You know how no one respects women more, while grabbing them by the pussy -- whether they consent or not -- than Trump? Well, no one respects women’s Contributions to STEM, while discrediting one woman -- Mlieva Maric, in the harshest terms possible -- than these authors. They want to make sure you never, ever see her as capable of making any contribution, whatsoever, to Einstein's work. In fact, they want to make sure you know she was below average in just about every way, except for her ability to be so emotional that she would not possibly be able to do math or physics.
It's not that their premise was a bad one. In fact, it started out really well. Through gross exaggerations and sheer imagination, many authors and screenwriters have conjured up the image that Mileva Maric was the real genius behind Einstein's ideas leading up to the 1905 papers and was relegated to the dust bin of history, robbing her of her rightful place in the history of physics and the history of women's achievements. These absurd claims, that were put forth without any actual evidence, needed to be challenged. The problem is, these authors are not the right scholars for the job. They, just like the people they criticize in their book, overshoot... by a lot. They excel at identifying original sources that started the myth of Maric as the "real mathematician" in the family and then identify authors who came later and uncritically and gullibly continued to repeat and strengthen this story. These authors provide grades for both Maric and Einstein as well as surviving documentation in the form of letters the couple wrote to each other. These documents demonstrate that Maric was not a superior mathematician and certainly not on par with Marcel Grossman, who Einstein enlisted help from in order to work out some of the maths for his theories. The problem arises when the authors claim that Maric provided *no* assistance. Einstein himself, in his own hand, wrote to Maric of presenting *their* ideas to the world. These authors, who spend an entire book lambasting anyone who didn't strictly govern themselves by evidence alone made myriad assertions that were not in any way tied to evidence. They *assumed* that Einstein was being kind by using the words "our ideas". They said outrageous things that amounted to suggesting that Maric was emotional and pregnant, and therefore obviously could not have done science. WTF? They cherry picked evidence from the past and then explained it away using smarmy lawyer speak. They showed no true understanding for Maric's role in Einstein's life. They showed no true understanding of what it was like for women in general. Sure, they rattled off a list of women such as Emmy Noether (my fave) and Lise Meitner, who had to overcome unbelievable obstacles and still did not receive the recognition they deserved. But, it felt as if they used these women merely as a tool to harm Mileva's reputation instead of a tool to convey to the reader what it was really like to be a woman at that time. No where, in all its pages, do the authors show any understanding of what it was like for Mileva, to have been forced to be the caretaker for children while Einstein continued on his own journey and never looked back. Never do they talk about what that must have been like, other than to say that she didn't have time to have helped him, and therefore doesn't deserve credit. They even had her own words at their disposal, that told them what it was like for her to be stranded. Yet, they could only look at those words through the lens of a lynch mob with one goal in mind, destroying her. The way they talk about Einstein v. the way the talk about Maric is so shockingly different, I felt as if I needed a shower after reading this book. These authors seem to me, to be misogynists who want to put on the mask of enlightened beings. No thanks. We can see through you. Maric's life deserves to be told by a fair author who does not imagine her as some genius who came up with all of Einstein's ideas or imagine her as a stupid, emotional, baby making machine who can't have sex and pop out babies *and* do science at the same time. So many books go to one extreme or the other and this one is no exception. I really hope someone writes Mileva Maric's story, using evidence, and only evidence, and shows her and Einstein both equal consideration, so that we, the public, can finally have a better understanding of this important time in history. Once that book is written, I hope this withers into obscurity, where it belongs. This whole book is built on an absurdly large number of strawman arguments. What a disappointment.