Yes, it's taken me too long to start this series. And yes, I started with book three. But since I'm pretty sure they're standalones, and since I needed this one for a challenge, I finally took the plunge. And...I loved it!
So...the characters. Of course I fell in love with Gerrit. How could I not? But I fell deeply in love with the adult characters too, in spite of, or maybe because of, their flaws. Ivory struck me right away as quite naive--someone who had come into this lonely mountain community with the best of intentions and pretty much no idea of what she was getting herself into. She was so bubbly and happy and ready to make friends--and that went over just about exactly how you would expect in a quiet, stoic, isolated community, even without the superstitions that attached to her almost immediately. Ben, on the other hand, was exactly what you would expect from a son of that community--keeping his emotions close to his chest even as he's trying to figure out exactly how to respond to this perky stranger who's turning his world upside down. I understood both of them so well and empathized with their perspectives, even as I could see where the problems were going to come in. Also--the fact that they were BOTH wrong and BOTH right in the same argument? That was incredible!!! I kind of saw Ivory's point--and then Ben corrected her, and I thought, "Wow, he's so right!" and then he got corrected himself, and I was absolutely blown away. It's not because you have a good point that makes the other person's point invalid, and you can both challenge someone else's perspective and have your own challenged without having to choose one over the other--I loved it SO MUCH!!! I'm not sure how I can express how much I loved the way that whole plot point and message worked out. So, so good!!!
As far as the other characters, I enjoyed meeting all of the other librarians, and I'm looking forward to their stories. Edna has me especially intrigued... I wasn't entirely sure how to take Curt--he kind of hovered right on the line between adorably awkward and slightly creepy. Ugh. And I wasn't at all a fan of how he acted during the crisis, even if I did recognize that he was stuck in a hard place. :P
There are only two things that drop my rating a little. First, the romance was a little more appearance-based/physically focused than I like. Totally clean, but a lot of noticing the other's physique, trying not to think too much about the other's body, etc. And second, there was one scene where Ivory was hurt and the only available painkiller was some strong moonshine--so no, there was nothing sinful in the situation and it was completely understandable, but--I didn't see the reason that we had to have that scene described except to make things awkward, and presumably funny. But (and this may be just me) I've never found drunkenness funny, even if it's unintentional and innocent. It just makes me sad and uncomfortable, and without that scene, I would likely have rated this at least a half star higher.
The two issues above lower my rating by about a star, but I still very much enjoyed this book and really loved both the characters and the message. Looking forward to reading the rest of the series soon!
Content--some noticing, touching, and kissing (slightly descriptive); a man tries not to think about a woman changing her clothes after a rainstorm; a woman is trapped with a man and a boy in a cabin when a river floods, and nasty rumors are floated, although nothing inappropriate happened; mentions of various superstitions, including a woman being labeled a witch for no reason; use of alcohol for a painful injury and resulting drunkenness, including embarrassing comments; a few mentions of outhouses, etc.