Let me preface this review by letting you know that I received a free electronic copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
I took my time writing this review. It was something that I wanted to allow myself to stew on for a little while before I shared my thoughts with the rest of the reading world. This book, in and of itself, is not a bad book, however, I did have some major problems with it that caused me to not feel as strongly about it as I would have liked to have done.
Let me set the scene for you first and foremost: Of Light and Darkness takes place in the rural Czech Republic, in mostly the modern day, quite near to the capital city of Prague. Leighton does a fantastic job of introducing us to her magical world, and it's inhabitants, that cohabitate in our very mortal world alongside us, yet unseen in our mortal, day-to-day lives. Save for one very special mortal girl, that is, named Charlotte. Charlotte was taken in by a vampire by the name of Valek and has been raised in a world of the Occult; an enchanted village that is unbeknownst to mortals that is made up of witches, elves, vampires, fae, fairies, and the like. However, the town is becoming full of increasing unrest as campaigns continue to plague the magical community with countless, unspeakable reports of atrocities that continue to befall the Occult at the hands of the vampires. Many citizens are unaware, but it is a full-on war between the Light and the Dark.
There are so many ways in which I wanted to love this book. Fantasy elements? Check. A various assortment of fantastical races of creatures? Check. A quite sound parallel between, historical elements and the magical world created by the author? Check.
By all rights, this book should have had me hook, line, and sinker! The sad reality is, within the first three chapters I became extremely uncomfortable. Why do you ask? It's because of the glaring Oedipal relationship between the two main characters. Yes, between Valek, the adoptive father, and Charlotte, the adopted daughter. The whole relationship was quite one-sided until Valek too decided he had the creepy hots for his adopted daughter. The relationship would not have made me so uncomfortable, had the dynamic not been anything other than father-daughter before this point. But it was. And it's gross and oh-so-wrong.
Moving past good old Oedipus, I enjoyed most of the story. I was engaged and found that I was interested in what was coming next. Again, however, I must bring in the "but" to interrupt my review.
While the story was quite enjoyable an entertaining, and I will not deny that Leighton put a lot of time into her world-building, I found too many times in the story where I had to jump back and re-read a section. Normally, having to go back and read something again, in and of itself, is not a problem. However, the reason I would go back and re-read constantly is that I thought I was actually missing something. As it turns out, there were literally just parts of the plot that ran away with the author. Things that would jump out of nowhere, like, for instance, a birthday party. One moment the group is having a very serious conversation about danger and how they are going to approach the enemy, and then, suddenly, Sarah rambles on about people not daring to spoil the surprise (yes, I get it, vampires can read minds and all in this book, but there was ZERO indication that a birthday party was going to happen, and as a reader, instead of feeling surprised, I felt drunk when the party finally hit me out of nowhere).
On the whole, it was not an entirely unpleasant book. If you are willing to look past the uncomfortable situation of an adopted child being in lusty, lusty love with her adopted father who, approximately half-way through the book decides he also has the hots for her back (and we blame it all on being soul mates *gags*), this does have the potential to be a good-ish book. I will be the first to acknowledge that everyone is into different things, and perhaps, unlike me, you will not be driven away by this weird dynamic being the centrally focused relationship. Oh wait, there is also a raging doucher of a "nice-guy" elf. I suppose it's nice to see that some things supersede the ties of morality.
All in all, because I am not able to give half stars on Goodreads, I would rate this book as 3/5, but hope you know it's actually a solid 2.5 stars.