were the negotiations towards the end of this novella. They were a completely “on-the-nose” attempt to illustrate Rysn’s skills in trade and negotiation but I did not buy it for a second! The fact that she managed to sway the minds of this ancient species with such a half-assed alternative to just killing them was so unconvincing and, frankly, laughable.
What the Bejesus was the deal with Huio and Lopen’s Third Ideals?! So, for the Windrunners, it’s supposed to be something loosely based on “I will protect even those I hate…” right? Well, Huio achieves the ideal by basically protecting those (Lopen) that he… Um, doesn’t hate but occasionally can be a little bit annoying and hurtful when teasing people. And Lopen achieves it by basically declaring, “I will become a more boring version of myself and think more about others when I joke. Yes, I will get a lobotomy.” What the fudge?! Kaladin really took the hard road to get to the same point, huh!
The revelations within the later chapters in this novella will, no doubt, have major implications for not only the future of Roshar but the Cosmere as a whole, however, it’s unclear when we will see the payoff. On to the main course, Rhythm of War awaits!