Horn Book Guide March, 1998
Lil is a larger-than-life librarian who manages to turn a town full of television addicts into readers, and even converts members of a tough motorcycle gang into library lovers. Though the tall tale is overly didactic, Kellogg's trademark detailed, exaggerated illustrations suit the outrageous story.
Kirkus Reviews 1997
Move over, Paul Bunyan--here comes Library Lil, who can toss a motorbike over her head like an apple core, balance a set of encyclopedias on the palm of one hand, speed-read every book in the children's room, tell a whale of a story, and convert an entire town to reading. Williams (Made in China, 1997, etc.) teams up with Kellogg for an exuberant, tongue-in-cheek adventure that will certainly strike a chord with book lovers. Lil, who always wanted to be a librarian, works in Chesterville, where the people watch too much television (which Lil labels "the Devil's Invention"). When a horrible storm takes down the power lines, Lil seizes her chance, pushing the bookmobile up and down the darkened streets and making sure that every man, woman, and child has a book to read. By the time electricity is restored two weeks later, the whole town is full of readers. When Bust-'em-up and his motorcycle gang roar into town and park in Lil's spot, there are more changes in the wind: Soon Bust-'em-up Bill becomes Bookworm Bill, and Lil finds time for a little Tuesday night wrestling on television. Great fun, with Kellogg's watercolors working hand-in-glove to put the humor of the tale over the top.
Publishers Weekly October 6, 1997
"I bet you think that all librarians are mousy little old ladies," opens Williams's (Mommy Doesn't Know My Name) jovial tale of a spunky, book-loving girl who grows up to become a charismatic librarian. Though Lil plans a storytelling festival and stocks the stacks with new books, no one comes to check them out. The town's residents are too busy watching TV, which to her "was an evil that ranked right up there with poison ivy and mosquitoes." When a storm knocks out the electricity for two weeks, the resourceful bibliophile hooks the population on reading as she pushes a bookmobile (whose battery is "deader than a pickled herring") through town, using muscle power acquired from schlepping stacks of books as a child. Her awesome strength also helps the woman make book lovers of a barely literate motorcycle gang--a humorous feat that won't be lost on reluctant young readers. Kellogg's wit is in full evidence in his waggish illustrations, prepared using ink and pencil line and watercolor washes. Adding to the sparkle of Williams's narrative are such spectacles as multiple TVs lighting up the windows of every single house and the bikers, in a pig-pile on the library floor, fighting for a copy of Beverly Cleary's The Mouse and the Motorcycle. Lighthearted yet illuminating, this is a volume bound to lure kids from the TV screen. Ages 4-8. (Oct.)
Publishers Weekly May 21, 2001
"Lighthearted yet illuminating, this is a volume bound to lure kids from the TV screen," said PW about this story of a bibliophile determined to get her boob tube-loving town reading. Ages 4-8. (May) Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information.
School Library Journal November 1997
Gr 2-4--A librarian's favorite fantasy. Lil the librarian is discouraged because no one comes to her dynamite storytimes, and no one checks out her terrific new books. The whole town would rather watch TV. Then one happy, stormy night, the power fails and stays off for two solid weeks. Lil pushes (credit her childhood practice lifting encyclopedias) the bookmobile (dead battery) around town and--presto!--changes vacant-eyed boob tubers into avid readers. But pretty soon, here comes trouble in the person of Bust-'em--up Bill, the tattooed leader of the (gasp) motorcycle gang. Bill blames Lil because there's no danged TV in the pool hall. Confrontation in the library parking lot! Bill's gang is waiting right where Lil wants to park her bookmobile. Will they move their bikes? Are you kidding? Nobody messes with Big Bad Bill, except of course, our heroine Lil. One by one, she tosses them aside, earning the respect of the not-so-scary desperadoes. The payoff is reading books, and since these guys are not academically gifted, Lil starts them off with Easys (Kellogg titles, natch). Pretty soon Lil has a new assistant. Bust-'em-up Bill is now Bookworm Bill, and the two even watch a little TV now and then. The silliness of both story and pictures are perfectly matched. Kellogg's distinctive toothy kids and laughing cats crowd the pages, fitting right in with the baby-faced biker banditos. A winner for storytimes anywhere.--Ruth Semrau, formerly at Lovejoy School, Allen, TX