This is the third book in the Palace of Rogues series. I really enjoyed this story. The two main characters are physically and mentally attracted to each other. Each has their own history, and the author does an excellent job of unfolding it for the reader.
Extremely beautiful FMC Lillias Vaughn was first introduced at the end of the second book when MMC Hugh Cassidy catches her smoking a cheroot. He grounds it under his boot and then later discreetly informs her parents. The Earl and Countess of Vaughn are tenants of the The Grand Palace on the Thames while their London home is being de-snaked and restored to its former condition. Lillias’ punishment for smoking is confinement to the premises of the Grand Palace for a fortnight. She decides to use her beauty and wit to get even with the American Mr. Cassidy:
“And now here she was, confined to her room like a child for her transgression, as though she’d never had any power at all and never would. But now she understood the most infuriating thing of all about him: two minutes with Hugh Cassidy had given her a taste of the true, thrilling, unnerving power she possessed.”
“And then he’d stripped her of that power with a few words.” (‘Go inside, little girl.’)
“She intended to take it back from him.”
MMC Hugh Cassidy traveled from America to England to find the daughter of a close friend. His goal is to locate her and bring her safely back to America. His search has been futile so far. In the meantime, he assists the proprietors in building a stage in the ballroom of their new annex. During the evenings when guests are required to convene and engage in various activities such as reading, needlepoint, or chess, Hugh and Lillias engage in their own conversational battles. Chapter Three sees their mental dance begin when the Myth of Hades and Persephone are discussed. It's a complex story viewed as either a dark abduction or a powerful, if unconventional, love story where Persephone and Hades rule as equals. Blend this myth and “Robinson Crusoe” together and you have somewhat of a foundation for this book.
In the beginning, Lillias comes off as a spoiled woman. Over time, the reader learns she’s harboring a broken heart. She knows most of the titled gentry want her hand in marriage, but there’s only one man she has secretly longed for since childhood. Over the course of the first half of the book, my opinion of her character changes. She’s a woman who feels trapped in her titled culture. Hearing about Hugh’s American adventures intrigues her. She seeks Hugh out not only to help take her mind off an event she’s loathing to attend, but also because she’s drawn to him physically and mentally. Hugh challenges her in an exciting way.
Hugh, on the other hand, is fighting his attraction for Lillias. He knows nothing can come of it because he is not English and considered well below her class status. He also has his own plans and is anxious to find Amelia Woodley and return to America. But in Chapter 12,
everything
changes. The book goes from being slow burning to I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough.
Some of the best highlights are when Earl Vaughn offers Helga a job at his estate, the advice Mr. Hardy and Lord Bolt give Hugh, the shooting contest at Heatherfield, Hugh, (a veteran of two American wars) defending the American way against Giles’ accusations, and of course Lillias’ drawings filling her once empty sketch book. Maybe it was my mood, but I found this to be a really good book to start 2026 with.
I rated it 4.5 stars because selfishly, I wanted more closure on Amelia’s character at the end.
Great book, good series, and one that I hope to finish this year.